XSF Discussion - 2018-09-25

00:01:34 jjrh has left
00:02:13 jjrh has left
00:05:20 alacer has left
00:11:33 jjrh has left
00:11:45 UsL has joined
00:11:53 jjrh has left
00:11:56 Maranda has left
00:12:06 Maranda has joined
00:13:21 lumi has joined
00:13:44 Dave Cridland has left
00:13:45 Maranda SamWhited, and it's not falling back either on malformed request...
00:13:52 Maranda I'll have to blacklist the mechanism
00:15:06 efrit has joined
00:15:31 SamWhited Oh yah, it doesn't do that, otherwise it would be a potential DOS
00:15:49 SamWhited It only falls back if the feature isn't advertised at all and no successful auth has caused a mechanism to be pinned, IIRC
00:16:05 SamWhited *a higher-priority mechanism to be pinned
00:16:22 vanitasvitae has left
00:19:03 Maranda has left
00:19:10 Maranda has joined
00:20:46 Maranda has left
00:21:35 jjrh has left
00:21:36 jjrh has left
00:31:35 jjrh has left
00:32:46 jjrh has left
00:40:50 Maranda has joined
00:42:01 jjrh has left
00:42:25 jjrh has left
00:44:24 Dave Cridland has left
00:51:35 jjrh has left
00:52:02 jjrh has left
00:53:52 peter has left
00:55:54 Maranda has left
00:56:09 Maranda has left
01:00:49 Maranda has left
01:01:12 Maranda has left
01:01:34 jjrh has left
01:02:57 jjrh has left
01:03:14 Maranda has left
01:05:13 Maranda has joined
01:05:21 Maranda has left
01:05:27 Maranda has joined
01:06:06 Maranda has left
01:06:11 Maranda has joined
01:13:46 alexis has joined
01:14:44 Dave Cridland has left
01:16:53 alexis has left
01:21:35 jjrh has left
01:21:51 jjrh has left
01:23:35 peter has joined
01:23:51 Maranda has left
01:24:01 lskdjf has left
01:24:06 l has left
01:26:45 Maranda has joined
01:26:57 alexis has joined
01:27:54 alexis has left
01:28:18 tux has left
01:28:19 tux has joined
01:31:35 jjrh has left
01:33:04 Maranda has left
01:34:50 jjrh has left
01:35:52 l has left
01:35:57 l has joined
01:38:11 Maranda has joined
01:39:11 Maranda has left
01:39:16 Maranda has joined
01:41:34 jjrh has left
01:41:44 jjrh has left
01:45:14 Dave Cridland has left
01:50:48 Maranda has left
01:52:00 jjrh has left
01:52:05 Maranda has joined
01:52:08 Maranda has left
01:52:16 Maranda has joined
01:52:22 Maranda has left
01:52:26 Maranda has joined
01:52:39 Neustradamus has left
01:53:02 Neustradamus has joined
01:53:12 jjrh has left
01:55:20 SamWhited has left
01:58:42 moparisthebest has left
01:59:39 lskdjf has joined
02:01:41 jjrh has left
02:02:09 l has joined
02:11:35 jjrh has left
02:12:37 jjrh has left
02:12:59 j.r has joined
02:13:18 j.r has joined
02:15:44 Dave Cridland has left
02:16:49 alacer has joined
02:17:22 alacer has left
02:17:39 alacer has joined
02:32:11 jjrh has left
02:33:01 jjrh has left
02:35:04 Yagiza has joined
02:37:54 Yagiza has left
02:38:20 labdsf has left
02:38:21 labdsf has joined
02:39:58 Yagiza has left
02:42:09 jjrh has left
02:42:59 jjrh has left
02:44:14 alacer has left
02:46:14 Dave Cridland has left
02:52:12 jjrh has left
02:52:58 Yagiza has left
02:55:44 Yagiza has left
02:57:19 Yagiza has joined
02:59:32 Yagiza has left
03:01:35 jjrh has left
03:03:43 jjrh has left
03:09:24 Dave Cridland has left
03:09:53 alacer has joined
03:10:56 Dave Cridland has left
03:11:35 jjrh has left
03:11:48 jjrh has left
03:11:59 Yagiza has left
03:14:07 alacer has left
03:14:10 alacer has joined
03:16:54 Dave Cridland has left
03:21:33 jjrh has left
03:21:35 jjrh has left
03:25:51 peter has left
03:33:07 jjrh has left
03:33:21 jjrh has left
03:36:15 Yagiza has left
03:36:58 Yagiza has left
03:37:16 Yagiza has joined
03:40:10 labdsf has left
03:40:56 labdsf has joined
03:41:51 jjrh has left
03:47:11 Yagiza has left
03:47:14 Dave Cridland has left
03:52:05 jjrh has left
03:54:10 Yagiza has left
03:54:29 Yagiza has joined
04:01:10 Neustradamus has left
04:01:35 jjrh has left
04:02:15 Yagiza has left
04:02:32 Neustradamus has joined
04:06:54 muppeth has left
04:08:53 Dave Cridland has left
04:11:34 jjrh has left
04:12:01 jjrh has left
04:13:15 Dave Cridland has left
04:16:44 Yagiza has left
04:19:34 Yagiza has left
04:21:36 jjrh has left
04:22:01 jjrh has left
04:26:06 labdsf has left
04:31:35 jjrh has left
04:32:58 jjrh has left
04:35:42 lnj has joined
04:39:05 labdsf has joined
04:39:29 Dave Cridland has left
04:40:09 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:40:09 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:40:19 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
04:40:36 moparisthebest has joined
04:41:34 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:41:34 jjrh has left
04:41:34 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:41:37 jjrh has left
04:41:41 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
04:42:17 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:42:17 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:42:22 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
04:42:53 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:42:54 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:42:56 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
04:43:31 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:43:32 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:43:38 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
04:44:07 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:44:10 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:44:14 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
04:45:11 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:45:13 Andrew Nenakhov has left
04:45:15 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
04:46:53 labdsf has left
04:47:09 daniel has left
04:50:19 daniel has joined
04:51:35 jjrh has left
04:51:59 jjrh has left
04:52:11 alacer has left
04:52:13 alacer has joined
04:55:52 daniel has left
04:57:32 mimi89999 has left
05:00:56 Andrew Nenakhov has left
05:01:29 Andrew Nenakhov has left
05:01:33 lorddavidiii has joined
05:01:36 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
05:02:03 daniel has joined
05:06:32 andy has joined
05:07:46 jjrh has left
05:09:50 Dave Cridland has left
05:12:24 labdsf has joined
05:15:33 j.r has left
05:15:36 j.r has joined
05:17:47 jjrh has left
05:18:56 alacer has left
05:18:58 alacer has joined
05:21:34 jjrh has left
05:23:19 Andrew Nenakhov has left
05:23:23 jjrh has left
05:23:26 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
05:26:28 labdsf has left
05:26:28 SamWhited has left
05:31:35 jjrh has left
05:31:48 jjrh has left
05:37:16 Andrew Nenakhov has left
05:40:15 Dave Cridland has left
05:41:17 Andrew Nenakhov has left
05:41:35 jjrh has left
05:42:24 jjrh has left
05:50:24 daniel has left
05:50:45 daniel has joined
05:51:35 jjrh has left
05:51:53 Dave Cridland has left
05:53:05 Andrew Nenakhov has left
06:01:33 jjrh has left
06:01:36 jjrh has left
06:09:10 alacer has left
06:09:38 alacer has joined
06:10:54 Dave Cridland has left
06:14:49 Andrew Nenakhov has left
06:15:38 j.r has joined
06:17:19 vinx55 has joined
06:17:47 ralphm has left
06:17:52 Str4tocaster has joined
06:18:33 karp has left
06:18:33 karp has joined
06:18:34 Zash has left
06:19:45 ralphm has joined
06:20:45 daniel has left
06:21:04 daniel has joined
06:21:24 jjrh has left
06:21:34 jjrh has left
06:22:12 jjrh has left
06:23:01 vinx55 has left
06:23:20 Andrew Nenakhov has left
06:23:28 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
06:24:04 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
06:26:04 Str4tocaster has left
06:30:26 vinx55 has joined
06:31:09 Andrew Nenakhov has left
06:31:30 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
06:31:35 jjrh has left
06:32:12 jjrh has left
06:36:03 vinx55 has left
06:39:11 valo has joined
06:39:53 valo has joined
06:39:53 thorsten has joined
06:41:24 Dave Cridland has left
06:43:44 jjrh has left
06:45:59 Zash has left
06:49:22 lorddavidiii has left
06:50:22 karp has left
06:50:23 karp has joined
06:51:36 jjrh has left
06:52:03 jjrh has left
06:54:27 Dave Cridland has left
06:56:36 lorddavidiii has joined
07:01:53 Nekit has joined
07:09:39 Dave Cridland has left
07:11:24 jjrh has left
07:11:44 Dave Cridland has left
07:11:48 jjrh has left
07:12:21 karp has left
07:12:22 karp has joined
07:12:57 Zash has left
07:15:56 Guus has left
07:18:05 Zash has joined
07:18:30 Guus has joined
07:21:26 Andrew Nenakhov has left
07:21:32 flow has joined
07:21:34 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
07:21:49 lnj has left
07:22:06 jjrh has left
07:22:13 lnj has joined
07:22:37 jjrh has left
07:28:07 j.r has joined
07:29:32 goffi has joined
07:31:35 jjrh has left
07:33:09 Dave Cridland has left
07:36:04 Str4tocaster has joined
07:37:40 Dave Cridland has left
07:38:26 Str4tocaster has left
07:39:14 Str4tocaster has joined
07:40:32 Dave Cridland has left
07:41:37 jjrh has left
07:41:38 jjrh has left
07:42:05 edhelas was there some discussions regarding the GDPR and the usage of transports with XMPP ?
07:42:28 Seve/SouL has joined
07:44:29 Dave Cridland has left
07:46:26 Str4tocaster has left
07:46:50 Dave Cridland has left
07:50:44 Dave Cridland has joined
07:51:30 404.city has joined
07:51:49 jjrh has left
07:53:06 Dave Cridland has left
07:54:03 Kev has joined
07:54:32 Dave Cridland has joined
07:54:59 Kev has left
08:01:34 jjrh has left
08:04:11 Neustradamus has left
08:04:48 Dave Cridland has left
08:04:56 Neustradamus has joined
08:05:25 Dave Cridland has joined
08:06:01 j.r has joined
08:09:35 flow has left
08:09:36 flow has joined
08:12:10 Andrew Nenakhov has left
08:12:18 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
08:12:19 jjrh has left
08:12:49 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
08:13:39 Andrew Nenakhov has left
08:13:47 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
08:14:14 Andrew Nenakhov has left
08:14:43 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
08:15:58 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
08:16:41 Andrew Nenakhov has left
08:18:12 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
08:20:50 flow has left
08:21:33 jjrh has left
08:21:48 jjrh has left
08:25:27 UsL has joined
08:33:00 mrdoctorwho has left
08:35:22 Dave Cridland has left
08:38:04 waqas has left
08:41:24 jjrh has left
08:41:34 jjrh has left
08:42:14 jjrh has left
08:45:12 karp has left
08:51:34 jjrh has left
08:53:14 winfried has joined
08:53:20 jjrh has left
09:00:14 Dave Cridland has left
09:01:29 l has joined
09:01:34 jjrh has left
09:02:15 jjrh has left
09:03:32 winfried has joined
09:04:13 Dave Cridland has left
09:05:22 Guus has left
09:05:58 Dave Cridland has left
09:10:14 winfried has joined
09:11:34 jjrh has left
09:12:35 jjrh has left
09:18:29 Steve Kille has left
09:18:29 Steve Kille has left
09:27:54 Guus has joined
09:29:00 Nekit has left
09:29:22 Nekit has joined
09:29:32 j.r has joined
09:29:45 Dave Cridland has left
09:30:01 lnj has left
09:31:25 jjrh has left
09:33:40 edhelas > and Mojave completes the transition by pulling out Jabber support
09:33:53 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
09:36:50 Zash Who
09:40:03 vanitasvitae has left
09:40:59 vanitasvitae has left
09:41:25 jjrh has left
09:41:33 jjrh has left
09:41:39 edhelas macOS Mojave, the state of XMPP in iMessage was already bad, now it's gone
09:41:48 jjrh has left
09:41:56 edhelas so leave us with not much actually
09:42:38 edhelas Dino doesn't has a stable built yet for macOS, Adium is based on libpurple, there's maybe Swift
09:42:47 edhelas and Movim but it's an Electron client :p
09:43:08 jonas’ gajim?
09:43:46 mrdoctorwho has joined
09:45:36 edhelas yes indeed
09:49:23 Andrew Nenakhov has left
09:51:34 jjrh has left
09:52:13 Andrew Nenakhov has left
09:54:34 jjrh has left
09:55:08 mrdoctorwho has left
10:01:34 jjrh has left
10:02:01 jjrh has left
10:02:38 derdaniel has left
10:02:39 derdaniel has joined
10:06:32 efrit has left
10:11:33 jjrh has left
10:11:34 jjrh has left
10:12:46 Zash has left
10:17:11 equil has left
10:18:37 Zash Monal?
10:22:25 jjrh has left
10:24:42 Neustradamus has left
10:26:18 Str4tocaster has joined
10:26:50 Zash has left
10:26:53 Str4tocaster has left
10:27:05 Str4tocaster has joined
10:29:12 Neustradamus has joined
10:31:35 jjrh has left
10:32:53 moparisthebest has left
10:34:31 jjrh has left
10:35:39 flow has joined
10:38:59 Dave Cridland has left
10:41:35 jjrh has left
10:43:24 Andrew Nenakhov has left
10:43:25 jjrh has left
10:43:33 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
10:44:00 lskdjf has joined
10:44:43 goffi Cagou (SàT) is working on Mac OS, but need people to test it (I have no Mac myself)
10:46:13 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
10:51:06 Dave Cridland has left
10:51:34 jjrh has left
10:54:36 lnj has left
10:57:04 Dave Cridland has left
10:57:47 Str4tocaster has left
10:57:56 mrdoctorwho has joined
11:00:17 Dave Cridland has left
11:03:23 Dave Cridland has left
11:06:06 Andrew Nenakhov has left
11:06:15 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
11:09:31 Dave Cridland has left
11:09:33 Dave Cridland has left
11:11:38 jjrh has left
11:14:46 ThibG has left
11:14:49 ThibG has joined
11:15:47 Andrew Nenakhov has left
11:15:53 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
11:17:56 Zash has left
11:18:54 lnj has joined
11:22:12 jjrh has left
11:23:44 muppeth has joined
11:28:17 labdsf has joined
11:28:26 Zash has left
11:31:59 Seve/SouL has left
11:32:12 jjrh has left
11:40:54 Andrew Nenakhov has left
11:41:04 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
11:41:33 jjrh has left
11:41:48 jjrh has left
11:42:52 Nekit has left
11:43:09 Dave Cridland has left
11:46:30 Nekit has joined
11:46:45 labdsf has left
11:51:02 alacer has left
11:51:04 alacer has joined
11:51:22 Dave Cridland has left
11:51:54 Dave Cridland has left
11:52:03 Dave Cridland has left
11:59:58 labdsf has joined
12:01:27 Andrew Nenakhov has left
12:01:34 jjrh has left
12:01:36 jjrh has left
12:02:01 alacer has left
12:02:22 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
12:06:12 j.r has joined
12:12:16 jjrh has left
12:12:24 labdsf has left
12:13:54 jjrh has left
12:14:18 labdsf has joined
12:16:18 l has left
12:21:36 jjrh has left
12:21:59 jjrh has left
12:22:37 Kev has joined
12:22:45 Kev has left
12:22:59 equil has left
12:23:23 equil has left
12:23:26 equil has left
12:23:40 ThibG has joined
12:26:14 ThibG has joined
12:29:45 j.r has joined
12:32:09 jjrh has left
12:32:16 jjrh has left
12:32:29 andy has left
12:40:43 Zash has left
12:41:34 jjrh has left
12:41:48 Dave Cridland has left
12:42:19 peter has joined
12:42:28 Dave Cridland has left
12:43:21 Str4tocaster has joined
12:43:43 peter has left
12:44:34 Nekit has left
12:44:57 Nekit has joined
12:46:12 daniel has left
12:46:31 daniel has joined
12:46:31 Str4tocaster has left
12:47:12 labdsf has left
12:47:39 labdsf has joined
12:51:35 jjrh has left
12:52:36 jjrh has left
12:53:08 Alex has joined
12:53:30 j.r has joined
12:57:23 alacer has joined
12:58:06 Nekit has left
12:59:02 alacer has left
12:59:10 alacer has joined
12:59:55 jere has joined
13:01:34 jjrh has left
13:01:40 jjrh has left
13:01:54 Nekit has joined
13:04:00 Alex has left
13:04:51 Tobias has joined
13:04:53 Tobias has joined
13:09:00 winfried has left
13:09:28 Zash has left
13:12:34 Steve Kille has joined
13:12:41 jjrh has left
13:13:48 jjrh has left
13:18:39 j.r has joined
13:18:40 Holger has left
13:18:47 j.r has joined
13:20:53 winfried has joined
13:21:18 valo has left
13:21:19 valo has joined
13:21:34 jjrh has left
13:21:48 jjrh has left
13:27:06 labdsf has left
13:27:06 Guus has joined
13:27:37 Guus has joined
13:28:23 j.r has left
13:28:31 j.r has joined
13:31:34 jjrh has left
13:31:41 j.r has left
13:31:50 j.r has joined
13:32:16 jjrh has left
13:33:08 moparisthebest has left
13:33:13 !xsf_martin has left
13:35:07 alacer has left
13:35:09 alacer has joined
13:35:40 dos there's Monal, but it still feels somewhat beta, especially regarding MUCs
13:36:52 Ge0rG And it's absent from the EU.
13:36:52 dos I've tried it when looking for a client for gf, but eventually opted to fixing movim's electron client, it really felt like the best xmpp chat option on macOS :P
13:37:43 dos I'm in Poland and I downloaded it from the app store... month ago?
13:37:53 dos but it might be absent on iOS
13:38:17 Zash GDPR FUD ey?
13:40:28 dos well, yeah, when I read the blog post on Monal site I facepalmed pretty hard xd
13:41:05 ThibG has joined
13:41:15 peter has joined
13:41:26 dos it would be way more understandable for Movim to have such concerns, but Monal?
13:41:48 jjrh has left
13:42:54 dos I mean... unless there's something in Monal we don't know about ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
13:43:07 alacer has left
13:43:22 edhelas Maybe for Movim as well ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
13:48:10 peter has left
13:48:39 dos has left
13:49:33 moparisthebest Speaking as a service operator who has 'banned EU residents' we don't really care if you use it, just don't want to be bothered with GDPR crap
13:50:10 Link Mauve Because it’s so hard to just not sell our data, and to allow us to retrieve or delete it.
13:50:20 dos has joined
13:50:57 moparisthebest Will I can lie to your face and swear I've audited everything and I'm compliant
13:51:04 moparisthebest Or just not bother
13:51:17 moparisthebest I'm probably compliant, just don't care
13:51:34 jjrh has left
13:51:47 jjrh has left
13:52:37 j.r has left
13:52:43 j.r has joined
13:54:45 j.r has left
13:55:02 j.r has joined
13:55:43 j.r has joined
13:55:51 j.r has joined
13:57:22 j.r has left
13:57:28 j.r has joined
13:58:18 Andrew Nenakhov has left
13:58:35 ThibG has joined
14:00:00 ThibG has joined
14:00:58 j.r has left
14:01:03 j.r has joined
14:01:53 jjrh has left
14:06:06 labdsf has joined
14:06:30 Maranda Too bad that GDPR protects nothing basically, and causes only annoyances to operators and ultimately users. One of those proper "EU style" things.
14:07:35 Andrew Nenakhov has left
14:07:36 Andrew Nenakhov has left
14:07:46 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:08:02 Maranda Like the latest filter shit they came out with, that's just brilliant.
14:08:22 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:08:31 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:08:34 Andrew Nenakhov has left
14:08:42 lumi has joined
14:09:14 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:11:35 jjrh has left
14:11:37 jjrh has left
14:13:12 moparisthebest yep Maranda basically that
14:13:31 moparisthebest GDPR compliance costs google and facebook nothing, they already have a million engineers, customer service, and lawyers
14:14:12 Dave Cridland has left
14:14:26 moparisthebest meanwhile now I have to know journald's default retention period, make sure it doesn't change with updates, document it somewhere public, hire an EU rep, then have a lawyer check over everything and declare if I'm GDPR compliant or not?
14:14:30 SamWhited has left
14:14:38 SamWhited has joined
14:14:54 moparisthebest or... I can just tell EU residents to buzz off and not think about it. :D
14:15:01 Maranda And they can pay the fines anyways or refuse to, and eventually just bury EU under tons of stamped paper.
14:15:45 Zash It got kinda tiresome to read that kind of thing in May.
14:18:54 jjrh has left
14:19:50 Maranda 🤣
14:25:31 Ge0rG especially as most of it is wrong.
14:26:19 Zash As I said before, > GDPR FUD ey?
14:26:21 moparisthebest Ge0rG, allow me to simplify, if not required by law, is it easier to care about it or not care about it? :)
14:26:47 Ge0rG moparisthebest: if you want to use my data, you better know where it's stored
14:26:57 jjrh has left
14:27:42 moparisthebest Ge0rG, so you know the retention period of every log on every server, and go line by line over all code changes every update to make sure it doesn't change?
14:27:53 moparisthebest cause, that sounds like a lot of work compared to 'not caring'
14:28:55 Yagiza has left
14:29:06 dos GDPR doesn't care about your "every log"
14:30:09 Ge0rG moparisthebest: in the strictest sense I've seen so far, you need to ensure that if you roll back a backup, all accounts deleted since that backup will be deleted after the rollback
14:31:13 jjrh has left
14:32:52 moparisthebest and that means what for IRC
14:33:57 moparisthebest also, by definition, if my server explodes and I have to restore from backup, how would I ever know which accounts had been deleted in between date-of-last-backup and server-explosion
14:34:06 moparisthebest that's an insane requirement
14:34:38 Ge0rG moparisthebest: since when does an IRC server store *anything*?
14:34:45 moparisthebest services and logs
14:35:57 Ge0rG moparisthebest: I'm not sure if you are attempting to be ignorant or arrogant here. I'm sure you haven't missed first my and then the XSF announcement of an XMPP server data privacy template. You could have just copied the relevant section about logging from there.
14:36:00 lumi has joined
14:36:16 moparisthebest seriously though, with any type of service, if you are restoring from backup you presumably don't have any data from before that backup right?
14:36:22 moparisthebest such as, what accounts were deleted
14:38:39 Ge0rG Sorry, I have some real work to be done. If you need further assistance, I can ask my emplyer for a consulting offer :P
14:39:09 moparisthebest thanks for confirming what I said about google/facebook being able to afford GDPR compliance and normal people not being able to
14:40:11 SamWhited As far as I can tell the GDPR is mostly perfectly reasonable requirements, unlike most of the tech laws that come out of europe. If you can't afford compliance, you're probably either misunderstanding and aren't covered by it or shouldn't be operating a service that stores other peoples private data.
14:40:13 Ge0rG moparisthebest: the good thing is that normal people will not be held to the same standards as Google.
14:40:43 moparisthebest good thing is people outside the insanity that is EU won't be held to those insane standards at all
14:40:59 Zash Yeah the requirements and therefore costs seemed to scale with size well enough
14:41:41 SamWhited What's insane about requiring that you disclose who you're sharing user data with and making it easy for them to ask you to purge it? That seems perfectly reasonable.
14:41:43 Ge0rG moparisthebest: oh, right. It's much better to live in a country where your ISP is free to datamine you, sell your location data to the highest bidder, to slow down your video streaming and to inject ads into your traffic.
14:43:24 moparisthebest all networks are to be treated as an attacker, that's what encryption/authentication is for
14:43:51 moparisthebest not 'please don't look at my data sir'
14:44:20 SamWhited So encrypt your data? The law heavily encourages that because you're more responsible for losing your users data
14:44:34 Ge0rG moparisthebest: oh, great. Now tell me about that magic protocol that will protect my traffic from all analysis, even from traffic pattern recognition
14:45:07 Ge0rG and don't say "use VPN" because the VPN provider is obviously subject to the same (lack of) laws
14:45:15 moparisthebest are ISPs doing that now, I thought only govts that aren't affected by these laws did that anyhow
14:45:30 moparisthebest doesn't seem like there would be a lot of money in it
14:45:48 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:45:49 Ge0rG moparisthebest: https://eu.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2017/04/04/isps-can-now-collect-and-sell-your-data-what-know-internet-privacy/100015356/
14:45:59 SamWhited None of this has anything to do with the law other than that it encourages is by making you more responsible though. I'm not even sure what the encryption thing was about, are you suggesting the law should have been *more* specific and required it?
14:46:11 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:46:53 Ge0rG SamWhited: I think moparisthebest was speaking of encryption as a means for users to protect themselves from data collection
14:47:12 SamWhited Ge0rG: which is fine, I just don't see what that has to do with this argument unless it's just a strawman
14:47:15 moparisthebest SamWhited, I'm suggesting laws are useless with regard to internet privacy, and that encryption is the only option
14:47:38 SamWhited If nothing else tons of companies have now put "Delete account" buttons on their product, which sounds great. That's not useless.
14:47:48 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:47:51 SamWhited They also are making lists of all the people that they're selling or otherwise sharing my data with, which has been very nice.
14:48:15 Andrew Nenakhov has left
14:48:20 Link Mauve moparisthebest, now please tell me how to encrypt my Facebook friends in a way to prevent Facebook from knowing them.
14:48:23 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
14:48:24 SamWhited So it doens't appear that laws related to the internet are useless, quite the contrary, it's been fantastic.
14:48:33 Link Mauve And from selling this graph to some other companies.
14:48:38 Andrew Nenakhov has left
14:48:42 Ge0rG SamWhited: nice but illegal. Almost none of the big data-selling news outlets actually honor the opt-in requirement
14:48:58 Ge0rG SamWhited: and most just say "if you don't want our tracking, delete your cookies"
14:49:01 SamWhited Ge0rG: so your argument is that some people won't follow laws, so we shouldn't have any?
14:49:24 Ge0rG SamWhited: not at all. As a user, I love the GDPR
14:49:28 Link Mauve Ge0rG, now let’s wait until enough of their users sue them.
14:49:41 Link Mauve Now that the EU introduced class actions too.
14:49:54 Zash What if we have both laws and tech to back them up?
14:49:57 moparisthebest Link Mauve, easy, if you don't give them the data, they don't have it
14:50:25 Ge0rG moparisthebest: you can't not give your data to a web site you are visiting
14:50:55 SamWhited Anyways, I'm a big fan. It gets me frustrated when people dismiss it as another link tax sort of law that doesn't make sense, having implemented it at two companies where it *definitely* made the users data safer
14:51:03 Link Mauve moparisthebest, I can also throw away my computer and start growing potatoes, but that’s not something most people will want to do.
14:51:45 Link Mauve Also, I am able to understand the implications of giving my data to Facebook, while most people aren’t.
14:52:42 SamWhited Yah, if you have superpowers and can convince everyone to get off facebook, great, do that. In the mean time, since they're already on it, we need some sort of law that requires that Facebook plays nicely when they leave and cleans up their data.
14:54:38 Ge0rG except that facebook isn't following the law, so we'll see some major fines in the next five to twenty years.
14:54:45 moparisthebest so what's your opinion of latest EU laws? the actual link tax, and forced filtering of all uploaded content?
14:54:57 moparisthebest are those good like GDPR too or is that over the line?
14:55:16 moparisthebest I haven't seen the prosody or ejabberd modules to scan all stanzas for copyright violations that will be required either so
14:55:19 Ge0rG moparisthebest: those are utter junk, pushed forward by big media lobbying
14:55:21 SamWhited Those don't make any sense and are garbage because they're pretty much impossible to follow. The GDPR just lists basic data protections you should have been doing anyways
14:56:07 SamWhited But I also haven't helped implement those anywhere, so I don't really know who has to follow them or what the specific details are.
14:57:14 Dave Cridland has left
14:57:31 moparisthebest I agree the general basis of the GDPR is good general data practice to follow, I think it's both unenforceable in general and onerous to small operators though, and shouldn't really be a law, meh
14:58:17 SamWhited God I wish we had something similar here; I'm sure it's not perfect, but I'm pretty okay with it being onerous if those small operators weren't bothering to protect my data before
14:58:57 Ge0rG moparisthebest: it wouldn't have become a law if everybody was respecting users' privacy from day 1
14:59:02 SamWhited As for unenforceable, I have no idea. We'll see if fines start rolling out or not I guess. But even if it's unenforceable, it's made two companies I've worked for improve their practices, so it seems to be doing good either way.
14:59:28 Ge0rG and I'm sure it will be enforced.
14:59:51 Ge0rG It just takes time. Significant time. Have a look at the timeframe of the Google Android antitrust case.
15:00:26 SamWhited yah, I don't see why it wouldn't be, it seems straight forward enough… we may not have similar laws in the U.S., but people complain to the FCC about Google and then Google gets fined all the time. This seems to be the same just with more teeth.
15:00:40 Holger has left
15:00:58 j.r has joined
15:01:03 SamWhited (or whomever, Google's just a good stand in for "large company doing things they probably shouldn't be")
15:01:33 Ge0rG Heh
15:01:54 lskdjf has left
15:01:57 lskdjf has joined
15:02:24 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:02:24 j.r has left
15:02:25 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:02:31 j.r has joined
15:02:34 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:02:57 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:03:05 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:04:32 j.r has left
15:04:39 j.r has joined
15:06:31 Maranda has joined
15:07:04 karp has left
15:15:14 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:15:24 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:15:55 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:20:49 edhelas ok let's move the discussion there Link Mauve
15:20:51 edhelas regarding https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/muc-avatars.html
15:21:06 edhelas what is the current supports of the code 104 in XMPP clients ?
15:21:14 peter has joined
15:26:24 Yagiza has left
15:26:35 Nekit has left
15:33:10 waqas has joined
15:33:19 lorddavidiii has left
15:34:15 lorddavidiii has joined
15:36:51 Yagiza has left
15:38:51 ThibG has joined
15:38:57 ThibG has joined
15:40:31 Zash has left
15:41:40 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:41:48 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:42:13 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:42:20 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:43:53 lovetox has joined
15:44:02 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:44:11 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:46:56 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:46:57 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:47:07 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
15:48:20 Andrew Nenakhov has left
15:52:54 alacer has joined
15:53:10 Yagiza has left
15:56:38 j.r has left
15:56:59 j.r has joined
15:58:17 ta has joined
15:59:29 edhelas I'm currently having some though on that XEP and I'd like to propose some changes to generalize it
15:59:53 ThibG has joined
16:00:11 edhelas the core idea of this XEP is to expose the vcard hash in the bare MUC JID disco#info and notify it using a message 104
16:00:42 edhelas I'd like to propose to do that for also disco#info of Pubsub nodes and all JIDs (including users ones)
16:01:15 edhelas the notification will then be done using a message for MUC, presence or message for users and pubsub message for Pubsub nodes
16:01:27 edhelas then we basically cover all the cases using the same core mechanism
16:02:22 alacer has left
16:03:57 SamWhited has left
16:11:16 tux has left
16:12:03 Kev has joined
16:12:08 Kev has left
16:20:55 Andrew Nenakhov has left
16:21:42 l has joined
16:21:47 l has joined
16:23:53 marc has joined
16:28:45 ta has joined
16:36:57 SamWhited has left
16:37:33 jjrh has left
16:37:34 jjrh has left
16:37:40 ta has left
16:40:07 valo has left
16:40:12 valo has joined
16:43:33 labdsf has left
16:43:35 labdsf has joined
16:43:49 labdsf has left
16:43:51 labdsf has joined
16:49:11 SamWhited has left
16:50:31 Maranda has left
16:51:10 Maranda has joined
16:52:07 jonas’ has left
16:52:59 jonas’ has left
16:54:03 SamWhited has left
16:56:18 jonas’ has left
16:56:30 jonas’ has joined
16:57:58 jonas’ has left
16:58:03 jonas’ has joined
16:58:06 Ge0rG has joined
17:02:11 ta has joined
17:07:12 lskdjf has left
17:07:16 lskdjf has joined
17:07:20 jjrh has left
17:19:55 jjrh has left
17:23:56 marc has left
17:25:42 alacer has joined
17:29:03 Dave Cridland has left
17:29:47 Dave Cridland has left
17:30:42 marc has joined
17:32:08 Maranda SamWhited, if eventually you wanna have some fun ™️ https://conference.gajim.org:5281/pastebin/cd179f64-2dff-4968-9b36-c45b874b48fa
17:32:11 Maranda :D
17:32:17 dwd has joined
17:33:31 SamWhited My SCRAM implementation can take any generic hash algorithm, so they're already implemented. On the other hand, those aren't actually defined anywhere and haven't been vetted, so probably not a good idea to use them :)
17:34:32 dwd has left
17:35:05 jonas’ which are not?
17:35:40 SamWhited Anything other than SHA1 and SHA256, to my knowledge
17:36:20 jonas’ right
17:36:39 jonas’ although, I think SCRAM doesn’t care *too* much about the hash, as long as the hash is reversible; i.e. it should be as safe as any as long as the hash used is safe
17:36:46 jonas’ (that’s a property of PBKDF2 even)
17:36:57 Dave Cridland has left
17:37:28 SamWhited Yah, it should be safe, but probably best not to use random hash algorithms that aren't defined anywhere for no reason; SHA-1 and SHA-256 are both fine.
17:37:39 dwd has joined
17:37:39 dwd has left
17:37:43 jonas’ hmmm
17:37:45 SamWhited Kafka supports SCRAM-SHA-512 for some reason, so I guess you could use it with that
17:37:45 Dave Cridland has left
17:38:21 dwd has joined
17:38:31 Yagiza has left
17:38:37 jonas’ Maranda, if you just want to poke at your implementation, aioxmpp should support all of those (if your build of python has them).
17:38:51 jonas’ you’d have to play some tricks to force it to use a specific one of them though)
17:38:54 j.r has joined
17:38:55 SamWhited ugg, does aiosasl support all these too? That makes me sad
17:39:14 Maranda 👍
17:39:32 jonas’ SamWhited, I don’t see a convincing argument for *not* allowing other variants of the SHA-2 family if one variant of the SHA-2 family is specified
17:39:42 SamWhited Where security is concerned, just randomly changing things because it has a bigger number or whatever probably isn't a good idea. I can't imagine how this would go wrong, but for compatibility if nothing else it makes me sad that people are implementing them and other people consuming the library who don't know any better will think it's osmething to use
17:40:00 dwd has left
17:40:28 SamWhited I don't see a convincing argument to implement them, and as far as I'm concerned the burden of proof should be on that side of things whenver auth is concerned.
17:40:34 jonas’ to be honest, I somewhat assumed that they were specified due to the wildcard in the IANA registry
17:40:34 j.r has joined
17:41:03 SamWhited Oh, interesting; I could be wrong. I didn't see an RFC though, does the IANA registry link to a document?
17:41:15 jonas’ yes, to the one for SCRAM-SHA-256
17:41:17 jonas’ https://www.iana.org/assignments/sasl-mechanisms/sasl-mechanisms.xhtml
17:41:25 jonas’ I guess technically this is just a reservation of the SCRAM- prefix
17:41:58 SamWhited Oh, yah, that's just a reservation for the entire familyl
17:42:05 jonas’ Note to future SCRAM-mechanism designers: each new SASL SCRAM mechanism MUST be explicitly registered with IANA within the SASL SCRAM Family Mechanisms registry.
17:42:08 jonas’ yeah
17:42:10 jonas’ that’s pretty explicit
17:42:18 jonas’ also a very convincing argument to remove support
17:46:51 jonas’ SamWhited, there you go https://github.com/horazont/aiosasl/issues/6
17:47:38 jonas’ the "minimum iteration count" parameter of the registry is interesting, too
17:49:17 Yagiza has left
17:49:24 SamWhited ♡ thanks; between security concerns and standardization concerns this makes me very happy.
17:51:29 Dave Cridland has left
17:51:37 Yagiza has left
17:52:11 dwd has joined
17:54:01 Maranda hm, interesting, well the implementation in Metronome is SHA digesting algorithm agnostic as well so it doesn't matter.
17:55:25 SamWhited It matters in the sense that this is auth which is extremely important and security sensitive. In crypto, tiny insubstantial changes can often have a big impact that we don't forsee; it's not exactly intuitive. I doubt this is a problem, but it doesn't help to add more algorithms for no reason and it *possibly* hurts. Might as well just leave it to the experts and not make up your own crypto.
17:55:31 SamWhited has huge pet peeve about this sort of thing
17:56:28 jonas’ me too, normally, but I hadn’t seen this as "making up new crypto" to be honest
17:56:56 SamWhited Well, "changing existing crypto", then. I agree, I can't imagine this possibly causes any problems, but it's also not necessary so why take the risk?
17:57:13 jonas’ yeah
17:57:26 Maranda SamWhited, I didn't mean that way :P
17:57:37 SamWhited Heh, cool; sorry I'm being grumpy about it.
17:57:44 jonas’ ’tis fine
17:58:08 SamWhited This is just the kind of thing where I expect the longer hash will cause some buffer operation to behave slightly differently on some architecture and then suddenly you have a side channel, or something.
17:58:28 Maranda ~~I didn't know they weren't defined either, blame google for returning result on SCRAM-SHA-384 and SCRAM-SHA-512~~ ✎
17:58:31 SamWhited (well, I don't "expect" it, but I could see it happening)
17:58:40 Maranda I didn't know they weren't defined either, blame google for returning results on SCRAM-SHA-384 and SCRAM-SHA-512 ✏
17:58:58 jonas’ that doesn’t make sense to me, actually
17:59:03 jonas’ that would be a fundamental problem of pbkdf2 then
17:59:09 jonas’ which I think we would know about
17:59:27 jonas’ (we = the cryptography community, thus warning louder against it and deprecating pbkdf2 for that reason)
17:59:45 SamWhited I was just making up a random example, I agree it's not likely
17:59:50 jonas’ sure
17:59:59 Guus has left
18:00:06 Guus has joined
18:00:22 Yagiza has left
18:05:41 MattJ has left
18:08:57 Guus has left
18:13:47 Guus has joined
18:14:17 Yagiza has left
18:18:38 ThibG has left
18:18:40 ThibG has joined
18:19:52 dwd has left
18:22:00 dwd has left
18:22:53 Yagiza has left
18:23:27 Dave Cridland has left
18:23:29 dwd has left
18:24:09 dwd has joined
18:24:56 Maranda has joined
18:25:18 dwd has left
18:34:44 l has joined
18:35:48 lskdjf has joined
18:36:11 !xsf_martin has joined
18:37:31 j.r has left
18:37:49 j.r has joined
18:38:41 ThibG has left
18:38:42 ThibG has joined
18:40:55 marc has left
18:42:09 Yagiza has left
18:44:21 mimi89999 has joined
18:45:33 Yagiza has left
18:45:55 404.city has left
18:46:26 UsL has joined
18:55:28 dwd has joined
19:07:09 dwd has left
19:08:57 Guus has left
19:09:07 Guus has joined
19:13:02 labdsf has left
19:13:04 labdsf has joined
19:18:51 SamWhited has left
19:34:16 marc has left
19:34:32 Dave Cridland has left
19:34:33 dwd has left
19:35:13 Dave Cridland has left
19:35:17 dwd has left
19:40:00 dwd has left
19:41:51 lskdjf has joined
19:44:18 Neustradamus has left
19:45:16 Neustradamus has joined
19:46:28 dwd has left
19:47:32 alacer has left
19:50:15 Dave Cridland has left
19:51:09 dwd has left
19:54:23 Yagiza has left
19:54:46 dwd has joined
19:56:41 thorsten has joined
19:57:50 thorsten has left
19:58:38 thorsten has joined
19:59:22 Guus has left
20:02:37 Guus has joined
20:03:32 lnj has left
20:04:30 Yagiza has left
20:05:01 Dave Cridland has left
20:05:43 Dave Cridland has left
20:05:46 dwd has left
20:06:16 tux has left
20:06:54 dwd has left
20:16:00 dwd has left
20:21:06 ta has left
20:22:35 j.r has left
20:22:49 lnj has left
20:22:50 j.r has joined
20:25:14 dwd has joined
20:28:00 dwd has left
20:35:25 Dave Cridland has left
20:35:39 Dave Cridland has left
20:36:07 dwd has joined
20:36:07 dwd has left
20:36:07 Dave Cridland has left
20:36:08 dwd has joined
20:40:00 dwd has left
20:42:29 Seve/SouL has left
20:45:32 daniel has left
20:46:00 dwd has left
20:49:37 dwd has left
20:57:20 lskdjf has left
20:57:36 dwd has joined
20:57:44 vanitasvitae has left
20:58:16 dwd has left
20:58:32 goffi has left
21:01:53 ThibG has left
21:01:55 ThibG has joined
21:02:32 !xsf_martin has left
21:04:11 Andrew Nenakhov has left
21:04:16 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
21:05:49 Andrew Nenakhov has left
21:05:50 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
21:07:14 lovetox has left
21:07:52 ThibG has left
21:07:53 ThibG has joined
21:07:54 lovetox has joined
21:09:32 j.r has joined
21:09:41 daniel has left
21:09:43 daniel has joined
21:09:50 lovetox has left
21:10:01 SamWhited has left
21:10:06 lovetox has joined
21:13:20 j.r has joined
21:15:33 Tobias has left
21:15:34 Tobias has joined
21:19:21 lskdjf has joined
21:20:28 moparisthebest has joined
21:22:20 Dave Cridland has left
21:25:18 js has joined
21:25:38 j.r has joined
21:25:46 Dave Cridland has left
21:28:20 j.r has joined
21:28:25 lorddavidiii has left
21:28:47 dwd has joined
21:30:50 Dave Cridland has left
21:31:35 dwd has left
21:32:41 Andrew Nenakhov has left
21:32:45 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
21:33:13 Andrew Nenakhov has left
21:33:13 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
21:33:14 Andrew Nenakhov has left
21:34:25 Dave Cridland has left
21:36:52 marc has left
21:37:41 dwd has joined
21:39:35 Dave Cridland has left
21:40:00 dwd has left
21:40:43 j.r has joined
21:43:32 j.r has joined
21:46:00 dwd has left
21:47:39 Dave Cridland has left
21:50:35 Dave Cridland has left
21:50:58 dwd has left
21:51:39 dwd has joined
21:52:21 dwd has left
21:52:28 thorsten has joined
21:52:42 Dave Cridland has left
21:53:57 Dave Cridland has left
21:56:30 Dave Cridland has left
22:00:03 Dave Cridland has left
22:00:28 Dave Cridland has left
22:01:48 lovetox has left
22:05:31 Dave Cridland has left
22:06:46 Dave Cridland has left
22:07:22 Dave Cridland has left
22:07:51 Dave Cridland has left
22:08:13 thorsten has joined
22:08:53 Dave Cridland has left
22:09:58 Dave Cridland has left
22:12:16 j.r has joined
22:12:51 Dave Cridland has left
22:13:19 j.r has joined
22:18:45 jjrh has left
22:18:49 dwd has joined
22:19:00 dwd has left
22:22:25 404.city has joined
22:23:43 Dave Cridland has left
22:24:32 jjrh has left
22:24:38 404.city has left
22:25:55 Dave Cridland has left
22:28:10 Dave Cridland has left
22:28:19 j.r has joined
22:28:48 j.r has left
22:28:53 j.r has joined
22:30:35 Dave Cridland has left
22:33:16 Dave Cridland has left
22:33:43 Dave Cridland has left
22:34:19 Dave Cridland has left
22:35:13 jjrh has left
22:43:20 j.r has joined
22:46:10 dwd has joined
22:46:42 MattJ has joined
22:46:48 jjrh has left
22:49:00 dwd has left
22:49:22 vanitasvitae has left
22:50:53 efrit has joined
22:52:29 vanitasvitae has joined
22:53:25 vanitasvitae has left
22:53:53 Maranda has left
22:54:19 Maranda has left
22:54:42 Maranda has left
22:56:30 vanitasvitae has joined
22:56:36 js has left
22:57:14 jjrh has left
22:58:35 Dave Cridland has left
22:59:33 valo has joined
23:00:09 Dave Cridland has left
23:00:38 Dave Cridland has left
23:03:46 thorsten has left
23:03:51 thorsten has joined
23:04:01 Dave Cridland has left
23:07:02 dwd has joined
23:08:05 Dave Cridland has left
23:08:41 dwd has left
23:20:16 jjrh has left
23:22:40 jjrh has left
23:23:44 Dave Cridland has left
23:23:54 Dave Cridland has left
23:24:26 dwd has joined
23:24:26 dwd has left
23:24:26 dwd has joined
23:28:18 SamWhited has left
23:30:24 UsL has left
23:30:26 UsL has joined
23:32:11 jjrh has left
23:33:05 Dave Cridland has left
23:34:00 dwd has left
23:39:36 dwd has joined
23:40:01 dwd has left
23:40:49 efrit has left
23:41:34 jjrh has left
23:44:18 peter has left
23:51:33 jjrh has left
23:53:09 jjrh has left
23:55:38 peter has joined
23:55:39 Maranda has left
23:56:39 peter has left