XSF logo XMPP Council - 2017-12-13


  1. daniel has joined
  2. Holger has left
  3. daniel has left
  4. daniel has joined
  5. daniel has left
  6. daniel has joined
  7. daniel has left
  8. daniel has joined
  9. daniel has left
  10. daniel has joined
  11. daniel has left
  12. daniel has joined
  13. Tobias has joined
  14. daniel has left
  15. daniel has joined
  16. Tobias has joined
  17. Link Mauve has left
  18. Link Mauve has joined
  19. daniel has left
  20. daniel has joined
  21. daniel has left
  22. daniel has joined
  23. daniel has left
  24. daniel has joined
  25. daniel has left
  26. vanitasvitae has left
  27. daniel has joined
  28. daniel has left
  29. daniel has joined
  30. daniel has left
  31. jere has joined
  32. SamWhited has left
  33. daniel has joined
  34. Syndace has left
  35. Syndace has joined
  36. jere has left
  37. jere has joined
  38. daniel has left
  39. daniel has joined
  40. daniel has left
  41. daniel has joined
  42. daniel has left
  43. daniel has joined
  44. daniel has left
  45. daniel has joined
  46. Zash has left
  47. Zash has left
  48. Zash has joined
  49. jere has joined
  50. daniel has left
  51. daniel has joined
  52. daniel has left
  53. daniel has joined
  54. ralphm has left
  55. Tobias has joined
  56. daniel has left
  57. ralphm has left
  58. ralphm has left
  59. ralphm has joined
  60. ralphm has left
  61. daniel has left
  62. ralphm has joined
  63. ralphm has left
  64. ralphm has joined
  65. Tobias has joined
  66. ralphm has left
  67. Syndace has left
  68. Syndace has joined
  69. Kev has joined
  70. ralphm has joined
  71. Kev has left
  72. Kev has joined
  73. Kev has left
  74. ralphm has left
  75. Kev has left
  76. Kev has left
  77. Kev has joined
  78. ralphm has joined
  79. daniel has left
  80. ralphm has left
  81. Kev has left
  82. Kev has left
  83. Kev has joined
  84. Kev Reminder that I've sent apologies for this afternoon.
  85. jcbrand has joined
  86. ralphm has joined
  87. daniel has left
  88. ralphm has joined
  89. Tobias has joined
  90. ralphm has joined
  91. Tobias has joined
  92. ralphm has left
  93. ralphm has joined
  94. genofire has joined
  95. Tobias has left
  96. Syndace has left
  97. Syndace has joined
  98. Kev has left
  99. ralphm has joined
  100. daniel has left
  101. daniel has joined
  102. ralphm has joined
  103. ralphm has joined
  104. Kev has joined
  105. Kev has left
  106. ralphm has joined
  107. ralphm has left
  108. ralphm has joined
  109. genofire has left
  110. SamWhited has left
  111. SamWhited has joined
  112. ralphm has left
  113. vanitasvitae has left
  114. daniel has left
  115. ralphm has joined
  116. jcbrand has left
  117. daniel has joined
  118. ralphm has joined
  119. Kev has left
  120. Kev has joined
  121. Ge0rG Without Kev and dwd, can we do anything today?
  122. SamWhited I thought dave said he'd be here but just couldn't prepare an agenda before hand?
  123. Ge0rG Ah, right.
  124. Ge0rG "should be able to attend" were the exact words
  125. Ge0rG I actually do have two questions to the other council members that I'd like to place today.
  126. daniel Shall we begin?
  127. Kev has left
  128. SamWhited daniel: I think you just volunteered to run things
  129. daniel 1) roll call
  130. daniel Ge0rG?
  131. Ge0rG daniel: I'm there
  132. SamWhited I also am here
  133. Ge0rG ...for at least the next 50 minutes.
  134. daniel 1) reconsider instant stream resumption / accept that as proto xep
  135. daniel anyone want to say something or should we just vote on this?
  136. SamWhited I will be on list as I don't remember this one very well and haven't had a chance to re-read it.
  137. daniel +1 from myself
  138. daniel Ge0rG?
  139. Ge0rG I vaguely remember some question about the usefulness of this as opposed to 0198 and normal stream init, and challenges regarding token validity, so on-list
  140. daniel ok
  141. daniel i'm i guess a couple of LCs end today but it's not on the agenda so we should maybe move this to next time
  142. Ge0rG Are those the LCs that were initiated last week and MUST run for at least 14 days?
  143. daniel Ge0rG, well some XEPs have 12-12 in their headers like http upload for example. but either way; we'll move that to next week
  144. daniel 3) vote on xep-0060 publish-options changes
  145. Ge0rG I'd actually like to hear more from the senior folks regarding the 0060 changes.
  146. SamWhited Which one is this? Didn't you make several alternative PRs for 0060?
  147. daniel i've proposed three different PRs 555-557 where I personally think 557 is the most reasonable one. so i'd suggest we vote on that one first and if that doesn't get consensus we fall back to to voting on 555
  148. Ge0rG While I'm pretty sure we covered well the OSS implementations' feedback, maybe there are 0060 implementations we don't know about that would be broken by this.
  149. Ge0rG and maybe the missing council members do know more.
  150. daniel SamWhited, #557 is rendered here. https://gultsch.de/files/xep-0060.html#publisher-publish-options
  151. SamWhited Sorry, just went back and reminded myself which was which. I also liked 557
  152. daniel but yes maybe we should wait for some more list discussion
  153. Ge0rG I've got no first-hand experience, and I'm obviously biased because I helped write the wording in #557
  154. Kev has left
  155. daniel 4) Ge0rG's question to council
  156. daniel go ahead
  157. Ge0rG a) do we have any (proto) XEPs to enroll new accounts with a token / invitation code / similar things?
  158. SamWhited Not that I'm aware of, but I have considered writing something as a challenge on https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0389.html
  159. moparisthebest has joined
  160. SamWhited *something similar
  161. Ge0rG SamWhited: what's the status of 389? marc and I are working on extending PARS to account-invitation-tokens kind-of-thing
  162. Ge0rG and my question b) would be: is it legitimate to have a server-capability-indicated way to extend the IBR form with additional fields, which are not data-form fields?
  163. Ge0rG i.e. I want the client to initiate regular IBR with a token, so that the server can immediately validate the token and accept the request, instead of presenting a data-form
  164. daniel is this a question to council? shouldn't this be a on list discussion between you and the author?
  165. SamWhited Yah, let's discuss afterwards
  166. daniel ok
  167. daniel 5) date of next
  168. Ge0rG okay to move on then
  169. SamWhited +1 week WFM
  170. daniel i'm gonna be on a train w/o wifi next wednesday
  171. SamWhited Maybe we should settle on a new time on list then to make sure the people who aren't here this week don't have conflicts if we move it.
  172. Ge0rG +1w WFM
  173. Ge0rG SamWhited: sounds good
  174. daniel ok
  175. daniel 6) anything else?
  176. daniel ok. doesn't look like it.
  177. daniel thank you and please comment on list regarding the time for next time
  178. Ge0rG daniel: thank you!
  179. SamWhited Thanks daniel
  180. Ge0rG Did we have a note taker?
  181. daniel yes me
  182. Ge0rG daniel: thanks again!
  183. SamWhited Ge0rG: I'm stepping out briefly, but will be around today if you want to discuss IBR2 and your token thing. Feel free to ping me and I'll respond "soon".
  184. Ge0rG SamWhited: TL;DR, xmpp:user@host?;preauth=TOKEN;ibr - the "ibr" is a tag indicating that the TOKEN can be used for IBR authentication, even if generic IBR is disabled
  185. Ge0rG if a client does IBR with TOKEN piggy-backed somehow, the server will auto-subscribe the new account to the inviter.
  186. ralphm has joined
  187. Kev has joined
  188. ralphm has joined
  189. SamWhited Ge0rG: I'm not aware of a spec already doing something like that, but that was the type of thing that IBR2 was designed to allow.
  190. Tobias has left
  191. Lance has joined
  192. Lance has left
  193. ralphm has joined
  194. Holger has left
  195. Holger has joined
  196. jere has joined
  197. daniel has left
  198. daniel has left
  199. Tobias has left
  200. Zash has left
  201. daniel has left
  202. Kev has left
  203. Holger has left
  204. ralphm has joined
  205. ralphm has joined
  206. Zash has left
  207. Syndace has joined
  208. Syndace has joined
  209. Tobias has joined
  210. jere has joined
  211. jere has joined
  212. Tobias has joined
  213. Tobias has left
  214. Tobias has joined
  215. genofire has joined
  216. ralphm has joined
  217. jere has joined
  218. jere has joined
  219. ralphm has left
  220. jere has left
  221. jere has joined
  222. daniel has left
  223. ralphm has joined
  224. daniel has left
  225. jcbrand has joined
  226. jcbrand has left
  227. jcbrand has left
  228. daniel has left
  229. jere has joined
  230. daniel has left
  231. daniel has left
  232. ralphm has left
  233. daniel has left
  234. genofire has joined
  235. jonasw has left
  236. jere has joined
  237. ralphm has joined
  238. ralphm has joined
  239. ralphm has joined
  240. jcbrand has joined
  241. jcbrand has left
  242. daniel has left
  243. ralphm has joined
  244. jere has joined
  245. jere has joined
  246. ralphm has left
  247. jere has joined
  248. jere has joined
  249. daniel has left
  250. ralphm has joined
  251. daniel has left
  252. daniel has joined
  253. moparisthebest has joined
  254. Kev has joined
  255. jere has joined
  256. Kev has left
  257. jere has joined
  258. jere has joined
  259. jere has joined