jdev - 2022-03-11


  1. FireFly has left
  2. Apollo has left
  3. dezant has joined
  4. oxtyped has left
  5. oxtyped has joined
  6. larma has left
  7. oxtyped has left
  8. oxtyped has joined
  9. Millesimus has left
  10. oxtyped has left
  11. Millesimus has joined
  12. thomaslewis has joined
  13. thomaslewis has left
  14. thomaslewis has joined
  15. thomaslewis has left
  16. antranigv has joined
  17. Alex has left
  18. oxtyped has joined
  19. antranigv has left
  20. wurstsalat has left
  21. TheCoffeMaker has left
  22. debacle has left
  23. TheCoffeMaker has joined
  24. oxtyped has left
  25. Kev has left
  26. Kev has joined
  27. oxtyped has joined
  28. dezant has left
  29. larma has joined
  30. Yagizа has joined
  31. Zash has left
  32. oxtyped has left
  33. dezant has joined
  34. Zash has joined
  35. antranigv has joined
  36. nephele has joined
  37. antranigv has left
  38. nephele has left
  39. oxtyped has joined
  40. oxtyped has left
  41. larma has left
  42. Yagizа has left
  43. Yagizа has joined
  44. Yagizа has left
  45. Yagizа has joined
  46. marc0s has left
  47. marc0s has joined
  48. oxtyped has joined
  49. pasdesushi has joined
  50. oxtyped has left
  51. oxtyped has joined
  52. oxtyped has left
  53. oxtyped has joined
  54. libredev has left
  55. mirux has joined
  56. libredev has joined
  57. oxtyped has left
  58. kikuchiyo has left
  59. Yagizа has left
  60. Yagizа has joined
  61. Apollo has joined
  62. oxtyped has joined
  63. pasdesushi has left
  64. J Marinaro has left
  65. msavoritias has joined
  66. oxtyped has left
  67. msavoritias has left
  68. msavoritias has joined
  69. antranigv has joined
  70. oxtyped has joined
  71. atomicwatch has joined
  72. oxtyped has left
  73. xecks has left
  74. kikuchiyo has joined
  75. antranigv has left
  76. oxtyped has joined
  77. emus has joined
  78. Laura has joined
  79. wurstsalat has joined
  80. libredev has left
  81. abdullah has left
  82. abdullah has joined
  83. libredev has joined
  84. J Marinaro has joined
  85. pasdesushi has joined
  86. jgart has left
  87. Millesimus has left
  88. oxtyped has left
  89. libredev has left
  90. libredev has joined
  91. Laura has left
  92. dezant has left
  93. xnamed has left
  94. marmistrz has left
  95. antranigv has joined
  96. Alex has joined
  97. Kev has left
  98. atomicwatch has left
  99. atomicwatch has joined
  100. Laura has joined
  101. oxtyped has joined
  102. Kev has joined
  103. pulkomandy has left
  104. Laura has left
  105. oxtyped has left
  106. marmistrz has joined
  107. lovetox has left
  108. oxtyped has joined
  109. lovetox has joined
  110. goffi has joined
  111. Laura has joined
  112. oxtyped has left
  113. xecks has joined
  114. paul has left
  115. oxtyped has joined
  116. Wojtek has joined
  117. oxtyped has left
  118. raghavgururajan has joined
  119. xecks has left
  120. selurvedu has left
  121. selurvedu has joined
  122. oxtyped has joined
  123. xnamed has joined
  124. kfv has left
  125. kfv has joined
  126. paul has joined
  127. kfv has left
  128. kfv has joined
  129. selurvedu has left
  130. oxtyped has left
  131. kfv has left
  132. kfv has joined
  133. FireFly has joined
  134. xecks has joined
  135. xecks has left
  136. Apollo has left
  137. Apollo has joined
  138. marc0s has left
  139. marc0s has joined
  140. FireFly has left
  141. kfv has left
  142. kfv has joined
  143. marc0s has left
  144. marc0s has joined
  145. oxtyped has joined
  146. xecks has joined
  147. Alex has left
  148. debacle has joined
  149. emus has left
  150. emus has joined
  151. pulkomandy has joined
  152. oxtyped has left
  153. nephele has joined
  154. nephele has left
  155. nephele has joined
  156. Laura has left
  157. mister has joined
  158. nephele has left
  159. nephele has joined
  160. Millesimus has joined
  161. Alex has joined
  162. nephele has left
  163. nephele has joined
  164. iink has joined
  165. al has joined
  166. Kev has left
  167. oxtyped has joined
  168. pulkomandy has left
  169. nephele has left
  170. FireFly has joined
  171. kfv has left
  172. kfv has joined
  173. oxtyped has left
  174. libredev has left
  175. oxtyped has joined
  176. oxtyped has left
  177. Laura has joined
  178. FireFly has left
  179. FireFly has joined
  180. Apollo has left
  181. oxtyped has joined
  182. oxtyped has left
  183. Alex has left
  184. Wojtek has left
  185. Wojtek has joined
  186. Alex has joined
  187. iink has left
  188. oxtyped has joined
  189. moparisthebest has left
  190. al has left
  191. oxtyped has left
  192. Apollo has joined
  193. Alex has left
  194. Alex has joined
  195. dezant has joined
  196. Sam I think I asked this before but I can't remember or find if it was answered or if we went off on a tangent: is anyone aware of any non-standard uses of message types in the wild? Ie. type="foo" or an absent type attribute being treated different from type="normal"?
  197. kikuchiyo has left
  198. marmistrz has left
  199. Wojtek has left
  200. Wojtek has joined
  201. flow I'd expect that you find those plently (and probably mostly) in custom non-federated setups. Judging from the amount of Smack questions I see where people set a custom type
  202. flow e.g., type=avatar
  203. Sam *sigh* yah, that's kid of what I was expecting but I wanted confirmation. Thanks!
  204. Sam I'm not sure that I care to support such things, but if we do it helps me decide on an issue that I'm struggling with so it's good info to have.
  205. larma has joined
  206. flow fwiw Smack does not support custom message types, but IIRC xmppframework does. so that happens is that people aim for iOS first, because that's where the money is I suppose, and then later want to extend over to Android
  207. flow that said, I am not strictly opposed to supporting arbitrary types in smack. I always try to follow the specs, which IIRC allow for custom types. But someone just hast to implement it (or pay someone - doesn't have to be me - to implement it)
  208. Sam At least for message the specs don't allow it, I think. Anything other than a defined type is the same as type="normal"
  209. flow could be a interpreation thing
  210. flow I think In interpreted the spec as "everything not defined is routed as 'normal'", and assumed that ideally users also want to be able to retrieve the actual on the wire value (and not have it replaced with 'normal')
  211. Sam > If included, the 'type' attribute MUST have one of the following > values
  212. flow yeah, could very well be that the spec is not really clear in this regard, or that the spec authors intention was to keep a loophole open for non-standard values for type
  213. Sam But yah, should I always keep the wire value (and just treat it as "normal" when selecting a handler) or should I replace it with "normal" when we decode the wire value into our own representation is what I'm deciding (the user could still implement their own decoding to preserve the wire value, it would jsut be an extra hoop they'd have to jump through)
  214. moparisthebest has joined
  215. Sam https://mellium.im/issue/272 in case you're interested
  216. oxtyped has joined
  217. Ingolf has left
  218. Ingolf has joined
  219. kfv has left
  220. kfv has joined
  221. dezant has left
  222. raghavgururajan has left
  223. marmistrz has joined
  224. raghavgururajan has joined
  225. larma has left
  226. oxtyped has left
  227. Yagizа has left
  228. Yagizа has joined
  229. xecks has left
  230. xecks has joined
  231. Wojtek has left
  232. antranigv has left
  233. oxtyped has joined
  234. nephele has joined
  235. Wojtek has joined
  236. dezant has joined
  237. marmistrz has left
  238. nephele has left
  239. nephele has joined
  240. nephele has left
  241. nephele has joined
  242. nephele has left
  243. nephele has joined
  244. debacle has left
  245. nephele has left
  246. nephele has joined
  247. antranigv has joined
  248. disgyze has left
  249. nephele has left
  250. oxtyped has left
  251. nephele has joined
  252. Kev has joined
  253. larma has joined
  254. Kev has left
  255. nephele has left
  256. thomaslewis has joined
  257. Yagizа has left
  258. Yagizа has joined
  259. thomaslewis has left
  260. antranigv has left
  261. antranigv has joined
  262. Ingolf has left
  263. marmistrz has joined
  264. thomaslewis has joined
  265. thomaslewis has left
  266. oxtyped has joined
  267. Alex has left
  268. me9 has joined
  269. Alex has joined
  270. debacle has joined
  271. dezant has left
  272. oxtyped has left
  273. atomicwatch has left
  274. Kev has joined
  275. pulkomandy has joined
  276. Kev has left
  277. atomicwatch has joined
  278. FireFly has left
  279. FireFly has joined
  280. emus has left
  281. oxtyped has joined
  282. Holger has left
  283. marmistrz has left
  284. oxtyped has left
  285. Kev has joined
  286. Kev has left
  287. oxtyped has joined
  288. jgart has joined
  289. me9 has left
  290. oxtyped has left
  291. emus has joined
  292. kfv has left
  293. kfv has joined
  294. Kev has joined
  295. Kev has left
  296. antranigv has left
  297. nephele has joined
  298. nephele has left
  299. nephele has joined
  300. Millesimus has left
  301. Laura has left
  302. marmistrz has joined
  303. nephele has left
  304. spectrum has left
  305. pasdesushi has left
  306. marmistrz has left
  307. mister has left
  308. spectrum has joined
  309. moparisthebest has left
  310. syrupthinker has joined
  311. syrupthinker has left
  312. pasdesushi has joined
  313. nephele has joined
  314. nephele has left
  315. Laura has joined
  316. homebeach has left
  317. Matrix Traveler (bot) has left
  318. Matrix Traveler (bot) has joined
  319. homebeach has joined
  320. Mjolnir Archon has left
  321. Maranda has left
  322. Mjolnir Archon has joined
  323. Mjolnir Archon has left
  324. Mjolnir Archon has joined
  325. Maranda has joined
  326. spectrum has left
  327. Holger has joined
  328. spectrum has joined
  329. cedar has left
  330. jgart has left
  331. cedar has joined
  332. nephele has joined
  333. nephele has left
  334. nephele has joined
  335. Wojtek has left
  336. Wojtek has joined
  337. moparisthebest has joined
  338. marc0s has left
  339. marc0s has joined
  340. marc has left
  341. marc has joined
  342. nephele has left
  343. nephele has joined
  344. nephele has left
  345. nephele has joined
  346. nephele has left
  347. nephele has joined
  348. nephele has left
  349. nephele has joined
  350. debacle has left
  351. debacle has joined
  352. larma has left
  353. lovetox- has joined
  354. nephele has left
  355. Wojtek has left
  356. Wojtek has joined
  357. raghavgururajan has left
  358. raghavgururajan has joined
  359. nephele has joined
  360. nephele has left
  361. nephele has joined
  362. lovetox- has left
  363. lovetox- has joined
  364. lovetox- has left
  365. lovetox- has joined
  366. lovetox- has left
  367. lovetox- has joined
  368. larma has joined
  369. nephele has left
  370. lovetox- has left
  371. lovetox- has joined
  372. lovetox- has left
  373. nephele has joined
  374. nephele has left
  375. nephele has joined
  376. nephele has left
  377. nephele has joined
  378. antranigv has joined
  379. nephele has left
  380. nephele has joined
  381. nephele has left
  382. nephele has joined
  383. nephele has left
  384. nephele has joined
  385. paul has left
  386. nephele has left
  387. nephele has joined
  388. nephele has left
  389. nephele has joined
  390. nephele has left
  391. nephele has joined
  392. Millesimus has joined
  393. nephele has left
  394. nephele has joined
  395. nephele has left
  396. nephele has joined
  397. nephele has left
  398. nephele has joined
  399. nephele has left
  400. jgart has joined
  401. nephele has joined
  402. marmistrz has joined
  403. nephele has left
  404. nephele has joined
  405. larma has left
  406. emus has left
  407. nephele has left
  408. nephele has joined
  409. rafasaurus has left
  410. nephele has left
  411. nephele has joined
  412. rafasaurus has joined
  413. Yagizа has left
  414. xnamed has left
  415. nephele has left
  416. xnamed has joined
  417. nephele has joined
  418. Millesimus has left
  419. nephele has left
  420. nephele has joined
  421. nephele has left
  422. nephele has joined
  423. Millesimus has joined
  424. PapaTutuWawa has joined
  425. Apollo has left
  426. Apollo has joined
  427. jgart has left
  428. thomaslewis has joined
  429. thomaslewis has left
  430. nephele has left
  431. rafasaurus has left
  432. rafasaurus has joined
  433. mirux has left
  434. mirux has joined
  435. mirux has left
  436. marmistrz has left
  437. mirux has joined
  438. mirux has left
  439. mirux has joined
  440. larma has joined
  441. dezant has joined
  442. J Marinaro has left
  443. Apollo has left
  444. marmistrz has joined
  445. mirux has left
  446. Wojtek has left
  447. J Marinaro has joined
  448. PapaTutuWawa has left
  449. marmistrz has left
  450. thomaslewis has joined
  451. Millesimus has left
  452. thomaslewis has left
  453. me9 has joined
  454. PapaTutuWawa has joined
  455. Alex has left
  456. homebeach has left
  457. Matrix Traveler (bot) has left
  458. Matrix Traveler (bot) has joined
  459. homebeach has joined
  460. paul has joined
  461. emus has joined
  462. rafasaurus has left
  463. atomicwatch has left
  464. Millesimus has joined
  465. x51 has joined
  466. x51 has left
  467. PapaTutuWawa has left
  468. al has joined
  469. Apollo has joined
  470. Millesimus has left
  471. rafasaurus has joined
  472. me9 has left
  473. Millesimus has joined
  474. rafasaurus has left
  475. Kev has joined
  476. rafasaurus has joined
  477. Kev has left
  478. msavoritias has left
  479. Millesimus has left
  480. emus has left
  481. emus has joined
  482. moparisthebest has left
  483. moparisthebest has joined
  484. Millesimus has joined
  485. dezant has left
  486. Millesimus has left
  487. paul has left
  488. wurstsalat has left
  489. kfv has left
  490. Millesimus has joined
  491. kfv has joined
  492. marc0s has left
  493. marc0s has joined