jdev - 2020-06-14


  1. Neustradamus has joined
  2. xecks has left
  3. Neustradamus has left
  4. Neustradamus has joined
  5. Neustradamus has left
  6. waqas has left
  7. Neustradamus has joined
  8. sonny has left
  9. sonny has joined
  10. Kev has joined
  11. wurstsalat has left
  12. sonny has left
  13. sonny has joined
  14. sonny has left
  15. sonny has joined
  16. sonny has left
  17. sonny has joined
  18. sonny has left
  19. sonny has joined
  20. lovetox has joined
  21. lovetox has left
  22. lovetox has joined
  23. lovetox has left
  24. Neustradamus has left
  25. Holger has left
  26. Neustradamus has joined
  27. paul has joined
  28. Holger has joined
  29. h has joined
  30. goffi has joined
  31. h has left
  32. rion has left
  33. rion has joined
  34. rion has left
  35. lovetox has joined
  36. adiaholic_ has left
  37. adiaholic_ has joined
  38. asterix has joined
  39. lovetox has left
  40. asterix has left
  41. asterix has joined
  42. lovetox has joined
  43. eta has left
  44. eta has joined
  45. debacle has joined
  46. lovetox has left
  47. sonny has left
  48. sonny has joined
  49. debacle has left
  50. debacle has joined
  51. wurstsalat has joined
  52. rion has joined
  53. rion has left
  54. Ge0rG has joined
  55. xecks has joined
  56. adiaholic_ has left
  57. adiaholic_ has joined
  58. adiaholic_ has left
  59. adiaholic_ has joined
  60. alexis has left
  61. alexis has joined
  62. adiaholic_ has left
  63. adiaholic_ has joined
  64. kikuchiyo has joined
  65. kikuchiyo has left
  66. kikuchiyo has joined
  67. kikuchiyo has left
  68. kikuchiyo has joined
  69. kikuchiyo has left
  70. vaulor has joined
  71. kikuchiyo has joined
  72. kikuchiyo has left
  73. kikuchiyo has joined
  74. kikuchiyo has left
  75. kikuchiyo has joined
  76. kikuchiyo has left
  77. kikuchiyo has joined
  78. kikuchiyo has left
  79. kikuchiyo has joined
  80. kikuchiyo has left
  81. kikuchiyo has joined
  82. kikuchiyo has left
  83. pulkomandy has left
  84. pulkomandy has joined
  85. kikuchiyo has joined
  86. kikuchiyo has left
  87. kikuchiyo has joined
  88. kikuchiyo has left
  89. pulkomandy has left
  90. pulkomandy has joined
  91. kikuchiyo has joined
  92. kikuchiyo has left
  93. kikuchiyo has joined
  94. kikuchiyo has left
  95. kikuchiyo has joined
  96. kikuchiyo has left
  97. kikuchiyo has joined
  98. kikuchiyo has left
  99. kikuchiyo has joined
  100. kikuchiyo has left
  101. kikuchiyo has joined
  102. kikuchiyo has left
  103. kikuchiyo has joined
  104. kikuchiyo has left
  105. kikuchiyo has joined
  106. kikuchiyo has left
  107. kikuchiyo has joined
  108. kikuchiyo has left
  109. kikuchiyo has joined
  110. kikuchiyo has left
  111. kikuchiyo has joined
  112. kikuchiyo has left
  113. kikuchiyo has joined
  114. kikuchiyo has left
  115. kikuchiyo has joined
  116. kikuchiyo has left
  117. kikuchiyo has joined
  118. kikuchiyo has left
  119. kikuchiyo has joined
  120. kikuchiyo has left
  121. kikuchiyo has joined
  122. kikuchiyo has left
  123. kikuchiyo has joined
  124. kikuchiyo has left
  125. kikuchiyo has joined
  126. kikuchiyo has left
  127. kikuchiyo has joined
  128. waqas has joined
  129. debacle has left
  130. kikuchiyo has left
  131. lovetox has joined
  132. kikuchiyo has joined
  133. kikuchiyo has left
  134. kikuchiyo has joined
  135. kikuchiyo has left
  136. Yagizа has joined
  137. asterix has left
  138. asterix has joined
  139. asterix has left
  140. asterix has joined
  141. lovetox has left
  142. asterix has left
  143. asterix has joined
  144. kikuchiyo has joined
  145. rion has joined
  146. asterix has left
  147. asterix has joined
  148. asterix has left
  149. asterix has joined
  150. asterix has left
  151. asterix has joined
  152. lovetox has joined
  153. kikuchiyo has left
  154. asterix has left
  155. asterix has joined
  156. kikuchiyo has joined
  157. kikuchiyo has left
  158. adiaholic_ has left
  159. kikuchiyo has joined
  160. kikuchiyo has left
  161. Neustradamus has left
  162. kikuchiyo has joined
  163. kikuchiyo has left
  164. lovetox has left
  165. Neustradamus has joined
  166. kikuchiyo has joined
  167. kikuchiyo has left
  168. lovetox has joined
  169. adiaholic_ has joined
  170. adiaholic_ has left
  171. adiaholic_ has joined
  172. debacle has joined
  173. debacle has left
  174. debacle has joined
  175. Kev has left
  176. debacle has left
  177. kikuchiyo has joined
  178. kikuchiyo has left
  179. Neustradamus has left
  180. lovetox can somebody clear up my confusion with 0260
  181. lovetox https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0260.html
  182. lovetox the dstaddr has to be calculated (sid, initiator, responder)
  183. Neustradamus has joined
  184. lovetox ok let me rephrase
  185. lovetox in 0260, dstaddr is only mentioned regarding proxys
  186. lovetox its clear how dst addr is calculated there
  187. lovetox but we have to calc dstaddr also for our direct candidates
  188. lovetox is it there always (sid, initiator, responder)
  189. lovetox even for my offered candidates if im responder?
  190. kikuchiyo has joined
  191. kikuchiyo has left
  192. lovetox rion, ^
  193. rion Session initiator and responder. Everything else doesn't matter
  194. kikuchiyo has joined
  195. kikuchiyo has left
  196. rion For a proxy rules are different yes. There it matters who offers the proxy
  197. Martin has left
  198. lovetox yeah k thanks i thought so, but its weirdly not mentioned explicitly, its implied with XEP-0065 only having this one way to calculate it
  199. Martin has joined
  200. rion That was also my concern in some xep comments on wiki iiirc
  201. rion I even remember doing some PRs to the xep. But not sure if any related to this topic. In any case none was merged
  202. kikuchiyo has joined
  203. lovetox rion, do you support multiple file transfer contents per session?
  204. kikuchiyo has left
  205. lovetox and what does psi when a user sends multiple files
  206. lovetox do you create one session per file, or one session and multiple contents
  207. kikuchiyo has joined
  208. lovetox and can you give me a link to the wiki page
  209. lovetox https://wiki.xmpp.org/web/Tech_pages/Jingle
  210. lovetox i only found this, and there are no comments
  211. kikuchiyo has left
  212. rion > rion, do you support multiple file transfer contents per session? One session for in and out
  213. rion Unfortunately I haven't written any docs yet. I remind myself everytime to do this but still can find some spare time for this
  214. kikuchiyo has joined
  215. asterix has left
  216. asterix has joined
  217. Yagizа has left
  218. asterix has left
  219. asterix has joined
  220. kikuchiyo has left
  221. rion In short Psi has 1) manager for every application type and every transport type (global instances. e.g. S5Bmanager) 2) specific classes to make instances for every application type and every transport type (e.g. S5BTransport) 3) sessioned managers - a single instances of managers per session. From one side this thing has session and global manager from another side multiple instances of applications of transports. I call these things pads (kind of a place we where application can access global manager. e.g. S5BSessionManagerPad) s5b stuff is not quite standard but I hope it's compatible. It has optimizations wrt trickle candidates. And Psi heavily uses them. Basically it never waits to send session or session answer. If something can be discovered and sent later it will be discovered and sent later. Besides it has priority optimizations. Like if it's possible some higher priority candidate can be discovered later, it will wait before sending candidate-error/use.
  222. rion Most clients have simpler implementation. And the XEP doesn't explicitly say what's the preferred way to implement it.
  223. rion anyway I look forward to implement webrtc datachannels. I believe it's the future which will eventually deprecate s5b
  224. debacle has joined
  225. debacle has left
  226. debacle has joined
  227. lovetox hm how would you trickle candidates? and why? in what circumstance would a higher priority candidate discovered later?
  228. lovetox higest priority candidates is your own ip
  229. lovetox i guess you always know your own ip way before any jingle session
  230. lovetox my opinion about jingle is, its very generic, that does not mean one has to implement every possible option that one could imagine
  231. kikuchiyo has joined
  232. lovetox i say almost all circumstances, you give your own ip, and a proxy, if for what ever reason own ip does not work
  233. lovetox and thats about it, also 10 years of jingle FT told us there is no probably no client out there who implements more than, send one content with candidates, and thats about it
  234. lovetox and really FT should not need more than that
  235. lovetox also because probably nobody implements all what the spec could do theoretically, i think there are many wholes in the spec that just resulted from no implementation feedback
  236. lovetox probably because jingle allows many theoretically things, where no real use case is there for right now
  237. rion > i guess you always know your own ip way before any jingle session Think about upnp. If for some reason it's discovered later.
  238. moparisthebest has left
  239. rion > that does not mean one has to implement every possible option That's the real problem. Because everyone has in mind their own way. and it's usually it's incompatible with ways of others
  240. rion Just because of this I don't like jingle.
  241. flow has left
  242. rion I would better implemented sip
  243. moparisthebest has joined
  244. goffi has left
  245. rion I recently implemented new ICE (RFC 8445) and I have to say it's way more clear than for example XEP-0166. Even so XEP-0166 has way more circumstances described. In other words less freedom - simpler/more reliable/more compatible implementation
  246. rion I recently implemented new ICE (RFC 8445) and I have to say it's way more clear than for example XEP-0166. Even so RFC 8445 has way more circumstances described. In other words less freedom - simpler/more reliable/more compatible implementation
  247. rion waqas: how alive Adium nowadays? I was gooing to remove it from Psi's clients detector.
  248. adiaholic_ has left
  249. adiaholic_ has joined
  250. drops has left
  251. drops has joined
  252. asterix has left
  253. asterix has joined
  254. kikuchiyo has left
  255. lovetox has left
  256. asterix has left
  257. kikuchiyo has joined
  258. waqas rion: Not very, AFAIK. There were some commits 7 months ago, but before that was 2017. I haven't found another client I felt like switching to yet.
  259. adiaholic_ has left
  260. waqas has left
  261. rion waqas: pidgin?
  262. waqas has joined
  263. wurstsalat has left
  264. wurstsalat has joined
  265. kikuchiyo has left
  266. sonny has left
  267. sonny has joined
  268. debacle has left
  269. vaulor has left