XSF Editor Team - 2023-01-04

  1. Tobi has joined

  2. emus has left

  3. Millesimus has joined

  4. Millesimus has left

  5. Millesimus has joined

  6. Millesimus has left

  7. Millesimus has joined

  8. Millesimus has left

  9. Millesimus has joined

  10. Millesimus has left

  11. Millesimus has joined

  12. Millesimus has left

  13. Millesimus has joined

  14. Millesimus has left

  15. Millesimus has joined

  16. Millesimus has left

  17. Millesimus has joined

  18. Millesimus has left

  19. Millesimus has joined

  20. Millesimus has left

  21. Millesimus has joined

  22. Millesimus has left

  23. Millesimus has joined

  24. Millesimus has left

  25. Millesimus has joined

  26. Millesimus has left

  27. Millesimus has joined

  28. Millesimus has left

  29. Millesimus has joined

  30. Millesimus has left

  31. Millesimus has joined

  32. Millesimus has left

  33. Millesimus has joined

  34. Millesimus has left

  35. Millesimus has joined

  36. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  37. Millesimus has left

  38. Millesimus has joined

  39. Millesimus has left

  40. Millesimus has joined

  41. Millesimus has left

  42. Millesimus has joined

  43. emus has joined

  44. Millesimus has left

  45. Millesimus has joined

  46. Millesimus has left

  47. Millesimus has joined

  48. emus has left

  49. emus has joined

  50. Daniel has left

  51. Daniel has joined

  52. Daniel has left

  53. Daniel has joined

  54. Daniel has left

  55. Daniel has joined

  56. Millesimus has left

  57. Kev has joined

  58. Millesimus has joined

  59. Millesimus has left

  60. Millesimus has joined

  61. Millesimus has left

  62. Millesimus has joined

  63. wurstsalat has joined

  64. Millesimus has left

  65. Millesimus has joined

  66. soul has left

  67. soul has joined

  68. winfried has left

  69. winfried has joined

  70. wurstsalat has left

  71. wurstsalat has joined

  72. wurstsalat has left

  73. wurstsalat has joined

  74. wurstsalat has left

  75. wurstsalat has joined

  76. Kev

    I don't have time to update anything at the moment, but based on Council discussion a moment ago, I think the intention is that when authors are pinged for feedback on Experimental changes that council@ or standards@ (standards@ is better in my view) are also copied so there's visibility.

  77. Kev

    So we should probably update the procedure doc.

  78. jonas’


  79. Kev

    Actually, maybe I do have time. I'll see if I can sort that quickly.

  80. Daniel

    Another problem is that a lot of feedback happens out of band. As someone who has done this myself multiple times because it seems easier and faster - and often actually is easier because you can talk to a colleague in a more direct manner then saying this publicly on list - it can be a problem

  81. Daniel

    (nothing that the editor team can figure out of course)

  82. Kev

    I don't see discussions out of band as a problem, as long as the important things happen on list.

  83. Kev

    Maybe important is the wrong word there. Gatekeeping and/or procedural, possibly.

  84. moparisthebest

    Maybe the editor message should ask the author to at least ack on list?

  85. Kev

    jonas': Is there a practical reason I shouldn't push this doc-only update directly to master without a PR?

  86. Kev

    Did so, so I guess we'll see if anything goes boom.

  87. Tobi has left

  88. Tobi has joined

  89. Tobi has left

  90. Tobi has joined

  91. Tobi has left

  92. Tobi has joined

  93. Tobi has left

  94. Tobi has joined

  95. Tobi has left

  96. Tobi has joined

  97. Tobi has left

  98. Tobi has joined

  99. soul has left

  100. soul has joined

  101. soul has left

  102. soul has joined

  103. Daniel has left

  104. Daniel has joined

  105. Daniel has left

  106. Daniel has joined

  107. Daniel has left

  108. Daniel has joined

  109. Daniel has left

  110. Daniel has joined

  111. Daniel has left

  112. Daniel has joined

  113. Daniel has left

  114. Daniel has joined

  115. Daniel has left

  116. Daniel has joined

  117. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  118. wurstsalat has left

  119. Tobi has left

  120. wurstsalat has joined

  121. Tobi has joined

  122. wurstsalat has left

  123. wurstsalat has joined

  124. wurstsalat has left

  125. wurstsalat has joined

  126. wurstsalat has left

  127. wurstsalat has joined

  128. wurstsalat has left

  129. Tobi has left

  130. Tobi has joined

  131. Tobi has left

  132. Tobi has joined

  133. wurstsalat has joined

  134. wurstsalat has left

  135. wurstsalat has joined

  136. wurstsalat has left

  137. wurstsalat has joined

  138. wurstsalat has left

  139. wurstsalat has joined

  140. wurstsalat has left

  141. wurstsalat has joined

  142. wurstsalat has left

  143. Kev has left