XMPP Council - 2023-02-28


  1. emus has left

  2. Tobias has joined

  3. Tobi has joined

  4. gooya has left

  5. daniel has left

  6. Tobi has left

  7. Tobias has left

  8. Kev has left

  9. Kev has joined

  10. Tobi has joined

  11. Tobias has joined

  12. Tobias has left

  13. Tobi has left

  14. daniel has joined

  15. paul has joined

  16. Tobias has joined

  17. Tobi has joined

  18. pprrks has joined

  19. Tobias has left

  20. Tobi has left

  21. Tobias has joined

  22. kusoneko has left

  23. kusoneko has joined

  24. neox has joined

  25. emus has joined

  26. Tobi has joined

  27. Tobi has left

  28. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  29. pprrks has left

  30. pprrks has joined

  31. paul has left

  32. marc0s has left

  33. marc0s has joined

  34. marc0s has left

  35. marc0s has joined

  36. marc0s has left

  37. marc0s has joined

  38. marc0s has left

  39. marc0s has joined

  40. marc0s has left

  41. marc0s has joined

  42. pprrks has left

  43. pprrks has joined

  44. vaulor has left

  45. vaulor has joined

  46. marc0s has left

  47. marc0s has joined

  48. pprrks has left

  49. marc0s has left

  50. marc0s has joined

  51. gooya has joined

  52. pprrks has joined

  53. Wojtek has joined

  54. pprrks has left

  55. pprrks has joined

  56. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  57. sonny has left

  58. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  59. sonny has joined

  60. marc0s has left

  61. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  62. neox has left

  63. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  64. neox has joined

  65. neox has left

  66. pprrks has left

  67. neox has joined

  68. sonny has left

  69. pprrks has joined

  70. sonny has joined

  71. tmolitor

    I like to put PR #1215 on the council agenda: https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1215

  72. marc0s has joined

  73. pprrks has left

  74. sonny has left

  75. sonny has joined

  76. Wojtek has left

  77. daniel

    IIRC council pretty much pre-approved this change (at least saying it is in the right general direction) but wanted to wait until the xeps that this depend on have been updated

  78. tmolitor

    okay, next week then, I hope...

  79. daniel

    There is a slight awkwardness with SM then depending on an experimental xep. Which personally I think I'd be fine with because it's a dependency that could be reversed. Alternatively it shouldn't be too difficult to last call sasl2 (and maybe bind 2)

  80. daniel

    Either way I think we first need an editor to do something as we can't last call a xep that hasn't been published

  81. daniel

    Last calling bind2 and sasl2 soonish might be a good thing to do anyway and sm depending on it could give us the extra incentive

  82. Tobias has left

  83. Tobias has joined

  84. tmolitor

    keep in mind that the SASL2 framework consists of XEP-0388 AND this protoxep not yet moved to the inbox: https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1248

  85. Tobias has left

  86. Tobias has joined

  87. daniel

    Kev: I think 424 and 425 can be moved back to experimental given their unsuccessful last call

  88. daniel

    I don't know if there is a procedure...

  89. Zash

    REJECTED

  90. Kev

    Zash is technically correct.

  91. daniel

    Or one could argue that the author is currently applying last call feedback.

  92. larma

    > If the Approving Body decides after Last Call that the XEP is not ready for advancement yet, but nevertheless useful, it can vote to move it back to Experimental state.

  93. larma

    we have to vote šŸ™‚

  94. Zash

    Yes, lets pause everything for a few months to implement a new XEP state, "ApplyingLastCallFeedback" ! :D

  95. daniel

    OK. We'll vote on it tomorrow

  96. Kev

    Would Council be ok with replying on GitHub post-vote, or would that not work as a scheme? I'm aware that with both Peter and Me acting as Editor at the moment a mail to just one of us doesn't really work. Come to think of it, I should have included Peter in that mail to council@ as well.

  97. daniel

    I can reply on Github

  98. Kev

    Thanks, Daniel.

  99. pprrks has joined

  100. Tobias has left

  101. Tobias has joined

  102. Tobias has left

  103. Tobias has joined

  104. Tobias has left

  105. Tobias has joined

  106. Tobias has left

  107. Tobias has joined

  108. Tobias has left

  109. Tobias has joined

  110. Tobias has left

  111. Tobias has joined

  112. Tobias has left

  113. Tobias has joined

  114. Wojtek has joined

  115. Tobias has left

  116. Tobias has joined

  117. Kev

    So if I'm following what Link Mauve's saying on https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1269/commits/f8351a86e28c28063bdbc29d2f3495f0d59f2c5b correctly, they submitted a protoXEP. Edhelas submitted changes to it while it was still in the inbox, adding themselves as an Author, and it was merged without Link Mauve being asked, and it was (consequently ?) rejected. Link Mauve now wants to revert it to its original state as they submitted it, make some changes, and have it reconsidered. This seems like something it would be expedient for Council to just say "Go ahead and merge that, Kev", because this feels messy and Council have more authority than me.

  118. pprrks has left

  119. Link Mauve

    Iā€™m just resubmitting the first version under a different track (Historical this time).

  120. daniel

    The cop-out would be to just give it a new short name

  121. daniel

    Then neither council nor editor needs to figure out what went wrong in the past

  122. daniel

    But 'just merge it Kev' is likely fine too

  123. daniel

    The outcome (documenting what we currently doing with muc avatars without saying anything about pubsub) is a good thing

  124. vaulor has left

  125. vaulor has joined

  126. emus has left

  127. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  128. Tobias has left

  129. Tobias has joined

  130. Tobias has left

  131. Tobias has joined

  132. neox has left

  133. Tobias has left

  134. Tobias has joined

  135. Tobias has left

  136. Tobias has joined

  137. neox has joined

  138. Tobias has left

  139. Tobias has joined

  140. Tobias has left

  141. Tobias has joined

  142. Tobias has left

  143. Tobias has joined

  144. moparisthebest has left

  145. moparisthebest has joined

  146. Tobias has left

  147. Kev

    Merged it anyway, edhelas replied.

  148. Tobias has joined

  149. marc0s has left

  150. marc0s has joined

  151. Tobias has left

  152. Wojtek has left

  153. marc0s has left

  154. marc0s has joined