-
goffi
Daniel, I see that XEP-0424 LC is not mentioned in the agenda, is that because of the origin-id discussion? A new LC will be emitted after the update, right?
-
Daniel
Technically the voting period is still open if you want to vote on that. So if anything I would have put it under 'pending votes' instead of restarting the vote or something
-
Daniel
But I believe that our last discussion was to the effect that we need at least one more revision
-
Daniel
*if* we get that revision before the voting period runs out we might as well vote on it
-
Daniel
If not the editor will likely restart LC
-
goffi
OK make sense, thanks!
-
dan.caseley
> dan.caseley: feel free (but not pressured) to vote on 0421 in between meetings too. +1 I can't work out what my problem is with the paragraph on force enabling, but whatever it is, it's going to be a minor nitpick on wording that shouldn't block this, since we can add clarification text later (right?)
-
Daniel
Thanks dan.caseley
-
Daniel
Do you have a problem with the language of how that feature is described or with the functionality itself?
-
Daniel
I mean the conditions under which this feature would appear are clear to me. From a client POV it's unclear under what circumstances I would need that feature. But whatever 🤷♂️
-
dan.caseley
Specifically the wording. I feel like there's a possibility that one of the states gets to ambiguity, but I can't spot it.
-
dan.caseley
So long as process allows for clarification wording later, pretend I said nothing but '+1'
-
daniel
it’s time
-
daniel
1) Roll call
-
goffi
.o/
-
dan.caseley
Here
-
daniel
larma, singpolyma are you here too?
-
singpolyma
Hi
-
daniel
2) Agenda Bashing
-
daniel
nothing to bash
-
daniel
3) Editors update
-
daniel
* Proposed XMPP Extension: GRE Formatter: MIME * Proposed XMPP Extension: GRE Encrypter: OpenPGP * Proposed XMPP Extension: Gateway Relayed Encryption * LAST CALL: XEP-0484 (Fast Authentication Streamlining Tokens)
-
daniel
4) Items for voting
-
daniel
goffi, would you be ok with following the proposal that marvin and myself made?
-
goffi
using a single XEP?
-
daniel
yes
-
goffi
I have read your feedback but haven't had time to answer, sorry (working on non XMPP related stuff today).
-
daniel
that‘s fine. that‘s why I'm asking here.
-
singpolyma
Im attracted to the goal but unsure about specifying every legacy network as a xep
-
daniel
personally i'd probably go +/-0 on the current proto xeps. but if you could merge that into on xep i'm +1
-
goffi
I'm OK for a single XEP yes, but I have the feeling that numbers are cheap, and OpenPGP and MIME are separated stuff. My long term goal would be to have a single generic mechanism anyway (webassembly based)
-
goffi
Any, this is very experimental stuff, and I expect it to evolve a lot.✎ -
goffi
Anyway, this is very experimental stuff, and I expect it to evolve a lot. ✏
-
singpolyma
Is there a benefit to a xep number if it will yet evolve a lot?
-
dan.caseley
I think there's a benefit to 1 number
-
goffi
yes, to experiment, it a place where current status and specification can be referred.
-
daniel
your call. we can let the vote play out to see how other council members feel
-
daniel
or i'm quickly going -1 to formally end this one and we wait until you submit one xep
-
goffi
sorry somebody was at the door
-
goffi
anyway, I'm open to merge in a single one sure.
-
goffi
we can maybe discuss it and postpone vote to next week?
-
goffi
I think this must be discussed on standard and not in a rush here.
-
goffi
I'll answer feedbacks in coming days.
-
daniel
ok
-
daniel
skipping the votes from the agenda then
-
daniel
and moving to
-
daniel
5) Pending votes
-
daniel
none after dan.caseley voted earlier
-
daniel
6) Date of next
-
daniel
+1w wfm
-
goffi
+1w wfm
-
singpolyma
+1w wfm
-
dan.caseley
I'll miss next week
-
dan.caseley
I'm travelling and attending a family thing all of Tues/Weds
-
dan.caseley
But can catch up after the fact
-
daniel
noted. thanks
-
daniel
7) AOB
-
goffi
I'm waiting for Link Mauve feedback on the mailing list for shared XML Editing
-
goffi
then I would like to add the PR on next agenda.
-
daniel
yes i’m monitoring that. but feel free to ping me again once that has been resolved
-
goffi
sure I will.
-
goffi
we can see in Brussels if not resolved before.
-
goffi
as he will be there.
-
daniel
assuming no other AOB?
-
daniel
8) Close
-
goffi
Thanks Daniel, thanks all.
-
daniel
thank you all