-
alexkurisu
> Ensuring compatibility and providing a consistent user experience. That's what Modern XMPP should be striving for. Everyone has a different opinion on what "consistent UX" even means
-
leke
Oh, I meant the Modern XMPP project at modernxmpp.org.
-
alexkurisu
Modern XMPP's idea of "consistent UX" is "blindly clone whatever whatsapp/telegram/line/etc do", not actually doing a good independent UX
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
i think it makes sense to have groups of clients with consistent UX. i.e. i'm hoping to make my client entirely cross platform which means you can get consistent ux on all platforms if you want it. i dont think it should be a restrictive measure though
-
leke
My understanding is that it should at least provide a consistent interpretation and user experience, without introducing differences. For example, the OOB issue we discussed earlier.
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
i would agree with that but i think that should be a spec job, not some offshoot project
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
albeit, i would argue that this is a case of the interpretation being pretty clear, and clients just choosing to not align with the spec
-
kuyuhi
to be fair the odd implementation of oob is still well within spec, so spec is doing its job just fine here
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
> to be fair the odd implementation of oob is still well within spec, so spec is doing its job just fine here sending true, but id argue its not really following it in spirit on the accepting side ↺
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
like its not violating the spec, but its not fully supporting the spec
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
the spec doesnt define that a fallback range can be used, so i could understand that not being expected, but it seems like an artificial limitation
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
idk its beating a dead horse though
-
kuyuhi
my point being the specification did about everything it even could here, so its just up to the developers themselves at this point
👍 1 -
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
conversations ends up being used as a reference client a lot, and im not sure thats appropriate
-
kuyuhi
whether that be a third-party project like modernxmpp establishing guidelines to follow, or the client devs just agreeing regardless
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
> my point being the specification did about everything it even could here, so its just up to the developers themselves at this point ah yeah that wos my point, its just an odd client choice ↺
-
kuyuhi
yeah i sent my first message before i saw the one you sent just before it. slow internet and all </3
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
how are you on internet so bad that _xmpp_ takes forever to send
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
ive only ever had that be a server issue (thanks single threaded prosody)
-
kuyuhi
not sure. just every so often some of my messages take like five to eight seconds to send for a few minutes
-
kuyuhi
usually later at night my internet gets less stable, so the timing lines up
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
> usually later at night my internet gets less stable, so the timing lines up weird ass internet ↺
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
anywhere ive lived its always faster at night when everyone else is offline lol
-
kuyuhi
timezones bro 🥀
-
kuyuhi
almost midnight for me
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
> almost midnight for me i was going off the assumption it was midnight or later yeah ↺
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
back when i lived on campus i would get gigabit internet at like 2am
-
kuyuhi
it used to be fine even really late at night but ever since the datacenters nearby its gotten less stable especially at night </3
-
alexkurisu
> conversations ends up being used as a reference client a lot, and im not sure thats appropriate Conversations has a ton of very questionable choices, yeah
-
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
> it used to be fine even really late at night but ever since the datacenters nearby its gotten less stable especially at night </3 ahhhh ↺
-
leke
Conversations still lacks basic features like message replies to this day, and it seems reluctant to accept pull requests from external contributors.
👍 1 -
moparisthebest
luckily you can fork it or create your own !
-
theTedd
"Just fork it, bro! You can add the one feature you want, bro! It's so easy, bro!" But then you also have to continue to maintain that fork forevermore - which is also "so easy, bro!" (if we just ignore the countless unmaintained and abandoned forks of open source projects.)
☝️ 1 -
jjj333_p (any pronouns)
theres also already forks of conversations that do add many of the features it doesnt have (notably cheogram which has far saner interpretations of xeps imo)
-
theTedd
> Modern XMPP's idea of "consistent UX" is "blindly clone whatever whatsapp/telegram/line/etc do", not actually doing a good independent UX Consistency is an important part of UX, in particular _don't surprise users._ But there are two forms of consistency here: 1. being consistent within your own product; 2. being consistent with other, similar products. While every client shouldn't just be a clone of every other, being different for the sake of being different is also a bad choice. Users are familiar with the way things work in other products and will expect them to work the same way in yours; that doesn't mean everyone should copy verbatim, but it does mean there should be a good reason for deviating from such expectations (only surprise users in a good way!) ↺
-
moparisthebest
> "Just fork it, bro! You can add the one feature you want, bro! It's so easy, bro!" But then you also have to continue to maintain that fork forevermore - which is also "so easy, bro!" (if we just ignore the countless unmaintained and abandoned forks of open source projects.) and the alternative is... slavery or what ? I don't know what else you'd describe forcing someone else to accept and maintain your changes they don't want ↺
-
moparisthebest
for the record I'm pro forking and anti slavery
-
singpolyma
I think we can disagree without that kind of extreme language
-
theTedd
> and the alternative is... slavery or what ? I don't know what else you'd describe forcing someone else to accept and maintain your changes they don't want Wild take. My point was simply that "just fork it" isn't necessarily as easy as just fork and be done with it - there is a lot more that's required beyond that. ↺
💯 1 -
moparisthebest
of course
-
theTedd
Then it's not a simple, easy option that suits everyone; "just fork it" is another dismissive version of "Stop complaining and do it yourself."
-
Sunglocto
> and the alternative is... slavery or what ? I don't know what else you'd describe forcing someone else to accept and maintain your changes they don't want Interesting point
-
Holger
theTedd: The idea behind that statetement probably isn't that it would be feasible for everyone to actually go ahead and fork. The idea is rather that open source code can be forked, so if a maintainer is doing a bad job, chances are a successful fork will emerge eventually.
-
moparisthebest
there is no easy option (other than whining and doing nothing else) so yes that was the exact point