Ge0rG wanted to add issuing and shepherding a '280 LC to the agenda
jonas’
which we shall hereby do
Ge0rG
That
jonas’
any other amendments?
Zash
none here
jonas’
also, if anyone has any AOB, just shout throughout the meeting so that we can avoid the awkward silence in the end :)
jonas’
(thanks to dwd for that idea)
jonas’
3) Editor’s Update
jonas’
LC for '313 issued, please respond
jonas’
4) Items for voting
jonas’
4a) Issue LC for XEP-0280 with Ge0rG as shepherd
dwd
+1
Ge0rG
jonas’: well, technically that's not quite what I asked for.
jonas’
I think we don’t *have* to formally vote on this necessarily, but it is borderline to an author addition so I want to play this safe
jonas’
Ge0rG, it is not?
Zash
+1
jonas’
then please clarify
Ge0rG
jonas’: I wanted to become *the* author of the document.
jonas’
ah well
Zash
THE
jonas’
did you contact the current authors already?
dwd
Either, both.
Ge0rG
jonas’: it was discussed on standards@
jonas’
look at that, I missed it
jonas’
*skimming*
jonas’
ok, so Joe ACKed, we’d just have to get hold of Matthew Miller or force remove them. I never had any interactions with them, so I don’t know how reachable they’d be
Kev
Becoming *The* author would be unusual. Our SOP is to add unless the original author asked to be removed.
Ge0rG
Well, not technically the *author* but the maintainer. Whatever that means in terms of ordering names on the frontpage.
Kev
Is there any reason to remove them?
Ge0rG
Kev: no
jonas’
right
jonas’
so, let me rephrase
Kev
Then I suggest Council says “Thanks Georg, welcome to the author list”.
jonas’
4a') Add Ge0rG to the XEP-0280 authors
Zash
How is that different from shepherd then?
Ge0rG
Zash: the shepherd is a temporary position AFAICT
dwd
+1 to that too.
jonas’
+1
Kev
Zash: Shepherd just gets through the standards process.
Ge0rG
+1
Zash
+1
jonas’
Zash, doesn’t matter if it gets accepted, but if it transitions back to Experimental it matters
dwd
Shepherd is not as good for acknowledgement.
Ge0rG
I can't put "shepherd" on my CV
jonas’
I can, kind of
jonas’
but in a very different way
jonas’
(scnr)
Ge0rG
jonas’: but you are shepherd of all XEPs.
Zash
XEPherd?
Ge0rG
Is there a hoodie for that?
jonas’
daniel, vote?
Zash
There's a yak joke somewhere, I can feel it.
daniel
+1
jonas’
thanks
Ge0rG
anything to vote on re LC?
jonas’
Ge0rG, then please go ahead and make the changes you’d like to make to '280, adding yourself as the author
jonas’
no, LC is requested by the author
Ge0rG
Hereby I fromally ask ~Council~ The Editor to do a Last Call of 0280.✎
Ge0rG
Hereby I formally ask ~Council~ The Editor to do a Last Call of 0280. ✏
jonas’
Ge0rG, you’re not an author of that doc… nevermind ;)
jonas’
will do, soon™
jonas’
5) Pending Votes
jonas’
PR#1044 had some discussion on-list
jonas’
https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1044
jonas’
AFAIK, we’re still missing votes from Ge0rG, dwd and me
Ge0rG
Yes. Was that hidden in the council minutes thread?
jonas’
was what hidden?
Ge0rG
Ah, no. A real thread!
jonas’
yeah, crazy, I know
Ge0rG
Thanks fippo! I'll read it up ASAP.
dwd
+1
jonas’
I am +1 based on the lack of negative feedback and the presence of that positive feedback and my own judgement about the addition being "probably fine"