XMPP Council - 2016-05-25

it is time

0) Roll call

Afternoon.

Tobias MattJ psa Dave Cridland

here

here

Here

ralphm, You're three years late.

1) ProtoXEP: http://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/spam-report.html

I'm +1

will vote on list

Hey

+1 :)

+1, though I think it needs work.

Dave Cridland, I look forward to your feedback

I think it's good as it is

psa?

You don't have it? I thought I'd sent to the list.

Oh, I guess I missed it

I'm not sure how it interacts with / replaces http://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0287.html

but I can post to the list about it

ta

2) http://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/userrating.html

This one I think needs more work, but I'm +1 to experimental

will vote on list

(I see that Matthew already replied to the query about XEP-0287 so I'm +1 to publishing spam-report)

and userrating also replaces http://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0275.html

I see that we're in reinvent the wheel mode :-)

Ah, I'm confused.

I will post to the list about userrating

It'#s user rating I sent feedback on, not spam reporting.

Ah, ok

i'll vote on list as well for userrating

3) Date of next

Maybe I should actually look at both in the light of 287/275 and see whether this is just a duplication or if it's introducing something genuinely new.

on first view I see some overlap between 275 and userrating

perhaps some combination is in order

Date of next, sbtsbc?

Lance, wfm

WFM

btw: who moves things from https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pulls on our agenda?

wfm

4) AOB?

Tobias: maybe our Chair?

no AOB except Tobias's question

that'd be me

psa, Dave Cridland: User Rating definitely has some overlap with XEP-0275

ah..ok

No AOB here

No AOB.

no further aob here

thanks all

thx Lance

MattJ, Overlap is OK. Complete replacement is OK. But only if we think 275/287 is a dead-end technically.

As mentioned on the list, I don't think Spam Reporting has much overlap with XEP-0287

👍 will publish the reporting one and the outstanding jingle PR when I'm next at my desk.

a more accurate title would be User Blocking Annotations

SamWhited, there's also a XEP-300 PR

Yeah, I think the title could be improved for clarity

Anyone have ideas for a shortname for the spam reporting one?

Do we really use shortnames?

They're in there, so I assumed we should create one but I have no idea what it's actually for ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Xep-Editor-Tastic!

Because mam or pubsub is better than typing out the full xep title

And settling on a single short name is useful

I remember something about shortnames being assigned when it's draft or somesuch

Lance, where did I +1 for spam reports? i said i'll vote on list ;)

woops. sorry about that, misread lines :(

no problem :)

SamWhited: Smack uses shortnames as part of the java package scheme of the API. I've already requested the editor to keep a registry of shortnames to keep them unique. That would be really great.

Yep, shortnames are really useful

Yah, short names sound good to me. I don't know that anyone is handling registrar stuff right now?