XSF Discussion - 2017-10-25


  1. dwd has left

  2. la|r|ma has joined

  3. Arc has left

  4. Zash has left

  5. arc has left

  6. daniel has left

  7. arc has joined

  8. daniel has joined

  9. arc has left

  10. arc has joined

  11. arc has left

  12. arc has joined

  13. arc has left

  14. arc has joined

  15. Zash has joined

  16. arc has left

  17. arc has joined

  18. daniel has left

  19. daniel has joined

  20. la|r|ma has left

  21. la|r|ma has joined

  22. dwd has joined

  23. dwd has left

  24. Alex has joined

  25. Alex has left

  26. Valerian has left

  27. zinid has left

  28. la|r|ma has joined

  29. Valerian has joined

  30. lskdjf has joined

  31. arc has left

  32. arc has joined

  33. lumi has left

  34. Arc has joined

  35. Valerian has left

  36. ralphm has left

  37. Valerian has joined

  38. Valerian has left

  39. Valerian has joined

  40. Valerian has left

  41. tux has left

  42. tux has joined

  43. nyco has left

  44. sonny has joined

  45. sonny has joined

  46. dwd has joined

  47. Lance has joined

  48. Lance has left

  49. SouL has joined

  50. alacer has left

  51. alacer has joined

  52. arc has left

  53. arc has joined

  54. Arc has left

  55. arc has left

  56. arc has joined

  57. uc has joined

  58. arc has left

  59. arc has joined

  60. Tobias has joined

  61. sonny has joined

  62. arc has left

  63. arc has joined

  64. goffi has joined

  65. sonny has joined

  66. arc has left

  67. arc has joined

  68. Tobias has joined

  69. Guus has left

  70. Arc has joined

  71. SamWhited has left

  72. ralphm has left

  73. dwd has left

  74. dwd has joined

  75. dwd has left

  76. ralphm has left

  77. Guus has left

  78. ralphm has joined

  79. Guus has left

  80. ralphm has left

  81. intosi has joined

  82. arc has left

  83. arc has joined

  84. daniel has left

  85. intosi has left

  86. dwd has joined

  87. jcbrand has joined

  88. arc has left

  89. arc has joined

  90. ralphm has joined

  91. daniel has joined

  92. Guus has left

  93. daniel has left

  94. Arc has left

  95. daniel has joined

  96. Guus has left

  97. Guus has joined

  98. jcbrand has left

  99. arc has left

  100. arc has joined

  101. arc has left

  102. arc has joined

  103. Kev has left

  104. jcbrand has joined

  105. daniel has left

  106. daniel has joined

  107. Guus has left

  108. Kev has joined

  109. Guus has joined

  110. Steve Kille has left

  111. Steve Kille has joined

  112. lskdjf has joined

  113. Syndace has left

  114. jcbrand has left

  115. daniel has left

  116. daniel has joined

  117. ralphm has left

  118. arc has left

  119. arc has joined

  120. Tobias has joined

  121. arc has left

  122. arc has joined

  123. arc has left

  124. arc has joined

  125. arc has left

  126. arc has joined

  127. jubalh has joined

  128. arc has left

  129. arc has joined

  130. arc has left

  131. arc has joined

  132. Arc has joined

  133. dwd has left

  134. daniel has left

  135. daniel has joined

  136. dwd has left

  137. dwd has left

  138. dwd has left

  139. dwd has left

  140. dwd has left

  141. ralphm has left

  142. mimi89999 has joined

  143. mimi89999 has joined

  144. dwd has left

  145. jubalh has left

  146. ralphm has left

  147. ralphm has joined

  148. lskdjf has joined

  149. ralphm has left

  150. Ge0rG has left

  151. Guus has left

  152. Guus has joined

  153. dwd has left

  154. ralphm has joined

  155. dwd has left

  156. dwd has left

  157. daniel has left

  158. daniel has joined

  159. ralphm has left

  160. ralphm has joined

  161. jcbrand has joined

  162. ralphm has joined

  163. Arc has left

  164. la|r|ma has joined

  165. zinid has left

  166. Tobias has joined

  167. dwd has left

  168. ralphm has joined

  169. alacer has joined

  170. zinid has left

  171. zinid has left

  172. Syndace has left

  173. alacer has joined

  174. ralphm has left

  175. ralphm has left

  176. jubalh has joined

  177. zinid has left

  178. Zash has left

  179. Zash has joined

  180. lskdjf has joined

  181. dwd has left

  182. daniel has left

  183. daniel has joined

  184. dwd has left

  185. Guus has left

  186. Guus has joined

  187. jubalh has left

  188. alacer has joined

  189. Syndace has left

  190. ralphm has joined

  191. jubalh has left

  192. ralphm has left

  193. Bunneh has left

  194. Bunneh has joined

  195. jere has joined

  196. jere has left

  197. jere has joined

  198. Valerian has joined

  199. daniel has left

  200. jcbrand has left

  201. lumi has joined

  202. ralphm has joined

  203. daniel has left

  204. la|r|ma has left

  205. tux has joined

  206. Valerian has left

  207. ralphm has left

  208. lskdjf has left

  209. jubalh has left

  210. jubalh has left

  211. Guus has left

  212. Guus has joined

  213. jubalh has left

  214. jubalh has joined

  215. jubalh has left

  216. jubalh has joined

  217. jubalh has left

  218. jubalh has left

  219. intosi has joined

  220. jubalh has left

  221. jubalh has joined

  222. sonny has left

  223. sonny has joined

  224. jubalh has left

  225. sonny has left

  226. sonny has joined

  227. jubalh has left

  228. jubalh has left

  229. ralphm has joined

  230. uc has left

  231. sonny has left

  232. sonny has joined

  233. sonny has left

  234. sonny has joined

  235. jubalh has left

  236. uc has left

  237. jubalh has left

  238. Valerian has joined

  239. jubalh has left

  240. jubalh has left

  241. jubalh has left

  242. jubalh has left

  243. sonny has left

  244. sonny has joined

  245. jonasw has left

  246. jonasw has joined

  247. jonasw

    poezio looks confused

  248. sonny has joined

  249. sonny has joined

  250. jere has left

  251. jere has joined

  252. sonny has left

  253. sonny has joined

  254. sonny has joined

  255. sonny has joined

  256. lskdjf has left

  257. lskdjf has left

  258. jere has left

  259. jere has joined

  260. sonny has joined

  261. ralphm has left

  262. la|r|ma has joined

  263. lskdjf has left

  264. lskdjf has left

  265. jubalh has joined

  266. jubalh has joined

  267. ralphm has joined

  268. sonny has joined

  269. Tobias has joined

  270. Wiktor has joined

  271. jubalh has joined

  272. daniel has left

  273. edhelas

    hey guys, already heard about that ? https://software-otomax.com/setting-jabber-di-otomax.html

  274. edhelas

    some services are using XMPP servers as money transaction system, mostly in Indonesia

  275. edhelas

    I'm considering those accounts created as spam and deleting them on my server

  276. Zash

    Isn't this more of an operators@ topic?

  277. edhelas

    oh sorry, will discuss about that on operators@

  278. jere has left

  279. jere has joined

  280. jcbrand has joined

  281. Valerian has left

  282. Valerian has joined

  283. Arc has joined

  284. Zash has left

  285. Arc

    wait, crytocurrency transactions, or actual currency?

  286. stefandxm has left

  287. Zash has left

  288. zinid

    xmpp can be used for cryptocurrencies, because, despite the intention, they fall into "trust your server" category (e.g. there is full-mode node holding blockchain and lots of tiny clients)

  289. Guus has left

  290. Guus has joined

  291. lumi has joined

  292. lskdjf has left

  293. Arc

    ok

  294. lskdjf has left

  295. ralphm has left

  296. Guus has left

  297. Guus has joined

  298. pps has joined

  299. lskdjf has joined

  300. lskdjf has left

  301. tux has left

  302. lskdjf has left

  303. ralphm has joined

  304. lskdjf has joined

  305. Arc

    ralphm: nyco: you around?

  306. ralphm

    Yes

  307. daniel has left

  308. Arc

    ok so team A today

  309. ralphm

    Awesome?

  310. Arc

    sure A can be awesome, refering to we either have mattj + martin, or ralph + nyco

  311. lskdjf has left

  312. Arc

    do we have anything for the agenda?

  313. ralphm has joined

  314. dwd

    Arc, I believe Martin is travelling right now.

  315. ralphm has joined

  316. ralphm has joined

  317. Arc

    meeting time

  318. Arc

    but do we have quorum?

  319. jere has joined

  320. ralphm

    Hi

  321. ralphm bangs gavel

  322. ralphm

    0. Welcome + Agenda

  323. ralphm

    Who do we have?

  324. Arc

    Here

  325. waqas has joined

  326. jjrh has left

  327. nyco

    hey

  328. nyco

    sorry

  329. nyco

    late... :'(

  330. nyco

    quorum achieved

  331. ralphm

    Besides trello items, anything else we should discuss?

  332. nyco

    I don't see...

  333. Steve Kille has left

  334. Guus

    Summit/fosdem?

  335. Arc

    google code-in is happening

  336. Arc

    XSF missed the application window tho

  337. MattJ has joined

  338. ralphm

    Guus: yeah, I was going to put that on

  339. MattJ

    Sorry, thought I was in the room but I wasn't

  340. ralphm

    Hi MattJ

  341. ralphm

    I see Draft/Stable

  342. ralphm

    And the eternal editor recruitment that I think we can remove

  343. ralphm

    Also elections

  344. nyco

    yeah, summit, only one day this year?

  345. ralphm

    So let's get going

  346. ralphm

    1. FOSDEM / XMPP Summit

  347. nyco

    we got the RTC devroom, thx to Saul, again, thx to him

  348. ralphm

    Why one day only? Last time we easily filled up two days.

  349. nyco

    we have no RTC lounge... yet... afaik

  350. ralphm

    nyco: yeah, I was aware of it all

  351. ralphm

    I will apply for the Lounge as always

  352. nyco

    thx

  353. nyco

    also, isn't that for the SCAM team? what would the board contribute to this?

  354. Guus

    ralphm: please educate me

  355. Guus

    So that I can do it next year

  356. ralphm

    Guus: I know I haven't been very communicative regarding SCAM, but I consider myself associated with it :_D

  357. Guus

    Scam lacks the experience

  358. ralphm

    It is just filling in a form, mostly copy/paste

  359. Steve Kille has left

  360. ralphm

    And the org knows me so that helps too

  361. Guus

    ralphm:cool, but still, you should not be the only capable one

  362. ralphm

    Agreed

  363. ralphm

    So I will list you as contact, too

  364. Guus

    I'm a car now, let's take this on later, scam MUC?

  365. ralphm

    Anyway, board-wise I can only think of two things

  366. dwd has left

  367. ralphm

    a) do we do a Summit?

  368. Valerian has left

  369. lskdjf has left

  370. Arc

    of course?

  371. lskdjf has left

  372. lskdjf has left

  373. ralphm

    b) what things do we need for Summit/FOSDEM and how much money would we need

  374. ralphm

    For b) I think we need to make a little plan within SCAM and then tell board

  375. ralphm

    For a), I totally think we should yes

  376. Guus

    +1

  377. nyco

    you are a car ?

  378. ralphm

    I am not a car.

  379. Guus

    In a car

  380. nyco

    summit, yeah, of course, why not?

  381. nyco

    I guessed, joking ;-)

  382. nyco

    question is rather: 1 or 2 days? and is it a real question?

  383. dwd has left

  384. ralphm

    I'd go with 2 as always

  385. nyco

    why not 5? ;-)

  386. nyco

    2 days, +1 for me as well

  387. Valerian has joined

  388. ralphm

    I pensiled in Feb 1 and 2

  389. Zash has left

  390. Valerian has left

  391. intosi has left

  392. lskdjf has joined

  393. nyco

    so, we pass the hot potato to the SCAM team?

  394. ralphm

    if SCAM has a good plan for more days, I'm very curious about it :-D

  395. nyco

    we can ask this team

  396. nyco

    team answers: none so far

  397. Arc

    the first 365-day summit

  398. ralphm

    Hah

  399. nyco

    oh wow

  400. nyco

    how about 366?

  401. stefandxm has joined

  402. Arc

    because after 365, the next summit begins

  403. dwd has left

  404. nyco

    and, still an open question to the SCAM team: do we keep the very same format?

  405. ralphm

    Good questions. I'd love to answer that with Guus and whoever is in SCAM these days

  406. ralphm

    Is that just nyco?

  407. Guus

    Will formulate answer for next weeks board meeting

  408. Guus

    Daniel too

  409. ralphm

    Ok

  410. nyco

    and Daniel, and you

  411. ralphm

    right

  412. nyco

    left

  413. ralphm

    I didn't leave?

  414. Zash

    ↑↓↑↓

  415. ralphm

    ah

  416. ralphm

    funny

  417. ralphm

    anyway

  418. ralphm

    2. Elections

  419. dwd has left

  420. nyco

    oh

  421. Arc

    they're up

  422. ralphm

    I read in the minutes from last time that Alex was on this, but no update?

  423. Arc

    the pages are on the wiki, official announcements have been made

  424. Guus

    Announcement was made

  425. Arc

    https://wiki.xmpp.org/web/Membership_Applications_Q4_2017

  426. nyco

    so, what do we have to discuss here?

  427. Arc

    https://wiki.xmpp.org/web/Board_and_Council_Elections_2017

  428. Guus

    Board should find candidates of possible

  429. ralphm

    Well, I haven't seen an announcement on that we are looking for candidates?

  430. nyco

    oh, Joe Demo is a candidate, welcome Joe Demo

  431. jjrh has left

  432. ralphm

    In any case, if anyone currently on Board wants to do another term, do add your name there

  433. Arc

    is joe demo a person or a placeholder page

  434. dwd has left

  435. nyco

    placeholder

  436. Arc

    that's what i thought

  437. ralphm

    Well, it is a red link, so not even a page

  438. Arc

    i guess someone could be named Joe Demo...

  439. nyco

    why Joe Demo? we have Juliet and Romeo all over the places...

  440. dwd has left

  441. nyco

    ok, interesting debate

  442. nyco

    so, what do we have to discuss/decide here?

  443. ralphm

    Well, we are responsible for making sure elections can happen

  444. nyco

    so, checklist ok?

  445. ralphm

    So I wanted to know what the current state is. I don't see Alex here

  446. Arc

    we're responsible for handing over the baton to the new board

  447. ralphm

    well that too

  448. nyco

    I don't have a baton

  449. nyco

    ok then

  450. nyco

    next agenda item?

  451. ralphm

    yes

  452. ralphm

    3. XEP-0001 Draft/Stable

  453. ralphm

    Where are we on this?

  454. lskdjf has joined

  455. Guus

    Iirc a request for more feedback was supposed to be sent, but in think our was not

  456. ralphm

    Minutes says MattJ will send a proposal

  457. Guus

    Mattj?

  458. ralphm

    didn't see one

  459. MattJ

    Errr, sorry, totally dropped that one

  460. ralphm

    Can we remove this from 'to be discussed'?

  461. MattJ

    Yeah

  462. MattJ

    Writing it on my todo now, like I should have done at the time

  463. ralphm

    I'll put it in commitments

  464. MattJ

    Thanks

  465. Guus

    Tx

  466. Steve Kille has left

  467. ralphm

    Ok

  468. ralphm

    I think that was it

  469. ralphm

    4. AOB?

  470. ralphm

    Anything?

  471. ralphm

    Taking that as a no.

  472. ralphm

    5. Date of Next

  473. ralphm

    +1W

  474. ralphm

    6. Close

  475. ralphm

    Thanks all!

  476. ralphm bangs gavel

  477. nyco

    ok, thx ;-)

  478. nyco

    wow, finished before :30!!!

  479. ralphm

    Yeah, I'm getting back to be on top of the game

  480. Arc

    thats amazing

  481. stefandxm has left

  482. nyco

    great to see

  483. Guus

    Arc: Observatory docker status?

  484. Guus

    You volunteer ed for that iirc

  485. Valerian has joined

  486. Arc

    still working on it

  487. Arc

    i have a bit of docker to do this month

  488. Guus

    Cool. Dare to ETA?

  489. la|r|ma has joined

  490. valo has joined

  491. jubalh has left

  492. jubalh has joined

  493. jubalh has joined

  494. jubalh has joined

  495. Zash has left

  496. Zash has joined

  497. Zash has left

  498. Zash has left

  499. Zash has left

  500. Zash has left

  501. Zash has left

  502. Zash has left

  503. Zash has left

  504. Zash has left

  505. Zash has left

  506. Zash has left

  507. Zash has left

  508. Zash has left

  509. jubalh has left

  510. jubalh has joined

  511. Zash has left

  512. Zash has left

  513. Zash has left

  514. Zash has left

  515. Zash has left

  516. Zash has left

  517. Zash has left

  518. Zash has left

  519. Zash has left

  520. daniel has left

  521. Zash has left

  522. Zash has joined

  523. Arc has left

  524. Tobias has joined

  525. Alex has joined

  526. uc has left

  527. jubalh has left

  528. sonny has joined

  529. pps has left

  530. sonny has joined

  531. Alex has left

  532. sonny has joined

  533. sonny has joined

  534. Guus has left

  535. Guus has joined

  536. ralphm has left

  537. zinid

    > So with 3 (+1) votes and 2 (-1) votes, we decide to change the state of XEP-0071: XHTML-IM to Obsolete Hehe

  538. zinid

    ah, then council decided not to deprecate, neat

  539. edhelas

    can't wait for JSON-IM

  540. SamWhited

    It was a misunderstanding of the rules; 0001 was confusing.

  541. SamWhited

    We thought it was a simple majority, but it's a majority +1s and no -1s

  542. MattJ

    (in this case I'm glad, *ducks*)

  543. SamWhited

    :'(

  544. lskdjf has left

  545. MattJ

    We have problems, but declaring that we essentially don't have any way of communicating formatted messages (especially when most clients support it) would be wrong

  546. Kev

    Council didn't know how their voting worked, but thankfully someone else did ;)

  547. MattJ

    It's not like declaring it obsolete will solve the security issues, people will still implement it if other clients do, if there is no replacement

  548. lskdjf has left

  549. nyco has left

  550. Zash

    Rewrite it as 90% security considerations and get an audited JS implementation?

  551. zinid

    we can write it in ocaml, prove it in coq and compile to javascript :D

  552. edhelas

    I have a question, do we really need XHTML-IM at first ? I mean who is using it ?

  553. edhelas

    I'd like to have some clear usecases here, because if it's about embedding pictures and so we already have other XEPs for that

  554. sonny has joined

  555. jubalh has joined

  556. la|r|ma has left

  557. Kev has left

  558. sonny has joined

  559. sonny has joined

  560. sonny has left

  561. sonny has joined

  562. iiro.laiho has joined

  563. sonny has left

  564. sonny has joined

  565. Link Mauve

    Zash, sounds like the best course of action.

  566. sonny has joined

  567. Link Mauve

    zinid, I’d love if you did that. <3

  568. dwd has left

  569. jubalh has left

  570. Wiktor

    edhelas: I'm sending command outputs as pre tags

  571. dwd has left

  572. Link Mauve

    Wiktor, about that, I’m going to change poezio’s implementation to send <pre><code class="lang-python">print('Hello world!')</code></pre> instead of the current way, and hopefully specify this usage of the class attribute at the same time.

  573. Wiktor

    Sounds good 👍

  574. Wiktor

    With this nice Google coloring library I can just insert it into DOM...

  575. Wiktor ducks

  576. sonny has joined

  577. Wiktor

    No just kidding but images are already solved in a different way so for me preformatted text is the most important use case... I like code snippets and nicely aligned ASCII tables...

  578. MattJ

    XHTML-IM should be a whitelist of tags, no CSS and no dangerous attributes, it needs to have very clear guidelines on how to implement it safely

  579. dwd has left

  580. MattJ

    and maybe that's a new XEP that replaces the current one, that's fine

  581. MattJ

    But changing the status of the current one is not the fix for the issue

  582. waqas

    MattJ: I went with a whitelist of attribute values, CSS keys and values

  583. MattJ

    Sanitizing CSS is not easy

  584. Zash

    Throw out CSS but have some predefined list of classes

  585. Zash

    {fg,bg}-$colorname if you want that kind of thing

  586. waqas

    So, I don't think the implementations are really paying attention to the spec's exact langauge…

  587. jonasw

    nice, one week away and still the same discussion <3. I was afraid I would be missing the key part :)

  588. Wiktor

    Also remember while list of protocol schemes so that <a href="javascript:... is unsafe

  589. waqas

    Wiktor: That too

  590. waqas

    (as part of allowed attribute values for a.href)

  591. waqas

    But really, I expect language lawyering in a XEP to have exactly zero impact on the security in the wild.

  592. Link Mauve

    waqas, the specification is currently quite unclear about the possible attacks on web clients.

  593. Guus has left

  594. Link Mauve

    It should state what every web dev should know wrt user input, but it doesn’t currently.

  595. jcbrand has left

  596. zinid

    jonasw: nah, I just resurrected it here :) /troll

  597. Wiktor

    Also enabling strict Content Security Policy mitigates a lot of these attacks, including script injection

  598. Link Mauve

    Yeah, that should be part of the security considerations.

  599. Link Mauve

    But that header obviously didn’t exist back in 2003.

  600. Guus has joined

  601. Guus has left

  602. Guus has joined

  603. ralphm has joined

  604. stefandxm has joined

  605. lskdjf has left

  606. dwd has left

  607. dwd has left

  608. dwd has left

  609. sonny has joined

  610. jere has left

  611. jere has joined

  612. vanitasvitae has left

  613. sonny has joined

  614. Guus has left

  615. Guus has joined

  616. stefandxm has left

  617. stefandxm has joined

  618. iiro.laiho has left

  619. iiro.laiho has joined

  620. lovetox has joined

  621. ralphm has joined

  622. lovetox

    omg im here

  623. iiro.laiho has left

  624. iiro.laiho has joined

  625. iiro.laiho has left

  626. iiro.laiho has joined

  627. la|r|ma has joined

  628. la|r|ma has joined

  629. goffi has left

  630. lskdjf has joined

  631. jubalh has joined

  632. Zash has left

  633. lskdjf has left

  634. lskdjf has left

  635. ralphm has joined

  636. iiro.laiho has left

  637. lskdjf has left

  638. lskdjf has left

  639. Valerian has left

  640. Valerian has joined

  641. Valerian has left

  642. mimi89999 has left

  643. mimi89999 has joined

  644. Zash has left

  645. SouL has left

  646. Zash has left

  647. Zash has left

  648. Zash has left

  649. Zash has left

  650. nyco has left

  651. lumi has left

  652. Zash has left

  653. Zash has left

  654. Zash has left

  655. jubalh has left

  656. lumi has joined

  657. Zash has joined

  658. lumi has left

  659. lskdjf has left

  660. lumi has joined

  661. lskdjf has left

  662. lskdjf has left

  663. lskdjf has left

  664. lskdjf has left

  665. sonny has joined

  666. dwd has left

  667. sonny has joined

  668. dwd has left

  669. dwd has left

  670. lskdjf has left

  671. dwd has left

  672. Alex has joined

  673. Valerian has joined

  674. dwd has left

  675. ralphm has joined

  676. lskdjf has left

  677. lskdjf has left

  678. uc has joined

  679. sonny has joined

  680. matlag has joined

  681. la|r|ma has left

  682. dwd has left

  683. uc has joined

  684. dwd has left

  685. dwd has left

  686. ralphm has left

  687. zinid

    "As for me; I recently moved from XMPP to matrix, mostly because I couldn't get XMPP to work reliably on ios, with my server"

  688. zinid

    citation from reddit

  689. zinid

    is everything bad on ios?

  690. dwd has left

  691. ThurahT

    yes.

  692. SamWhited

    ios is fine, the clients are just terrible as far as I can tell. People complain because it kills TCP connections aggressively, but we should be tolerating that anyways.

  693. zinid

    yeah...

  694. SamWhited

    Although, does anything actually describe how reconnect behavior should work with XMPP? That might make a nice informational XEP.

  695. zinid

    there is a more fundamental problem

  696. Zash

    SamWhited: :´(

  697. zinid

    ios assumes your application to run as little as possible

  698. zinid

    so you almost always in "push" mode

  699. zinid

    and we have problems with IQs here

  700. la|r|ma has left

  701. Alex has left

  702. zinid

    the solution is to implement A/V (jingle, sip, no matter) and then ios will allow you to run in background :)

  703. Zash

    Suppose you could do BOSH with high timeouts.

  704. Alex has joined

  705. pep.

    zinid, that seems like a win/win, for users and devs :P

  706. SamWhited

    but then you'd have to implement BOSH, and that way lies madness.

  707. zinid

    pep.: yes, however "voip certification" was quite notorious in apple store

  708. zinid

    dunno how it's now

  709. Steve Kille has joined

  710. pep.

    I see

  711. stefandxm has left

  712. Tobias has joined

  713. daniel has left

  714. la|r|ma has left

  715. zinid has left

  716. zinid

    "For me the biggest advantage that Matrix gives over XMPP is the very simple JSON based communication over plain HTTP"

  717. zinid

    this reddit thread is brilliant

  718. pep.

    Nice :)

  719. Alex has left

  720. la|r|ma has left

  721. la|r|ma has joined

  722. la|r|ma has left

  723. tux has left

  724. jere has left

  725. jere has joined

  726. dwd has left

  727. nyco has left

  728. la|r|ma has left

  729. SamWhited

    That is an advantage of Matrix, regardless of how complicated that all is under the hood it makes it way easier for most developers to get up and running. We can scorn it all we want, but it's a valid reason that a lot of people would chose to use something else.

  730. la|r|ma has left

  731. zinid has left

  732. Arc has joined

  733. dwd has left

  734. uc has joined

  735. Zash

    Without a TCP socket, what's left of XMPP? You basically have to become a stateless HTTP-like thing and then we're competing againtst something that is that already.

  736. SamWhited

    I'm not suggesting we need to change the protocol or anything, just that pretending that advantages our competitors have aren't advantages isn't helpful.

  737. la|r|ma has left

  738. Zash

    I'd like to strongly object to the statement that iOS is fine. // FOSS person who wants to be in control

  739. zinid

    SamWhited: we have BOSH 😁

  740. Zash

    As a server dev, I'm not sure what madness lies in the direction of BOSH

  741. Zash

    Works fine afaik and negates the need for 198

  742. ralphm has joined

  743. Wiktor

    Zinid, just for a little bit of context this is written by a Matrix developer: "For me the biggest advantage that Matrix gives over XMPP is the very simple JSON based communication over plain HTTP. XMPP on the other hand is complex XML."

  744. dwd has left

  745. Wiktor

    The entire thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/privacytoolsIO/comments/678xfm/xmpp_vs_matrix_could_someone_explain_me_the/

  746. zinid

    Zash: there are several bug reports in ejabberd bugtracker and I have no idea how to fix them because the logic is very complicated (there is some mess with how to handle out of order or duplicates)

  747. SamWhited

    It's true. I don't especially like JSON or think it was the right tool for the job, but we have a culture that ignores the end user or developer point of view and only thinks about the experts designing the protocols point of view for whatever reasson. XML *is* too complex, to the point where the XMPP specs have to use a restricted subset of it.

  748. zinid

    Wiktor: ah, ok

  749. zinid

    Wiktor: we should have our spy on Reddit then 😀

  750. ralphm

    I mentioned this before and I think most agree: it is not about the actual wire protocol, but about libraries.

  751. Zash

    ralphm: Sounds true enough. Even SOAP is probably fine if the libs hide it from you :)

  752. zinid

    Lol

  753. SamWhited

    Indeed.

  754. Zash

    And yeah, trying to write your own lib from scratch when you actually want to make a client is not a recipie for a good time

  755. ralphm

    Right

  756. la|r|ma has left

  757. Zash

    Question is, is it better to take a tool that doesn't have what you need and hack those things on, or take a tool that has too much and disable features in it?

  758. ralphm

    Not sure. Somebody asked me if it was a good idea to build a chat system on MQTT. My response: if you don't mind inventing your own chat semantics from scratch.

  759. SamWhited

    On an unrelated note, I just gave an XMPP intro or overview sort of talk to my office, which was fun.

  760. ralphm

    Yay

  761. SamWhited

    (we do a Wednesday lunc-and-learn sort of thing and today was my day to present)

  762. SamWhited

    lunch-and-learn, even.

  763. la|r|ma has left

  764. ralphm has joined

  765. la|r|ma has left

  766. Guus

    Sam, do you have some sort of template for that? Either to reproduce, or to distill in a blogpost or intro article or something.

  767. SamWhited

    Guus: not really, you can steal my slides if you want (warning, the PDFs are out of date): git@bitbucket.org:SamWhited/xmpp-intro-slides.git

  768. la|r|ma has left

  769. SamWhited

    But I never try to make presentation slides work well on their own; I probably should

  770. zinid

    ralphm: people indeed resort to using hand made chats because they think it's easier to write from scratch instead of fiddling with existing tools/libraries

  771. ralphm has joined

  772. Zash

    Also don't underestimate the siren song of NIH

  773. ralphm

    SamWhited: I made these a while ago: https://ralphm.net/publications/xmpp_intro/#/

  774. dwd has left

  775. ralphm

    zinid: writing a chat system is easy. Writing a good one is incredibly hard. In any language or protocol.

  776. SamWhited

    ralphm: oh nice! mind if I borrow from that?

  777. ralphm

    Totally, you have the source right there

  778. zinid

    ralphm: I understand that 😀

  779. SamWhited

    Thanks; I want to go back through and remove some of the XEPs I talk about (which were tailored for the same presentation for HipChat but which others probably don't care about) and add some of the bigger ones for common chat features.

  780. SamWhited

    So I might steal your bullets for Jingle/MUC/etc.

  781. dwd has left

  782. Guus

    Nice, ralphm

  783. ralphm has joined

  784. dwd has left

  785. dwd has left

  786. SamWhited

    I don't have my login on me to update the PDF of mine, but do have my SSH key so I just lazily comitted it to version control like a bad person: https://bitbucket.org/SamWhited/xmpp-intro-slides/src/f4e4c6fe52afd5783f8444325e69b2520fd02514/slides.pdf?at=master&fileviewer=file-view-default

  787. ralphm has joined

  788. dwd has left

  789. dwd has left

  790. Alex has joined

  791. Valerian has left

  792. dwd has left

  793. Alex has left

  794. Valerian has joined

  795. ralphm has joined

  796. dwd

    Currently at Surevine, we have two guys working on XMPP clients (of sorts), and neither is touching XML.

  797. dwd

    Well. Almost not, anyway.

  798. jubalh has joined

  799. Guus

    You make 'm work in the office at 10:27pm while the rest of you are at home? Harsh.

  800. Guus has left

  801. stefandxm has joined

  802. Guus has joined

  803. Guus has left

  804. Guus has joined

  805. Zash has left

  806. Guus has left

  807. Guus has joined

  808. la|r|ma has left

  809. sonny has joined

  810. tux has left

  811. lovetox has left

  812. jubalh has left

  813. lskdjf has joined

  814. SamWhited has left

  815. Guus has left

  816. Steve Kille has left

  817. sonny has left

  818. sonny has joined

  819. sonny has left

  820. sonny has joined

  821. sonny has left

  822. sonny has joined

  823. dwd has left

  824. Arc

    SamWhited: where you working these days?

  825. dwd has left

  826. jere has left

  827. jere has joined

  828. waqas has left

  829. Steve Kille has joined

  830. SamWhited

    Arc: Cloudflare

  831. dwd has left

  832. dwd has left

  833. Valerian has left

  834. dwd has left

  835. jjrh has left

  836. jjrh has left

  837. dwd has left

  838. jere has left

  839. jere has joined

  840. Guus has joined

  841. jere has left

  842. Guus has left

  843. jere has joined

  844. dwd has left

  845. la|r|ma has left