XMPP Council - 2016-05-25

  1. m&m has left
  2. Tobias has left
  3. Tobias has left
  4. SamWhited has left
  5. SamWhited has left
  6. Tokodomo has left
  7. Tokodomo has left
  8. Tobias has joined
  9. Lance has left
  10. SamWhited has joined
  11. Lance has joined
  12. Lance has left
  13. SouL has left
  14. Lance has joined
  15. SouL has left
  16. SamWhited has left
  17. SamWhited has joined
  18. Flow has joined
  19. Flow has left
  20. SouL has left
  21. SouL has left
  22. Flow has joined
  23. Tokodomo has joined
  24. Flow has left
  25. Dave Cridland has left
  26. SouL has left
  27. SouL has left
  28. Flow has joined
  29. Dave Cridland has left
  30. ralphm has left
  31. Dave Cridland has left
  32. Dave Cridland has left
  33. Dave Cridland has left
  34. SouL has left
  35. SouL has left
  36. Lance has joined
  37. SouL has left
  38. SouL has left
  39. SouL has left
  40. Tokodomo has left
  41. Tobias has joined
  42. ralphm has left
  43. Dave Cridland has left
  44. ralphm has left
  45. m&m has joined
  46. SamWhited has joined
  47. SamWhited has joined
  48. psa has joined
  49. psa has left
  50. psa has left
  51. psa has joined
  52. Lance has joined
  53. Flow has left
  54. ralphm has left
  55. Lance it is time
  56. Lance 0) Roll call
  57. Dave Cridland Afternoon.
  58. Lance Tobias MattJ psa Dave Cridland
  59. psa here
  60. Tobias here
  61. SamWhited is not here to take notes again; sorry. Poorly timed meetings.
  62. ralphm Here
  63. Dave Cridland ralphm, You're three years late.
  64. Lance 1) ProtoXEP: http://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/spam-report.html
  65. Lance I'm +1
  66. Tobias will vote on list
  67. MattJ Hey
  68. MattJ +1 :)
  69. Dave Cridland +1, though I think it needs work.
  70. MattJ Dave Cridland, I look forward to your feedback
  71. MattJ I think it's good as it is
  72. Lance psa?
  73. Dave Cridland You don't have it? I thought I'd sent to the list.
  74. MattJ Oh, I guess I missed it
  75. psa I'm not sure how it interacts with / replaces http://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0287.html
  76. psa but I can post to the list about it
  77. Lance ta
  78. Lance 2) http://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/userrating.html
  79. MattJ This one I think needs more work, but I'm +1 to experimental
  80. Tobias will vote on list
  81. psa (I see that Matthew already replied to the query about XEP-0287 so I'm +1 to publishing spam-report)
  82. psa and userrating also replaces http://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0275.html
  83. psa I see that we're in reinvent the wheel mode :-)
  84. Dave Cridland Ah, I'm confused.
  85. psa I will post to the list about userrating
  86. Dave Cridland It'#s user rating I sent feedback on, not spam reporting.
  87. MattJ Ah, ok
  88. Lance i'll vote on list as well for userrating
  89. Lance 3) Date of next
  90. Dave Cridland Maybe I should actually look at both in the light of 287/275 and see whether this is just a duplication or if it's introducing something genuinely new.
  91. psa on first view I see some overlap between 275 and userrating
  92. psa perhaps some combination is in order
  93. Flow has joined
  94. Lance Date of next, sbtsbc?
  95. Tobias Lance, wfm
  96. psa WFM
  97. Tobias btw: who moves things from https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pulls on our agenda?
  98. MattJ wfm
  99. Lance 4) AOB?
  100. psa Tobias: maybe our Chair?
  101. psa no AOB except Tobias's question
  102. Lance that'd be me
  103. MattJ psa, Dave Cridland: User Rating definitely has some overlap with XEP-0275
  104. Tobias ah..ok
  105. MattJ No AOB here
  106. Dave Cridland No AOB.
  107. Tobias no further aob here
  108. Lance bangs gavel
  109. Lance thanks all
  110. Tobias thx Lance
  111. Dave Cridland MattJ, Overlap is OK. Complete replacement is OK. But only if we think 275/287 is a dead-end technically.
  112. MattJ As mentioned on the list, I don't think Spam Reporting has much overlap with XEP-0287
  113. SamWhited 👍 will publish the reporting one and the outstanding jingle PR when I'm next at my desk.
  114. Lance a more accurate title would be User Blocking Annotations
  115. SamWhited has left
  116. Tobias SamWhited, there's also a XEP-300 PR
  117. MattJ Yeah, I think the title could be improved for clarity
  118. ralphm has left
  119. psa has left
  120. SamWhited Anyone have ideas for a shortname for the spam reporting one?
  121. Flow has joined
  122. Flow has joined
  123. Dave Cridland Do we really use shortnames?
  124. SamWhited They're in there, so I assumed we should create one but I have no idea what it's actually for ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
  125. Dave Cridland Xep-Editor-Tastic!
  126. ralphm Because mam or pubsub is better than typing out the full xep title
  127. ralphm And settling on a single short name is useful
  128. Flow has left
  129. Flow has joined
  130. Flow has left
  131. Zash has joined
  132. Zash I remember something about shortnames being assigned when it's draft or somesuch
  133. Dave Cridland has left
  134. Flow has joined
  135. psa has left
  136. psa has left
  137. psa has left
  138. Dave Cridland has left
  139. psa has left
  140. psa has joined
  141. m&m has left
  142. m&m has joined
  143. psa has left
  144. psa has joined
  145. psa has left
  146. psa has left
  147. Dave Cridland has left
  148. Dave Cridland has left
  149. Dave Cridland has left
  150. psa has joined
  151. Dave Cridland has left
  152. Dave Cridland has left
  153. Dave Cridland has left
  154. Dave Cridland has left
  155. Dave Cridland has left
  156. Tobias Lance, where did I +1 for spam reports? i said i'll vote on list ;)
  157. Lance woops. sorry about that, misread lines :(
  158. Tobias no problem :)
  159. Flow SamWhited: Smack uses shortnames as part of the java package scheme of the API. I've already requested the editor to keep a registry of shortnames to keep them unique. That would be really great.
  160. Flow also thinks that shortnames should be assigned in 'experimental' (but i could not found an official policy on that or if they need to be unique)
  161. Tobias has left
  162. Zash has left
  163. Dave Cridland has left
  164. Flow has left
  165. psa has left
  166. psa has joined
  167. MattJ Yep, shortnames are really useful
  168. psa has left
  169. psa has joined
  170. psa has left
  171. SamWhited Yah, short names sound good to me. I don't know that anyone is handling registrar stuff right now?
  172. m&m has left
  173. psa has left
  174. psa has left
  175. psa has left
  176. psa has left
  177. SouL has left