XSF Discussion - 2017-12-19

  1. Guus has left

  2. stefandxm has joined

  3. la|r|ma has joined

  4. marc has left

  5. lskdjf has left

  6. daniel has left

  7. marc has joined

  8. marc has left

  9. marc has joined

  10. daniel has left

  11. ralphm has joined

  12. daniel has joined

  13. lskdjf has left

  14. Kev has left

  15. daniel has joined

  16. sonny has joined

  17. sonny has joined

  18. daniel has joined

  19. lskdjf has left

  20. lskdjf has left

  21. lskdjf has left

  22. lskdjf has joined

  23. lskdjf has left

  24. lskdjf has left

  25. lskdjf has joined

  26. lskdjf has left

  27. lskdjf has joined

  28. lskdjf has left

  29. lskdjf has joined

  30. lskdjf has left

  31. lskdjf has joined

  32. marc has left

  33. remko has joined

  34. lskdjf has left

  35. sonny has joined

  36. sonny has joined

  37. efrit has joined

  38. sonny has left

  39. sonny has joined

  40. SamWhited has left

  41. Guus has left

  42. Guus has joined

  43. mrkiko has joined

  44. SamWhited has joined

  45. mrkiko has joined

  46. @Alacer has left

  47. waqas has left

  48. @Alacer has joined

  49. Guus has left

  50. tux has left

  51. tux has joined

  52. efrit has left

  53. jmpman has joined

  54. jmpman has joined

  55. la|r|ma has left

  56. SamWhited has left

  57. SamWhited has joined

  58. SamWhited has joined

  59. uc has joined

  60. SamWhited has joined

  61. SamWhited has joined

  62. stefandxm has left

  63. stefandxm has joined

  64. stefandxm has left

  65. stefandxm has joined

  66. stefandxm has left

  67. stefandxm has joined

  68. stefandxm has left

  69. stefandxm has joined

  70. SamWhited has joined

  71. SamWhited has joined

  72. stefandxm has left

  73. stefandxm has joined

  74. SamWhited has joined

  75. SamWhited has joined

  76. SamWhited has joined

  77. SamWhited has joined

  78. stefandxm has left

  79. stefandxm has joined

  80. stefandxm has left

  81. stefandxm has joined

  82. stefandxm has left

  83. stefandxm has joined

  84. stefandxm has left

  85. stefandxm has joined

  86. SamWhited has joined

  87. SamWhited has joined

  88. stefandxm has left

  89. stefandxm has joined

  90. SouL has joined

  91. SamWhited has left

  92. SamWhited has joined

  93. stefandxm has left

  94. stefandxm has joined

  95. SouL has left

  96. stefandxm has left

  97. stefandxm has joined

  98. stefandxm has left

  99. stefandxm has joined

  100. xnyhps has left

  101. SouL has left

  102. SouL has joined

  103. SouL has left

  104. stefandxm has left

  105. stefandxm has joined

  106. la|r|ma has left

  107. la|r|ma has left

  108. SamWhited has joined

  109. SamWhited has joined

  110. @Alacer has left

  111. SamWhited has joined

  112. SamWhited has joined

  113. @Alacer has joined

  114. la|r|ma has joined

  115. goffi has joined

  116. @Alacer has left

  117. @Alacer has joined

  118. @Alacer has left

  119. @Alacer has joined

  120. remko has joined

  121. remko has left

  122. remko has joined

  123. Tobias has joined

  124. Guus has joined

  125. stefandxm has left

  126. Guus has left

  127. Guus has joined

  128. ralphm has joined

  129. daniel has left

  130. Guus has left

  131. stefandxm has joined

  132. daniel

    jonasw, could you hit the the merge button on my protoxep when you have a minute so it makes the 24h notice window for the council agenda tomorrow?

  133. jonasw


  134. jonasw

    didn’t see the mail, sorry

  135. Kev has joined

  136. daniel

    jonasw: thank you

  137. stefandxm has left

  138. ralphm has left

  139. stefandxm has joined

  140. mimi89999 has left

  141. Steve Kille has left

  142. jonasw

    daniel, mail sent :-)

  143. marc has joined

  144. Steve Kille has left

  145. pep. has left

  146. ralphm has left

  147. Steve Kille has joined

  148. Guus has joined

  149. Guus has left

  150. Guus has joined

  151. zinid has left

  152. ralphm has joined

  153. moparisthebest has joined

  154. Guus has left

  155. daniel has left

  156. Alex has joined

  157. Guus has left

  158. lskdjf has joined

  159. marc has left

  160. ralphm has joined

  161. daniel has left

  162. daniel has left

  163. efrit has joined

  164. Syndace has left

  165. Syndace has joined

  166. SouL has left

  167. uc has joined

  168. ralphm has left

  169. matlag has left

  170. matlag has left

  171. matlag has joined

  172. sonny has left

  173. SouL has joined

  174. Tobias has joined

  175. sonny has joined

  176. ralphm has joined

  177. SouL has joined

  178. daniel has left

  179. SouL has joined

  180. SouL has joined

  181. uc has joined

  182. SamWhited has joined

  183. SamWhited has joined

  184. SouL has joined

  185. jcbrand has joined

  186. Alex has left

  187. SouL has joined

  188. daniel has left

  189. tim@boese-ban.de has joined

  190. lumi has joined

  191. SouL has joined

  192. Syndace has joined

  193. Syndace has joined

  194. pep. has joined

  195. SouL has joined

  196. jcbrand has left

  197. jcbrand has left

  198. Ge0rG has left

  199. jcbrand has left

  200. jcbrand has joined

  201. vanitasvitae has left

  202. vanitasvitae has joined

  203. la|r|ma has joined

  204. SouL has joined

  205. daniel has left

  206. @Alacer has left

  207. @Alacer has joined

  208. efrit has left

  209. @Alacer has left

  210. @Alacer has joined

  211. SouL has left

  212. Syndace has left

  213. Syndace has joined

  214. mrkiko has left

  215. mrkiko has joined

  216. Guus has left

  217. SouL has joined

  218. SouL has joined

  219. pep. has left

  220. Guus has left

  221. SouL has left

  222. SouL has left

  223. tim@boese-ban.de has joined

  224. lumi has left

  225. Tobias has left

  226. jjrh has left

  227. SouL has joined

  228. SouL has joined

  229. jubalh has joined

  230. ralphm has joined

  231. SouL has joined

  232. lovetox has joined

  233. SouL has joined

  234. SamWhited has joined

  235. SamWhited has joined

  236. daniel has left

  237. daniel has joined

  238. jjrh has left

  239. jjrh has left

  240. SouL has left

  241. jjrh has left

  242. jjrh has left

  243. SouL has left

  244. jjrh has left

  245. Syndace has left

  246. Syndace has joined

  247. lskdjf has joined

  248. lskdjf has joined

  249. SamWhited has left

  250. Alex has joined

  251. Guus has left

  252. ralphm has joined

  253. SouL has left

  254. jcbrand has left

  255. Guus has left

  256. SouL has joined

  257. matlag has left

  258. matlag has joined

  259. jubalh has left

  260. ralphm has joined

  261. SouL has joined

  262. pep. has left

  263. SouL has joined

  264. SouL has left

  265. SouL has left

  266. efrit has joined

  267. Holger has left

  268. SouL has left

  269. efrit has left

  270. efrit has joined

  271. ralphm has joined

  272. zinid has left

  273. sonny has left

  274. SouL has joined

  275. SouL has joined

  276. sonny has left

  277. matlag has left

  278. SouL has joined

  279. SouL has joined

  280. lskdjf has joined

  281. ralphm has joined

  282. jubalh has joined

  283. jubalh has left

  284. ralphm has left

  285. SouL has joined

  286. Guus has left

  287. Tobias has joined

  288. efrit has left

  289. SouL has joined

  290. jubalh has joined

  291. jubalh has left

  292. Guus has left

  293. SouL has left

  294. SouL has left

  295. daniel has left

  296. SouL has left

  297. SouL has joined

  298. sonny has joined

  299. daniel has left

  300. Tobias has joined

  301. daniel has left

  302. ralphm has left

  303. jubalh has joined

  304. SouL has left

  305. waqas has joined

  306. SouL has joined

  307. SouL has left

  308. pep.

    What's the difference between {xep 0363} and {xep 0370}? Both can do more or less the same thing, right? 0370 doesn't require a server component but it would be feasible as well I think

  309. Bunneh

    pep.: Multiple matches: Stanza Headers and Internet Metadata https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0131.html Ad-Hoc Commands https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0050.html Dialback Key Generation and Validation https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0185.html Out of Band Data https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0066.html Blocking Command https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0191.html Atomically Compare-And-Publish PubSub Items https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0395.html Jingle In-Band Bytestreams Transport Method https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0261.html A Transport for Initiating and Negotiating Sessions (TINS) https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0111.html In-Band Real Time Text https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0301.html Spim Markers and Reports https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0287.html Out-of-Band Stream Data https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/outofband.html File Repository and Sharing https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0214.html Jingle In-Band Bytestreams Transport https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/jingle-ibb.html Stanza Interception and Filtering Technology https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/sift.html Mandatory-to-Implement Technologies for Jingle RTP Sessions https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/jingle-rtp-mti.html Spim Markers and Reports https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/spim.html Field Standardization for Data Forms https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0068.html The /me Command https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0245.html Stanza Interception and Filtering Technology (SIFT) https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0273.html In-Band Bytestreams https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0047.html XMPP Date and Time Profiles https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0082.html In-Band Registration https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0077.html Unique and Stable Stanza IDs https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0359.html Best Practices for Handling Offline Messages https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0160.html Extensible In-Band Registration https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0389.html Incident Handling https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0268.html Impact of TLS and DNSSEC on Dialback https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0344.html Form Discovery and Publishing https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0346.html Zero Handshake Server to Server Protocol https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0361.html Out-of-Band Stream Data https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0265.html Invisible Command https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0186.html Best Practices for Roster and Subscription Management https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0162.html Atomically Compare-And-Publish PubSub Items https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/cap.html

  310. pep.


  311. lskdjf has joined

  312. Zash


  313. Zash

    Maybe it did a search for "0363} and {xep 0370" and thought you really wanted all XEPs with the word "and" anywhere in them

  314. jjrh has left

  315. Zash

    Two {} commands at the same time don't work anyways

  316. pep.


  317. jjrh has left

  318. pep.

    -xep 0363

  319. Bunneh

    pep.: HTTP File Upload (Standards Track, Proposed, 2017-12-03) See: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0363.html

  320. pep.

    -xep 0370

  321. Bunneh

    pep.: Jingle HTTP Transport Method (Standards Track, Deferred, 2017-09-11) See: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0370.html

  322. Zash

    pep.: compare {xep 65} and ...

  323. Bunneh

    pep.: SOCKS5 Bytestreams (Standards Track, Draft, 2015-09-17) See: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0065.html

  324. Zash

    -xep 260

  325. Bunneh

    Zash: Jingle SOCKS5 Bytestreams Transport Method (Standards Track, Draft, 2016-05-17) See: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0260.html

  326. pep.


  327. jjrh has left

  328. Zash

    Holy carp, do we have a bazillion XEPs mentioning "jingle"

  329. pep.

    Is there any implementation of 0370?

  330. zinid

    we need no carpy jingle

  331. lumi has joined

  332. jjrh has left

  333. SouL has joined

  334. jjrh has left

  335. sonny has left

  336. ralphm has left

  337. SouL has joined

  338. SouL has left

  339. Steve Kille has left

  340. Steve Kille has left

  341. jjrh has left

  342. waqas has left

  343. SouL has joined

  344. sonny has joined

  345. Steve Kille has joined

  346. lumi has joined

  347. marc

    Ge0rG, what is the input field on your easy-xmpp-invitation website for?

  348. jjrh has left

  349. sonny has left

  350. sonny has joined

  351. sonny has joined

  352. SouL has joined

  353. SouL has joined

  354. zinid has left

  355. SouL has left

  356. ralphm has left

  357. la|r|ma has left

  358. SouL has joined

  359. mimi89999 has left

  360. uc has left

  361. remko has left

  362. mimi89999 has joined

  363. uc has joined

  364. mimi89999 has joined

  365. Guus has left

  366. Guus has left

  367. ralphm has left

  368. Syndace has joined

  369. lumi has joined

  370. SouL has joined

  371. vanitasvitae has left

  372. vanitasvitae has joined

  373. SouL has left

  374. SouL has joined

  375. SouL has left

  376. la|r|ma has joined

  377. ralphm has left

  378. Syndace has left

  379. Syndace has joined

  380. McKael has joined

  381. jjrh has left

  382. SouL has joined

  383. McKael has joined

  384. SouL has joined

  385. McKael has joined

  386. ralphm has joined

  387. Guus has left

  388. jjrh has left

  389. SouL has joined

  390. Guus has left

  391. jcbrand has joined

  392. ralphm has left

  393. jcbrand has left

  394. ralphm has left

  395. ralphm has joined

  396. jubalh has joined

  397. SouL has joined

  398. Tobias has joined

  399. jubalh has left

  400. goffi has left

  401. jjrh has left

  402. daniel has left

  403. jjrh has left

  404. jjrh has left

  405. daniel has left

  406. jjrh has left

  407. SouL has left

  408. jjrh has left

  409. SouL has left

  410. edhelas

    I think that we have to start to work on spam issues seriously

  411. jabberatdemo has joined

  412. edhelas

    we have to see how people are spamming XMPP today on a wider scale than just blocking a type of message

  413. Link Mauve

    Oh, is it a new wave?

  414. edhelas

    Link Mauve it basically never stopped

  415. edhelas


  416. Alex

    ya, SPAM is getting horrible, in the mood of shutting down my XMPP clients :(

  417. Link Mauve

    Might be our anti-spam solution working great then. ^^

  418. edhelas


  419. edhelas

    for now

  420. Link Mauve

    edhelas, it brings nothing to ban individual JIDs to the network.

  421. edhelas

    it's super easy to create a new host on your XMPP serve, put a let's encrypt certificate on it and start spamming the others

  422. edhelas

    yes I know

  423. Link Mauve

    Alex, if you’re running Prosody, https://yaxim.org/blog/2017/12/12/spam-reduction-on-yax-dot-im/

  424. edhelas

    what I'd like to do is have a look at all those domains, see if they are pointing to same IPs

  425. edhelas

    and basically figure out from where those SPAMs are coming

  426. edhelas

    but we seriously have to take the problem

  427. Link Mauve

    edhelas, pretty sure most spammers are currently relying on insecure public infrastructure rather than using their own servers.

  428. Link Mauve

    edhelas, just read that blog article, that’s how we’ve been handling it at JabberFR for the past year or so.

  429. edhelas

    that's not exactly true

  430. edhelas

    I have more spam comming from new domains than known ones

  431. MattJ

    edhelas, can you share some example domains?

  432. edhelas

    well I just did

  433. MattJ

    There are multiple spammers, they use different techniques, and not everyone will have their JID on every spammer's list

  434. edhelas

    I can give you a longer list, give me a bit of time

  435. Link Mauve

    edhelas, blocking by domain is almost never a solution.

  436. MattJ

    So while Link Mauve and I receive spam from existing domains, maybe you experience it more from a spammer who uses new domains

  437. edhelas

    MattJ that's what i'm saying, we have different kind of spams, we have to differentiate them and see how we can block them

  438. Link Mauve

    I should log all of the spams I’m blocking, to get better statistics.

  439. jabberatdemo has left

  440. edhelas

    well hopefully I have MAM and Movim cache for that

  441. edhelas

    also, again, for now we have simple SPAM messages

  442. Link Mauve

    Ge0rG, I’m interested in your statistics module btw.

  443. edhelas

    I start to have roster subscriptions request from spammers

  444. edhelas

    and the next kind will be Pubsub publications I think

  445. edhelas

    so I'm already talking with ejabberd dev to put quotas and limitations on Pubsub

  446. Link Mauve

    Wouldn’t reach nearly as many people as plain messages.

  447. uc has left

  448. uc has joined

  449. daniel

    > and the next kind will be Pubsub publications I think lol that's unnecessarily complex. normal messages will reach people just fine

  450. Tobias has left

  451. edhelas

    I'm deleting one or two accounts of users that are publishing articles with links to weird urls and warez places :)

  452. edhelas

    but yes this is pretty long term

  453. Tobias has joined

  454. daniel

    also; while i'm not denying that spam is a problem it is not really for the average user; normal users don't publish their jid everywhere. the lists the spammers are using are (in parts) very old. while *we* see a lot of spam normal users don't

  455. edhelas


  456. daniel

    yes it creates load and servers and requires work from sys admins; but we shouldn't necessarily let this distract us from other problems

  457. daniel

    especially since normal users - and even we - are not the target audience of the spam

  458. daniel

    we don't speak russian and we don't usually buy stolen credit cards

  459. daniel

    ok; some of us speak russian…

  460. jjrh has left

  461. edhelas

    ok I've compiled a list of JID that are sending messages to Movim users without been in their roster

  462. tim@boese-ban.de has left

  463. daniel has left

  464. daniel has left

  465. jjrh has left

  466. SouL has left

  467. edhelas

    some statistics per server :)

  468. edhelas


  469. ralphm has joined

  470. matlag has left

  471. jjrh has left

  472. ralphm has joined

  473. jjrh has left

  474. Ge0rG

    marc: it's not an input field, it's a text selection field where you can copy the xmpp: URI from

  475. marc

    Ge0rG, https://projects.zapb.de/tmp/easy-xmpp-invitation/

  476. marc

    I can edit the xmpp URI

  477. Ge0rG

    Link Mauve: thank you for sharing a private link, btw.

  478. ralphm has joined

  479. Link Mauve

    Oh, I saw it in public somewhere today, sorry. :x

  480. Ge0rG

    Link Mauve: it isn't published yet, and I'm in the middle of refactoring it into a technical post on my personal blog and a high-level post on yaxim.org

  481. jubalh has joined

  482. Ge0rG

    which technically means I've stopped working on it for now ;)

  483. Link Mauve

    I didn’t see any mention that it was a draft or anything either.

  484. Ge0rG

    Link Mauve: I'm sure I wrote it's a draft where I posted it.

  485. Link Mauve


  486. Link Mauve

    Sorry. :x

  487. Link Mauve

    You can still yank it out probably.

  488. Ge0rG

    Link Mauve: I'm sure nobody will notice

  489. Ge0rG

    let's hope it won't get picked up. yet.

  490. Ge0rG

    Link Mauve: but now you made me curious, you are not a member of the places I posted it in. :P

  491. Link Mauve

    I’m already looking for the place I got it from. ^^

  492. debacle has joined

  493. Ge0rG

    Sigh. advert364@yax.im - 1600 outgoing subscription requests.

  494. Ge0rG

    MattJ: can we have presence blocking in mod_firewall please?

  495. MattJ

    "presence blocking"?

  496. MattJ

    KIND: presence DROP.

  497. MattJ

    Presence. Blocked.

  498. MattJ


  499. Ge0rG

    MattJ: I'm sure users will love this.

  500. MattJ

    They'll love the simplicity, which is good for UX

  501. Ge0rG

    MattJ: I want to block/revert presence subscriptions from accounts that are spamming.

  502. MattJ

    Incoming or outgoing?

  503. Ge0rG

    MattJ: both

  504. Ge0rG

    I've deleted some 2000 spammer accounts in the last weeks

  505. Ge0rG

    Link Mauve: the stats for that blog non-post I gathered by grepping prosody.log for JIDs captured by mod_firewall spammer.pfw

  506. MattJ

    I don't think a server should allow a new account to *have* 1600 open subscription requests

  507. Ge0rG

    MattJ: that's a great idea.

  508. Link Mauve


  509. Ge0rG

    Link Mauve: not sure if this will help you much. `zgrep -ho 'spam:.*message.*' /var/log/prosody/prosody.log*|grep -ho "from='[a-z0-9._-]*@[^']*'" > 2017-12-13-alljids.txt`

  510. Ge0rG

    MattJ: the other spam accounts I deleted have between 10 and 200 pending subscriptions. Which is still too much.

  511. edhelas

    Ge0rG you have IBR ?

  512. Ge0rG

    MattJ: but the worst thing is that I'm getting a dozen a subscriptions a day.

  513. Ge0rG

    edhelas: yes

  514. edhelas

    well then you know where they are coming from

  515. Link Mauve

    Ge0rG, it’s super weird, I can’t find any mention of this blog post in my logs before I posted it. oO

  516. jjrh has left

  517. edhelas

    on my side I'm starting to blacklist list of domains for s2s

  518. Ge0rG

    edhelas: from Tor and open proxies

  519. pep.

    wut, is that url private? it seems awfully public to me and I've seen it around already

  520. Zash

    Ge0rG: Maybe it would be clearer to say you wanna retract presence subscription requests from mod_firewall

  521. Ge0rG

    Zash: yes, that's exactly what I want. I'm sure I asked for that already one or two times

  522. jjrh has left

  523. Ge0rG

    pep.: I can't imagine how it made the rounds, or where

  524. pep.

    the spam reduction article right?

  525. Zash

    I thought I saw you ask for "blocking"

  526. pep.

    I'm confused

  527. ralphm has joined

  528. Ge0rG

    Zash: to block them I need to know they are spammers before they send their spam

  529. Link Mauve

    Maybe it would be simpler by writing another module, that would hook into the event fired by mod_firewall on someone being flagged as a spammer, and then proceed to remove its presence subscription.

  530. Link Mauve

    pep., do you remember where you saw it?

  531. Link Mauve

    Because grep doesn’t help. :/

  532. Ge0rG

    Zash: ideally it should delay incoming subscriptions for a minute and just discard them if the user sends incoming spam

  533. Link Mauve

    Ge0rG, one second would be enough currently.

  534. Ge0rG

    So kind of like a bastard of mod_smacks and mod_csi_pump

  535. Zash

    Hm, that sounds a bit tricky for mod_firewall?

  536. Zash

    Or? What sayeth MattJ?

  537. SamWhited has joined

  538. SamWhited has joined

  539. MattJ

    Some kind of tarpit has always been on my mind for mod_firewall, but it is indeed tricky

  540. Ge0rG

    I'm okay with a separate module if it helps tame subscription spam

  541. pep.

    Ah, hmm, no I've never read it. Dec 12th 2017

  542. jjrh has left

  543. Link Mauve

    Ge0rG, could you have used an URL shortener?

  544. edhelas

    is it risky to publish publicly my list of blacklisted s2s servers ?

  545. Ge0rG

    edhelas: I don't think so

  546. edhelas

    I'd like to be transparent regarding my configuration

  547. Link Mauve

    edhelas, it’s a good thing, it will allow them to start the process to get un-blacklisted.

  548. pep.

    edhelas, might also be nice to send a message to the contact address of that server when you blacklist it

  549. Link Mauve


  550. edhelas


  551. pep.


  552. pep.

    Of course you can automate that

  553. edhelas

    step by step :)

  554. edhelas

    first publish the list

  555. jjrh has left

  556. jjrh has left

  557. Ge0rG

    MattJ: currently I'm actively monitoring prosody.log for outgoing spam, listing all accounts registered from the same ip as the perpetrator, checking whether any of them have proper roster subscriptions and deleting all that look like spammers.

  558. jjrh has left

  559. Ge0rG

    I've automated most of the steps so it boils down to copying a JID and a list of user:delete commands, but the monitoring itself is tedious and in theory easy to automate

  560. MattJ

    To automate that, I'd fire an event from the firewall "reject spam" chain, and just handle the rest in a module

  561. zinid has left

  562. MattJ

    At least log the IP to a separate file

  563. Ge0rG

    MattJ: yes, it would help to have a quarantine flag on accounts that could be set this way

  564. MattJ


  565. Ge0rG

    I've pulled a number for that one recently

  566. Ge0rG

    MattJ: but none of this solves the incoming subscriptions problem

  567. Ge0rG

    It merely reduces the outgoing subscriptions problem, slightly

  568. Ge0rG

    As I said, I've deleted around 2k accounts so far.

  569. MattJ

    Automatically rejecting a pending incoming subscription should be pretty straightforward to add as an action

  570. Ge0rG

    And one real user, by accident. Which is why I want a quarantine flag that's less terminal than a deletion

  571. MattJ

    Any "hold the stanza for X seconds/minutes" is full of performance and correctness problems

  572. Ge0rG

    MattJ: yes, I know. But holding a stanza long enough to check the next stanza from the same JID might actually work without melting the server

  573. MattJ

    We had a lot of discussion about this when you first had the idea

  574. MattJ

    Nice idea, but the spammer only has to wait N+1 seconds

  575. MattJ

    and they have plenty of time on their hands

  576. Ge0rG

    MattJ: maybe they do, maybe not.

  577. MattJ

    Whatever you choose for N, they can wait longer, and as you increase N you're going to effectively open yourself up to DoS attacks

  578. debacle has left

  579. Ge0rG

    Greylisting has turned out to work exceptionally well for email

  580. Ge0rG

    MattJ: besides, even if they wait, they won't get past the spam filter, so they have no incentive to modify their code

  581. MattJ

    What's their incentive for sending the subscription request in the first place?

  582. MattJ

    btw, I don't see anything about your account quarantine flag: https://prosody.im/issues/?q=state%3Dopen+firewall

  583. Ge0rG

    MattJ: I suppose it's too trick dumb clients / servers to accept the following message

  584. Ge0rG

    MattJ: https://prosody.im/issues/1057

  585. Ge0rG

    MattJ: my firewall blocks all spam messages anyway, so they won't gain anything by waiting longer

  586. Alex has left

  587. Alex has joined

  588. Ge0rG

    MattJ: please feel free to suggest a different method to mitigate the incoming subscriptions.

  589. MattJ

    I think we ultimately ended up at UI changes on the clients when we last discussed this

  590. MattJ

    That is, a subscription request should not be "noisy"

  591. Ge0rG

    MattJ: I would accept a subscription denial from the firewall as a first step.

  592. MattJ

    Yes, that can be done

  593. Ge0rG

    MattJ: except that we haven't implemented anything after the discussion, and are repeating it now.

  594. MattJ

    I'll get you your account flagging thing, which will at least help to improve your current process

  595. MattJ

    and then I'll get you automated rejection/retraction of subscription requests

  596. Ge0rG

    MattJ: thanks, that's awesome!

  597. MattJ

    The tarpit thing may happen one day, or it may never happen

  598. MattJ

    It's a nice idea with too many practical issues

  599. Ge0rG

    MattJ: what about making the flagging depend on the number of roster items the user has? I.e. when pending >(to+both)

  600. MattJ

    Simply because you have to queue every stanza for the same destination JID following a match, and they can send to an unbounded number of destination JIDs

  601. Ge0rG

    MattJ: I'm sure we can also stop incoming mass subscriptions from the same JID

  602. Ge0rG

    Just not from the same server...

  603. MattJ

    Ge0rG, they'll just add bot accounts to bot accounts rosters

  604. Ge0rG

    MattJ: maybe

  605. Ge0rG

    MattJ: but yes, das things first please.

  606. Ge0rG is leaving for the night now. CU

  607. MattJ

    Good night

  608. Ge0rG

    s/das/easy/ it's too late for auto completion

  609. ralphm has joined

  610. mimi89999 has joined

  611. jjrh has left

  612. jjrh has left

  613. ralphm has joined

  614. ralphm has left

  615. ralphm has joined

  616. ralphm has left

  617. ralphm has joined

  618. jjrh has left

  619. lovetox has left

  620. peter has joined

  621. Alex has left

  622. Alex has joined

  623. Alex has left

  624. vanitasvitae has left

  625. vanitasvitae has joined

  626. vanitasvitae has left

  627. vanitasvitae has joined

  628. SamWhited has left

  629. SouL has left

  630. SamWhited has joined