XMPP Council - 2023-04-24

  1. Kev

    Could https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1278 go onto the agenda, please?

  2. larma

    That's just changing examples, which are not normative, no?

  3. Kev

    Correct - but I'm not sure that 'non-normative' and 'Editor should merge without checking with Council' are necessarily the same. I'd rather err on the side of caution than overstep.

  4. Kev

    https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1270 too please.

  5. larma

    That's experimental and thus needs to be approved by author only, no?

  6. Kev

    The script tells me it's proposed and should go to Council

  7. larma

    I think 0424 should have moved back to experimental after council decided to not move it to stable after the last call expired in January 2022

  8. Kev

    I did try to go through Council minutes to see if there were any actions for me to take, but couldn't find any going back an awfully long time.

  9. larma

    Also I read 0001 such that even in Proposed state, Council is not required, but last call feedback is incorporated by XEP author or Document Shepherd

  10. Kev

    Jan 2022 was further back than I looked.

  11. larma

    Not saying you did anything wrong 🙂

  12. larma

    The proposal to move 424 and 425 to stable was rejected on 2022-01-05 es per my logs

  13. Kev

    To check - they were rejected, or chosen to return to Experimental?

  14. Kev

    I'll make a note to myself to handle that next time I do an Editor parse (just finished this one)

  15. larma

    Technically, council voted no on "Move XEP-0424 (Message Retraction) to stable"

  16. larma

    That lacks clear action for editor

  17. Kev

    Could I ask Council to let me know whether they're going back to Experimental or being rejected, please? :)

  18. larma

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1aA6tQJ8XJ_UjCKrcJ6CyG-l3L5xETSlBrPRR-37Z_1E/edit#gid=0 also doesn't list any editor action for that voting item

  19. larma

    Yes 😉

  20. Kev

    I also note that Council (Daniel, IIRC) promised to leave a comment on GitHub on behalf of Council for PRs that have had actions voted on them, and I don't see any. I'm not sure if that's because the "letting me know" hasn't happened, or votes haven't happened. I don't mind getting those notifications as GH comments, a mail to Editor or in Council minute mails, if GH comments aren't good.