XSF Editor Team - 2018-08-30

  1. jcbrand

    jonasw For XEP-0384, you asked daniel to ack, but the author is Andreas Straub. Is daniel also considered an author or did you ask him due to another reason?

  2. jcbrand

    jonasw https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/686

  3. jcbrand

    I'm asking, because I'm considering pinging the author on the PR

  4. jonasw

    jcbrand, it was probably a mistake by me

  5. jcbrand

    Ok, I pinged Andreas

  6. jcbrand

    jonasw XEP-0363 has been moved to Last Call, so changes to it now needs Council, right? Which means this PR needs to be updated I believe https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/625

  7. jonasw

    uh… did it advance?

  8. jonasw

    can you check the "spreadsheet of doom" (I don’t have the link with me … we should probably put it in the topic here)

  9. jcbrand

    jonasw From what I can tell, it's not advanced yet. Line 72 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1AZ-Sna6OiRG--b-mJMKv3XXfrn3Nehm0kAtlyJvImL0/htmlview

  10. jcbrand

    But it's currently in "Last Call", so I'm not sure how that affects triaging

  11. jcbrand

    I.e. whether we can simply ask the author, or whether Council needs to discuss any change

  12. jonasw

    jcbrand, also, I think it doesn’t matter, because the author rejected it on standards@

  13. jcbrand

    ah, I was still going through that

  14. jcbrand

    ok, so then I'll close the PR

  15. jonasw

    I’m not 100% sure on that, double check it maybe

  16. jonasw

    but I recall that it was at least controversial

  17. jcbrand

    jonasw daniel didn't outright reject it. You asked for his opinion on your change, and he never gave it. I'll ping him on the PR

  18. jcbrand

    "never gave it" => at least not in the mailing list thread

  19. jcbrand

    jonasw You proposed that I make a PR with changes for you to review, but to be honest, I'm not sure what would go into such a PR. For example, as an exercise I'd like to merge Link Mauve's PrototXEP and then send out an email.

  20. jonasw

    jcbrand, I meant to suggest that you create a branch off master, do all the merges into that branch, push that branch as a Pull Request

  21. jonasw

    which I can then review

  22. jonasw

    kind of a meta-PR so to speak

  23. jonasw

    hm

  24. jcbrand

    ok, working on that

  25. jcbrand

    jonasw https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/701 AFAICT there are only 2 mergeable PRs

  26. jonasw

    another action which needs to be taken is accepting Ge0rGs MUC XEP

  27. jonasw

    there’s a utility for that

  28. jonasw

    python3 tools/accept.py

  29. jonasw

    it requires an up-to-date xeplist, so run make build/xeplist.xml first

  30. jonasw

    it needs the name of the protoxep as argument. so if you’re on your branch, you can run: python3 tools/accept.py --commit muc-selfping I think

  31. jcbrand

    ok, I'll do that later today... on to something else now

  32. jonasw

    good luck