XMPP Council - 2020-03-11


  1. stpeter has left

  2. kusoneko has left

  3. kusoneko has joined

  4. kusoneko has left

  5. kusoneko has joined

  6. daniel has left

  7. daniel has joined

  8. kusoneko has left

  9. kusoneko has joined

  10. kusoneko has left

  11. kusoneko has joined

  12. daniel has left

  13. daniel has joined

  14. daniel has left

  15. daniel has joined

  16. kusoneko has left

  17. kusoneko has joined

  18. kusoneko has left

  19. kusoneko has joined

  20. moparisthebest has joined

  21. kusoneko has left

  22. kusoneko has joined

  23. kusoneko has left

  24. kusoneko has joined

  25. debacle has left

  26. kusoneko has left

  27. kusoneko has joined

  28. kusoneko has left

  29. kusoneko has joined

  30. daniel has left

  31. daniel has joined

  32. kusoneko has left

  33. kusoneko has joined

  34. kusoneko has left

  35. kusoneko has joined

  36. moparisthebest has left

  37. kusoneko has left

  38. kusoneko has joined

  39. kusoneko has left

  40. kusoneko has joined

  41. kusoneko has left

  42. kusoneko has joined

  43. kusoneko has left

  44. kusoneko has joined

  45. moparisthebest has joined

  46. daniel has left

  47. daniel has joined

  48. kusoneko has left

  49. kusoneko has joined

  50. kusoneko has left

  51. kusoneko has joined

  52. kusoneko has left

  53. kusoneko has joined

  54. Tobias has joined

  55. undefined has left

  56. undefined has joined

  57. daniel has left

  58. daniel has joined

  59. kusoneko has left

  60. kusoneko has joined

  61. kusoneko has left

  62. kusoneko has joined

  63. daniel has left

  64. daniel has joined

  65. kusoneko has left

  66. kusoneko has joined

  67. kusoneko has left

  68. kusoneko has joined

  69. kusoneko has left

  70. kusoneko has joined

  71. guy has left

  72. guy has joined

  73. kusoneko has left

  74. kusoneko has joined

  75. kusoneko has left

  76. kusoneko has joined

  77. paul has left

  78. paul has joined

  79. guy has left

  80. kusoneko has left

  81. kusoneko has joined

  82. kusoneko has left

  83. kusoneko has joined

  84. kusoneko has left

  85. kusoneko has joined

  86. kusoneko has left

  87. kusoneko has joined

  88. kusoneko has left

  89. kusoneko has joined

  90. kusoneko has left

  91. kusoneko has joined

  92. Wojtek has left

  93. undefined has left

  94. undefined has joined

  95. kusoneko has left

  96. kusoneko has joined

  97. kusoneko has left

  98. kusoneko has joined

  99. larma has left

  100. larma has joined

  101. susmit88 has joined

  102. kusoneko has left

  103. kusoneko has joined

  104. guy has joined

  105. kusoneko has left

  106. kusoneko has joined

  107. guy has left

  108. susmit88 has left

  109. susmit88 has joined

  110. guy has joined

  111. guy has left

  112. guy has joined

  113. raspbeguy has left

  114. raspbeguy has joined

  115. kusoneko has left

  116. kusoneko has joined

  117. kusoneko has left

  118. kusoneko has joined

  119. debacle has joined

  120. guy has left

  121. kusoneko has left

  122. kusoneko has joined

  123. kusoneko has left

  124. kusoneko has joined

  125. debacle has left

  126. kusoneko has left

  127. kusoneko has joined

  128. sonny has left

  129. sonny has joined

  130. kusoneko has left

  131. kusoneko has joined

  132. kusoneko has left

  133. kusoneko has joined

  134. susmit88 has left

  135. susmit88 has joined

  136. paul has left

  137. paul has joined

  138. susmit88 has left

  139. susmit88 has joined

  140. kusoneko has left

  141. kusoneko has joined

  142. kusoneko has left

  143. kusoneko has joined

  144. paul has left

  145. paul has joined

  146. kusoneko has left

  147. kusoneko has joined

  148. kusoneko has left

  149. kusoneko has joined

  150. Wojtek has joined

  151. kusoneko has left

  152. kusoneko has joined

  153. kusoneko has left

  154. kusoneko has joined

  155. alin has joined

  156. stpeter has joined

  157. kusoneko has left

  158. kusoneko has joined

  159. kusoneko has left

  160. kusoneko has joined

  161. kusoneko has left

  162. kusoneko has joined

  163. kusoneko has left

  164. kusoneko has joined

  165. kusoneko has left

  166. Ge0rG looks at the clock

  167. kusoneko has joined

  168. jonas’

    I do, too

  169. kusoneko has left

  170. Zash

    Soon

  171. jonas’

    now

  172. jonas’

    1) Roll Call

  173. Zash

    Here!

  174. kusoneko has joined

  175. jonas’

    is that all?

  176. jonas’

    Ge0rG!

  177. Zash

    forever alone

  178. Ge0rG ,o/

  179. jonas’

    that’s a quorum

  180. jonas’

    2) Agenda Bashing

  181. jonas’

    anything to add to the posted agenda?

  182. daniel

    Here

  183. jonas’ adds daniel to the Agenda

  184. daniel

    I have nothing to add

  185. jonas’

    alright, assuming no addition to the agenda

  186. jonas’

    3) Editor’s Update - ProtoXEP: Reminders - Expired calls: CFE on XEP-0066 - Calls in progress: - CFE: XEP-0184 (Message Delivery Receipts), ends: 2020-03-17

  187. jonas’

    4) Items for voting

  188. jonas’

    4a) Decide on advancement of XEP-0066 Title: Out of Band Data URL: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0066.html Abstract: This specification defines two XMPP protocol extensions for communicating URIs, one for use in XMPP message stanzas and the other for use in a structured request-response interaction via XMPP IQ stanzas. Among other things, this enables one entity to inform another entity about a file that is available at an HTTP URL.

  189. jonas’

    4a) Decide on advancement of XEP-0066 Title: Out of Band Data URL: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0066.html Abstract: This specification defines two XMPP protocol extensions for communicating URIs, one for use in XMPP message stanzas and the other for use in a structured request-response interaction via XMPP IQ stanzas. Among other things, this enables one entity to inform another entity about a file that is available at an HTTP URL.

  190. daniel

    Very little feedback. I'd say -1

  191. jonas’

    (one day I’ll remember to strip the line breaks first)

  192. jonas’

    -1, there are a few sensible points brought up on-list

  193. jonas’

    those should be addressed first

  194. Ge0rG

    -1, I totally missed the CFE, but I'm pretty sure it's not There Yet

  195. Zash

    Eh, -1 then.

  196. daniel

    It seems to get hard to get feedback

  197. daniel

    I wonder why that is

  198. jonas’

    to get feedback on '66 or in general?

  199. daniel

    Does the community not know that this is important?

  200. daniel

    In general

  201. jonas’

    we can discuss this as AOB

  202. jonas’

    5) Outstanding Votes I’m updating the spreadsheet of doom, one second

  203. jonas’

    we have a few outstanding votes: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ANu9KGmNf2r-qpLYqF7NdJTtqA1GIu55rf2deKbM0GA/edit?ts=5de7debe#gid=0

  204. jonas’

    the only thing which is about to expire is VETOED either way, so no hurry

  205. jonas’

    6) Date of Next

  206. jonas’

    +1w wfm

  207. daniel

    For me too

  208. Zash

    wfm

  209. jonas’

    7) AOB

  210. daniel

    I have a minor one

  211. jonas’

    daniel, so, re feedback: I was under the impression that we got above-average feedback in this LC/CFE spree

  212. jonas’

    maybe that was just my perception though

  213. daniel

    Dunno. I was particularly missing this for 66 and Avatar conversion

  214. jonas’

    I’m not sure how we’d be able to find out the cause of lack of feedback

  215. jonas’

    ah yeah, those in particular were pretty low.

  216. daniel

    Delivery receipts was bike shredded a bit

  217. jonas’

    (haha shredded)

  218. jonas’

    in case of '66, I was meaning to give feedback, but I didn’t make it to the deadline and others already stated things which need to be fixed either way

  219. daniel

    But yeah what ever. We probably won't find an answer to that anyway

  220. jonas’

    in case of avatar conversion I personally simply lack experience

  221. jonas’

    probably

  222. jonas’

    daniel, what’s your AOB?

  223. Zash

    jonas’: didn't we have a thread on avatar conversion?

  224. daniel

    Since council was involved in that a couple of weeks ago I would just like to inform council that the omemo situation should be resolved now

  225. jonas’

    ah yes, I noted the update

  226. jonas’

    it was quite extensive

  227. kusoneko has left

  228. kusoneko has joined

  229. jonas’

    I’m pleased to see that it now uses SCE

  230. daniel

    We have more authors who are willing to incorporate feedback

  231. daniel

    And we resolved the GPL situation

  232. kusoneko has left

  233. kusoneko has joined

  234. daniel

    That's it. Just wanted to have that on the record

  235. pep.

    note that it doesn't mean all libraries won't be GPL.. just that the spec is not bound to GPL anymore. Up to people to implement it :p

  236. daniel

    As it had been council business before

  237. jonas’

    alright

  238. jonas’

    anything else?

  239. daniel

    No

  240. jonas’

    alright

  241. jonas’

    8) Ite Meeting Est

  242. jonas’

    Thanks all, thanks Tedd in particular

  243. Zash

    Thanks all

  244. paul has left

  245. Ge0rG

    So I've read the Reminders XEP and the respective thread, and I have very mixed feelings about it all.

  246. flow

    Ge0rG, which you probably want to share in xsf@?

  247. Ge0rG

    flow: no, I'm currently wondering which Council decisioun would be the right one.

  248. kusoneko has left

  249. kusoneko has joined

  250. kusoneko has left

  251. kusoneko has joined

  252. pep.

    what kind of mixed feelings Ge0rG

  253. Ge0rG

    I'll write to standards@

  254. pep.

    k

  255. guy has joined

  256. guy has left

  257. kusoneko has left

  258. kusoneko has joined

  259. kusoneko has left

  260. kusoneko has joined

  261. debacle has joined

  262. paul has joined

  263. undefined has left

  264. undefined has joined

  265. kusoneko has left

  266. kusoneko has joined

  267. kusoneko has left

  268. kusoneko has joined

  269. kusoneko has left

  270. kusoneko has joined

  271. kusoneko has left

  272. kusoneko has joined

  273. daniel has left

  274. daniel has joined

  275. robertooo has joined

  276. kusoneko has left

  277. kusoneko has joined

  278. kusoneko has left

  279. kusoneko has joined

  280. kusoneko has left

  281. kusoneko has joined

  282. kusoneko has left

  283. kusoneko has joined

  284. daniel has left

  285. daniel has joined

  286. susmit88 has left

  287. susmit88 has joined

  288. Wojtek has left

  289. Wojtek has joined

  290. daniel has left

  291. kusoneko has left

  292. kusoneko has joined

  293. kusoneko has left

  294. kusoneko has joined

  295. daniel has joined

  296. susmit88 has left

  297. kusoneko has left

  298. kusoneko has joined

  299. kusoneko has left

  300. kusoneko has joined

  301. Tobias has left

  302. kusoneko has left

  303. kusoneko has joined

  304. kusoneko has left

  305. kusoneko has joined

  306. kusoneko has left

  307. kusoneko has joined

  308. kusoneko has left

  309. kusoneko has joined

  310. robertooo has left

  311. robertooo has joined

  312. kusoneko has left

  313. kusoneko has joined

  314. kusoneko has left

  315. kusoneko has joined

  316. Wojtek has left

  317. kusoneko has left

  318. kusoneko has joined

  319. kusoneko has left

  320. kusoneko has joined

  321. kusoneko has left

  322. kusoneko has joined

  323. daniel has left

  324. kusoneko has left

  325. daniel has joined

  326. kusoneko has joined