XMPP Council - 2022-06-22


  1. eu has left
  2. eu has joined
  3. Kev has joined
  4. Ray22 has joined
  5. Kev has left
  6. Tobias has joined
  7. Kev has joined
  8. Tobias has left
  9. Kev has left
  10. pprrks has joined
  11. pprrks has left
  12. Kev has joined
  13. pprrks has joined
  14. pprrks has left
  15. Kev has left
  16. pprrks has joined
  17. pprrks has left
  18. Tobias has joined
  19. Kev has joined
  20. pprrks has joined
  21. Tobias has left
  22. Kev has left
  23. pprrks has left
  24. pprrks has joined
  25. Kev has joined
  26. Ray22 has left
  27. pprrks has left
  28. SouL has joined
  29. Tobias has joined
  30. Tobias has left
  31. pprrks has joined
  32. Tobias has joined
  33. Kev has left
  34. marc0s has left
  35. marc0s has joined
  36. marc0s has left
  37. marc0s has joined
  38. Kev has joined
  39. pprrks has left
  40. msavoritias has joined
  41. pprrks has joined
  42. Kev has left
  43. marc0s has left
  44. marc0s has joined
  45. marc0s has left
  46. marc0s has joined
  47. pprrks has left
  48. pprrks has joined
  49. Kev has joined
  50. Kev has left
  51. pprrks has left
  52. pprrks has joined
  53. Kev has joined
  54. marc0s has left
  55. marc0s has joined
  56. Kev has left
  57. debacle has joined
  58. pprrks has left
  59. pprrks has joined
  60. marc0s has left
  61. marc0s has joined
  62. Kev has joined
  63. marc0s has left
  64. marc0s has joined
  65. debacle has left
  66. marc0s has left
  67. marc0s has joined
  68. pprrks has left
  69. marc0s has left
  70. marc0s has joined
  71. pprrks has joined
  72. pprrks has left
  73. pprrks has joined
  74. pprrks has left
  75. pprrks has joined
  76. Ingolf has left
  77. Ingolf has joined
  78. neox has joined
  79. debacle has joined
  80. pprrks has left
  81. pprrks has joined
  82. pprrks has left
  83. pprrks has joined
  84. larma has left
  85. larma has joined
  86. larma has left
  87. pprrks has left
  88. pprrks has joined
  89. Kev has left
  90. Kev has joined
  91. Sam has left
  92. Sam has joined
  93. Kev has left
  94. Kev has joined
  95. pprrks has left
  96. Zash has joined
  97. pprrks has joined
  98. pprrks has left
  99. pprrks has joined
  100. pprrks has left
  101. marc0s has left
  102. marc0s has joined
  103. marc0s has left
  104. marc0s has joined
  105. marc0s has left
  106. marc0s has joined
  107. pprrks has joined
  108. larma has joined
  109. pprrks has left
  110. pprrks has joined
  111. marc0s has left
  112. marc0s has joined
  113. marc0s has left
  114. marc0s has joined
  115. marc0s has left
  116. marc0s has joined
  117. marc0s has left
  118. marc0s has joined
  119. marc0s has left
  120. marc0s has joined
  121. marc0s has left
  122. marc0s has joined
  123. pprrks has left
  124. pprrks has joined
  125. pprrks has left
  126. pprrks has joined
  127. marc0s has left
  128. marc0s has joined
  129. marc0s has left
  130. marc0s has joined
  131. marc0s has left
  132. marc0s has joined
  133. marc0s has left
  134. marc0s has joined
  135. Sam has left
  136. Sam has joined
  137. pprrks has left
  138. pprrks has joined
  139. Ray22 has joined
  140. Sam has left
  141. pprrks has left
  142. Sam has joined
  143. marc0s has left
  144. marc0s has joined
  145. daniel 30 minute warning
  146. pprrks has joined
  147. moparisthebest I'll still be here
  148. jonas’ I probably will
  149. pprrks has left
  150. Ge0rG good evening!
  151. jonas’ bagfuiaredufigaesduifgae
  152. moparisthebest o/
  153. moparisthebest jonas’, gesundheit
  154. daniel It’s time
  155. daniel 1) Roll call
  156. Ge0rG ,o/
  157. daniel do we have larma?
  158. larma Not really
  159. daniel i guess not?
  160. daniel 2) Agenda bashing
  161. daniel i didn’t send out an explicit agenda for today; but we are going to use last weeks agenda
  162. daniel 3) Editors update
  163. daniel a) Proposed XMPP Extension: WebSocket S2S (https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/websocket-s2s.html)
  164. daniel b) Proposed XMPP Extension: XMPP over QUIC (https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/xmpp-over-quic.html)
  165. larma Had no time to read but love the initiative :)
  166. daniel quick reminder to the editor (no rush I know you are on holiday) that we wanted to start a last call
  167. daniel for 215
  168. daniel 4) Items for voting
  169. daniel b) Proposed XMPP Extension: XMPP over QUIC (https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/xmpp-over-quic.html)
  170. jonas’ daniel, thanks, I noted it in the spreadsheet of doom and will hopefully remember to look at it next week
  171. moparisthebest +1 (obviously)
  172. Ge0rG on-list
  173. jonas’ why do we start with 4b?
  174. daniel as a developer I understand the "just do everything rfc xyz is doing except" but I'm not sure this is correct form
  175. daniel copy paste error. sorry
  176. jonas’ I like the idea, +1.
  177. daniel ignore the above feedback because that's for 4a
  178. daniel i’m +1 on xmpp over quic
  179. pprrks has joined
  180. moparisthebest the risk of copy+pasting from the other RFC is that something is missed or wrong, I guess
  181. daniel i'm assuming larma is on list too
  182. daniel a) Proposed XMPP Extension: WebSocket S2S (https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/websocket-s2s.html)
  183. moparisthebest +1
  184. daniel now my feedback applies: as a developer I understand the "just do everything rfc xyz is doing except" but I'm not sure this is correct form
  185. jonas’ I... I have ethical issues with this and I'll need to ponder on-list.
  186. jonas’ A proper section on "motivation" may convince me, but I note that this is missing completely.
  187. moparisthebest I think I put that https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/websocket-s2s.html#usecases
  188. Ge0rG on-list
  189. jonas’ I don't scroll that far to find motivation :-).
  190. daniel does anyone else feel that this should rather go into a new version of rfc 7395?
  191. jonas’ ah that too, yes
  192. daniel and/or be an informational xep?
  193. daniel plus it creates ietfs namespaces?
  194. moparisthebest eventually they should probably both be RFCs, I'm completly unfamiliar with that process though
  195. daniel which i think we are not allowed to do?
  196. jonas’ we're most certainly not
  197. daniel moparisthebest, i understand that that's why I was offering "informational" xep as a cheap alternative
  198. moparisthebest it's that or live with a tmp namespace forever :)
  199. daniel with a different namespace
  200. jonas’ moparisthebest, could also use urn:xmpp:...?
  201. jonas’ (which we own)
  202. daniel I think in it's current form I have to be -1
  203. moparisthebest could also just use jabber:server ? :P
  204. moparisthebest re: "just do what RFC X says" I think there is prior art there, ie https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7858 which says "just do TLS like RFC X and then just do DNS like RFC Y"
  205. moparisthebest daniel, just based on the namespace or what else?
  206. daniel a combination of the namespace thing (which would be an easy) fix. and it just not feeling right. I'm not familiar with the "prior art" you mentioned. I guess i should read into that
  207. daniel maybe "on list" until i checked that out
  208. moparisthebest re: namespace any objections to jabber:server ?
  209. daniel but fwiw I don’t think creating an RFC (with your name not a number. is there a term for experimental rfc?) is super hard
  210. moparisthebest yea I gotta look into that one day...
  211. daniel that just feels like a more proper way to handle that. or as I said make it informational to get around the hacky nature
  212. daniel but i also don’t want to be the only one blocking this. so let's see how the other votes turn out
  213. jonas’ I'm happy to be a second blocker if you need one ;)
  214. moparisthebest just making it informational so we can ignore things seems like a hack
  215. jonas’ yeah, I agree on that moparisthebest
  216. jonas’ I don't think making it informational solves anything here
  217. daniel ok; but let's move on. i'll read up on the other rfcs moparisthebest mentioned and vote on list
  218. daniel 5) Pending votes none
  219. daniel 6) Date of next
  220. jonas’ +1w wfm
  221. daniel +1w wfm
  222. moparisthebest +1w wfm
  223. daniel 7) AOB
  224. jonas’ none from me
  225. daniel 8) Close thank you all
  226. jonas’ thanks daniel
  227. moparisthebest thanks all !
  228. Kev Various things have migrated from XEP to RFC, or back again, in the past, FWIW.
  229. Kev So to my mind unless Council/XSF lacks the ability to review it sensibly (which is sometimes the case with security things), I don't think something starting as a XEP and migrating over would be the end of the world.
  230. marc0s has left
  231. marc0s has joined
  232. moparisthebest thanks Kev that's how I'd prefer to do it anyway :)
  233. marc0s has left
  234. marc0s has joined
  235. marc0s has left
  236. marc0s has joined
  237. pprrks has left
  238. pep. has left
  239. pep. has joined
  240. pprrks has joined
  241. pprrks has left
  242. pprrks has joined
  243. Ray22 has left
  244. Kev has left
  245. marc0s has left
  246. marc0s has joined
  247. pprrks has left
  248. debacle has left
  249. Wojtek has left
  250. pprrks has joined
  251. pprrks has left
  252. Kev has joined
  253. pprrks has joined
  254. Kev has left
  255. marc0s has left
  256. marc0s has joined
  257. marc0s has left
  258. marc0s has joined
  259. pprrks has left
  260. marc0s has left
  261. marc0s has joined
  262. marc0s has left
  263. marc0s has joined
  264. marc0s has left
  265. marc0s has joined
  266. pprrks has joined
  267. pprrks has left
  268. marc0s has left
  269. marc0s has joined
  270. debacle has joined
  271. Sam has left
  272. pprrks has joined
  273. Sam has joined
  274. Kev has joined
  275. Kev has left
  276. marc0s has left
  277. marc0s has joined
  278. marc0s has left
  279. marc0s has joined
  280. marc0s has left
  281. marc0s has joined
  282. marc0s has left
  283. marc0s has joined
  284. pprrks has left
  285. pprrks has joined
  286. pprrks has left
  287. pprrks has joined
  288. pprrks has left
  289. pprrks has joined
  290. Wojtek has joined
  291. pprrks has left
  292. Wojtek has left
  293. Ingolf has left
  294. Kev has joined
  295. Ray22 has joined
  296. Kev has left
  297. pprrks has joined
  298. pprrks has left
  299. Ray22 has left
  300. Kev has joined
  301. pprrks has joined
  302. pprrks has left
  303. Kev has left
  304. msavoritias has left
  305. vaulor has left
  306. pprrks has joined
  307. pprrks has left
  308. SouL has left
  309. Kev has joined
  310. pprrks has joined
  311. vaulor has joined
  312. SouL has joined
  313. pprrks has left
  314. moparisthebest re: s2s websocket namespace, I do include the contact of who to register namespaces with on there, unsure if it works like ALPN where the editor just rings them up and they register it or not though
  315. Zash The starting point to look for who's responsible for some urn:* would be https://www.iana.org/assignments/urn-namespaces/urn-namespaces.xhtml
  316. Kev has left
  317. Tobias has left
  318. pprrks has joined
  319. pprrks has left
  320. pprrks has joined
  321. pprrks has left
  322. Kev has joined
  323. Kev has left
  324. pprrks has joined
  325. marc0s has left
  326. marc0s has joined
  327. pprrks has left
  328. pprrks has joined
  329. moparisthebest So it's just expert review and look who the team leader is: > Peter Saint-Andre
  330. moparisthebest We can probably contact that guy!!!! :)
  331. pprrks has left
  332. pprrks has joined
  333. moparisthebest Turns out jabber: isn't registered, we are all breaking the law!
  334. pprrks has left
  335. Zash Yeah, it's from before anyone knew about needing to register these things.
  336. debacle has left
  337. Zash I feel like I've seen mention of it somewhere as a thing that was used without being registered, hysterical raisins etc.
  338. Kev has joined
  339. moparisthebest > To date, the XML > namespaces defined within the Jabber/XMPP community have used names > of the form "jabber:*" (deprecated since early 2002) https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc4854.html
  340. moparisthebest Oopsies
  341. pprrks has joined
  342. neox has left
  343. Kev has left
  344. Tobias has joined
  345. pprrks has left
  346. pprrks has joined
  347. Tobias has left
  348. pprrks has left
  349. pprrks has joined
  350. marc0s has left
  351. marc0s has joined
  352. pprrks has left
  353. Kev has joined
  354. pprrks has joined
  355. pprrks has left
  356. Kev has left