XMPP Council - 2021-06-30

1) Roll Call

Here

Here!

quorum!

2) Agenda Bashing

The Agenda is missing "tacos"

tacos would be nice

I don’t have any though, so you don’t get any either

Is that a new operating system?

3) Editor’s Update * Proposed XMPP Extension: Moved 2

hi

I think we can just continue with a new XEP

4) Items for voting

4a) PR#1064: XEP-0227: New revision 1.1 URL: https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1064 Re-vote as it was modified during voting.

there was a minor change, so we have to re-vote

I am +1 though

I am +1 too.

+1

+1, but see my post to the list

there has been some feedback on-list or elsewhere to also include PEP affiliations and stuff, but my feeling is that this can be done in another update with more newly namespaced elements

jonas’, same.

excellent

Ge0rG is allegedly drugged, so let’s move on

4b) Proposed XMPP Extension: Moved 2 URL: https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/moved2.html Abstract: This specification details a way for a user to notify their contacts about an account move.

+1

I cnotacted the author of Moved 1.0, and haven’t heard back yet

Oh, hi

+1 on 4b

i don’t see any upsides of taking over Moved 1.0

I would prefer getting this merged into the existing moved XEP over creating a fresh one, especially since it is really similar

What jonas’ said.

+1

We already have too many ways to do one thing.

Yeah, I think I'd be happier just changing the existing.

I don't think there's huge implementation of the other one is there?

I'm neutral on new vs replace.

I've had a discussion of the shortcomings I see in Moved 2 with jonas’ and the author over in the xsf@ room.

It would be great if somebody could on-list that.

I am +1 for overwriting Moved 1.0 and granting authorship to MattJ, but I’d like to give the original author another week to reply to my email.

jonas’: +1 to that

SGTM

I don’t want to vote on accepting as Experimental before that reply

dwd, do you want to cast a vote?

~(also Zash)~ ✏

XEP-0283 hasn't had an update in nearly three years; it feels like that could be updated with the contents of this one.

10 years rather

And I, like you, am happy to wait to find out if that's a sensible option.

11

Oh, yes, trivial typo in 2018...

ok, then, moving on

Great, let's postpone this for a week in case the Moved author comes back, and reassign the XEP if not

5) Pending Votes None, except for those from today.

In that case I'm leaning toward vetoing this one in favour of updating XEP-0283.

dwd, which we can just make a thing we let the editor do, no need to do a full round trip

6) Date of Next

+1w wfm

+1 wfm

jonas’, Indeed so.

+1w wfm

+1 wfm

No guarantee on next week yet

(sorry, lots of things happening at the same time right now)

7) AOB

has anyone got any?

not me

8) Ite Meeting Est

thanks everyone

Thanks jonas’, all

jonas’, Thanks!

Thank you very much, jonas’