This one I think needs more work, but I'm +1 to experimental
Tobias
will vote on list
psa
(I see that Matthew already replied to the query about XEP-0287 so I'm +1 to publishing spam-report)
psa
and userrating also replaces http://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0275.html
psa
I see that we're in reinvent the wheel mode :-)
Dave Cridland
Ah, I'm confused.
psa
I will post to the list about userrating
Dave Cridland
It'#s user rating I sent feedback on, not spam reporting.
MattJ
Ah, ok
Lance
i'll vote on list as well for userrating
Lance
3) Date of next
Dave Cridland
Maybe I should actually look at both in the light of 287/275 and see whether this is just a duplication or if it's introducing something genuinely new.
psa
on first view I see some overlap between 275 and userrating
psa
perhaps some combination is in order
Flowhas joined
Lance
Date of next, sbtsbc?
Tobias
Lance, wfm
psa
WFM
Tobias
btw: who moves things from https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pulls on our agenda?
MattJ
wfm
Lance
4) AOB?
psa
Tobias: maybe our Chair?
psa
no AOB except Tobias's question
Lance
that'd be me
MattJ
psa, Dave Cridland: User Rating definitely has some overlap with XEP-0275
Tobias
ah..ok
MattJ
No AOB here
Dave Cridland
No AOB.
Tobias
no further aob here
Lancebangs gavel
Lance
thanks all
Tobias
thx Lance
Dave Cridland
MattJ, Overlap is OK. Complete replacement is OK. But only if we think 275/287 is a dead-end technically.
MattJ
As mentioned on the list, I don't think Spam Reporting has much overlap with XEP-0287
SamWhited
👍 will publish the reporting one and the outstanding jingle PR when I'm next at my desk.
Lance
a more accurate title would be User Blocking Annotations
SamWhitedhas left
Tobias
SamWhited, there's also a XEP-300 PR
MattJ
Yeah, I think the title could be improved for clarity
ralphmhas left
psahas left
SamWhited
Anyone have ideas for a shortname for the spam reporting one?
Flowhas joined
Flowhas joined
Dave Cridland
Do we really use shortnames?
SamWhited
They're in there, so I assumed we should create one but I have no idea what it's actually for ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Dave Cridland
Xep-Editor-Tastic!
ralphm
Because mam or pubsub is better than typing out the full xep title
ralphm
And settling on a single short name is useful
Flowhas left
Flowhas joined
Flowhas left
Zashhas joined
Zash
I remember something about shortnames being assigned when it's draft or somesuch
Dave Cridlandhas left
Flowhas joined
psahas left
psahas left
psahas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
psahas left
psahas joined
m&mhas left
m&mhas joined
psahas left
psahas joined
psahas left
psahas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
psahas joined
Dave Cridlandhas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
Tobias
Lance, where did I +1 for spam reports? i said i'll vote on list ;)
Lance
woops. sorry about that, misread lines :(
Tobias
no problem :)
Flow
SamWhited: Smack uses shortnames as part of the java package scheme of the API. I've already requested the editor to keep a registry of shortnames to keep them unique. That would be really great.
Flowalso thinks that shortnames should be assigned in 'experimental' (but i could not found an official policy on that or if they need to be unique)
Tobiashas left
Zashhas left
Dave Cridlandhas left
Flowhas left
psahas left
psahas joined
MattJ
Yep, shortnames are really useful
psahas left
psahas joined
psahas left
SamWhited
Yah, short names sound good to me. I don't know that anyone is handling registrar stuff right now?