XMPP Council - 2022-04-29


  1. neox has left

  2. Sam has left

  3. SouL has joined

  4. Tobias has joined

  5. Tobias has left

  6. Tobias has joined

  7. marc0s has left

  8. marc0s has joined

  9. Sam has joined

  10. msavoritias has joined

  11. neox has joined

  12. Sam has left

  13. marc0s has left

  14. marc0s has joined

  15. neox has left

  16. debacle has joined

  17. pprrks has joined

  18. Sam has joined

  19. marc0s has left

  20. marc0s has joined

  21. marc0s has left

  22. marc0s has joined

  23. neox has joined

  24. daniel

    Link Mauve, what do you want council to do with this?

  25. daniel

    take ownership away?

  26. daniel

    ping peter again?

  27. Link Mauve

    Maybe one of these.

  28. Link Mauve

    It might also be a case of it being stable enough for advancement.

  29. Kev has joined

  30. Sam has left

  31. marc0s has left

  32. marc0s has joined

  33. daniel

    do we have someone who wants to become author?

  34. daniel

    tbh it's not fully clear to me what 371 brings to the table that 176 doesn't. it mentions TCP but that could easily be done with an additional disco feature in 176

  35. neox has left

  36. daniel

    and/or just do it. i mean it's pretty clear how one would send tcp candidates with 176 if one would ignore the spec (and some implementations actually did this after parsing sdp)

  37. daniel

    personally (not with my council hat on) i'd honestly be fine with just abandoning 371

  38. daniel

    iirc 371 is also more explicit about allowing trickle ice. but a lot of 176 already do this just fine

  39. daniel

    371's goal apparently is to "avoid confusion" but i'm afraid it will actually add more. with 176 currently being in the compliance suite and on the verge of somewhat being implemented in the wild (finally)

  40. marc0s has left

  41. marc0s has joined

  42. daniel

    and I think you don’t necessarily even need tcp for file transfer. datachannels can be reliable too

  43. Link Mauve

    Hmm, that might be the case; I don’t think I’ve seen it implemented in the wild yet.

  44. daniel

    I guess we can start a last call. see if we get feedback (that PR of yours is feedback too); see if the author processes the feedback (as authors are supposed to); and if they don’t it's rightfully abandoned? and we will see if there is actually any feedback (demand) from the community to have the XEP

  45. neox has joined

  46. pprrks has left

  47. pprrks has joined

  48. pprrks has left

  49. pprrks has joined

  50. pprrks has left

  51. pprrks has joined

  52. pprrks has left

  53. pprrks has joined

  54. pprrks has left

  55. pprrks has joined

  56. debacle has left

  57. pprrks has left

  58. pprrks has joined

  59. Wojtek has joined

  60. pprrks has left

  61. pprrks has joined

  62. pprrks has left

  63. pprrks has joined

  64. marc0s has left

  65. marc0s has joined

  66. marc0s has left

  67. marc0s has joined

  68. pprrks has left

  69. pprrks has joined

  70. marc0s has left

  71. marc0s has joined

  72. pprrks has left

  73. pprrks has joined

  74. Wojtek has left

  75. Wojtek has joined

  76. Sam has joined

  77. pprrks has left

  78. pprrks has joined

  79. pprrks has left

  80. pprrks has joined

  81. pprrks has left

  82. pprrks has joined

  83. neox has left

  84. pprrks has left

  85. pprrks has joined

  86. marc0s has left

  87. marc0s has joined

  88. marc0s has left

  89. marc0s has joined

  90. marc0s has left

  91. marc0s has joined

  92. marc0s has left

  93. marc0s has joined

  94. marc0s has left

  95. marc0s has joined

  96. marc0s has left

  97. marc0s has joined

  98. pprrks has left

  99. Wojtek has left

  100. Wojtek has joined

  101. marc0s has left

  102. marc0s has joined

  103. neox has joined

  104. pprrks has joined

  105. pprrks has left

  106. pprrks has joined

  107. debacle has joined

  108. pprrks has left

  109. pprrks has joined

  110. marc0s has left

  111. marc0s has joined

  112. marc0s has left

  113. marc0s has joined

  114. marc0s has left

  115. marc0s has joined

  116. marc0s has left

  117. marc0s has joined

  118. marc0s has left

  119. marc0s has joined

  120. marc0s has left

  121. marc0s has joined

  122. marc0s has left

  123. marc0s has joined

  124. pprrks has left

  125. pprrks has joined

  126. vanitasvitae_ has left

  127. vanitasvitae_ has joined

  128. Tobias has left

  129. Tobias has joined

  130. Tobias has left

  131. Tobias has joined

  132. pprrks has left

  133. Tobias has left

  134. Tobias has joined

  135. Tobias has left

  136. Tobias has joined

  137. marc0s has left

  138. marc0s has joined

  139. Tobias has left

  140. Tobias has joined

  141. Tobias has left

  142. Tobias has joined

  143. pprrks has joined

  144. Tobias has left

  145. Tobias has joined

  146. pprrks has left

  147. pprrks has joined

  148. Tobias has left

  149. Tobias has joined

  150. Tobias has left

  151. Tobias has joined

  152. Tobias has left

  153. Tobias has joined

  154. vanitasvitae_ has left

  155. vanitasvitae_ has joined

  156. Tobias has left

  157. Tobias has joined

  158. Kev has left

  159. Tobias has left

  160. Tobias has joined

  161. Tobias has left

  162. Tobias has joined

  163. Tobias has left

  164. Tobias has joined

  165. Tobias has left

  166. Tobias has joined

  167. marc0s has left

  168. marc0s has joined

  169. marc0s has left

  170. marc0s has joined

  171. debacle has left

  172. Tobias has left

  173. Tobias has joined

  174. marc0s has left

  175. marc0s has joined

  176. paul has left

  177. Tobias has left

  178. Tobias has joined

  179. Tobias has left

  180. Tobias has joined

  181. Tobias has left

  182. Tobias has joined

  183. Tobias has left

  184. Tobias has joined

  185. Tobias has left

  186. Tobias has joined

  187. Tobias has left

  188. Tobias has joined

  189. Sam has left

  190. Tobias has left

  191. Tobias has joined

  192. Tobias has left

  193. Tobias has joined

  194. Sam has joined

  195. Kev has joined

  196. Kev has left

  197. Wojtek has left

  198. paul has joined

  199. Tobias has left

  200. Tobias has joined

  201. Tobias has left

  202. Tobias has joined

  203. Tobias has left

  204. Tobias has joined

  205. Tobias has left

  206. Tobias has joined

  207. Tobias has left

  208. Tobias has joined

  209. Tobias has left

  210. Tobias has joined

  211. Tobias has left

  212. Tobias has joined

  213. msavoritias has left

  214. Tobias has left

  215. Tobias has joined

  216. Tobias has left

  217. Tobias has joined

  218. Tobias has left

  219. Tobias has joined

  220. Tobias has left

  221. Tobias has joined

  222. Tobias has left

  223. Tobias has joined

  224. Tobias has left

  225. Tobias has joined

  226. Tobias has left

  227. Tobias has joined

  228. Tobias has left

  229. Tobias has joined

  230. Tobias has left

  231. Tobias has joined

  232. debacle has joined

  233. Tobias has left

  234. Tobias has joined

  235. Tobias has left

  236. Tobias has joined

  237. Tobias has left

  238. Tobias has joined

  239. SouL has left

  240. marc0s has left

  241. marc0s has joined

  242. debacle has left

  243. neox has left