XMPP Service Operators - 2022-03-11


  1. greenkeeper has left

  2. candyman188 has left

  3. candyman188 has joined

  4. Apollo has left

  5. candyman188 has left

  6. candyman188 has joined

  7. TheXanMan has joined

  8. p55s has joined

  9. candyman188 has left

  10. candyman188 has joined

  11. kr1p has joined

  12. mjk has left

  13. Ivan A. has left

  14. Ivan A. has joined

  15. rozzin

    TheCoffeMaker: isn't it... actually better to wait a bit before retweeting?

  16. neox has left

  17. belove has joined

  18. TheCoffeMaker has left

  19. TheCoffeMaker has joined

  20. Steven Roose has left

  21. william.chatner has left

  22. info has left

  23. info has joined

  24. Steven Roose has joined

  25. croax has left

  26. ChronosX88 has left

  27. Ivan A. has left

  28. TheXanMan has left

  29. Ivan A. has joined

  30. TheCoffeMaker

    > TheCoffeMaker: isn't it... actually better to wait a bit before retweeting? Maybe ... Depends on the tweet I guess, i.e. the tweet abt xmpp + activity pub needs to be on time

  31. Bjarkan has joined

  32. Abbe has left

  33. Steven Roose has left

  34. Steven Roose has joined

  35. Bjarkan has left

  36. ffuentes has left

  37. ffuentes has joined

  38. fantoski has left

  39. fantoski has joined

  40. ffuentes has left

  41. ffuentes has joined

  42. writer77 has left

  43. writer77 has joined

  44. TheXanMan has joined

  45. millesimus has left

  46. millesimus has joined

  47. belove has left

  48. belove has joined

  49. Ivan A. has left

  50. Ivan A. has joined

  51. Echo1 has left

  52. Echo1 has joined

  53. candyman188 has left

  54. candyman188 has joined

  55. kr1p has left

  56. kryptos has left

  57. kryptos has joined

  58. TheXanMan has left

  59. candyman188 has left

  60. candyman188 has joined

  61. ibikk has left

  62. Abbe has joined

  63. Ivan A. has left

  64. Ivan A. has joined

  65. candyman188 has left

  66. candyman188 has joined

  67. antranigv has joined

  68. belove has left

  69. belove has joined

  70. candyman188 has left

  71. candyman188 has joined

  72. ross has left

  73. ross has joined

  74. Steven Roose has left

  75. theo has left

  76. theo has joined

  77. antranigv has left

  78. Steven Roose has joined

  79. kryptos has left

  80. candyman188 has left

  81. candyman188 has joined

  82. Stephen has left

  83. patasca has joined

  84. candyman188 has left

  85. candyman188 has joined

  86. fpyrih has joined

  87. patasca has left

  88. ' has left

  89. ' has joined

  90. TheXanMan has joined

  91. Bjarkan has joined

  92. Dexter has left

  93. patasca has joined

  94. jayteeuk has left

  95. Bjarkan has left

  96. Stephen has joined

  97. Ian Blas has left

  98. Ian Blas has joined

  99. fpyrih has left

  100. TheXanMan has left

  101. jayteeuk has joined

  102. TheXanMan has joined

  103. patasca has left

  104. patasca has joined

  105. Stephen has left

  106. Menel has left

  107. henrik has left

  108. Stephen has joined

  109. ffuentes has left

  110. ffuentes has joined

  111. antranigv has joined

  112. jakob has left

  113. henrik has joined

  114. patasca has left

  115. quantumwings has joined

  116. antranigv has left

  117. jakob has joined

  118. ' has left

  119. ' has joined

  120. Ivan A. has left

  121. Ivan A. has joined

  122. balabol.im has joined

  123. belove has left

  124. belove has joined

  125. jayteeuk has left

  126. patasca has joined

  127. jayteeuk has joined

  128. ernst.on.tour has left

  129. ernst.on.tour has joined

  130. mightyBroccoli has left

  131. Ivan A. has left

  132. Ivan A. has joined

  133. patasca has left

  134. TheXanMan has left

  135. Steven Roose has left

  136. ChronosX88 has joined

  137. candyman188 has left

  138. TheXanMan has joined

  139. candyman188 has joined

  140. Ivan A. has left

  141. Ivan A. has joined

  142. candyman188 has left

  143. candyman188 has joined

  144. mightyBroccoli has joined

  145. candyman188 has left

  146. Ivan A. has left

  147. candyman188 has joined

  148. Ivan A. has joined

  149. ChronosX88 has left

  150. ChronosX88 has joined

  151. ilmaisin_ has joined

  152. mightyBroccoli has left

  153. marc0s has left

  154. marc0s has joined

  155. ffuentes has left

  156. ffuentes has joined

  157. mightyBroccoli has joined

  158. ilmaisin_ has left

  159. Ivan A. has left

  160. Ivan A. has joined

  161. neox has joined

  162. jl4 has joined

  163. theo has left

  164. theo has joined

  165. pod has joined

  166. martin has left

  167. martin has joined

  168. patasca has joined

  169. Ivan A. has left

  170. Ivan A. has joined

  171. ibikk has joined

  172. candyman188 has left

  173. candyman188 has joined

  174. sven has left

  175. candyman188 has left

  176. candyman188 has joined

  177. Licaon_Kter

    > *people* don't care about new xeps they care about "apps" they can use Not sure that's the subject, again emus said "xep", yes that's another demographic, developers, and they need another type of info. Devs can't make apps or add features if they believe xmpp is dead. Hearing about a new Siskin update every 6 months (and the latest one breaks group omemo _"Why I've decided to implement OMEMO?". I do not use it, yet I have to deal with issues with OMEMO_) does not help that much. _Ohhhhh look weekly info on new shiny stuff libmatrix added that's easy to use_

  178. John has left

  179. candyman188 has left

  180. mightyBroccoli has left

  181. candyman188 has joined

  182. Ivan A. has left

  183. Ivan A. has joined

  184. Menel has joined

  185. croax has joined

  186. libredev has left

  187. mirux has joined

  188. Ivan A. has left

  189. Ivan A. has joined

  190. frog has joined

  191. libredev has joined

  192. kikuchiyo has left

  193. Apollo has joined

  194. fhtest has joined

  195. mightyBroccoli has joined

  196. Licaon_Kter

    > *people* don't care about new xeps they care about "apps" they can use Apparently they care about "app names" most, that's the most important part...if it's not the same on alr platforms it's unusable MattJ found the golden goose right there Ref: https://eylenburg.github.io/im_comparison.htm

  197. Licaon_Kter

    > *people* don't care about new xeps they care about "apps" they can use Apparently they care about "app names", that's the most important part...if it's not the same on all platforms it's unusable omg MattJ found the golden goose right there Ref: https://eylenburg.github.io/im_comparison.htm

  198. moparisthebest

    > XMPP and Matrix leak metadata, Signal doesn't ugh this lie again

  199. ' has left

  200. ' has joined

  201. Ivan A. has left

  202. Ivan A. has joined

  203. MSavoritias (she,they) has joined

  204. MSavoritias (she,they) has left

  205. MSavoritias (she,they) has joined

  206. Menel

    Someone needs to manage to selfhost signal and then be an evil admin to test it.. Otherwise people will believe..

  207. Menel

    Ans then demand yet another update to the admin-in-the-middle article 馃槅

  208. moparisthebest

    not needed, it's obvious any centralized service like signal has *all* the metadata

  209. info has left

  210. moparisthebest

    whether they pinky-promise not to look at it is beside the point

  211. Menel

    Not for infosec it seems

  212. info has joined

  213. Menel

    They believed in the magic

  214. homebeach has left

  215. homebeach has joined

  216. jl4 has left

  217. moparisthebest

    as usual, they are malicious or stupid or both

  218. Licaon_Kter

    Menel: > Not for infosec it seems > They believed in the magic They did remove Signal recommendation when they republished the posts each year They also deflect the Signal criticism as whataboutism

  219. Menel

    Its just.. People believe more in actions then in words.. So a life test with signal would be devastating I think. Just saying how it is does nothing as we see

  220. Menel

    From the not existing article:"I could actually see who is messaging who at any time" 馃槻馃槻馃槻

  221. moparisthebest

    if there's a system you run where 2 people connect and you relay messages back and forth between them, obviously you can see this

  222. antranigv has joined

  223. Menel

    Yes. But somehow doing it imoresses people still..

  224. Menel

    Yes. But somehow doing it impresses people still..

  225. bake has left

  226. moparisthebest waves hands "signal has more metadata than all of XMPP and Matrix combined"

  227. info has left

  228. ChronosX88 has left

  229. ChronosX88 has joined

  230. wael has joined

  231. ChronosX88 has left

  232. fhtest has left

  233. ChronosX88 has joined

  234. kikuchiyo has joined

  235. info has joined

  236. karim has left

  237. antranigv has left

  238. karme has joined

  239. karim has joined

  240. savagepeanut

    Probably off topic but from past actions Signal does seem legit. I wouldn't complain too much if a contact insisted on signal, certainly better than WhatsApp or SMS. Not to say it's perfect or won't turn spooky, but it does look like a good option and is easy to use/understand. https://signal.org/bigbrother/cd-california-grand-jury/

  241. jc has joined

  242. David has left

  243. Bjarkan has joined

  244. emus has joined

  245. MattJ

    I don't want to make a bold claim I can't back up right now, but as far as I can tell they lied to the courts 馃槄

  246. MattJ

    Check the DB schema in their server repo, and consider that they also store device IDs for push notifications at least

  247. MattJ

    This can be used, with the help of Google/Apple, to identify a specific user/device

  248. patasca has left

  249. homebeach has left

  250. homebeach has joined

  251. savagepeanut

    Hmm. Something to think about and look into

  252. MattJ

    But I agree, if someone wants to do this properly, they should set up a Signal server and do a full write-up

  253. MattJ

    I'm 100% certain there are operational attacks that Signal can perform on its users

  254. moparisthebest

    savagepeanut: and again, this is them saying "we set up our systems not to log" they can change that at anytime without anyone knowing, and an XMPP server can be set up to log nothing also

  255. MattJ

    But am I that interested in taking Signal down a peg? Not especially

  256. moparisthebest

    The difference is there is 1 signal server with metadata on everyone, where as your XMPP server has no metadata on my users, and vice versa

  257. moparisthebest

    Not "you promise not to look" but "you couldn't look if you wanted"

  258. libredev has left

  259. yyyyyypx4 has left

  260. libredev has joined

  261. Bjarkan has left

  262. Bjarkan has joined

  263. savagepeanut

    I am here because I support xmpp and decentralization in general :) I do think the metadata concern is poorly explained whenever mentioned with xmpp, because of what you say about setting up a server. And it's not like anyone I manage to drag onto my server isn't already linked to me.

  264. patasca has joined

  265. *IM* has left

  266. jgart has left

  267. millesimus has left

  268. Bjarkan has left

  269. kuba_ has left

  270. kuba_ has joined

  271. Bjarkan has joined

  272. libredev has left

  273. libredev has joined

  274. frog has left

  275. bake has joined

  276. Huxx has joined

  277. ru_maniac has left

  278. ru_maniac has joined

  279. Ivan A. has left

  280. Ivan A. has joined

  281. Bjarkan has left

  282. Bjarkan has joined

  283. ru_maniac has left

  284. ru_maniac has joined

  285. kuba_ has left

  286. mjk has joined

  287. rozzin

    moparisthebest: > if there's a system you run where 2 people connect and you relay messages back and forth between them, obviously you can see this https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094

  288. sven has joined

  289. Bjarkan has left

  290. kuba_ has joined

  291. Ivan A. has left

  292. Ivan A. has joined

  293. Licaon_Kter

    Yes, maybe reiterate that Signal, just like XMPP and Matrix and Whatsapp and everything else except Briar or Jami, they are ALL store-and-forward systems. So they seed to STORE the message until contact is online and they need to KNOW the contact to be able to forward that message. So if you contact is offline, Signal has your message on their server (ahem Amazons server or Googles server or Microsofts server actually) and they have in memory the ID of your contact. That's why having the LEA asking for "info on target NOW" might be 2 bits of info (like they blog) or "info on target for 1 week" might be...more than 2 lol

  294. Licaon_Kter

    Yes, maybe reiterate that Signal, just like XMPP and Matrix and Whatsapp and everything else except Briar or Jami, they are ALL store-and-forward systems. So they need to STORE the message until contact is online and they need to KNOW the contact to be able to forward that message. So if you contact is offline, Signal has your message on their server (ahem Amazons server or Googles server or Microsofts server actually) and they have in memory the ID of your contact. That's why having the LEA asking for "info on target NOW" might be 2 bits of info (like they blog) or "info on target for 1 week" might be...more than 2 lol

  295. Licaon_Kter

    Yes, maybe reiterate that Signal, just like XMPP and Matrix and Whatsapp and everything else except Briar or Jami, they are ALL store-and-forward systems. So they need to STORE the message until contact is online and they need to KNOW the contact to be able to forward that message. So if your contact is offline, Signal has your message on their server (ahem Amazons server or Googles server or Microsofts server actually) and they have in memory the ID of your contact. That's why having the LEA asking for "info on target NOW" might be 2 bits of info (like they blog) or "info on target for 1 week" might be...more than 2 lol

  296. Licaon_Kter

    Yes, maybe reiterate that Signal, just like XMPP and Matrix and Whatsapp and everything else except Briar or Jami, they are ALL store-and-forward systems. So they need to STORE the message until contact is online and they need to KNOW the contact to be able to forward that message. So if your contact is offline, Signal has your message on their server (ahem Amazons server or Googles server or Microsofts server actually) and they have in memory/storage the ID of your contact. That's why having the LEA asking for "info on target NOW" might be 2 bits of info (like they blog) or "info on target for 1 week" might be...more than 2 lol

  297. patasca has left

  298. alberto has joined

  299. Bjarkan has joined

  300. wladmis has joined

  301. ru_maniac has left

  302. ru_maniac has joined

  303. kuba_ has left

  304. Julian has left

  305. Julian has joined

  306. kuba_ has joined

  307. *IM* has joined

  308. Bjarkan has left

  309. antranigv has joined

  310. MattJ

    Signal accounts have a UUID, a phone number, and a list of devices: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server/blob/65b49b2d9c4fe4a21468e2bb53fb6a7a8a8c49a9/service/src/main/java/org/whispersystems/textsecuregcm/storage/Account.java#L89 A device stores the 'created' and 'lastSeen' timestamps, as Signal often talks about. It also has a 'name', 'userAgent', and several unique IDs issued by Apple/Google: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server/blob/65b49b2d9c4fe4a21468e2bb53fb6a7a8a8c49a9/service/src/main/java/org/whispersystems/textsecuregcm/storage/Device.java#L79

  311. Ivan A. has left

  312. Ivan A. has joined

  313. ru_maniac has left

  314. sven has left

  315. ru_maniac has joined

  316. MattJ

    This is not more than an XMPP server operator has access to, but it's more than they are telling people in their blog posts :)

  317. sven has joined

  318. MattJ

    The difference in XMPP is that you can choose your operator (including yourself), whereas for Signal you can only choose one US entity with infrastructure on US cloud providers

  319. rozzin

    moparisthebest: I hate to be saying this like this, but when you find yourself making an argument like this: > The difference is there is 1 signal server with metadata on everyone, where as your XMPP server has no metadata on my users, and vice versa ... try to imagine that there is a sizable audience who actually is unable to follow any discussion which requires simultaneously visualizing what two separate entities are doing鈥攅ven if that image is symmetrical. Imagine an audience that is basically "not smart enough to grok concepts like 士symmetry示". And then imagine that those people are in all sorts of jobs where you think they couldn't be (like "infosec expert")..., because actually they are.

  320. candyman188 has left

  321. candyman188 has joined

  322. sven has left

  323. kuba_ has left

  324. mightyBroccoli has left

  325. Bjarkan has joined

  326. kuba_ has joined

  327. savagepeanut

    Thanks for the links Matt

  328. sven has joined

  329. mightyBroccoli has joined

  330. ru_maniac has left

  331. ru_maniac has joined

  332. Licaon_Kter

    rozzin: rephrase better

  333. savagepeanut

    > moparisthebest: I hate to be saying this like this, but when you find yourself making an argument like this: I think I've just cracked the code to xmpp adoption. Most people don't understand or care about the protocol you use, extendability, decentralization, or e2e. We need stickers like Signal.

  334. Licaon_Kter

    savagepeanut: old news

  335. frog has joined

  336. kuba_ has left

  337. savagepeanut

    Aw, looks like I'm not as original as I thought. I think Movim does already have stickers though, so I guess that was obvious.

  338. rozzin

    Licaon_Kter: I don't know鈥攊t's 3 AM here so TBH I'm not all that smart myself right now; that may be the best that I can manage.

  339. Bjarkan has left

  340. kuba_ has joined

  341. Bjarkan has joined

  342. gooya has joined

  343. ru_maniac has left

  344. ru_maniac has joined

  345. rozzin

    I also want to provide as a reference a conversation that I had in the Monal MUC in late June 2021, about a friend of mine basically 士running away screaming in terror示 after reading the description of Monal/XMPP in the App Store, but I'm not really even up for the copy/paste/link sequence at the moment.

  346. info has left

  347. candyman188 has left

  348. candyman188 has joined

  349. greenkeeper has joined

  350. Bjarkan has left

  351. homebeach has left

  352. homebeach has joined

  353. patasca has joined

  354. savagepeanut

    Doesn't seem _that_ bad to me, it explained what each extension does at least. Maybe just a "Features" list without scary numbers would be better though, idk.

  355. candyman188 has left

  356. candyman188 has joined

  357. Steven Roose has joined

  358. info has joined

  359. kuba_ has left

  360. kuba_ has joined

  361. JRHaigh has left

  362. Bjarkan has joined

  363. rozzin

    Basically, there are lots of people who are more easily confused than you might think is even possible, for whom what's totally obvious to you is not only 士not obvious at all示 but borderline unthinkable, and who can read what you intend to be positive/negative depictions completely backward e.g. "there's only 1 monopoly server" is "simpler and better because I don't have to think about complicated multi-server scenarios or multi-party trust scenarios or weigh alternatives and make choices; Moxie's a good guy and knows what he's doing, so if all I have to do is trust him then that's a win for me".

  364. karim has left

  365. karim has joined

  366. JRHaigh has joined

  367. Bjarkan has left

  368. Licaon_Kter

    We got that already.

  369. info has left

  370. Licaon_Kter

    I'm thinking a one phrase to encompass all that tech stuff would be nice.

  371. Licaon_Kter

    I'm thinking that one phrase to encompass all that tech stuff would be nice.

  372. candyman188 has left

  373. candyman188 has joined

  374. info has joined

  375. Licaon_Kter

    _"The Signal server has all the metadata of all Signal users, but Moxie promises not to look at it. An XMPP server has only that of its users, and You can be the admin._

  376. loopboom has joined

  377. Licaon_Kter

    I tried 炉\_(銉)_/炉

  378. Licaon_Kter

    -------- I tried 炉\_(銉)_/炉

  379. MRZA has left

  380. patasca has left

  381. theo has left

  382. MRZA has joined

  383. jayteeuk has left

  384. Bjarkan has joined

  385. Ivan A. has left

  386. Ivan A. has joined

  387. Silvio Titzmann has joined

  388. gooya has left

  389. gooya has joined

  390. jayteeuk has joined

  391. jayteeuk has left

  392. jayteeuk has joined

  393. mathieui

    "But they say they don't keep it!!! And it is split on several different servers managed by the same people on the same AWS tenant, so what could go wrong"

  394. JRHaigh has left

  395. info has left

  396. Licaon_Kter

    That's not an argument dismissing what I said lol

  397. Maranda

    > <mathieui> "But they say they don't keep it!!! And it is split on several different servers managed by the same people on the same AWS tenant, so what could go wrong" The NSA gonna catch 'em all? Pok茅mon style?

  398. Maranda

    馃樃

  399. ' has left

  400. theo has joined

  401. ' has joined

  402. [czar] has left

  403. [czar] has joined

  404. suren has left

  405. suren has joined

  406. alberto has left

  407. Steven Roose has left

  408. WojtekIM has joined

  409. Wojtek has joined

  410. raghavgururajan has joined

  411. [czar] has left

  412. [czar] has joined

  413. ChronosX88 has left

  414. ChronosX88 has joined

  415. kuba_ has left

  416. mjk

    To be frank, Signal's "sealed sender" sounds sound at a high level: do an anonimous drop that has "deliver to +1555..." written over it. This _could_ work (modulo the spam potential; although blind signature magic could maybe somehow make it not terrible), but the devil is in the implementation, of course. And also in the fact that they don't even mention the fact that it can't work without sender IP address anonymization.

  417. croax

    This one? _Signal is a very secure service mapping your messages to your phone number and hosted by a privacy concerned company on behalf of a NSA foundation while XMPP leaks valuable metadata about XEPs, protocol, coding and nerd stuff to evil admins._

  418. croax

    This one? _Signal is a very secure service mapping your messages to your phone number and hosted by a privacy concerned company on behalf of a NSA foundation while XMPP leaks valuable metadata about XEPs, protocol, coding and nerd stuff discussions to evil admins._

  419. kuba_ has joined

  420. info has joined

  421. Licaon_Kter

    Oh, I see what you did there...

  422. Licaon_Kter

    One correction: _only to your evil admins_

  423. kuba_ has left

  424. riccio has left

  425. riccio has joined

  426. Ivan A. has left

  427. Ivan A. has joined

  428. kuba_ has joined

  429. SUN has left

  430. ' has left

  431. ' has joined

  432. mjk

    > _ XMPP leaks valuable metadata about XEPs, protocol, coding and nerd stuff discussions_ *sad laugh*

  433. info has left

  434. alberto has joined

  435. Sammy8806 has left

  436. Ivan A. has left

  437. Ivan A. has joined

  438. JRHaigh has joined

  439. ' has left

  440. ' has joined

  441. Ivan A. has left

  442. Ivan A. has joined

  443. John has joined

  444. kfv has left

  445. kfv has joined

  446. loopboom has left

  447. kfv has left

  448. kfv has joined

  449. Sammy8806 has joined

  450. JRHaigh has left

  451. Ivan A. has left

  452. Ivan A. has joined

  453. kfv has left

  454. kfv has joined

  455. suren has left

  456. suren has joined

  457. JRHaigh has joined

  458. kuba_ has left

  459. Ivan A. has left

  460. Ivan A. has joined

  461. ChronosX88 has left

  462. ChronosX88 has joined

  463. suren has left

  464. suren has joined

  465. David has joined

  466. kuba_ has joined

  467. suren has left

  468. ChronosX88 has left

  469. ChronosX88 has joined

  470. Steven Roose has joined

  471. suren has joined

  472. Steven Roose has left

  473. Steven Roose has joined

  474. *IM* has left

  475. Apollo has left

  476. Apollo has joined

  477. jayteeuk has left

  478. jayteeuk has joined

  479. jayteeuk has left

  480. jayteeuk has joined

  481. marc0s has left

  482. marc0s has joined

  483. suren has left

  484. suren has joined

  485. kfv has left

  486. kfv has joined

  487. *IM* has joined

  488. marc0s has left

  489. marc0s has joined

  490. Steven Roose has left

  491. jayteeuk has left

  492. jayteeuk has joined

  493. Steven Roose has joined

  494. Steven Roose has left

  495. alacer has left

  496. Steven Roose has joined

  497. alacer has joined

  498. emus

    Sometimes I feel I troll without intention^^

  499. alacer has left

  500. Dexter has joined

  501. alacer has joined

  502. emus has left

  503. Huxx has left

  504. Huxx has joined

  505. emus has joined

  506. fhtest has joined

  507. fhtest has left

  508. ilmaisin_ has joined

  509. kuba_ has left

  510. ibikk has left

  511. loopboom has joined

  512. Menel

    No, it's everyone else 馃榾. You just provided the stage, without intention. But its more a social exercise then trolling I think

  513. emus

    ^^ I invite everyone to blame me if users start claiming about following a standards organsiation 馃槈炉\_(銉)_/炉

  514. kuba_ has joined

  515. agentcasey has left

  516. agentcasey has joined

  517. agentcasey has left

  518. agentcasey has joined

  519. TheXanMan has left

  520. mister has joined

  521. millesimus has joined

  522. iink has joined

  523. info has joined

  524. mjk

    All blame would be yours! :))

  525. loopboom has left

  526. ' has left

  527. ' has joined

  528. theo has left

  529. theo has joined

  530. info has left

  531. kuba_ has left

  532. wladmis has left

  533. wladmis has joined

  534. suren has left

  535. suren has joined

  536. uwind7 has joined

  537. wladmis has left

  538. wladmis has joined

  539. ChronosX88 has left

  540. ChronosX88 has joined

  541. *IM* has left

  542. kryptos has joined

  543. TheXanMan has joined

  544. undefined has left

  545. jayteeuk has left

  546. b43 has left

  547. suren has left

  548. suren has joined

  549. jayteeuk has joined

  550. kfv has left

  551. kfv has joined

  552. ChronosX88 has left

  553. ChronosX88 has joined

  554. libredev has left

  555. ChronosX88 has left

  556. ChronosX88 has joined

  557. alien has left

  558. undefined has joined

  559. suren has left

  560. suren has joined

  561. TheXanMan has left

  562. jayteeuk has left

  563. jayteeuk has joined

  564. ChronosX88 has left

  565. ChronosX88 has joined

  566. gooya has left

  567. gooya has joined

  568. ian has left

  569. ian has joined

  570. *IM* has joined

  571. Apollo has left

  572. xi has left

  573. loopboom has joined

  574. ross has left

  575. ross has joined

  576. karme has left

  577. ross has left

  578. ross has joined

  579. xi has joined

  580. kikuchiyo has left

  581. TheXanMan has joined

  582. jonas鈥

    all the blame are belong to us

  583. jonas鈥

    all your blame are belong to us

  584. suren has left

  585. xi has left

  586. emus

    yes

  587. suren has joined

  588. xi has joined

  589. Christopher M0YNG has left

  590. Bjarkan has left

  591. Christopher M0YNG has joined

  592. Bjarkan has joined

  593. WojtekIM has left

  594. Wojtek has left

  595. suren has left

  596. suren has joined

  597. Wojtek has joined

  598. WojtekIM has joined

  599. kuba_ has joined

  600. TheXanMan has left

  601. iink has left

  602. Bjarkan has left

  603. TheXanMan has joined

  604. suren has left

  605. suren has joined

  606. karme has joined

  607. alien has joined

  608. moparisthebest has left

  609. TheCoffeMaker

    Thx folks ... U provided a lot of arguments to have in the toolbox when its time discuss about IM providers and services

  610. Bjarkan has joined

  611. ChronosX88 has left

  612. ChronosX88 has joined

  613. Maranda[x] has left

  614. Maranda[x] has joined

  615. suren has left

  616. suren has joined

  617. xi has left

  618. ibikk has joined

  619. Bjarkan has left

  620. xi has joined

  621. emus

    There is something in development I think

  622. suren has left

  623. suren has joined

  624. jayteeuk has left

  625. jayteeuk has joined

  626. ian has left

  627. ian has joined

  628. TheXanMan has left

  629. Apollo has joined

  630. Bjarkan has joined

  631. suren has left

  632. suren has joined

  633. jayteeuk has left

  634. jayteeuk has joined

  635. Bjarkan has left

  636. suren has left

  637. suren has joined

  638. fhtest has joined

  639. fhtest has left

  640. fhtest has joined

  641. info has joined

  642. uwind7 has left

  643. Wojtek has left

  644. Wojtek has joined

  645. ian has left

  646. ian has joined

  647. fhtest has left

  648. jayteeuk has left

  649. loopboom has left

  650. jayteeuk has joined

  651. quantumwings has left

  652. Bjarkan has joined

  653. moparisthebest has joined

  654. quantumwings has joined

  655. suren has left

  656. suren has joined

  657. jayteeuk has left

  658. jayteeuk has joined

  659. jayteeuk has left

  660. jayteeuk has joined

  661. jayteeuk has left

  662. jayteeuk has joined

  663. jayteeuk has left

  664. jayteeuk has joined

  665. jayteeuk has left

  666. jayteeuk has joined

  667. Ingolf has left

  668. Ingolf has joined

  669. jayteeuk has left

  670. jayteeuk has joined

  671. croax has left

  672. croax has joined

  673. kfv has left

  674. kfv has joined

  675. patasca has joined

  676. Bjarkan has left

  677. Bjarkan has joined

  678. raghavgururajan has left

  679. raghavgururajan has joined

  680. Licaon_Kter

    https://upload.convorb.im/7c370453f738f2c0c995eaee643e5e0aba76aeb0/j4INu5LDqhEZxEVHxotVg8rrTKCggKQA9Jun8oWv/YWiUPyWEQBC3tTWNNDQH9A.jpg

  681. kuba_ has left

  682. Licaon_Kter

    Fedi fans, yours for the taking, spread out and zeal!

  683. info has left

  684. kr1p has joined

  685. info has joined

  686. TheCoffeMaker

    Licaon_Kter: 馃ぃ

  687. kuba_ has joined

  688. frog has left

  689. jayteeuk has left

  690. jayteeuk has joined

  691. Wojtek has left

  692. WojtekIM has left

  693. info has left

  694. jayteeuk has left

  695. jayteeuk has joined

  696. jayteeuk has left

  697. jayteeuk has joined

  698. jayteeuk has left

  699. jayteeuk has joined

  700. antranigv has left

  701. kuba has joined

  702. Bjarkan has left

  703. MRZA has left

  704. MRZA has joined

  705. jayteeuk has left

  706. jayteeuk has joined

  707. Bjarkan has joined

  708. jayteeuk has left

  709. jayteeuk has joined

  710. jayteeuk has left

  711. jayteeuk has joined

  712. Dexter has left

  713. WojtekIM has joined

  714. Wojtek has joined

  715. jayteeuk has left

  716. jayteeuk has joined

  717. b43 has joined

  718. Dexter has joined

  719. jayteeuk has left

  720. jayteeuk has joined

  721. neox has left

  722. frog has joined

  723. suren has left

  724. jayteeuk has left

  725. jayteeuk has joined

  726. suren has joined

  727. antranigv has joined

  728. theo has left

  729. theo has joined

  730. disgyze has left

  731. suren has left

  732. suren has joined

  733. kuba has left

  734. kuba_ has left

  735. jayteeuk has left

  736. jayteeuk has joined

  737. kuba_ has joined

  738. suren has left

  739. suren has joined

  740. b43 has left

  741. suren has left

  742. suren has joined

  743. suren has left

  744. suren has joined

  745. ian has left

  746. ian has joined

  747. Ivan A. has left

  748. Ivan A. has joined

  749. greenkeeper has left

  750. greenkeeper has joined

  751. ian has left

  752. ian has joined

  753. ian has left

  754. ian has joined

  755. suren has left

  756. suren has joined

  757. ian has left

  758. info has joined

  759. ian has joined

  760. frog has left

  761. ian has left

  762. ian has joined

  763. antranigv has left

  764. croax

    Looks like a big security _owl_

  765. antranigv has joined

  766. ' has left

  767. ' has joined

  768. jayteeuk has left

  769. jayteeuk has joined

  770. Ingolf has left

  771. TheXanMan has joined

  772. wladmis has left

  773. wladmis has joined

  774. jayteeuk has left

  775. jayteeuk has joined

  776. ibikk has left

  777. info has left

  778. info has joined

  779. alien has left

  780. patasca has left

  781. homebeach has left

  782. homebeach has joined

  783. jayteeuk has left

  784. jayteeuk has joined

  785. patasca has joined

  786. jayteeuk has left

  787. jayteeuk has joined

  788. suren has left

  789. suren has joined

  790. TheXanMan has left

  791. theo has left

  792. me9-backup has joined

  793. me9 has joined

  794. jayteeuk has left

  795. jayteeuk has joined

  796. patasca has left

  797. neox has joined

  798. alacer has left

  799. alacer has joined

  800. suren has left

  801. suren has joined

  802. TheXanMan has joined

  803. jayteeuk has left

  804. jayteeuk has joined

  805. Bjarkan has left

  806. ibikk has joined

  807. jayteeuk has left

  808. jayteeuk has joined

  809. ffuentes has left

  810. ffuentes has joined

  811. ross has left

  812. ross has joined

  813. emus has left

  814. TheXanMan has left

  815. Holger has left

  816. suren has left

  817. suren has joined

  818. Maranda[x] has left

  819. rozzin

    > The difference in XMPP is that you can choose your operator (including yourself), whereas for Signal you can only choose one US entity with infrastructure on US cloud providers So you're saying... that as an American, with Signal I only have to trust 1 domestic company that all of my peers already trust, instead of a whole bunch of different independent operators who might even be foreign spy agencies; and I can be sure that none of my data is ever leaving the country and going to China or Putinstan or whoever if I use Signal, whereas if I use XMPP I need to continually go through this giant effort to find out who's running the services that each and every person I talk to uses, and I have to read I-can't-even-know-how-many different operators ToS docs and decide whether I trust each of those operators to even keep whatever promises the make...?

  820. JRHaigh has left

  821. Maranda[x] has joined

  822. Ge0rG

    one domestic company, one domestic cloud provider and one domestic government with a dozen of secret agencies?

  823. Link Mauve

    rozzin, exactly, as long as you are sure you are and will stay in the good will of your country, you can trust it I guess.

  824. Ge0rG

    I've heard that depending on your skin color, you have high chances of being killed by the government in a random encounter, like a routine traffic inspection.

  825. Link Mauve

    Although I guess your country treats even its own citizens as potential threats.

  826. Link Mauve

    Right, or that.

  827. MattJ

    Okay, the borderline off-topic is going pretty off-topic

  828. rozzin

    馃う

  829. ffuentes has left

  830. info has left

  831. me9-backup has left

  832. Link Mauve

    Sorry.

  833. ian has left

  834. ian has joined

  835. Sam

    The threat vector difference discussion is worth having for operators, I think. The what-about-ism doesn't help that though. It may be perfectly reasonable to want to centralize in a single country or other political environment, even if that environment has serious problems. The problem with rozzin's initial argument is that it makes it sound like all the information is always going to untrusted sources, but it's not, you only have to trust servers that you *choose* to communicate with (or that you allow to communicate with you).

  836. candyman188 has left

  837. Sam

    So deciding between a single provider with resources in a single place and many providers with resources in many places really depends on what the threat is you're trying to protect against?

  838. MattJ

    Sam, I'm okay with on-topic stuff relevant to operators, but in the past 15 minutes or so there were specific countries named that are likely to provoke, discussion about skin colour and non-internet law enforcement scenarios, etc.

  839. ffuentes has joined

  840. Sam

    yah, I was trying to redirect it back to rozzin's initial threat discussion

  841. jgart has joined

  842. 404.city has joined

  843. MattJ

    Sure, that's fine if we can manage that

  844. 404.city has left

  845. Holger has joined

  846. MattJ

    I'm a pessimist in this regard, nowadays :)

  847. TheXanMan has joined

  848. Sam

    You could also argue that you don't have to trust the servers you're contacting yourself. In either situation you have to trust your contacts to not leave their phone in a bar, or screenshot and post your messages, so maybe it's worth trusting them to pick a safe server too (or maybe not? I don't know if that's significantly harder than not leaving your phone lying around unlocked or not)

  849. me9 has left

  850. Dexter has left

  851. Dexter has joined

  852. info has joined

  853. Licaon_Kter

    rozzin: the issue is _"my peers trust"_, how what that trust gained exactly? By false advertisment of "no messages on server" and "we don't know who you message"?

  854. emus has joined

  855. ian has left

  856. ian has joined

  857. rozzin

    I do want to be clear that the point of my comment was to show just how easily these sort of well-intentioned statements that we about "open and federated and international band of small independent hackers with no political ties" type of arguments that *we* (myself included, actually) find so appealing... can be pretty grossly misread when they land in the wrong audience. If you're wondering why we're failing at "mass appeal"..., it's helpful to remember that "the masses" are actually a pretty big part of anything with the word "mass" in it. And yes there are multiple different-even-if-overlapping "mass" audiences, so be clear on which ones you're targetting at any given point in time.

  858. kuba_ has left

  859. kuba_ has joined

  860. rozzin

    I'll try to pull together that monal MUC conversation I referenced last night, since I'm awake again now.

  861. alien has joined

  862. TheXanMan has left

  863. sven has left

  864. SUN has joined

  865. candyman188 has joined

  866. patasca has joined

  867. JRHaigh has joined

  868. kr1p has left

  869. suren has left

  870. suren has joined

  871. kfv has left

  872. kfv has joined

  873. theo has joined

  874. antranigv has left

  875. frog has joined

  876. suren has left

  877. suren has joined

  878. TheXanMan has joined

  879. patasca has left

  880. rozzin

    > The problem with rozzin's initial argument is that it makes it sound like all the information is always going to untrusted sources, but it's not, you only have to trust servers that you *choose* to communicate with (or that you allow to communicate with you). Well, no the issue there is that the prospective XMPP user is being told that they need to worry about "which *server*" at all, where that reads as a non-issue in the "only one operator to trust" alternative. And you actually just reinforced that with your response 馃槣

  881. MRZA has left

  882. millesimus has left

  883. zcyph

    I just wanted to say I really enjoy this nuanced conversation about the merits & issues of the different platforms/protocols, that is almost completely absent from most other places.

  884. Licaon_Kter

    rozzin: not sure XMPP zealots brought up this

  885. candyman188 has left

  886. zcyph

    I've used all of these and hosted both XMPP, Matrix, Session Open Groups etc. I like XMPP more as time goes on, because it doesn't seem to randomly run into issues and become bloated, small server resources footprint all things considered. I heard a lot about "the metadata issue" for Matrix and XMPP in Session chats (expected, since "no metadata" is their slogan)

  887. info has left

  888. info has joined

  889. Licaon_Kter

    The way I've seen discourse, _"hey, wanna get out of the toxic silo, use xmpp"_ and the answer from security ~theater~tweeter was _"omfg metadata, use signal, no message stored, they don't know who you talk with, etc"_

  890. candyman188 has joined

  891. zcyph

    Signal works great, but the phone number requirement, the centralization, and them being hosted on Google/AWS rubs me the wrong way.

  892. zcyph

    The flip side of that is, people often aren't interested in the added effort of needing to learn something other than the app automatically harvesting contacts *for your convenience

  893. patasca has joined

  894. Licaon_Kter

    Quicksy covers this case pretty neatly, has numbers for normies that don't care, but still has federation.

  895. mister has left

  896. MRZA has joined

  897. moparisthebest has left

  898. zcyph

    I didn't know Quicksy, I'll check it out

  899. rozzin

    Yeah in general "it's so much better, all you have to do is [list of new concerns you'd need to manage during and/or after switching that you don't need to think about now]" seems like... unlikely to be convincing.

  900. zcyph

    I liked xmpp for work environment, we used it for years at the telco i worked at until one day they decided to replace it with google hangouts :-(

  901. qy

    Ew

  902. zcyph

    apparently maintaining xmpp was too much for major national telco to justify

  903. balabol.im has left

  904. wladmis has left

  905. wladmis has joined

  906. kuba_ has left

  907. balabol.im has joined

  908. homebeach has left

  909. homebeach has joined

  910. kuba_ has joined

  911. Holger has left

  912. qy

    I thought telecom companies used erlang anyway

  913. info has left

  914. qy

    Just ejabberd it up

  915. Holger has joined

  916. MRZA has left

  917. frog has left

  918. info has joined

  919. kuba_ has left

  920. TheXanMan has left

  921. kuba_ has joined

  922. MRZA has joined

  923. theo has left

  924. suren has left

  925. suren has joined

  926. henrik has left

  927. andrath has left

  928. andrath has joined

  929. scilens has left

  930. Maranda has left

  931. Mjolnir Archon has left

  932. kuba_ has left

  933. Mjolnir Archon has joined

  934. Mjolnir Archon has left

  935. kuba_ has joined

  936. Mjolnir Archon has joined

  937. Maranda has joined

  938. scilens has joined

  939. ChronosX88 has left

  940. ChronosX88 has joined

  941. henrik has joined

  942. ChronosX88 has left

  943. fhtest has joined

  944. ChronosX88 has joined

  945. ChronosX88 has left

  946. ChronosX88 has joined

  947. ChronosX88 has left

  948. frog has joined

  949. ChronosX88 has joined

  950. jayteeuk has left

  951. jayteeuk has joined

  952. b43 has joined

  953. jgart has left

  954. mjk has left

  955. suren has left

  956. suren has joined

  957. mjk has joined

  958. patasca has left

  959. Wojtek has left

  960. WojtekIM has left

  961. WojtekIM has joined

  962. WojtekIM has left

  963. Wojtek has joined

  964. WojtekIM has joined

  965. patasca has joined

  966. jayteeuk has left

  967. jayteeuk has joined

  968. marc0s has left

  969. jayteeuk has left

  970. jayteeuk has joined

  971. marc0s has joined

  972. suren has left

  973. suren has joined

  974. patasca has left

  975. patasca has joined

  976. Steven Roose has left

  977. Steven Roose has joined

  978. moparisthebest has joined

  979. Steven Roose has left

  980. Steven Roose has joined

  981. b43 has left

  982. Bjarkan has joined

  983. suren has left

  984. suren has joined

  985. WojtekIM has left

  986. Wojtek has left

  987. WojtekIM has joined

  988. Wojtek has joined

  989. patasca has left

  990. TheXanMan has joined

  991. suren has left

  992. suren has joined

  993. patasca has joined

  994. ffuentes has left

  995. ffuentes has joined

  996. raghavgururajan has left

  997. raghavgururajan has joined

  998. JRHaigh has left

  999. info has left

  1000. ianblas27 has joined

  1001. ianblas27 has left

  1002. alien has left

  1003. info has joined

  1004. alien has joined

  1005. ffuentes has left

  1006. ffuentes has joined

  1007. fpyrih has joined

  1008. fhtest has left

  1009. ChronosX88 has left

  1010. ChronosX88 has joined

  1011. info has left

  1012. info has joined

  1013. Douglas Terabyte has left

  1014. *IM* has left

  1015. suren has left

  1016. suren has joined

  1017. sven has joined

  1018. kryptos has left

  1019. antranigv has joined

  1020. JRHaigh has joined

  1021. william.chatner has joined

  1022. *IM* has joined

  1023. ChronosX88 has left

  1024. ChronosX88 has joined

  1025. jayteeuk has left

  1026. suren has left

  1027. suren has joined

  1028. greenkeeper has left

  1029. greenkeeper has joined

  1030. millesimus has joined

  1031. Douglas Terabyte has joined

  1032. jayteeuk has joined

  1033. yyyyyypx4 has joined

  1034. ChronosX88 has left

  1035. ChronosX88 has joined

  1036. ChronosX88 has left

  1037. ChronosX88 has joined

  1038. yyyyyypx4 has left

  1039. yyyyyypx4 has joined

  1040. jgart has joined

  1041. TheXanMan has left

  1042. JRHaigh has left

  1043. info has left

  1044. emus has left

  1045. JRHaigh has joined

  1046. rafasaurus has left

  1047. rafasaurus has joined

  1048. opensourced has left

  1049. John has left

  1050. opensourced has joined

  1051. John has joined

  1052. patasca has left

  1053. kryptos has joined

  1054. TheXanMan has joined

  1055. info has joined

  1056. millesimus has left

  1057. p55s has left

  1058. Bjarkan has left

  1059. Bjarkan has joined

  1060. suren has left

  1061. suren has joined

  1062. jayteeuk has left

  1063. jayteeuk has joined

  1064. patasca has joined

  1065. Bjarkan has left

  1066. jayteeuk has left

  1067. jayteeuk has joined

  1068. patasca has left

  1069. patasca has joined

  1070. suren has left

  1071. suren has joined

  1072. TheXanMan has left

  1073. jayteeuk has left

  1074. jayteeuk has joined

  1075. millesimus has joined

  1076. Apollo has left

  1077. Apollo has joined

  1078. jgart has left

  1079. suren has left

  1080. suren has joined

  1081. homebeach has left

  1082. homebeach has joined

  1083. Douglas Terabyte has left

  1084. b43 has joined

  1085. rafasaurus has left

  1086. rafasaurus has joined

  1087. Bjarkan has joined

  1088. alacer has left

  1089. alacer has joined

  1090. mirux has left

  1091. mirux has joined

  1092. andrath has left

  1093. andrath has joined

  1094. mirux has left

  1095. suren has left

  1096. suren has joined

  1097. mirux has joined

  1098. mirux has left

  1099. mirux has joined

  1100. suren has left

  1101. suren has joined

  1102. Apollo has left

  1103. alacer has left

  1104. Ivan A. has left

  1105. Ivan A. has joined

  1106. alacer has joined

  1107. Ivan A. has left

  1108. Ivan A. has joined

  1109. patasca has left

  1110. Ivan A. has left

  1111. homebeach has left

  1112. homebeach has joined

  1113. Ivan A. has joined

  1114. ffuentes has left

  1115. ffuentes has joined

  1116. Ivan A. has left

  1117. Ivan A. has joined

  1118. Ivan A. has left

  1119. Ivan A. has joined

  1120. patasca has joined

  1121. mirux has left

  1122. jayteeuk has left

  1123. Wojtek has left

  1124. WojtekIM has left

  1125. suren has left

  1126. suren has joined

  1127. Ivan A. has left

  1128. Ivan A. has joined

  1129. millesimus has left

  1130. Ivan A. has left

  1131. Ivan A. has joined

  1132. alacer has left

  1133. me9-backup has joined

  1134. me9 has joined

  1135. Ivan A. has left

  1136. Ivan A. has joined

  1137. jayteeuk has joined

  1138. TheXanMan has joined

  1139. frog has left

  1140. patasca has left

  1141. ChronosX88 has left

  1142. ChronosX88 has joined

  1143. Ivan A. has left

  1144. Ivan A. has joined

  1145. kbt100 has left

  1146. loopboom has joined

  1147. kbt100 has joined

  1148. frog has joined

  1149. emus has joined

  1150. jc has left

  1151. suren has left

  1152. suren has joined

  1153. TheXanMan has left

  1154. jayteeuk has left

  1155. patasca has joined

  1156. rafasaurus has left

  1157. ibikk has left

  1158. alacer has joined

  1159. suren has left

  1160. suren has joined

  1161. Douglas Terabyte has joined

  1162. millesimus has joined

  1163. x51 has joined

  1164. Ivan A. has left

  1165. Ivan A. has joined

  1166. x51 has left

  1167. jayteeuk has joined

  1168. rafasaurus has joined

  1169. Ian Blas has left

  1170. Ivan A. has left

  1171. Ian Blas has joined

  1172. Apollo has joined

  1173. millesimus has left

  1174. me9 has left

  1175. millesimus has joined

  1176. suren has left

  1177. suren has joined

  1178. wladmis has left

  1179. Ivan A. has joined

  1180. jayteeuk has left

  1181. rafasaurus has left

  1182. TheXanMan has joined

  1183. rafasaurus has joined

  1184. suren has left

  1185. suren has joined

  1186. *IM* has left

  1187. MSavoritias (she,they) has left

  1188. frog has left

  1189. ffuentes has left

  1190. jayteeuk has joined

  1191. *IM* has joined

  1192. jayteeuk has left

  1193. jayteeuk has joined

  1194. ffuentes has joined

  1195. jayteeuk has left

  1196. jayteeuk has joined

  1197. alacer has left

  1198. Ivan A. has left

  1199. Ivan A. has joined

  1200. jayteeuk has left

  1201. jayteeuk has joined

  1202. Steven Roose has left

  1203. suren has left

  1204. suren has joined

  1205. millesimus has left

  1206. TheXanMan has left

  1207. neox has left

  1208. Menel has left

  1209. ' has left

  1210. suren has left

  1211. suren has joined

  1212. ' has joined

  1213. Silvio Titzmann has left

  1214. kuba_ has left

  1215. emus has left

  1216. kuba_ has joined

  1217. emus has joined

  1218. karme has left

  1219. [czar] has left

  1220. moparisthebest has left

  1221. [czar] has joined

  1222. moparisthebest has joined

  1223. millesimus has joined

  1224. mjk has left

  1225. alacer has joined

  1226. etaurus has left

  1227. etaurus has joined

  1228. suren has left

  1229. suren has joined

  1230. kr1p has joined

  1231. jayteeuk has left

  1232. karim has left

  1233. karim has joined

  1234. TheXanMan has joined

  1235. dinosaurdynasty has left

  1236. suren has left

  1237. etaurus has left

  1238. suren has joined

  1239. Dead Head has left

  1240. Dexter has left

  1241. alacer has left

  1242. Dexter has joined

  1243. fhtest has joined

  1244. etaurus has joined

  1245. alacer has joined

  1246. suren has left

  1247. suren has joined

  1248. Dead Head has joined

  1249. dinosaurdynasty has joined

  1250. TheXanMan has left

  1251. pod has left

  1252. alberto has left

  1253. suren has left

  1254. suren has joined

  1255. neox has joined

  1256. kuba_ has left

  1257. dinosaurdynasty has left

  1258. kuba_ has joined

  1259. millesimus has left

  1260. ilmaisin_ has left

  1261. ilmaisin_ has joined

  1262. dinosaurdynasty has joined

  1263. TheXanMan has joined

  1264. patasca has left

  1265. patasca has joined

  1266. p55s has joined

  1267. kfv has left

  1268. millesimus has joined

  1269. kfv has joined

  1270. marc0s has left

  1271. marc0s has joined