XMPP Council - 2022-04-13


  1. neox has left
  2. pprrks has left
  3. Sam has left
  4. Sam has joined
  5. Sam has left
  6. Sam has joined
  7. Kev has left
  8. Kev has joined
  9. Sam has left
  10. Sam has joined
  11. daniel has left
  12. Sam has left
  13. Sam has joined
  14. Sam has left
  15. Sam has joined
  16. moparisthebest has joined
  17. Sam has left
  18. Sam has joined
  19. Sam has left
  20. Sam has joined
  21. daniel has joined
  22. SouL has joined
  23. Sam has left
  24. menel has joined
  25. moparisthebest has left
  26. menel has left
  27. menel has joined
  28. menel has left
  29. menel has joined
  30. menel has left
  31. marc0s has left
  32. marc0s has joined
  33. menel has joined
  34. Sam has joined
  35. neox has joined
  36. Sam has left
  37. msavoritias has joined
  38. Ingolf has left
  39. Ingolf has joined
  40. msavoritias has left
  41. msavoritias has joined
  42. debacle has joined
  43. marc0s has left
  44. marc0s has joined
  45. Ingolf has left
  46. Sam has joined
  47. Sam has left
  48. marc0s has left
  49. marc0s has joined
  50. marc0s has left
  51. marc0s has joined
  52. debacle has left
  53. Ingolf has joined
  54. Tobias has left
  55. Tobias has joined
  56. Tobias has left
  57. Tobias has joined
  58. marc0s has left
  59. marc0s has joined
  60. menel has left
  61. marc0s has left
  62. marc0s has joined
  63. menel has joined
  64. pep. has joined
  65. Sam has joined
  66. Sam has left
  67. Wojtek has joined
  68. Sam has joined
  69. menel has left
  70. menel has joined
  71. larma has left
  72. moparisthebest has joined
  73. menel has left
  74. daniel has left
  75. debacle has joined
  76. menel has joined
  77. daniel has joined
  78. Wojtek has left
  79. Ingolf has left
  80. larma has joined
  81. daniel has left
  82. Ingolf has joined
  83. daniel has joined
  84. menel has left
  85. menel has joined
  86. moparisthebest is lacking important security considerations a reason to -1 a protoxep ? or can we ask them to fix it and postpone the vote or how does that work?
  87. Ge0rG AFAIR we have accepted proto-XEPs with zero security considerations in the past, in the expectation that those would be fledged out
  88. jonas’ ack
  89. jonas’ security considerations are tricky, and the idea is to develop as much as possible of the tricky stuff after the thing has entered the IPR policy of the XSF
  90. jonas’ which is only after acceptance
  91. moparisthebest that in particular makes me nervous
  92. jonas’ propose a patch right away?
  93. moparisthebest the one up for vote makes JID harvesting trivial
  94. moparisthebest in fact it doesn't even mention if you should have a mutual subscription before returning the result, maybe that means you shouldn't, but unsure
  95. jonas’ I think that's not undesirable in the social networking usecases
  96. daniel It's time
  97. daniel 1) Roll call
  98. Ge0rG ,o/
  99. moparisthebest at the bare minimum it should say the server should respond identically in the user-doesn't-exist and user-exists-but-has-no-public-subscriptions case
  100. larma 👋️
  101. jonas’ I am kind of here
  102. moparisthebest o/
  103. daniel 2) Agenda Bashing
  104. daniel no bashing today
  105. daniel 3) Editors update - Proposed XMPP Extension: Pubsub Public Subscriptions (https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/pubsub-public-subscriptions.html) - UPDATED: XEP-0356 (Privileged Entity) (https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0356.html)
  106. daniel 4) Items for voting
  107. daniel a) Proposed XMPP Extension: Pubsub Public Subscriptions (https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/pubsub-public-subscriptions.html)
  108. daniel +1
  109. Ge0rG +1
  110. larma +1
  111. moparisthebest +1 but lacking important security considerations, really need those added first thing after acceptance
  112. jonas’ +1, also +1 to what moparisthebest said
  113. daniel awesome. thank you
  114. daniel 5) Pending votes
  115. daniel none
  116. daniel 6) Date of Next
  117. daniel +1w wfm
  118. Ge0rG +1
  119. moparisthebest +1w wfm
  120. larma I might be in a train next week, so expect spotty connectivity 😀
  121. jonas’ +1w wfm
  122. daniel 7) AOB
  123. jonas’ none from me
  124. daniel 8) Close
  125. daniel Thank you everyone
  126. moparisthebest thanks daniel
  127. larma Thanks daniel 🙂
  128. jonas’ okay, gotta run, too. see you folks!
  129. Ge0rG Thanks daniel, thanks everyone!
  130. Ingolf has left
  131. debacle has left
  132. Ingolf has joined
  133. Ingolf has left
  134. Tobias has left
  135. Tobias has joined
  136. Wojtek has joined
  137. Tobias has left
  138. Tobias has joined
  139. marc0s has left
  140. marc0s has joined
  141. marc0s has left
  142. marc0s has joined
  143. Tobias has left
  144. Tobias has joined
  145. pep. has left
  146. Sam has left
  147. Sam has joined
  148. Sam has left
  149. Sam has joined
  150. Tobias has left
  151. Tobias has joined
  152. Tobias has left
  153. Tobias has joined
  154. Tobias has left
  155. Tobias has joined
  156. debacle has joined
  157. SouL has left
  158. Wojtek has left
  159. msavoritias has left
  160. menel has left
  161. marc0s has left
  162. marc0s has joined
  163. Tobias has left
  164. Tobias has joined
  165. debacle has left
  166. neox has left