XMPP Council - 2023-04-24

  1. gooya has joined

  2. emus has joined

  3. gooya has left

  4. moparisthebest has left

  5. moparisthebest has joined

  6. Tobias has joined

  7. Tobias has left

  8. emus has left

  9. SouL has joined

  10. Tobias has joined

  11. SouL has left

  12. neox has joined

  13. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  14. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  15. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  16. emus has joined

  17. SouL has joined

  18. Kev has joined

  19. sonny has left

  20. sonny has joined

  21. gooya has joined

  22. gooya has left

  23. gooya has joined

  24. pprrks has joined

  25. gooya has left

  26. gooya has joined

  27. gooya has left

  28. Kev

    Could https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1278 go onto the agenda, please?

  29. larma

    That's just changing examples, which are not normative, no?

  30. Kev

    Correct - but I'm not sure that 'non-normative' and 'Editor should merge without checking with Council' are necessarily the same. I'd rather err on the side of caution than overstep.

  31. Kev

    https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1270 too please.

  32. gooya has joined

  33. larma

    That's experimental and thus needs to be approved by author only, no?

  34. Kev

    The script tells me it's proposed and should go to Council

  35. larma

    I think 0424 should have moved back to experimental after council decided to not move it to stable after the last call expired in January 2022

  36. Kev

    I did try to go through Council minutes to see if there were any actions for me to take, but couldn't find any going back an awfully long time.

  37. gooya has left

  38. larma

    Also I read 0001 such that even in Proposed state, Council is not required, but last call feedback is incorporated by XEP author or Document Shepherd

  39. Kev

    Jan 2022 was further back than I looked.

  40. larma

    Not saying you did anything wrong 🙂

  41. larma

    The proposal to move 424 and 425 to stable was rejected on 2022-01-05 es per my logs

  42. Kev

    To check - they were rejected, or chosen to return to Experimental?

  43. Kev

    I'll make a note to myself to handle that next time I do an Editor parse (just finished this one)

  44. larma

    Technically, council voted no on "Move XEP-0424 (Message Retraction) to stable"

  45. larma

    That lacks clear action for editor

  46. Kev

    Could I ask Council to let me know whether they're going back to Experimental or being rejected, please? :)

  47. larma

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1aA6tQJ8XJ_UjCKrcJ6CyG-l3L5xETSlBrPRR-37Z_1E/edit#gid=0 also doesn't list any editor action for that voting item

  48. larma

    Yes 😉

  49. Kev

    I also note that Council (Daniel, IIRC) promised to leave a comment on GitHub on behalf of Council for PRs that have had actions voted on them, and I don't see any. I'm not sure if that's because the "letting me know" hasn't happened, or votes haven't happened. I don't mind getting those notifications as GH comments, a mail to Editor or in Council minute mails, if GH comments aren't good.

  50. gooya has joined

  51. Zash has left

  52. Zash has joined

  53. Wojtek has joined

  54. mdosch has left

  55. mdosch has joined

  56. Wojtek has left

  57. Wojtek has joined

  58. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  59. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  60. Wojtek has left

  61. Wojtek has joined

  62. poliux has left

  63. Wojtek has left

  64. Wojtek has joined

  65. Wojtek has left

  66. Wojtek has joined

  67. Wojtek has left

  68. Wojtek has joined

  69. sonny has left

  70. sonny has joined

  71. pep. has joined

  72. gooya has left

  73. sonny has left

  74. sonny has joined

  75. Wojtek has left

  76. Kev has left

  77. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  78. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  79. SouL has left

  80. gooya has joined

  81. SouL has joined

  82. Kev has joined

  83. gooya has left

  84. Wojtek has joined

  85. pep. has left

  86. pprrks has left

  87. poliux has joined

  88. neox has left

  89. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  90. Tobias has left

  91. pep. has joined

  92. gooya has joined

  93. sonny has left

  94. sonny has joined

  95. Wojtek has left

  96. Wojtek has joined

  97. pep. has left

  98. Kev has left

  99. sonny has left

  100. pep. has joined

  101. sonny has joined

  102. SouL has left

  103. SouL has joined

  104. gooya has left

  105. neox has joined

  106. emus has left

  107. marc0s has left

  108. SouL has left

  109. sonny has left

  110. sonny has joined

  111. Wojtek has left