XMPP Council - 2016-06-29

Lance, FYI, for todays agenda https://trello.com/c/y65m0uzI/109-use-of-trello-for-council-editor-flow

thanks!

Also Flow wants to add the status of CSI

it is time

0) Roll call

here

here

MattJ Dave Cridland

Here

1) Use of Trello for Council/Editor flow

I'm in favor of this

+1

and we need to cleanup the current trello state

WFM

+1

2) Followup on Carbons

I can create a PR for my suggestions

Thanks :)

the main thing is overlap with that other XEP

Are you blocking until those are merged?

what other XEP?

MAM?

<private/> vs. <no-copy/>

http://mail.jabber.org/pipermail/standards/2015-September/030288.html

I suggested that we punt on it for now to get the rest of Carbons to Draft

also this feels like a less central feature than everything else

+1, let's get the rest to draft

I can pull that out in my PR too

thanks stpeter

Once that PR is merged Carbons can go to draft :)

yay!

2) Move CSI to Draft

sounds good

MattJ: is CSI ready to advance?

I believe so... it had an LC, I don't think there was any actionable feedback? I'd have to go and check to be 100% sure though

Right, it was https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/44

which was approved unanimously

So yes, it's good to advance

Ok, then let's vote on it

I'm +1

+1

+1

I'll vote on list - need to read it again

ta

4) Date of next

sbtsbc?

wfm

I'll be offline next week.

but feel free to proceed without me and I can catch up on the list

wfm

5) AOB?

perhaps we can all put some energy into cleaning up the Trello board

I know I have some GitHub issues / PRs to review

do all council members have access?

I thought so, double checking

ah, looks like Matt does not

Any other AOB?

none here

thanks all

thank you

i'll try to collect the votes from the mail archive in the trello cards for the inbox xeps

one negative vote on a protoxep is enough to not-accept it, correct? https://trello.com/c/JNnenvRn/84-http-xmpp-org-extensions-inbox-jid-mention-html shouldn't we send an official mail on that thread in that case, mark it done and move on?

correct

ah..there already was a card with voting info https://trello.com/c/OdcdWIhf/82-proposed-extension-jid-mention

maybe something for the editors column then?

yeah

that'd make sense

https://trello.com/c/RMyQ010D/94-proposed-extension-instant-stream-resumption-isr what's with this one?

it has two negative vots on it apparently

Hi all, catching up from this morning… I see that there is a "For Editors" column now; thanks! I'm hoping to make at least a little time this week to actually process a bit of the queue that's building up. I'll keep an eye on that column in case things change.

Although the only thing in that column right now is the JID mention XEP, and that doesn't appear to have votes checked

Oh, nevermind, I see why; needs a response.

SamWhited, basically Dave voted -1 on it...and that kind of makes other votes moot