XSF Discussion - 2018-12-10

Ugh https://www.irc.com/

Maybe someone should tell them about XMPP

Seems like a fine initiative.

is there a way to link to w3c specs from xeps the same way we link to rfcs?

i added a small section on CORS Headers to the http upload xep. any opinions before i submit this as a PR? https://gultsch.de/files/xep-0363.html#impl

> Since there is no reason for a client to wait between requesting the slot and starting the upload, relatively low timeout values of around 60s are RECOMMENDED. Was that in the XEP before already? 60s is a bit short in some mobile situations.

yes

what would a reasonable timeout it. when i'm editing anyway i can edit that as well

maybe 300s? which is a usual sm timeout

daniel: that's safe, yeah

Also your slot response might get caught in a SM session, so using 5m makes sense

yes

daniel "The make HTTP Upload work.."

i guess this should read "To make.."

lovetox, thanks

and one point too much at the end of section 7

daniel, LGTM

Steve Kille, I saw the mails on standards@; I’ll work on the PRs wednesday night or tomorrow night (CET), so that’ll work

in general, for this type of remarks, it’s safer to use the github interface, because I’ll read that before merging anyways.

cc @ daniel ^

(since those were editorial discussions anyways)

I'll try to add some comments tomorrow

ralphm, non-editorial things to the mailing list please

Yes

jonas: thanks. I'll let you know when I'm done, and then Ralph and Daniel can give me more things to do

Steve Kille, acknowledged. leaving a comment for myself so that I don’t merge it accidentally

nice, no discovery on private storage

lovetox, yupp

which also doesn’t matter much, you figure it out on write

then its too late

i want to show the user that he can bookmark a room, and disable the button if the server has no support

i guess i leave that available all the time, and just go with the assumption every server has either pubusb or privatestorage

Private storage is older than disco. Maybe some servers do advertise the namespaced, but it's not defined.

-d

Except it being listed here: https://xmpp.org/registrar/disco-features.html

I think prosody announces it

jonas’: just put the PR up for review by yourself

oh nice

thanks

jonas': Then you can't merge it.