XSF Discussion - 2018-05-15


  1. alexis has left
  2. alexis has joined
  3. forensic58 has joined
  4. forensic58 has left
  5. alexis has left
  6. alexis has joined
  7. rtq3 has joined
  8. flow has left
  9. flow has joined
  10. flow has left
  11. flow has joined
  12. flow has joined
  13. alexis has left
  14. alexis has joined
  15. Chobbes has joined
  16. forensic58 has joined
  17. SamWhited has left
  18. alexis has left
  19. Dave Cridland has left
  20. vanitasvitae has left
  21. alexis has joined
  22. marmistrz has joined
  23. marmistrz has joined
  24. rtq3 has left
  25. alexis has left
  26. alexis has joined
  27. rtq3 has joined
  28. forensic58 has left
  29. alexis has left
  30. alexis has joined
  31. alexis has left
  32. alexis has joined
  33. rtq3 has left
  34. rtq3 has joined
  35. rtq3 has left
  36. alexis has left
  37. alexis has joined
  38. rtq3 has joined
  39. rtq3 has left
  40. rtq3 has joined
  41. Steve Kille has left
  42. rtq3 has left
  43. Guus has left
  44. jere has left
  45. jere has joined
  46. Guus has left
  47. Guus has left
  48. Guus has left
  49. mrdoctorwho has left
  50. Guus has left
  51. mrdoctorwho has joined
  52. Guus has left
  53. Guus has left
  54. forensic58 has joined
  55. Guus has left
  56. forensic58 has left
  57. Guus has left
  58. alacer has left
  59. Dave Cridland has left
  60. Guus has left
  61. forensic58 has joined
  62. Guus has left
  63. Guus has left
  64. Guus has left
  65. Guus has left
  66. forensic58 has left
  67. Guus has left
  68. tux has left
  69. tux has joined
  70. Dave Cridland has left
  71. dwd has joined
  72. alacer has joined
  73. dwd has left
  74. dwd has joined
  75. Guus has left
  76. Guus has left
  77. dwd has left
  78. Guus has left
  79. Guus has left
  80. Guus has left
  81. jere has left
  82. jere has joined
  83. Guus has left
  84. lumi has joined
  85. Guus has left
  86. Guus has left
  87. Guus has left
  88. lorddavidiii has joined
  89. ibikk has joined
  90. forensic58 has joined
  91. alacer has left
  92. alacer has joined
  93. Guus has left
  94. forensic58 has left
  95. Dave Cridland has left
  96. dwd has joined
  97. Dave Cridland has left
  98. dwd has left
  99. dwd has joined
  100. Nekit has joined
  101. dwd has left
  102. dwd has joined
  103. Guus has left
  104. Yagiza has joined
  105. dwd has left
  106. forensic58 has joined
  107. j.r has joined
  108. j.r has joined
  109. Guus has left
  110. forensic58 has left
  111. Dave Cridland has left
  112. mimi89999 has left
  113. mimi89999 has left
  114. mimi89999 has joined
  115. lovetox has joined
  116. Dave Cridland has left
  117. Dave Cridland has left
  118. alacer has left
  119. dwd has joined
  120. Guus has left
  121. dwd has left
  122. marek has joined
  123. j.r has left
  124. j.r has joined
  125. lnj has joined
  126. alacer has joined
  127. forensic58 has joined
  128. jonasw MattJ, Ge0rG, to be fair, the "worst" I did XMPP-wise was on that plastic router with 64 MiB of RAM. I used libstrophe/libcouplet there (despite a lua runtime available; I didn’t want to get into building libexpat for that system; when I was going to crosscompile, I could also simply crosscompile my C application).
  129. jonasw the SASL handshake still took considerable time on that system :)
  130. jonasw (one really wants PLAIN on really constrained systems)
  131. Guus has left
  132. forensic58 has left
  133. alacer has left
  134. Guus has left
  135. forensic58 has joined
  136. Valerian has joined
  137. forensic58 has left
  138. Wiktor has joined
  139. Dave Cridland has left
  140. Dave Cridland has left
  141. la|r|ma has joined
  142. SamWhited has left
  143. forensic58 has joined
  144. rion has joined
  145. forensic58 has left
  146. Dave Cridland has left
  147. Dave Cridland has left
  148. Tim has joined
  149. Dave Cridland has left
  150. dwd has joined
  151. Dave Cridland has left
  152. andy has joined
  153. dwd has left
  154. dwd has joined
  155. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  156. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  157. vanitasvitae has left
  158. vanitasvitae has joined
  159. forensic58 has joined
  160. rion has left
  161. dwd has left
  162. rion has joined
  163. lskdjf has joined
  164. Chobbes has left
  165. Dave Cridland has left
  166. forensic58 has left
  167. dwd has left
  168. Dave Cridland has left
  169. Dave Cridland has left
  170. Dave Cridland has left
  171. rion has left
  172. Dave Cridland has left
  173. Dave Cridland has left
  174. forensic58 has joined
  175. Dave Cridland has left
  176. j.r has left
  177. j.r has joined
  178. Dave Cridland has left
  179. rtq3 has joined
  180. Dave Cridland has left
  181. forensic58 has left
  182. Dave Cridland has left
  183. Ge0rG I'm not sure I can even fit TLS into the ESP
  184. forensic58 has joined
  185. dwd has joined
  186. la|r|ma has joined
  187. ibikk MattJ, GeOrg: regarding home automation and mqtt: once I was fed up with openhab I hacked something which connects mqtt, some scripts and rules and a xmpp "command line interface". Maybe someone is interested? I'd have to document and upload it...
  188. la|r|ma has joined
  189. la|r|ma has joined
  190. la|r|ma has joined
  191. rtq3 has left
  192. Dave Cridland has left
  193. Ge0rG ibikk: that's great but I want an Android app, so OpenHab is rather practical for that.
  194. Ge0rG What I hate about it is that it consumes gigabytes of RAM and that there is no way to abstract multiple identical multi-item controllers as entities
  195. blabla has left
  196. blabla has joined
  197. rion has joined
  198. forensic58 has left
  199. ibikk the openhab app was OK, but I didn't want to expose openhab to the internet or use an VPN, therefore I did this xmpp command line, which in some aspects is far more powerful than openhab. also 'scripts' is misleading. it is a python app and provides scripts (have to be explicitly called by user) and (automatic) rules/controllers.
  200. forensic58 has joined
  201. ibikk in my home network there also is a browser interface.
  202. alexis has left
  203. alexis has joined
  204. Ge0rG There is a subcommunity of people claiming that XMPP is awesome for IoT. I want to see that in practice.
  205. Dave Cridland has left
  206. alexis has left
  207. alexis has joined
  208. Valerian has left
  209. Valerian has joined
  210. waqas has left
  211. alexis has left
  212. alexis has joined
  213. rion has left
  214. Valerian has left
  215. Valerian has joined
  216. Valerian has left
  217. alexis has left
  218. alexis has joined
  219. forensic58 has left
  220. rion has left
  221. ibikk I do not. mqtt seems fine.
  222. Dave Cridland has left
  223. Wiktor has joined
  224. UsL has joined
  225. Ge0rG ibikk: MQTT is okay for a small fleet of devices, but I want to have something where a device can bundle its API spec in a machine-readable way, like "I'm an RGBW controller and I support one HSV channel and one brightness channel and a global power switch"
  226. alexis has left
  227. alexis has joined
  228. jonasw Ge0rG, there is a bearssl implementation.
  229. Ge0rG is there also a bearxmpp?
  230. Ge0rG and a bearxmppiot?
  231. jonasw I think hooking up libcouplet with that shouldn’t be too hard.
  232. rtq3 has joined
  233. alexis has left
  234. Ge0rG jonasw: and then we are still lacking all of the IoT infrastructure that purportedly puts XMPP above MQTT for IoT.
  235. alexis has joined
  236. forensic58 has joined
  237. jonasw maybe
  238. Ge0rG jonasw: feel free to prove me wrong.
  239. Dave Cridland has left
  240. Ge0rG Right now I'm convinced that XMPP-IoT is overhyped to a degree that's actually harmful for IoT over XMPP
  241. marek has left
  242. lnj has left
  243. jonasw I haven’t followed the work actual IoT people do
  244. jonasw I just do my own stuff with some pubsub and IQs
  245. jonasw that was easy enough to do with libcouplet and sleek and aioxmpp
  246. la|r|ma has joined
  247. rtq3 has left
  248. alexis has left
  249. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  250. lovetox has left
  251. alexis has joined
  252. ibikk Ge0rG: I think people have proposed how to do something like this using mqtt? It does not fit my needs however. My devices don't even talk mqtt themselves.
  253. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  254. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  255. alacer has joined
  256. Valerian has joined
  257. goffi has joined
  258. rion has joined
  259. nyco has left
  260. nyco has joined
  261. Steve Kille has left
  262. Steve Kille has left
  263. Dave Cridland has left
  264. alacer has left
  265. ta has left
  266. dwd has left
  267. Valerian has left
  268. Valerian has joined
  269. Valerian has left
  270. alacer has joined
  271. lumi has left
  272. alacer has left
  273. Dave Cridland has left
  274. forensic58 has left
  275. lovetox has joined
  276. Ge0rG winfried: what was the scheduled appointment time again?
  277. forensic58 has joined
  278. jonasw Ge0rG, 1230 CEST
  279. Ge0rG Alright, thanks.
  280. lskdjf has left
  281. forensic58 has left
  282. MattJ Ge0rG, have you looked at Home Assistant? OpenHAB was a bit too heavy for me
  283. Ge0rG MattJ: that looks very interesting, thanks
  284. Ge0rG And it's not running node.js, despite being hosted on .io
  285. MattJ Indeed
  286. Ge0rG "Learn how Hass.io can turn your Raspberry Pi into the ultimate home automation hub" - Hass is the German word for "hate". So appropriate.
  287. Dave Cridland has left
  288. MattJ They have an MQTT mode where the device posts its configuration
  289. daniel has left
  290. daniel has joined
  291. MattJ Ge0rG, https://www.home-assistant.io/docs/mqtt/discovery/
  292. dwd has left
  293. jubalh has joined
  294. Ge0rG <node_id> (Optional): ID of the node providing the topic. <object_id>: The ID of the device. This is only to allow for separate topics for each device and is not used for the entity_id. node_id, object_id, entity_id... This looks like Designed by the XSF™
  295. jubalh has left
  296. rion has left
  297. MattJ :)
  298. Ge0rG I'm not sure why they need multiple topics for a single switch (set and state), if they could just have one that is read and written to and retained.
  299. Ge0rG and embedding the full path of that into the config kind of defeats the purpose
  300. rion has joined
  301. la|r|ma has left
  302. MattJ The API has to handle many different kinds of devices, many APIs separate command and state, because in reality they are different
  303. Ge0rG right. Devices that react to "ON" and then set the HSV state to "0,0,100" or somesuch.
  304. Ge0rG It's awesome how fast you end up with a huge complexity overhead.
  305. MattJ Indeed
  306. jonasw also, sometimes setting might not work
  307. jonasw for example if the device is offline
  308. jonasw and you’d normally want to be able to detect that
  309. jonasw (or if it is slow or something)
  310. MattJ Yeah, the state essentially doubles as an ack for any command
  311. jonasw it’s common in commanding systems actually
  312. MattJ Also in Home Assistant it's generally optional anyway, if it's absent then the UI just assumes the state is whatever was requested, instantly (which obviously has downsides)
  313. Ge0rG Right.
  314. Ge0rG I see where this is going.
  315. Dave Cridland has left
  316. dwd has left
  317. dwd has joined
  318. MattJ FWIW I consider XMPP suitable for higher-level IoT stuff, but not for device<->controller comms, unless the devices are powerful enough
  319. Dave Cridland has left
  320. Ge0rG MattJ: my devices are sufficiently powerful.
  321. MattJ I consider most of the IoT XEPs to be over-engineered though
  322. Dave Cridland has left
  323. dwd has left
  324. MattJ Then XEP-0060 them and enjoy
  325. dwd has joined
  326. Ge0rG the hass discovery looks like a nice trade-off between complexity and comfort.
  327. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  328. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  329. Tobias has left
  330. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  331. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  332. jubalh has joined
  333. ralphm has joined
  334. dwd has left
  335. Dave Cridland has left
  336. dwd has joined
  337. Ge0rG The Converse.js on http://www.xmpp-iot.org is great. You have to click it away after Every. Freaking. Click.
  338. daniel has left
  339. daniel has left
  340. daniel has joined
  341. rion has left
  342. jubalh has left
  343. forensic58 has joined
  344. la|r|ma has joined
  345. Tobias has joined
  346. marmistrz has left
  347. nyco has left
  348. nyco has joined
  349. Guus has left
  350. jubalh has joined
  351. jubalh has left
  352. rion has joined
  353. alacer has joined
  354. Dave Cridland has left
  355. dwd has left
  356. daniel has left
  357. Dave Cridland has left
  358. dwd has joined
  359. dwd has left
  360. dwd has joined
  361. Dave Cridland has left
  362. dwd has left
  363. dwd has joined
  364. pep. When was the last gdpr meeting again, the one with all of us
  365. pep. 0504?
  366. Ge0rG pep.: I could tell you, but I need to gain consent from all attendees first.
  367. pep. yeah that sounds about right
  368. jubalh has joined
  369. pep. Ge0rG, shut up :p
  370. jubalh has left
  371. Dave Cridland has left
  372. dwd has left
  373. Dave Cridland has left
  374. Ge0rG pep.: do you want to make use of your right to Erasure?
  375. dwd has joined
  376. dwd has left
  377. dwd has joined
  378. rion has left
  379. pep. let me gdpr the hell out of you. *goes and create a yax.im account*
  380. Ge0rG Damn. You win this round.
  381. Ge0rG goes looking for yax.im's power plug
  382. pep. hmm no there was nothing on 0504
  383. pep. last one with all of us seems to be 0430
  384. stefandxm has left
  385. pep. Or my logs are lying to me
  386. alacer has left
  387. forensic58 has left
  388. dwd has left
  389. forensic58 has joined
  390. nyco has left
  391. nyco has joined
  392. jubalh has joined
  393. jubalh has left
  394. rtq3 has joined
  395. Guus has left
  396. pep. Ok I'm sending something for the minutes, 11 (& 12 that was cancelled)
  397. Guus has left
  398. Guus has joined
  399. Tobias has left
  400. alacer has joined
  401. pep. Ge0rG, jonasw, winfried, meeting in ~10min
  402. winfried (Y)
  403. Ge0rG I'm on the run right now, can't promise anything
  404. pep. k
  405. SaltyBones has left
  406. SaltyBones has joined
  407. alacer has left
  408. lorddavidiii has left
  409. pep. !
  410. winfried t -2 ;-)
  411. lorddavidiii has joined
  412. jonasw 🙋‍
  413. Ge0rG Okay, so I'm in the expected lunch break, but I'm alone so I can focus on the GDPR.
  414. winfried great
  415. winfried lets recapp
  416. pep. There's a question (quotes) I added in the minutes, that I think we didn't really focus on
  417. pep. I don't know if we can answer it by ourselves though
  418. winfried pep.: can you repeat the question(s) here?
  419. pep. Do we have to find all the data scattered across all different services, re export/deletion
  420. pep. "all different services", meaning not ours
  421. Ge0rG We'd have to monitor all the services a user uses and how
  422. winfried pep.: from a legal perspective not: the data is transferred and not 'our' responsibility anymore
  423. pep. Ge0rG, I'm not saying it'd be easy or even fun, just asking from a legal standpoint
  424. pep. winfried, k
  425. winfried still thinking it would be fun ;-)
  426. pep. Ok, so what's left
  427. Ge0rG winfried: that's too easy for an answer. If we are the controller, we are probably still responsible, aren't we?
  428. Ge0rG What if Facebook "transfers" the data from Facebook EU Inc. to Facebook USA?
  429. winfried Ge0rG: IF we are controller yes, but there is no controller - processor situation but a transfer between two controllers
  430. winfried Ge0rG: FB EU -> FB US is transfer between two controllers, in the FB case that is not covered by 6.1b, so it has to be 6.1a
  431. Ge0rG winfried: so we are controllers, but the other servers are controllers too?
  432. winfried Ge0rG: yes... that was one of the first premises we started with ;-)
  433. Ge0rG winfried: I've always seen that as "controllers of our users' friends' data"
  434. daniel has left
  435. Ge0rG Which is not the same thing
  436. winfried what difference do you see (I am still digesting that one)
  437. pep. Ge0rG, that would make the s2s server a processor, but then how do you say you're not liable for what the contact does with MAM
  438. jonasw I think with Ge0rGs interpretation we can argue that after the transfer the data is at the recipients control and the handling of the data is owned by the recipent, thus the recipient is responsible for all things GDPR and whether the senders privacy preferences are matched is a matter of trust between recipient and sender.
  439. Ge0rG winfried: remote PubSub is data that a user's server transmits to a different server (controller?) on behalf of the user. Now does the remote server need to obtain consent from the user?
  440. Ge0rG I'm explicitly not talking about data sent to other users.
  441. valo has joined
  442. winfried Ge0rG: no, that is still 6.1b, so no consent. But the remote server, when it falls under the jurisdiction of the GDPR, needs to publish its privacy policy
  443. Ge0rG winfried: and if it's in a third country?
  444. pep. then it's 49.1b, no consent required
  445. winfried pep.: thanks, you got the article number before me ;-)
  446. pep. Ah hmm, if that's not a controller that's different?
  447. Dave Cridland has left
  448. pep. Ah nvm
  449. Ge0rG winfried: great. Can we have that in the wiki, then?
  450. winfried yes pep. plz remind me ;-)
  451. stefandxm has joined
  452. pep. So wait, that means.. transfer between controllers? Or what Ge0rG said?
  453. Ge0rG pep.: it is transfer between controllers
  454. Ge0rG And what I said
  455. pep. > Ge0rG> winfried: I've always seen that as "controllers of our users' friends' data"
  456. Ge0rG What did I say? And when?
  457. Ge0rG pep.: two different use cases. Messages sent to other users vs things we store on other servers.
  458. winfried Ge0rG: yes, good to distinguish between them
  459. Ge0rG pep.: if I send you a message, you become the owner on your server. If I publish a post on movim, I stay the owner
  460. pep. Ok, so what winfried said doesn'T apply to MAM?
  461. Ge0rG pep.: what kind of MAM?
  462. pep. 1:1
  463. winfried pep.: if it is my server archiving your messages in the conversation I had with you, then that MAM is my responsibility
  464. Ge0rG pep.: and what did winfried say?
  465. pep. winfried, yes that's what I thought until now, but you're all confusing me with words :p
  466. winfried I propose I try to write it down in clear wording in the Wiki, plz correct if that is still confusing/incorrect. agreed?
  467. pep. Ge0rG, so "Ge0rG> winfried: I've always seen that as "controllers of our users' friends' data"" < this is wrong?
  468. pep. Well..
  469. Ge0rG winfried: s/propose/volunteer/, right?
  470. pep. It's "not the interpretation we choose to think will be applied"
  471. winfried Ge0rG: yes
  472. Ge0rG pep. [12:57]: > Ge0rG, so "Ge0rG> winfried: I've always seen that as "controllers of our users' friends' data"" < this is wrong? This is true as well, for the remote copy of the message I sent to my friend
  473. winfried pep.: correct, but we can only discuss/check an interpretation if it is worded complete and clear
  474. Ge0rG We need to choose an interpretation anyway, and then hope we don't have to defend it in court
  475. Ge0rG It's better to have an interpretation that we can reasonably agree on than not to have any
  476. pep. sure
  477. winfried and there is an interesting subtle issue here: when becomes my message the responsibility of the receiving person?
  478. pep. Once it gets over s2s?
  479. winfried I will try to word as precise as I can so we can decide ...
  480. Ge0rG winfried: when the receiving person opted to use offline storage / MAM and the message arrives there?
  481. winfried :-D I see different opinions here
  482. winfried I tend to the pov of Ge0rG
  483. winfried as long as it is on the receivers server and not transferred to the receiver, the message is nobodies responsibility if we take s2s as border
  484. rtq3 has left
  485. winfried but let me think about that one a bid and let me word it in the wiki
  486. rtq3 has joined
  487. pep. k
  488. forensic58 has left
  489. stefandxm has left
  490. Ge0rG winfried: if the message is discarded, it doesn't matter. If it is stored, the recipient is the most logical person
  491. forensic58 has joined
  492. winfried Ge0rG: correct
  493. pep. I'd like to see setups where there is no offline storage / MAM at all
  494. winfried Have you seen the pdf I posted to the members list? Is that the way to go for the consequences for server operators? (Q1.2)
  495. winfried (oops it was odg)
  496. winfried (silence)
  497. pep. yes, digesting all this
  498. Wiktor has left
  499. jonasw still sick :(
  500. jonasw I’m half-following
  501. winfried jonasw: :-( hope you get better soon!
  502. jonasw thanks
  503. Ge0rG I didn't see a PDF, but there was an .odg
  504. winfried :-D
  505. pep. The table?
  506. pep. So today is clarification day
  507. pep. How are we regarding things that can be sent to standards@ already
  508. winfried GDPR scheme.odg attached to a reply to minutes 10
  509. andy has left
  510. andy has joined
  511. andy has left
  512. andy has joined
  513. alacer has joined
  514. pep. hmm, should we plan for next, doesn't seem to be really active today
  515. winfried Waiting for reactions... ;-)
  516. andy has joined
  517. Ge0rG winfried: waiting for the mail server? Forget it.
  518. jonasw why waiting for the email server?
  519. pep. winfried, you're talking about https://wiki.xmpp.org/web/GDPR/Table ?
  520. Ge0rG winfried> GDPR scheme.odg attached to a reply to minutes 10
  521. jonasw Ge0rG, it’s already been sent last week
  522. jonasw https://sotecware.net/images/dont-puush-me/bOy6D9sQg3BxiP0GYdDkXcUBcdfc3o2_Pi4PW-5zUdQ.png
  523. jonasw that’s a screen shot of it
  524. Ge0rG oh, I misread that as "10 minutes ago" and was looking for new replies.
  525. jonasw timestamp of the mail is 2018-05-08 11:56Z
  526. pep. oh
  527. Ge0rG yeah, had that open already.
  528. winfried jonasw: that is the first page
  529. jonasw there are more pages?
  530. jonasw ugh
  531. pep. winfried, "on a large scale", is this even important?
  532. jonasw I don’t know that tool
  533. Ge0rG Oh, there is a second page!
  534. jonasw I assumed when I scroll down and reach the end of a page there aren’t more pages :D
  535. lskdjf has joined
  536. winfried jonasw: yeah bad UI
  537. Dave Cridland has left
  538. winfried pep.: not for the XSF context, but it helps asses server operators if they should to anything
  539. pep. hmm
  540. pep. I guess I should start working on that XEP quick
  541. pep. 10days to write it and get it council approved(tm)!
  542. winfried :-D
  543. pep. And just after that, deployed everywhere!
  544. jonasw noooot gonna happen
  545. jonasw unless you manage to submit it today :)
  546. pep. hmm
  547. pep. nope
  548. SaltyBones has left
  549. winfried of you don't have your act together on the 25th in the Netherlands, you may get a warning and some more months to correct it :-P
  550. pep. cool
  551. pep. I guess they'll have to do that for a lot more people
  552. winfried any amendments to the scheme?
  553. Ge0rG in Austria you get a warning. Full stop.
  554. pep. winfried, template looks ok to me. Maybe alongside MAM specify offline storage
  555. mimi89999 has left
  556. pep. How do you even set offline storage available but not active by default
  557. Ge0rG winfried: step 5 might be "require consent for processing beyond the XSF template"
  558. winfried good points!
  559. winfried maybe split step 5 in two options: when using the XSF template (or equivalent) or when doing processing beyond that.
  560. pep. Zash, MattJ, is there a way to have offline storage stanby and do nothing atm?
  561. MattJ Hmm?
  562. pep. Have offline storage opt-in
  563. winfried Next meeting: friday 13:30 CEST
  564. pep. winfried, ok
  565. MattJ pep., not currently possible to configure per-user, if that's what you mean
  566. vanitasvitae has left
  567. pep. ok, I guess that also need changing in the protocol
  568. MattJ Totally possible, just not implemented
  569. pep. ah ok
  570. MattJ Well, M-Link uses ad-hoc commands for that
  571. MattJ Though a number of clients don't support them
  572. pep. Yeah so it's not specified
  573. ibikk has joined
  574. pep. -xep offline
  575. pep. Bunneh! where are you when I need you
  576. MattJ I always wanted a "user account configuration" XEP
  577. efrit has joined
  578. pep. There is IBR, in some ways
  579. SaltyBones has joined
  580. Ge0rG With data forms! And hookers!
  581. winfried pep.: do you summarize minutes again?
  582. pep. winfried, I'll try to do that yes :x
  583. winfried pep.: thanks!
  584. winfried then there is one thing left for me:
  585. winfried *bangs* the gavel
  586. winfried thanks once again guys!
  587. pep. Ge0rG, and jonasw ok with the date?
  588. jonasw thanks folks
  589. Ge0rG pep.: hope so
  590. jonasw pep., yes, still OK
  591. pep. k
  592. pep. Updated the date on the wiki
  593. winfried pep.: thanks!
  594. dwd has joined
  595. dwd has left
  596. lskdjf has joined
  597. lumi has joined
  598. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  599. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  600. tux has joined
  601. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  602. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  603. alexis has left
  604. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  605. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  606. Tobias has joined
  607. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  608. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  609. ta has joined
  610. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  611. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  612. alexis has joined
  613. Dave Cridland has left
  614. andy has left
  615. rtq3 has left
  616. lorddavidiii has left
  617. lorddavidiii has joined
  618. alexis has left
  619. alexis has joined
  620. edhelas winfried I'm telling it you here, I don't have OMEMO on my device, so please desactivate it with my JID
  621. rion has joined
  622. winfried Done, thank Daniel :-P
  623. alexis has left
  624. Dave Cridland has left
  625. alexis has joined
  626. edhelas because I'm getting more and more like that I'm thinking of an automatic reply
  627. Holger edhelas: I could sell you <https://github.com/processone/ejabberd-contrib/tree/master/mod_deny_omemo> ...
  628. edhelas no it's more a client side feature
  629. goffi has left
  630. alexis has left
  631. alexis has joined
  632. remko has joined
  633. remko has left
  634. remko has joined
  635. alexis has left
  636. alexis has joined
  637. Guus has left
  638. Dave Cridland has left
  639. alexis has left
  640. alexis has joined
  641. rtq3 has joined
  642. Guus has left
  643. Guus has left
  644. Guus has left
  645. Guus has joined
  646. Dave Cridland has left
  647. dwd has joined
  648. daniel has left
  649. stefandxm has joined
  650. daniel has joined
  651. blabla has left
  652. blabla has joined
  653. Dave Cridland has left
  654. efrit has left
  655. alexis has left
  656. Neustradamus has left
  657. alexis has joined
  658. moparisthebest has joined
  659. lovetox has left
  660. rtq3 has left
  661. stefandxm has left
  662. matlag has left
  663. matlag has joined
  664. lnj has joined
  665. goffi has joined
  666. Tobias has left
  667. lskdjf has joined
  668. Dave Cridland has left
  669. dwd has left
  670. dwd has joined
  671. Dave Cridland has left
  672. la|r|ma has joined
  673. Guus has left
  674. blabla has joined
  675. dwd has left
  676. lskdjf has joined
  677. mimi89999 has joined
  678. j.r has joined
  679. rtq3 has joined
  680. dwd has joined
  681. dwd has left
  682. jubalh has joined
  683. lovetox has joined
  684. goffi has left
  685. goffi has joined
  686. Dave Cridland has left
  687. Tobias has joined
  688. nyco has left
  689. nyco has joined
  690. rtq3 has left
  691. rtq3 has joined
  692. jjrh has left
  693. jjrh has left
  694. Wiktor has joined
  695. Wiktor has joined
  696. marmistrz has joined
  697. Guus has left
  698. Guus has left
  699. Guus has joined
  700. lovetox has left
  701. lnj has left
  702. lnj has joined
  703. lskdjf has left
  704. lskdjf has joined
  705. jere has left
  706. jere has joined
  707. Dave Cridland has left
  708. jubalh has left
  709. SaltyBones has left
  710. SaltyBones has joined
  711. jjrh has left
  712. jubalh has joined
  713. stefandxm has joined
  714. la|r|ma has joined
  715. la|r|ma has joined
  716. jubalh has left
  717. jubalh has joined
  718. Syndace has joined
  719. rion has left
  720. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  721. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  722. rion has joined
  723. jubalh has left
  724. alacer has left
  725. alacer has joined
  726. jubalh has joined
  727. rion has left
  728. ralphm has left
  729. rion has joined
  730. stefandxm has left
  731. Dave Cridland has left
  732. jubalh has left
  733. Wiktor has left
  734. dwd has joined
  735. Ge0rG has left
  736. ralphm has joined
  737. blabla has joined
  738. dwd has left
  739. alacer has left
  740. alacer has joined
  741. Guus has left
  742. marmistrz has joined
  743. Guus has left
  744. lorddavidiii has left
  745. lorddavidiii has joined
  746. alexis has left
  747. alexis has joined
  748. Lance has joined
  749. alexis has left
  750. rion has left
  751. alexis has joined
  752. rion has joined
  753. Ge0rG has left
  754. stefandxm has joined
  755. winfried has left
  756. mhterres has joined
  757. mhterres has left
  758. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  759. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  760. Guus has left
  761. Guus has left
  762. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  763. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  764. Guus has joined
  765. rion has left
  766. lorddavidiii has left
  767. lovetox has joined
  768. mimi89999 has joined
  769. marmistrz has joined
  770. Lance has left
  771. j.r has joined
  772. matlag has joined
  773. matlag has joined
  774. Ge0rG has left
  775. jubalh has joined
  776. jubalh has left
  777. Ge0rG has left
  778. winfried has left
  779. winfried has left
  780. winfried has joined
  781. winfried has left
  782. winfried has joined
  783. winfried has left
  784. lskdjf has joined
  785. lskdjf has joined
  786. winfried has joined
  787. winfried has left
  788. jubalh has joined
  789. jubalh has left
  790. winfried has joined
  791. jere has joined
  792. Ge0rG has left
  793. SaltyBones has left
  794. SaltyBones has joined
  795. Guus has left
  796. Ge0rG has left
  797. Holger has left
  798. ralphm has left
  799. jere has joined
  800. alexis has left
  801. alexis has joined
  802. Guus has left
  803. jere has left
  804. jere has joined
  805. marmistrz has left
  806. jjrh has left
  807. jjrh has left
  808. alexis has left
  809. alexis has joined
  810. jjrh has left
  811. jubalh has joined
  812. lorddavidiii has joined
  813. jjrh has left
  814. jjrh has left
  815. jjrh has left
  816. alexis has left
  817. alexis has joined
  818. stefandxm has left
  819. alexis has left
  820. alexis has joined
  821. Ge0rG Dave Cridland: was there an update to hacx to put it onto the agenda again? Cc jonasw
  822. moparisthebest nope will get it out tonight if we don't have another unexpected area-wide power outage :)
  823. rtq3 has left
  824. jonasw Ge0rG, not that I knew
  825. forensic58 has left
  826. forensic58 has joined
  827. andrey.g has left
  828. SaltyBones has left
  829. jubalh has left
  830. andrey.g has joined
  831. jjrh has left
  832. lnj has left
  833. forensic58 has left
  834. Steve Kille has left
  835. Steve Kille has left
  836. lorddavidiii has left
  837. Steve Kille has left
  838. Steve Kille has joined
  839. lorddavidiii has joined
  840. goffi has left
  841. jubalh has left
  842. Syndace has joined
  843. SaltyBones has joined
  844. Nekit has left
  845. Nekit has joined
  846. rtq3 has joined
  847. rtq3 has left
  848. rtq3 has joined
  849. j.r has left
  850. j.r has joined
  851. jubalh has joined
  852. Chobbes has joined
  853. valo has left
  854. Dave Cridland has left
  855. valo has joined
  856. dwd has joined
  857. Dave Cridland has left
  858. dwd has left
  859. la|r|ma has left
  860. dwd has joined
  861. Dave Cridland has left
  862. tux has joined
  863. rtq3 has left
  864. rtq3 has joined
  865. rtq3 has left
  866. winfried has joined
  867. rtq3 has joined
  868. stefandxm has joined
  869. dwd has left
  870. Dave Cridland has left
  871. forensic58 has joined
  872. jubalh has left
  873. valo has joined
  874. valo has joined
  875. forensic58 has left
  876. Dave Cridland has left
  877. dwd has joined
  878. valo has left
  879. valo has joined
  880. forensic58 has joined
  881. dwd has left
  882. rion has joined
  883. tux has joined
  884. tux has joined
  885. ibikk has joined
  886. rtq3 has left
  887. forensic58 has left
  888. forensic58 has joined
  889. goffi has joined
  890. Guus has left
  891. Guus has left
  892. Guus has joined
  893. j.r has joined
  894. j.r has joined
  895. stefandxm has left
  896. rion has left
  897. forensic58 has left
  898. Guus has left
  899. rion has joined
  900. Guus has left
  901. Guus has left
  902. Guus has left
  903. marc has left
  904. stefandxm has joined
  905. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  906. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  907. forensic58 has joined
  908. SaltyBones has left
  909. forensic58 has left
  910. SamWhited has left
  911. Alex has joined
  912. andy has joined
  913. waqas has joined
  914. matlag has joined
  915. matlag has joined
  916. Guus has left
  917. Guus has left
  918. SaltyBones has joined
  919. Guus has left
  920. Guus has left
  921. Guus has joined
  922. jubalh has joined
  923. jubalh has left
  924. Andrew Nenakhov has left
  925. Andrew Nenakhov has joined
  926. rtq3 has joined
  927. blabla has joined
  928. forensic58 has joined
  929. blabla has joined
  930. ThibG has joined
  931. ThibG has left
  932. j.r has left
  933. j.r has joined
  934. forensic58 has left
  935. winfried has left
  936. rtq3 has left
  937. rtq3 has joined
  938. rtq3 has left
  939. rtq3 has joined
  940. Yagiza has left
  941. ThibG has joined
  942. ibikk has joined
  943. Guus has left
  944. Chobbes has joined
  945. Tobias has joined
  946. remko has left
  947. vanitasvitae has left
  948. Ge0rG has left
  949. rtq3 has left
  950. blabla has joined
  951. daniel has left
  952. vanitasvitae has left
  953. Alex has left
  954. rtq3 has joined
  955. edhelas has left
  956. marmistrz has left
  957. vanitasvitae has left
  958. vanitasvitae has left
  959. jubalh has joined
  960. andy has left
  961. jubalh has left
  962. marc has left
  963. edhelas has left
  964. blabla has joined
  965. jubalh has joined
  966. Nekit has joined
  967. moparisthebest has joined
  968. Steve Kille has left
  969. Steve Kille has left
  970. valo has joined
  971. forensic58 has joined
  972. vanitasvitae has left
  973. marmistrz has joined
  974. lskdjf has left
  975. lskdjf has left
  976. lskdjf has left
  977. lskdjf has joined
  978. lorddavidiii has left
  979. lskdjf has joined
  980. forensic58 has left
  981. lnj has left
  982. rtq3 has left
  983. rtq3 has joined
  984. Dave Cridland No
  985. marmistrz has left
  986. blabla has joined
  987. test has joined
  988. jubalh has left
  989. edhelas has left
  990. edhelas has joined
  991. test has left
  992. marmistrz has left
  993. Guus has left
  994. moparisthebest has joined
  995. marmistrz has joined
  996. Guus has left
  997. jubalh has joined
  998. jere has left
  999. jere has joined
  1000. jubalh has left
  1001. lovetox has left
  1002. seandreas has joined
  1003. Chobbes has joined
  1004. mimi89999 has left
  1005. rtq3 has left
  1006. marmistrz has joined
  1007. moparisthebest has left
  1008. lnj has left
  1009. valo has joined
  1010. rtq3 has joined
  1011. Guus has left
  1012. Guus has left
  1013. Guus has joined
  1014. j.r has joined
  1015. seandreas has left
  1016. vanitasvitae has left
  1017. moparisthebest has joined
  1018. Dave Cridland has left
  1019. dwd has joined
  1020. goffi has left
  1021. seandreas has joined
  1022. marmistrz has joined
  1023. Dave Cridland has left
  1024. dwd has left
  1025. j.r has joined
  1026. dwd has joined
  1027. Guus has left
  1028. Steve Kille has left
  1029. Guus has left
  1030. dwd has left
  1031. seandreas has left
  1032. jjrh has left
  1033. rtq3 has left
  1034. lumi has left
  1035. seandreas has joined
  1036. marc has left
  1037. SaltyBones has left
  1038. SaltyBones has joined
  1039. seandreas has left
  1040. seandreas has joined
  1041. lskdjf has left
  1042. lskdjf has left
  1043. Holger has left
  1044. blabla has joined
  1045. rtq3 has joined
  1046. lnj has left
  1047. efrit has joined
  1048. j.r has joined
  1049. seandreas has joined
  1050. j.r has joined
  1051. UsL has left
  1052. rtq3 has left
  1053. la|r|ma has joined
  1054. j.r has joined
  1055. moparisthebest has joined
  1056. forensic58 has joined
  1057. seandreas has joined
  1058. nyco has left
  1059. nyco has joined
  1060. forensic58 has left