XSF Editor Team - 2020-11-12


  1. lnj has left
  2. debacle has left
  3. stpeter has left
  4. stpeter has joined
  5. stpeter has left
  6. stpeter has joined
  7. stpeter has left
  8. Tobi has joined
  9. winfried has left
  10. winfried has joined
  11. winfried has left
  12. winfried has joined
  13. debacle has joined
  14. lnj has joined
  15. debacle has left
  16. lnj has left
  17. lnj has joined
  18. winfried has left
  19. winfried has joined
  20. lnj has left
  21. debacle has joined
  22. lnj has joined
  23. debacle has left
  24. debacle has joined
  25. stpeter has joined
  26. lnj has left
  27. debacle has left
  28. lnj has joined
  29. lnj has left
  30. lnj has joined
  31. debacle has joined
  32. soul has left
  33. mdosch has left
  34. mdosch has joined
  35. mdosch So you would suggest the author to create a MR per ProtoXEP or leave it up to them?
  36. mdosch Also, is `ProtoXEP: Title of the new XEP` instead of `XEP-XXXX: Title of the new XEP` an issue? Don't know whether I'm too strict when I ask to change that or not. :)
  37. flow Re https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1003/files#diff-512dc13f3a81200a9c2fb1f66bfe27878c31f5aea42eabdfcda98d85c5f423daR32 → I am not aware that we have a policy on that, but I would welcome it if we could aggree that the shortname is either NOT_YET_ASSIGNED or assigned a unique shortname. I always wanted to add a lint check for that, would that be aggreeable?
  38. mdosch Sounds reasonable. Especially it's like that in the template and I see no reason to change it until one is assigned…
  39. mdosch Sounds reasonable. Especially because it's like that in the template and I see no reason to change it until one is assigned…
  40. jonas’ mdosch, if you don’t find anything to complain about, leaving it as-is is ok
  41. jonas’ (re proto xep splitting)
  42. jonas’ flow, agreed-ish
  43. jonas’ though I find the concept of trying to assign shortnames to XEPs a bit strange anyway
  44. flow I think the concept is great, but I would swap shortnames and numbers, i.e. shortnames should be the suffix of the XEP and a XEP number just something that is hidden in XEP the metadata
  45. flow I think the concept of shortnames for XEPs is great, but I would swap shortnames and numbers, i.e. shortnames should be the suffix of the XEP and a XEP number just something that is hidden in XEP the metadata
  46. flow XEP-0199 vs XEP-PING
  47. mdosch > mdosch, if you don’t find anything to complain about, leaving it as-is is ok > (re proto xep splitting) Thanks And regarding the subject?
  48. soul has joined
  49. jonas’ subject?
  50. jonas’ title of the PR?
  51. jonas’ add a `ProtoXEPs:` prefix and it’s good to go
  52. mdosch > subject? > title of the PR? Yes > add a `ProtoXEPs:` prefix and it’s good to go It has this one. It's just that triaging docs say `XEP-xxxx` but I read your answer as 'ProtoXEP is also ok.' 😃
  53. Kev has left
  54. jonas’ oh, I’ve always used ProtoXEP
  55. jonas’ ha, that’s a bug in the docs I think
  56. jonas’ I do prefer ProtoXEP over XEP-XXXX because it’s easier to distinguish from any other XEP-#### PR
  57. mdosch Ha. 😃
  58. soul has left
  59. soul has joined
  60. winfried has left
  61. winfried has joined
  62. winfried has left
  63. winfried has joined
  64. winfried has left
  65. winfried has joined
  66. winfried has left
  67. winfried has joined
  68. mdosch I got so many questions today… :D If someone wants a certain pr merged after another pr. Do we add some "blocked by pr-xyz" or so? Also is this a reasonable way to have a quick syntax check? `xmllint --noout --dtdvalid inbox/xep.dtd inbox/stickers.xml`
  69. Kev has joined
  70. Kev has left
  71. winfried has left
  72. winfried has joined
  73. winfried has left
  74. winfried has joined
  75. Kev has joined
  76. lnj has left
  77. Tobi has left
  78. winfried has left
  79. winfried has joined
  80. larma I feel I was causing unnecessary trouble when I thought I would make things easier. Sorry for that.
  81. larma now reads https://github.com/xsf/xeps/blob/master/docs/TRIAGING.md
  82. stpeter has left
  83. debacle has left