XMPP Council - 2018-10-03


  1. Dave has left

  2. Dave has joined

  3. dwd has joined

  4. Dave has left

  5. dwd has left

  6. dwd has joined

  7. Dave has joined

  8. dwd has left

  9. Dave has left

  10. Dave has joined

  11. dwd has joined

  12. dwd has left

  13. Dave has left

  14. dwd has joined

  15. Dave has joined

  16. peter has joined

  17. dwd has left

  18. dwd has joined

  19. SamWhited has left

  20. Dave has left

  21. Dave has joined

  22. dwd has left

  23. dwd has joined

  24. Dave has left

  25. dwd has left

  26. Dave has joined

  27. dwd has joined

  28. Dave has left

  29. Dave has joined

  30. dwd has left

  31. Dave has left

  32. Dave has joined

  33. dwd has joined

  34. dwd has left

  35. SamWhited has left

  36. dwd has joined

  37. peter has left

  38. dwd has left

  39. dwd has joined

  40. dwd has left

  41. moparisthebest has joined

  42. moparisthebest has joined

  43. dwd has joined

  44. moparisthebest has joined

  45. moparisthebest has joined

  46. dwd has left

  47. dwd has joined

  48. Dave has left

  49. Dave has joined

  50. dwd has left

  51. dwd has joined

  52. Dave has left

  53. dwd has left

  54. dwd has joined

  55. Dave has joined

  56. dwd has left

  57. dwd has joined

  58. dwd has left

  59. dwd has joined

  60. dwd has left

  61. moparisthebest has left

  62. Dave has left

  63. Dave has joined

  64. dwd has joined

  65. Dave has left

  66. dwd has left

  67. Dave has joined

  68. dwd has joined

  69. dwd has left

  70. ralphm has left

  71. Dave has left

  72. Dave has joined

  73. dwd has joined

  74. Dave has left

  75. dwd has left

  76. Dave has joined

  77. dwd has joined

  78. Dave has left

  79. Dave has joined

  80. Dave has left

  81. Dave has joined

  82. dwd has left

  83. dwd has joined

  84. Dave has left

  85. Dave has joined

  86. dwd has left

  87. dwd has joined

  88. Dave has left

  89. dwd has left

  90. dwd has joined

  91. Dave has joined

  92. labdsf has left

  93. dwd has left

  94. Dave has left

  95. Dave has joined

  96. Dave has left

  97. dwd has joined

  98. dwd has left

  99. Dave has joined

  100. dwd has joined

  101. dwd has left

  102. Dave has left

  103. Dave has joined

  104. dwd has joined

  105. martin has joined

  106. Dave has left

  107. dwd has left

  108. Dave has joined

  109. dwd has joined

  110. Dave has left

  111. Dave has joined

  112. dwd has left

  113. dwd has joined

  114. Dave has left

  115. dwd has left

  116. Dave has joined

  117. dwd has joined

  118. dwd has left

  119. dwd has joined

  120. Tobias has joined

  121. Tobias has joined

  122. dwd has left

  123. dwd has joined

  124. dwd has left

  125. labdsf has joined

  126. labdsf has left

  127. labdsf has joined

  128. flow has joined

  129. Dave has left

  130. Dave has joined

  131. dwd has joined

  132. labdsf has left

  133. Dave has left

  134. dwd has left

  135. Dave has joined

  136. martin has left

  137. dwd has joined

  138. guus.der.kinderen has left

  139. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  140. ralphm has left

  141. dwd has left

  142. guus.der.kinderen has left

  143. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  144. Dave has left

  145. Dave has joined

  146. dwd has joined

  147. guus.der.kinderen has left

  148. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  149. guus.der.kinderen has left

  150. moparisthebest has joined

  151. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  152. guus.der.kinderen has left

  153. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  154. Dave has left

  155. dwd has left

  156. dwd has joined

  157. Dave has joined

  158. Dave has left

  159. Dave has joined

  160. dwd has left

  161. Dave has left

  162. Dave has joined

  163. dwd has joined

  164. dwd has left

  165. guus.der.kinderen has left

  166. labdsf has joined

  167. Zash has left

  168. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  169. dwd has joined

  170. Zash has left

  171. dwd has left

  172. dwd has joined

  173. dwd has left

  174. daniel has left

  175. dwd has joined

  176. lnj has joined

  177. dwd has left

  178. dwd has joined

  179. labdsf has left

  180. labdsf has joined

  181. dwd has left

  182. Dave has left

  183. Dave has joined

  184. dwd has joined

  185. guus.der.kinderen has left

  186. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  187. guus.der.kinderen has left

  188. martin has joined

  189. dwd has left

  190. dwd has joined

  191. dwd has left

  192. daniel has left

  193. daniel has joined

  194. daniel has left

  195. daniel has joined

  196. daniel has left

  197. daniel has joined

  198. daniel has left

  199. daniel has joined

  200. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  201. guus.der.kinderen has left

  202. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  203. daniel has left

  204. daniel has joined

  205. guus.der.kinderen has left

  206. dwd has joined

  207. daniel has left

  208. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  209. daniel has joined

  210. dwd has left

  211. dwd has joined

  212. dwd has left

  213. dwd has joined

  214. labdsf has left

  215. guus.der.kinderen has left

  216. labdsf has joined

  217. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  218. guus.der.kinderen has left

  219. Tobias has left

  220. Tobias has joined

  221. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  222. Tobias has joined

  223. Tobias has joined

  224. jonas’ has joined

  225. jonas’ has joined

  226. Tobias has left

  227. Tobias has joined

  228. genofire has left

  229. genofire has joined

  230. guus.der.kinderen has left

  231. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  232. jonas’ has joined

  233. guus.der.kinderen has left

  234. genofire has left

  235. daniel has left

  236. daniel has joined

  237. labdsf has left

  238. daniel has left

  239. daniel has joined

  240. labdsf has joined

  241. daniel has left

  242. daniel has joined

  243. lnj has left

  244. Dave has left

  245. Dave has joined

  246. dwd has left

  247. dwd has joined

  248. genofire has joined

  249. dwd has left

  250. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  251. labdsf has left

  252. pep. has left

  253. dwd has joined

  254. labdsf has joined

  255. peter has joined

  256. peter has left

  257. Dave has left

  258. Dave has joined

  259. Dave has left

  260. dwd has left

  261. Dave has joined

  262. labdsf has left

  263. dwd has joined

  264. dwd has left

  265. dwd has joined

  266. dwd has left

  267. guus.der.kinderen has left

  268. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  269. Dave has left

  270. Dave has joined

  271. dwd has joined

  272. guus.der.kinderen has left

  273. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  274. dwd has left

  275. dwd has joined

  276. dwd has left

  277. labdsf has joined

  278. dwd has joined

  279. peter has joined

  280. lnj has joined

  281. dwd has left

  282. dwd has joined

  283. dwd has left

  284. peter has left

  285. guus.der.kinderen has left

  286. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  287. guus.der.kinderen has left

  288. dwd has joined

  289. dwd has left

  290. genofire has left

  291. dwd has joined

  292. peter has joined

  293. peter has left

  294. dwd has left

  295. genofire has joined

  296. genofire has left

  297. genofire has joined

  298. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  299. daniel has left

  300. daniel has joined

  301. dwd has joined

  302. lnj has left

  303. lnj has joined

  304. Ge0rG

    It looks like this day of the week again, and I'm more gone than here.

  305. SamWhited

    I'm more gone than here, but I just started a cup of coffee so I should be here in the next 9 minutes

  306. guus.der.kinderen has left

  307. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  308. Ge0rG

    SamWhited: your timing is awesome. I don't have coffee, so nothing is going to change with my situation.

  309. SamWhited

    For once, it's spot on

  310. guus.der.kinderen has left

  311. Kev

    Here.

  312. Kev

    dwd?

  313. daniel

    Here as well

  314. SamWhited

    o/

  315. Kev

    That's quorum, but not a Chair, maybe.

  316. Kev

    Let me dig out the agenda.

  317. Kev

    1) Roll call

  318. Kev

    Me, Daniel, Sam. Ge0rG more not here than here.

  319. Kev

    2) Agenda bashing.

  320. Kev

    Cool

  321. Kev

    3) https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/bookmarks-conversion.html

  322. Kev

    I'm not sure about the implication in the intro that BM2 isn't widely adopted, but that PEP BMs are.

  323. Kev

    (But that's not a blocking comment, naturally)

  324. Ge0rG

    On list

  325. Zash

    I think there are 3 client implementations actually.

  326. daniel

    +1

  327. Kev

    I'll be inclined to go straight to BM2, rather than ever implementing BM/PEP in Swift.

  328. daniel

    Kev: I have so many issues with BM2...

  329. Kev

    But I'm not blocking the protoXEP.

  330. Kev

    (+1)

  331. daniel

    But that's probably a discussion for another day

  332. Kev

    daniel: I don't necessarily mean BM2 as-written, so that might be fair.

  333. SamWhited

    +1

  334. Kev

    4) LC on 359 (stanza IDs)

  335. Kev

    I see no harm in issuing LCs in general, so +1.

  336. SamWhited

    +1 for LC

  337. daniel

    +1

  338. Kev

    5) LC on 357 (push).

  339. Kev

    Again, I see no harm in an LC (even if I don't think it's ready for advancement)

  340. Kev

    +1

  341. daniel

    I don't think it will make it

  342. daniel

    But yeah we can issue it

  343. Ge0rG

    +1 for both LCs

  344. Kev

    The main reason not to is if we're convinced Council is going to -1 advancement, and we can save the Editor some work, I think.

  345. Kev

    I suspect, rather than am convinced, that that's the case.

  346. Kev

    SamWhited?

  347. Dave

    Hiya, sorry - things a little hectic. :-(

  348. SamWhited

    err, sorry +1 on LC for 357 too

  349. daniel

    I'm fairly convinced that push will be -1 after the lc

  350. daniel

    But still +1 for the lc

  351. Kev

    k

  352. SamWhited

    If nothing else it will help flush out feedback from the community, which isn't necessarily bad

  353. Kev

    6) Date of next.

  354. Kev

    (Sam: Indeed)

  355. Kev

    SBTSBC?

  356. SamWhited

    WFM

  357. Kev

    7) AOB?

  358. Link Mauve

    AOB from the floor: what is still missing for the MUC avatars conversion ProtoXEP?

  359. Link Mauve

    AOB from the floor: what is still missing for the MUC avatars ProtoXEP?

  360. Kev

    I fear I missed that one while I was on my nearly-a-month holiday of bliss :)

  361. Kev

    (So I don't know)

  362. Kev

    Anyone else?

  363. Kev

    AFAICs, that had three +1s, and two on-lists a month ago.

  364. Kev

    So unless someone vetod on-list, it's ready to publish.

  365. Kev

    Let's see...

  366. Kev

    Ah, Sam vetod.

  367. SamWhited

    Do you have a link to that email? I'm struggling to find it

  368. Kev

    "Re: [Standards] XMPP Council Meeting 2018-09-05" if that helps.

  369. Kev

    It's the one in which you start by saying it's a great protoxep, and that you're vetoing it :)

  370. SamWhited

    Found it, thanks

  371. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  372. SamWhited

    ah yah, that's why, yup, I agree with myself still.

  373. Kev

    FWIW, I think delaying things that make life a little bit better with avatars, in the hope that some day everything gets sorted out, is probably not the best way here.

  374. Kev

    If people are doing this stuff anyway, interop is better than not, and provides a clear spec to deprecate later.

  375. Link Mauve

    That was my reason for not going full on PEP and postpone this even more.

  376. SamWhited

    I think it's as simple as mentioning that it can be done in one of the other avatar specs instead of completely re-hashing all of vcard-temp

  377. Kev

    I'd rather, I think, we could say at some point in the future "Here are all the ways people do it already. We're now deprecating them all in favour of the One True Ring" than "Here are some of the ways, we're deprecating those, but lots of people did other things and we can't say anything about those".

  378. Link Mauve

    SamWhited, so basically I should remove the examples, and only leave the disco and notification parts?

  379. SamWhited

    Link Mauve: I don't think it should be a separate XEP at all

  380. Dave

    I rather liked edhelas's suggestions for expanding this in such a way that it can do pubsub nodes and all sorts, personally.

  381. SamWhited

    Having 4 or 5 different avatar specs already, I don't think adding another reduces that confusion.

  382. Link Mauve

    You’d be in favour of adding discovery and MUC-specific notifications to e.g. XEP-0153?

  383. Link Mauve

    Dave, so moving discovery to another XEP-0128 dataform?

  384. Kev

    I think we've moved beyond Council discussion here and I'm inclined to close the meeting. Any objections?

  385. Link Mauve

    None from me.

  386. SamWhited

    Link Mauve: I'm not sure where the best place is; 0153 might be it. Or MUC itself.

  387. SamWhited

    Kev: oops, one more AOB

  388. SamWhited

    Is this a matter for council? https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/706

  389. SamWhited

    There was some confusion about this a few weeks ago, updating to the new language would have fixed it and we've been doing it this way anyways

  390. Kev

    I think that should be an agenda item, yes. For the next meeting.

  391. SamWhited

    WFM, thanks.

  392. Kev

    AOAOAOB?

  393. Kev

    Right, we're done then. Thanks all!

  394. Tobias has left

  395. Tobias has joined

  396. genofire has left

  397. ralphm has left

  398. Zash has left

  399. dwd has left

  400. dwd has joined

  401. dwd has left

  402. vanitasvitae has left

  403. daniel has left

  404. daniel has joined

  405. Dave has left

  406. Dave has left

  407. dwd has joined

  408. dwd has left

  409. dwd has joined

  410. peter has joined

  411. daniel has left

  412. daniel has joined

  413. dwd has left

  414. Dave has left

  415. dwd has joined

  416. daniel has left

  417. daniel has joined

  418. dwd has left

  419. dwd has joined

  420. vanitasvitae has joined

  421. guus.der.kinderen has left

  422. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  423. Kev has left

  424. Kev has left

  425. labdsf has left

  426. dwd has left

  427. dwd has joined

  428. dwd has left

  429. dwd has joined

  430. labdsf has joined

  431. vanitasvitae has left

  432. ralphm has left

  433. vanitasvitae has joined

  434. vanitasvitae has left

  435. labdsf has left

  436. Zash has left

  437. moparisthebest has left

  438. dwd has left

  439. dwd has joined

  440. Dave has left

  441. dwd has left

  442. dwd has joined

  443. Dave has left

  444. dwd has left

  445. dwd has joined

  446. Dave has left

  447. dwd has left

  448. dwd has joined

  449. dwd has left

  450. daniel has left

  451. daniel has joined

  452. labdsf has joined

  453. dwd has joined

  454. jere has joined

  455. jere has left

  456. Dave has left

  457. dwd has left

  458. dwd has joined

  459. Dave has left

  460. dwd has left

  461. dwd has joined

  462. daniel has left

  463. daniel has joined

  464. dwd has left

  465. pep. has left

  466. daniel has left

  467. daniel has joined

  468. daniel has left

  469. daniel has joined

  470. daniel has left

  471. daniel has joined

  472. daniel has left

  473. daniel has joined

  474. dwd has joined

  475. Tobias has left

  476. Tobias has joined

  477. daniel has left

  478. daniel has joined

  479. daniel has left

  480. daniel has joined

  481. daniel has left

  482. daniel has joined

  483. moparisthebest has joined

  484. daniel has left

  485. Dave has left

  486. dwd has left

  487. dwd has joined

  488. daniel has joined

  489. daniel has left

  490. daniel has joined

  491. Dave has left

  492. dwd has left

  493. dwd has joined

  494. dwd has left

  495. vanitasvitae has joined

  496. lnj has left

  497. Zash has left

  498. martin has left

  499. guus.der.kinderen has left

  500. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  501. guus.der.kinderen has left

  502. lnj has left

  503. vanitasvitae has left

  504. daniel has left

  505. daniel has joined

  506. SamWhited has left

  507. daniel has left

  508. daniel has joined

  509. dwd has joined

  510. daniel has left

  511. Holger has left

  512. Holger has left

  513. daniel has joined

  514. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  515. dwd has left

  516. dwd has joined

  517. dwd has left

  518. moparisthebest has joined

  519. moparisthebest has joined

  520. guus.der.kinderen has left

  521. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  522. guus.der.kinderen has left

  523. vanitasvitae has joined

  524. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  525. peter has left

  526. Zash has left

  527. guus.der.kinderen has left

  528. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  529. guus.der.kinderen has left

  530. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  531. Zash has left

  532. moparisthebest has left

  533. Zash has left

  534. Zash has left

  535. Zash has left

  536. moparisthebest has joined

  537. dwd has joined

  538. Zash has left

  539. guus.der.kinderen has left

  540. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  541. guus.der.kinderen has left

  542. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  543. Dave has left

  544. dwd has left

  545. dwd has joined

  546. guus.der.kinderen has left

  547. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  548. Dave has left

  549. dwd has left

  550. dwd has joined

  551. dwd has left