XSF Discussion - 2018-08-07

00:08:40 kasper.dement has joined
00:11:06 kasper.dement has joined
00:12:34 404.city has joined
00:15:00 Guus has left
00:15:27 Dave Cridland has left
00:16:03 Dave Cridland has left
00:16:30 bjc has joined
00:19:32 waqas has left
00:26:36 la|r|ma has joined
00:30:04 Andrew Nenakhov has left
00:30:47 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
00:34:51 daniel has left
00:34:55 daniel has joined
00:36:58 lskdjf has joined
00:39:13 Dave Cridland has left
00:40:38 Guus has left
00:43:57 Dave Cridland has left
00:47:47 Guus has left
00:50:20 vinx55 has joined
00:51:10 kasper.dement has joined
00:55:11 mrdoctorwho has left
00:55:38 Zash has left
00:55:46 Zash has joined
00:56:33 kasper.dement has joined
00:58:37 Syndace has left
00:58:38 Syndace has joined
01:01:23 marc has left
01:10:37 Guus has left
01:10:41 vinx55 has left
01:11:37 kasper.dement has left
01:11:39 kasper.dement has joined
01:26:41 kasper.dement has left
01:26:45 kasper.dement has joined
01:41:47 Guus has left
01:41:47 kasper.dement has left
01:42:34 Dave Cridland has left
01:43:07 Dave Cridland has left
01:48:13 waqas has joined
01:51:35 kasper.dement has joined
02:05:46 daniel has left
02:05:50 daniel has joined
02:08:28 mrdoctorwho has joined
02:22:03 kasper.dement has left
02:30:59 tux has left
02:31:00 tux has joined
02:31:12 Chobbes has joined
02:31:14 Chobbes has joined
02:33:02 kasper.dement has joined
02:35:28 bjc has left
02:35:36 bjc has joined
02:43:08 kasper.dement has joined
02:45:44 Zash has left
02:45:49 Guus has left
02:53:39 rishiraj22 has left
02:53:42 rishiraj22 has joined
02:53:59 rishiraj22 has left
02:54:01 rishiraj22 has joined
02:55:20 rishiraj22 has left
02:55:23 rishiraj22 has joined
02:55:43 jjrh has left
02:57:57 kasper.dement has joined
02:58:17 rishiraj22 has left
02:58:20 rishiraj22 has joined
02:58:45 Steve Kille has joined
02:59:51 Zash has joined
03:08:54 kasper.dement has left
03:09:05 Chobbes has joined
03:09:09 rishiraj22 has left
03:09:09 Chobbes has joined
03:09:13 rishiraj22 has joined
03:13:53 daniel has left
03:13:57 daniel has joined
03:15:03 kasper.dement has joined
03:15:16 daniel has left
03:15:21 daniel has joined
03:16:14 rishiraj22 has left
03:16:16 rishiraj22 has joined
03:16:33 rishiraj22 has left
03:16:35 rishiraj22 has joined
03:16:59 Guus has left
03:18:03 bjc has left
03:18:47 bjc has joined
03:19:38 404.city has left
03:20:00 matlag has left
03:20:28 kasper.dement has left
03:22:35 bjc has left
03:24:24 jjrh has left
03:24:49 alacer has left
03:25:07 alacer has joined
03:27:54 kasper.dement has joined
03:29:37 jjrh has left
03:29:44 ta has left
03:30:11 jjrh has left
03:31:01 jjrh has left
03:32:43 jjrh has left
03:33:59 daniel has left
03:34:04 daniel has joined
03:35:37 j.r has joined
03:38:22 jere has joined
03:39:23 Steve Kille has left
03:43:02 kasper.dement has left
03:51:20 dos has left
03:56:20 Steve Kille has left
03:57:58 kasper.dement has joined
04:05:11 rishiraj22 has left
04:05:14 rishiraj22 has joined
04:06:33 efrit has joined
04:09:00 rishiraj22 has left
04:09:03 rishiraj22 has joined
04:11:50 kasper.dement has left
04:17:14 bjc has joined
04:18:22 Guus has left
04:28:00 kasper.dement has joined
04:30:27 Bunneh has joined
04:30:29 Zash has joined
04:33:42 Guus has left
04:36:44 lnj has left
04:40:41 kasper.dement has left
04:44:22 Nekit has joined
04:49:56 Dave Cridland has left
04:50:22 Dave Cridland has left
04:50:27 lnj has joined
04:52:56 efrit has left
04:58:10 daniel has left
04:58:13 daniel has joined
05:03:28 waqas has left
05:04:12 lnj has left
05:04:13 lnj has joined
05:04:35 rishiraj22 has left
05:04:36 rishiraj22 has joined
05:07:00 kasper.dement has joined
05:07:10 bjc has left
05:08:05 goffi has joined
05:15:56 daniel has left
05:15:59 daniel has joined
05:19:15 Dave Cridland has left
05:19:48 Dave Cridland has left
05:22:40 kasper.dement has left
05:27:10 mrdoctorwho has joined
05:28:09 kasper.dement has joined
05:30:26 vinx55 has joined
05:30:58 daniel has left
05:31:02 daniel has joined
05:37:52 Dave Cridland has left
05:38:39 Dave Cridland has left
05:45:14 kasper.dement has left
05:45:53 flow What is the rationle behind having xep368 throwing xmpp and xmpps SRV RRs into the same bucket anyway?
05:47:21 Guus has left
05:49:47 kasper.dement has joined
05:51:25 daniel has left
05:53:17 edhelas has left
05:53:39 edhelas has joined
05:53:47 Guus has left
05:54:43 Guus has left
05:55:09 lnj has left
05:55:40 Guus has left
05:56:03 Guus has left
05:57:21 mimi89999 has left
05:57:21 Guus has left
05:58:29 Guus has left
05:59:10 vinx55 has left
06:05:23 kasper.dement has joined
06:06:10 Guus has left
06:09:52 Zash has joined
06:11:22 Zash has joined
06:14:40 marc has joined
06:17:16 muppeth has joined
06:20:07 muppeth has joined
06:21:29 valo has joined
06:22:39 Tobias has left
06:22:41 Tobias has joined
06:25:21 Guus has left
06:26:14 Guus has left
06:26:46 kasper.dement has joined
06:27:49 labdsf has left
06:31:49 marc has left
06:32:01 Dave Cridland has left
06:32:43 Dave Cridland has left
06:36:25 kasper.dement has left
06:37:48 xnyhps has joined
06:37:49 Andrew Nenakhov has left
06:38:16 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
06:39:40 marc has joined
06:40:30 Guus has left
06:41:05 Guus has left
06:42:04 kasper.dement has joined
06:42:10 edhelas would it be possible to tune RSM to be able to retrieve content simply using page number and count ?
06:45:55 Guus has left
06:46:50 jonasw edhelas, by rewriting it to be something completely different, yeah
06:47:04 jonasw (not saying that this wouldn’t be useful in some cases)
06:47:16 jonasw hm
06:47:38 jonasw edhelas, or, if a service offers this, it could have a query mode where <after/> and <before/> refer to indices instead of keys
06:48:00 Valerian has joined
06:48:04 jonasw actually nevermind
06:48:07 jonasw edhelas, what is wrong with: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0059.html#jump
06:48:11 jonasw that should be doing exactly what you want
06:48:12 Nekit has left
06:48:22 jonasw multiply page size with number of page you want and you’re good to go
06:48:34 jonasw multiply page size with number of page you want to calculate the index and you’re good to go
06:50:48 Nekit has joined
06:51:24 rishiraj22 has left
06:51:28 rishiraj22 has joined
06:52:04 kasper.dement has joined
06:54:56 marc has left
06:55:22 blabla has left
06:55:32 blabla has joined
07:00:26 la|r|ma has joined
07:02:08 Holger has left
07:02:50 Andrew Nenakhov has left
07:02:51 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
07:02:51 flow jonasw, what if a service choose to user a smaller page size as requested?
07:03:15 flow or is the page size locked in at size point?
07:04:49 jonasw flow, you can then request more pages until you’ve got the amount of items you want
07:05:01 mimi89999 has joined
07:05:02 jonasw imagine a web view with a simple page number pagination
07:05:25 jonasw if the user chooses 100 items per page, but the service only provides 20, you simply have to fire 5 queries to fill the view page
07:05:51 jonasw so first RSM query woudl be with index=100*pagenumber, the subsequent four would be with <after/> based on the results of the respective previous query
07:06:39 moparisthebest has joined
07:07:47 muppeth has joined
07:08:22 muppeth has joined
07:11:01 kasper.dement has joined
07:13:17 Dave Cridland has left
07:19:49 mrdoctorwho has left
07:22:04 kasper.dement has left
07:24:23 daniel has joined
07:25:26 daniel has left
07:25:32 daniel has joined
07:27:20 Holger Index support is optional though (and typically expensive).
07:32:55 Dave Cridland has left
07:33:12 Martin has left
07:33:22 jonasw yupp
07:37:11 rion has left
07:41:07 kasper.dement has joined
07:45:48 Andrew Nenakhov has left
07:45:51 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
07:46:11 edhelas jonasw "simply have to query", well it's not that simple
07:46:20 Andrew Nenakhov has left
07:46:24 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
07:46:45 edhelas this means that you kinda have to cache the items while their coming, be sure that no new items came in between
07:47:15 edhelas having everything ready to handle the append of items, update the previous/next button to ensure that you can navigate to the other pages
07:47:57 edhelas and also you never know in advance what the server config is, so I cannot "prepare" my UI to request 25 items, the server can return 15 and I have to change my plans
07:48:06 Dave Cridland has left
07:49:04 Alex has joined
07:51:12 kasper.dement has joined
07:52:13 flow edhelas, why not prepare the UI once you know how many items the page yielded?
07:52:33 flow after all, the query itself could fail too
07:55:05 edhelas so each time a user request a page, I need a first round to check then request the articles :)
07:55:29 rishiraj22 has left
07:55:44 rishiraj22 has joined
07:56:40 rishiraj22 has left
07:56:55 rishiraj22 has joined
07:57:58 flow edhelas, I was thinking more of: user action causes a new page request, issue the query, gather results, prepare UI
07:59:45 mimi89999 has left
07:59:53 Valerian has left
07:59:55 Valerian has joined
08:05:09 rishiraj22 has left
08:06:13 kasper.dement has joined
08:06:33 Valerian has left
08:07:10 rishiraj22 has joined
08:07:36 lskdjf has joined
08:10:04 valo has joined
08:12:08 labdsf has joined
08:13:16 Martin has left
08:18:12 404.city has joined
08:19:05 Alex has left
08:19:16 valo has joined
08:21:06 Valerian has joined
08:21:18 kasper.dement has joined
08:26:11 kasper.dement has joined
08:28:02 lumi has joined
08:30:47 rishiraj22 has left
08:31:36 kasper.dement has joined
08:40:26 lskdjf has left
08:40:30 Guus has left
08:41:30 lskdjf has left
08:42:44 Kev has left
08:44:23 rishiraj22 has left
08:46:49 Martin has left
08:47:01 kasper.dement has joined
08:47:07 la|r|ma has left
08:48:50 xnyhps has joined
08:50:26 Dave Cridland has left
08:50:44 Dave Cridland has left
08:51:29 Dave Cridland has left
08:54:04 Martin has left
08:54:42 mikaela has joined
08:55:32 lskdjf has joined
08:57:06 kasper.dement has left
08:57:48 Alex has joined
08:58:17 rishiraj22 has left
08:58:27 xnyhps has joined
08:59:20 Andrew Nenakhov has left
08:59:33 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
09:00:32 Andrew Nenakhov has left
09:00:35 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
09:06:35 rishiraj22 has left
09:08:53 jere has joined
09:09:44 Holger has left
09:09:58 lskdjf has left
09:10:03 lskdjf has joined
09:12:11 Valerian has left
09:17:07 kasper.dement has joined
09:18:25 Andrew Nenakhov has left
09:18:27 jubalh has joined
09:18:29 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
09:21:25 lnj has joined
09:27:12 kasper.dement has left
09:28:44 valo has joined
09:30:28 ThibG has left
09:30:32 ThibG has joined
09:33:32 Guus has left
09:34:04 Guus has left
09:39:42 Valerian has joined
09:41:59 Kev has left
09:44:59 Str4tocaster has joined
09:45:14 Str4tocaster has left
09:45:23 Str4tocaster has joined
09:46:18 Str4tocaster has left
09:46:20 rishiraj22 has left
09:48:05 Str4tocaster has joined
09:50:12 Str4tocaster has left
09:50:48 Str4tocaster has joined
09:51:27 Str4tocaster has left
09:52:14 Str4tocaster has joined
09:52:30 Valerian has left
09:52:31 Valerian has joined
09:54:26 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
09:54:47 Kev has left
09:55:43 moparisthebest has joined
09:58:37 jubalh has joined
10:00:59 mikaela has left
10:02:11 alacer has left
10:02:13 alacer has joined
10:03:24 Str4tocaster has left
10:03:40 xnyhps has joined
10:03:43 Str4tocaster has joined
10:03:44 Andrew Nenakhov has left
10:03:49 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
10:04:41 Str4tocaster has left
10:05:16 Str4tocaster has joined
10:05:25 xnyhps has joined
10:10:04 404.city has left
10:10:22 Str4tocaster has left
10:10:28 Str4tocaster has joined
10:11:55 la|r|ma has joined
10:12:34 Str4tocaster has left
10:12:50 Str4tocaster has joined
10:13:00 j.r has joined
10:14:46 Str4tocaster has left
10:15:00 Str4tocaster has joined
10:15:18 Str4tocaster has left
10:15:32 Str4tocaster has joined
10:17:12 kasper.dement has joined
10:19:47 j.r has joined
10:19:55 j.r has joined
10:21:44 rishiraj22 has left
10:25:18 j.r has left
10:25:22 Guus has left
10:25:22 j.r has joined
10:26:00 Valerian has left
10:26:04 Valerian has joined
10:26:32 Guus has left
10:28:15 blabla has left
10:28:21 blabla has joined
10:29:35 Valerian has left
10:29:35 Valerian has joined
10:30:05 kasper.dement has left
10:32:23 kasper.dement has joined
10:40:47 Valerian has left
10:46:29 kasper.dement has left
10:47:22 mrdoctorwho has joined
10:48:25 lumi has left
10:51:25 kasper.dement has joined
10:56:05 Str4tocaster has left
10:56:15 Str4tocaster has joined
10:56:34 Martin has joined
10:58:29 Str4tocaster has left
10:58:39 Str4tocaster has joined
10:59:16 Guus has left
10:59:52 Guus has left
11:04:25 Alex has left
11:11:34 Str4tocaster has left
11:11:41 Str4tocaster has joined
11:11:53 Str4tocaster has left
11:11:58 Str4tocaster has joined
11:12:04 mikaela has joined
11:14:32 Valerian has joined
11:16:51 Valerian has left
11:19:02 jubalh has joined
11:19:40 jere has left
11:19:43 jere has joined
11:22:32 Str4tocaster has left
11:22:45 Alex has joined
11:22:49 Str4tocaster has joined
11:23:03 Str4tocaster has left
11:23:24 Str4tocaster has joined
11:23:31 Str4tocaster has left
11:23:35 Str4tocaster has joined
11:23:35 Str4tocaster has left
11:23:37 Str4tocaster has joined
11:23:51 Str4tocaster has left
11:24:09 Str4tocaster has joined
11:24:20 Str4tocaster has left
11:24:37 Str4tocaster has joined
11:24:49 Str4tocaster has left
11:24:51 Str4tocaster has joined
11:25:25 Alex has left
11:25:27 Alex has joined
11:28:20 alacer has left
11:28:27 alacer has joined
11:32:21 Ge0rG has left
11:38:05 lskdjf has joined
11:42:50 Valerian has joined
11:43:14 jubalh has joined
11:45:36 404.city has joined
11:46:27 Kev has left
11:48:03 Str4tocaster has left
11:48:59 Str4tocaster has joined
11:51:15 jabberjocke has joined
11:51:25 Str4tocaster has left
11:51:39 Str4tocaster has joined
11:52:07 Str4tocaster has left
11:53:13 Str4tocaster has joined
11:56:28 Str4tocaster has left
11:56:41 Str4tocaster has joined
11:57:13 jubalh has joined
11:57:58 Str4tocaster has left
11:58:20 rishiraj22 has left
11:58:26 rishiraj22 has left
11:58:48 Str4tocaster has joined
11:59:55 la|r|ma has joined
12:00:10 Str4tocaster has left
12:03:08 dos has joined
12:16:20 rishiraj22 has left
12:23:13 rishiraj22 has left
12:23:39 Martin has left
12:27:01 Kev has left
12:28:40 jubalh has joined
12:32:24 lorddavidiii has joined
12:38:30 andrey.g has left
12:39:43 mrdoctorwho has joined
12:40:30 jubalh has joined
12:41:34 andrey.g has joined
12:42:40 ta has left
12:45:10 dos has left
12:47:30 matlag has joined
12:50:23 xnyhps has joined
12:50:34 Valerian has left
12:50:34 Valerian has joined
12:57:51 SamWhited has left
13:00:27 Andrew Nenakhov has left
13:03:19 jubalh has joined
13:08:01 marc has joined
13:08:15 lorddavidiii has left
13:11:44 muppeth has joined
13:13:52 muppeth has joined
13:14:43 Valerian has left
13:22:50 kasper.dement has joined
13:25:07 Valerian has joined
13:27:19 kasper.dement has joined
13:27:59 jabberjocke has left
13:28:50 moparisthebest has joined
13:29:40 moparisthebest has joined
13:30:03 jere has left
13:30:37 alacer has left
13:30:38 alacer has joined
13:32:52 mrdoctorwho has joined
13:34:22 xnyhps has joined
13:35:20 kasper.dement has left
13:38:54 kasper.dement has joined
13:41:20 marc has left
13:42:36 alacer has left
13:42:39 alacer has joined
13:44:43 labdsf has left
13:44:51 muppeth has joined
13:45:17 muppeth has joined
13:47:31 mikaela has left
13:47:37 mikaela has joined
13:48:38 labdsf has joined
13:49:10 lorddavidiii has joined
13:50:35 lorddavidiii has left
13:52:00 lorddavidiii has joined
13:52:06 lorddavidiii has left
13:52:57 jere has joined
13:53:27 lorddavidiii has joined
13:53:33 lorddavidiii has left
13:53:59 alacer has left
13:54:03 alacer has joined
13:54:52 lorddavidiii has joined
13:55:00 lorddavidiii has left
13:56:21 lorddavidiii has joined
13:56:30 lorddavidiii has left
13:56:53 rion has left
13:56:55 rion has joined
13:57:49 lorddavidiii has joined
13:57:59 lorddavidiii has left
13:59:17 lorddavidiii has joined
13:59:25 lorddavidiii has left
14:00:38 jere has left
14:00:46 lorddavidiii has joined
14:00:51 lorddavidiii has left
14:02:14 lorddavidiii has joined
14:02:18 lorddavidiii has left
14:03:00 jubalh has joined
14:03:42 lorddavidiii has joined
14:04:46 lskdjf has left
14:05:16 lorddavidiii has left
14:06:41 lorddavidiii has joined
14:06:46 Kev has left
14:08:05 lorddavidiii has left
14:08:10 lorddavidiii has joined
14:08:26 jere has joined
14:09:33 lorddavidiii has left
14:09:38 lorddavidiii has joined
14:11:08 lorddavidiii has left
14:11:14 lorddavidiii has joined
14:12:43 kasper.dement has joined
14:12:45 lorddavidiii has left
14:12:50 lorddavidiii has joined
14:14:05 kasper.dement has joined
14:14:57 lnj has left
14:18:09 lorddavidiii has left
14:18:58 marc has joined
14:19:06 lnj has joined
14:21:05 Valerian has left
14:21:06 Valerian has joined
14:30:35 marc has left
14:31:38 daniel has left
14:32:13 daniel has joined
14:39:23 marc has joined
14:39:47 jubalh has joined
14:42:13 kasper.dement has joined
14:42:23 jubalh has joined
14:47:23 Ge0rG has left
14:47:48 j.r has joined
14:51:39 dos has joined
14:54:52 Valerian has left
14:58:18 Kev has left
15:01:08 kasper.dement has joined
15:03:42 Guus has left
15:04:34 elegantfox has joined
15:04:56 elegantfox has left
15:07:19 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:09:18 Guus has left
15:11:07 jubalh has left
15:13:23 kasper.dement has joined
15:15:14 jubalh has joined
15:15:22 rishiraj22 has left
15:15:41 Tobias has left
15:15:43 Tobias has joined
15:15:51 mrdoctorwho has joined
15:16:40 edhelas flow I have to see how I can refactor my flow to handle that more properly indeed
15:17:02 kasper.dement has joined
15:17:41 edhelas also I have to check how XMPP servers are handling that, ejabberd had RSM bugs a few months ago still, and I don't know how if Prosody and the others are implementing RSM
15:18:05 edhelas a nice compliance test would also be really awesome to build
15:18:16 jonasw the aioxmpp test suite starts to become something like that
15:18:28 edhelas publish 100 items, request them in many different way to see if they are consistant
15:19:13 Ge0rG publish a message archive, join a MIX, check if history replay works
15:20:17 Valerian has joined
15:21:08 lovetox has joined
15:22:10 lnj has left
15:29:14 kasper.dement has joined
15:29:44 j.r has joined
15:29:47 waqas has joined
15:34:39 Guus has left
15:36:19 waqas has left
15:39:17 rion has left
15:40:40 jubalh has joined
15:40:42 jubalh has joined
15:41:11 waqas has joined
15:43:49 jubalh has left
15:43:50 jubalh has joined
15:45:01 lnj has joined
15:46:39 vinx55 has joined
15:46:45 j.r has joined
15:46:58 kasper.dement has joined
15:50:36 lnj has left
15:51:54 jubalh has joined
15:52:59 rishiraj22 has left
15:53:18 lnj has joined
15:55:09 waqas has left
15:56:33 Guus has left
15:58:07 j.r has joined
15:58:33 lnj has left
15:58:34 Kev has left
16:00:39 Guus has left
16:01:40 Martin has left
16:01:40 Martin has left
16:01:40 Martin has left
16:02:15 Valerian has left
16:02:16 Valerian has joined
16:02:38 Guus has left
16:04:17 Guus has left
16:04:47 Guus has left
16:05:13 Guus has left
16:05:24 ta has joined
16:05:42 Guus has left
16:06:45 Martin has joined
16:08:11 Guus has left
16:09:17 vinx55 has left
16:10:28 Guus has left
16:15:43 ta has joined
16:15:43 lnj has joined
16:15:55 ta has joined
16:17:59 Guus has left
16:18:48 jubalh has joined
16:22:42 Guus has left
16:25:38 Alex has left
16:26:28 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
16:30:31 rion has joined
16:33:06 muppeth has left
16:34:46 Kev has left
16:39:38 rishiraj22 has left
16:43:28 matlag has joined
16:44:27 alacer has left
16:45:24 alacer has joined
16:45:56 rishiraj22 has left
16:45:58 dos has left
16:46:13 marc has left
16:48:18 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
16:51:33 ta has left
16:51:44 ta has joined
17:00:39 Dave Cridland has left
17:01:17 Martin has left
17:01:38 j.r has joined
17:04:50 j.r has joined
17:06:18 Chobbes has joined
17:08:18 mrdoctorwho has joined
17:09:04 Andrew Nenakhov has left
17:09:15 Dave Cridland has left
17:09:18 lskdjf has joined
17:09:20 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
17:14:11 rishiraj22 has left
17:16:15 Guus has left
17:16:46 Guus has left
17:17:52 Dave Cridland has left
17:20:21 Ge0rG has left
17:20:32 Dave Cridland has left
17:21:04 Dave Cridland has left
17:21:19 Yagiza has joined
17:21:36 Dave Cridland has left
17:24:13 Guus has left
17:24:58 Dave Cridland has left
17:25:12 Dave Cridland has left
17:26:18 alacer has left
17:26:20 alacer has joined
17:28:27 Chobbes has joined
17:29:11 lnj has left
17:29:20 Valerian has left
17:29:21 Valerian has joined
17:30:15 j.r has joined
17:31:20 Alex has joined
17:34:32 Guus has left
17:36:19 lnj has joined
17:36:37 Guus has left
17:37:13 Guus has left
17:41:43 labdsf has left
17:41:51 lnj has left
17:42:58 SamWhited has left
17:43:12 Dave Cridland has left
17:43:20 marc has joined
17:46:38 lnj has joined
17:49:48 Guus has left
17:50:14 SamWhited has left
17:50:21 Guus has left
17:52:02 Guus has left
17:52:10 lnj has left
17:54:00 Guus has left
17:54:44 lnj has joined
17:57:07 dos has joined
17:58:23 edhelas has left
17:58:49 Guus has left
17:58:54 edhelas has joined
17:59:01 kasper.dement has left
18:00:32 Syndace has left
18:00:34 Syndace has joined
18:00:34 Martin has left
18:02:06 kasper.dement has joined
18:02:07 j.r has joined
18:03:50 j.r has left
18:03:54 j.r has joined
18:06:31 404.city has left
18:07:48 waqas has joined
18:08:26 lumi has joined
18:15:23 winfried has joined
18:16:26 Dave Cridland has left
18:18:01 Kev has left
18:22:21 ThibG has joined
18:22:43 Demoaccount has joined
18:23:07 Demoaccount has left
18:24:56 ThibG has joined
18:26:59 Andrew Nenakhov has left
18:27:05 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
18:29:51 winfried has joined
18:34:25 Guus has left
18:35:30 Guus has left
18:38:20 Guus has left
18:39:58 winfried has joined
18:40:03 winfried has joined
18:43:59 ThibG has joined
18:44:32 ThibG has joined
18:45:21 Valerian has left
18:45:23 Valerian has joined
18:45:32 Andrew Nenakhov has left
18:45:41 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
18:45:55 Alex has left
18:46:44 Yagiza has left
18:49:16 rishiraj22 has left
18:50:44 Guus has left
18:51:08 winfried has joined
18:51:10 winfried has joined
18:51:18 Guus has left
18:54:40 kasper.dement has joined
18:55:03 kasper.dement has joined
18:55:09 la|r|ma has joined
18:55:10 lskdjf has joined
18:55:55 Guus has left
19:02:17 waqas has left
19:02:17 Guus has left
19:03:11 labdsf has joined
19:05:59 labdsf has left
19:06:01 labdsf has joined
19:06:15 karp has joined
19:08:31 labdsf has left
19:08:36 labdsf has joined
19:09:38 labdsf has left
19:09:40 labdsf has joined
19:10:07 labdsf has left
19:10:13 labdsf has joined
19:10:53 mrdoctorwho has joined
19:11:33 Kev has left
19:18:17 edhelas disco items for a pubsub node with RSM, what do you think about it ?
19:18:31 edhelas or for any services basically
19:20:17 jonasw edhelas, isn’t that even a suggestion in XEP-0059?
19:20:23 jonasw makes sense to have
19:20:55 edhelas then ordering is also important
19:21:14 edhelas I'd like to ensure for Pubsub to disco the items based on the most recent first
19:21:25 edhelas (then I don't have to resolve the payload each time)
19:21:28 jonasw define most recent
19:21:43 jonasw most rcent isn’t a suitable key for RSM
19:21:46 edhelas well based of the "recent" definition in 0060 :p
19:22:02 edhelas https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0060.html#subscriber-retrieve-requestrecent
19:22:09 jonasw an RSM key (for use with <before/> and <after/>) must be an immutable property of the items which are enumerated
19:22:22 jonasw edhelas, eh, that’s for a node, not for a service
19:22:57 edhelas yes but the disco#items of a pubsub node should behave the same as a service afaik
19:23:30 edhelas or we have to specify that for a service it behave in a specific manner, alphabetically for example
19:23:30 jubalh has joined
19:23:51 karp has left
19:24:03 edhelas but the XMPP server need to order by something before doing the limit/offset (for a SQL database)
19:24:33 edhelas and this need to be consistent between the XMPP servers, if not I can't rely on using disco#items with RSM in my client
19:25:05 edhelas (except by requesting everything and order the result locally…)
19:26:32 jonasw that’s what you have to do anyways
19:26:55 jonasw because in very few cases your users will want to sort by the name (as in, the @node value, not the @name) of the node
19:27:33 edhelas pubsub nodes can have hundreds of items, conference services thousands of rooms
19:27:39 jonasw yes
19:27:47 jonasw and sorting with RSM can only happen by primary keys
19:27:53 edhelas and the info is actually available on the xmpp server to sort a bit the things
19:27:56 jonasw (or unique, immutable keys at least)
19:28:12 jonasw or it is going to be rather expensive
19:28:27 jonasw
19:30:19 jubalh has joined
19:40:45 jubalh has joined
19:41:08 Guus has left
19:41:46 Guus has left
19:49:11 waqas has joined
19:55:11 Ge0rG has left
19:56:23 lskdjf has joined
20:00:25 kasper.dement has joined
20:01:52 efrit has joined
20:01:59 kasper.dement has joined
20:10:57 kasper.dement has joined
20:12:39 kasper.dement has joined
20:18:08 waqas has left
20:20:55 Chobbes has joined
20:21:23 labdsf has left
20:23:55 marc has left
20:26:46 Valerian has left
20:26:47 Valerian has joined
20:27:23 labdsf has joined
20:27:41 ThibG has joined
20:28:03 ThibG has joined
20:28:36 Kev has left
20:31:11 jere has joined
20:32:09 la|r|ma has joined
20:32:14 la|r|ma has joined
20:35:31 jubalh has joined
20:39:48 Andrew Nenakhov has left
20:42:38 efrit has left
20:43:29 Alex has joined
20:43:40 ThibG has left
20:43:42 ThibG has joined
20:43:49 js has joined
20:45:28 j.r has joined
20:46:04 kasper.dement has joined
20:48:00 lskdjf has left
20:49:10 blabla has left
20:50:22 blabla has joined
20:50:23 kasper.dement has joined
20:54:53 j.r has joined
20:56:03 Holger has left
20:57:21 tux has joined
20:57:46 Valerian has left
20:57:51 Valerian has joined
20:58:34 Valerian has left
21:00:53 Martin has left
21:01:47 Dave Cridland has left
21:04:11 Dave Cridland has left
21:04:20 lskdjf has joined
21:06:16 lskdjf has left
21:09:48 lskdjf has left
21:15:29 Alex has left
21:15:36 Alex has joined
21:24:04 js has left
21:24:44 js has joined
21:26:06 tux has left
21:26:08 tux has joined
21:29:49 Dave Cridland has left
21:32:22 Dave Cridland has left
21:32:55 Dave Cridland has left
21:33:21 Dave Cridland has left
21:34:17 Dave Cridland has left
21:34:57 edhelas has left
21:35:27 edhelas has joined
21:36:23 Dave Cridland has left
21:39:00 Dave Cridland has left
21:41:27 Dave Cridland has left
21:43:44 xnyhps has joined
21:43:50 lumi has left
21:44:18 xnyhps has joined
21:48:07 lovetox has left
21:49:57 lnj has left
21:50:35 daniel has left
21:51:21 daniel has joined
21:52:10 Dave Cridland has left
21:52:39 Dave Cridland has left
21:54:00 lskdjf has left
21:54:22 kasper.dement has joined
21:56:11 lskdjf has left
21:58:16 goffi has left
22:00:09 Dave Cridland has left
22:01:14 Dave Cridland has left
22:01:50 kasper.dement has joined
22:03:06 lskdjf has joined
22:06:08 mikaela has left
22:11:27 waqas has joined
22:14:59 Dave Cridland has left
22:15:06 kasper.dement has left
22:17:08 Dave Cridland has left
22:18:29 kasper.dement has joined
22:20:11 Dave Cridland has left
22:20:44 Dave Cridland has left
22:22:49 rion has left
22:25:48 Dave Cridland has left
22:26:55 Dave Cridland has left
22:27:20 Nekit has joined
22:27:40 daniel has left
22:28:23 daniel has joined
22:28:34 kasper.dement has left
22:29:00 Dave Cridland has left
22:30:04 Dave Cridland has left
22:33:26 kasper.dement has joined
22:37:35 Dave Cridland has left
22:40:31 j.r has joined
22:41:57 j.r has joined
22:59:45 kasper.dement has left
22:59:51 Alex has left
23:00:42 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
23:06:14 j.r has joined
23:07:48 Dave Cridland has left
23:13:51 ta has joined
23:16:16 daniel has left
23:16:32 valo has joined
23:18:34 kasper.dement has joined
23:24:05 Syndace has left
23:24:06 Syndace has joined
23:24:28 kasper.dement has left
23:26:24 xnyhps has joined
23:27:45 js has left
23:33:31 kasper.dement has joined
23:33:48 lorddavidiii has joined
23:45:53 SamWhited has left
23:48:59 kasper.dement has left
23:51:40 la|r|ma has joined
23:58:48 Syndace has left
23:58:49 Syndace has joined