XSF Discussion - 2019-03-03

00:09:37 jmpman has joined
00:16:04 rtq3 has left
00:16:27 rtq3 has joined
00:35:58 wurstsalat has left
00:48:43 valo has joined
00:52:03 UsL has left
00:52:03 UsL has joined
01:03:34 Kev has joined
01:12:08 j.r has left
01:22:53 arc has left
01:22:53 arc has joined
01:23:37 efrit has joined
01:32:07 lskdjf has left
01:37:48 larma has left
01:46:38 arc has left
01:46:48 arc has joined
02:13:19 debacle has left
02:16:42 ThibG has left
02:22:19 alacer has joined
02:26:12 alacer has left
02:34:38 lskdjf has joined
02:42:41 efrit has left
02:51:32 alacer has joined
02:52:32 alacer has left
02:58:04 lskdjf has left
02:58:05 lskdjf has joined
02:59:12 lskdjf has left
02:59:13 lskdjf has joined
02:59:34 lskdjf has left
02:59:35 lskdjf has joined
03:04:14 lnj has left
03:08:28 Half-ShotX has left
03:22:01 alacer has joined
03:42:33 lskdjf has left
03:51:25 kokonoe has left
03:55:27 kokonoe has joined
04:02:06 jmpman has left
04:34:30 jmpman has joined
04:52:17 wurstsalat has joined
04:57:23 alacer has left
04:59:43 alacer has joined
05:04:49 arc has left
05:04:50 arc has joined
05:09:34 kokonoe has left
05:10:31 kokonoe has joined
05:20:58 arc has left
05:21:04 arc has joined
05:29:28 alacer has left
05:32:13 wurstsalat has left
05:55:30 404.city has joined
06:01:03 Neustradamus has left
06:01:19 Neustradamus has joined
06:07:36 novnov has joined
06:19:29 Yagiza has joined
06:20:37 larma has joined
06:38:24 Neustradamus has left
06:39:46 Neustradamus has joined
06:45:24 derdaniel has joined
06:48:16 derdaniel has left
06:48:18 derdaniel has joined
06:50:06 derdaniel has left
06:50:08 derdaniel has joined
06:50:47 Neustradamus has left
06:51:28 Neustradamus has joined
06:55:00 derdaniel has left
06:55:01 derdaniel has joined
06:58:28 jmpman has left
06:59:00 derdaniel has left
06:59:02 derdaniel has joined
07:04:25 ThibG has joined
07:05:53 derdaniel has left
07:05:55 derdaniel has joined
07:11:05 goffi has joined
07:26:00 Nekit has joined
07:26:43 oli has joined
07:35:24 404.city has left
07:36:10 Maranda has left
07:36:11 Maranda has joined
07:36:48 Neustradamus has left
07:37:06 Neustradamus has joined
07:37:20 alacer has joined
07:38:34 jmpman has joined
07:38:41 Neustradamus has left
07:40:20 Neustradamus has joined
07:43:58 404.city has joined
07:44:34 404.city has left
07:58:08 Neustradamus has left
07:58:20 Neustradamus has joined
08:07:00 efrit has joined
08:11:05 !xsf_Martin has joined
08:17:17 404.city has joined
08:20:51 arc has left
08:20:51 arc has joined
08:28:11 lovetox has joined
08:30:58 lskdjf has joined
08:33:28 novnov has left
08:34:07 novnov has joined
08:43:41 arc has left
08:43:42 arc has joined
08:44:12 oli has left
08:46:37 novnov has left
08:47:11 novnov has joined
08:48:24 novnov has left
08:51:23 novnov has joined
08:57:33 blabla has left
08:57:33 frainz has left
08:57:40 lovetox has left
09:00:13 kokonoe has left
09:00:38 kokonoe has joined
09:06:52 jonas’ I also wanna make a high-level-ish language on top of sed to re-implement the echo bot in that
09:07:06 jonas’ and then maybe a libc implementation with a shim wrapper around sed to invoke syscalls
09:11:53 alacer has left
09:12:59 vaulor has left
09:13:00 vaulor has joined
09:16:55 ThibG has left
09:17:01 ThibG has joined
09:22:06 debacle has joined
09:25:26 bowlofeggs has left
09:26:39 wurstsalat has joined
09:44:49 Andrew Nenakhov has left
09:44:56 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
09:47:36 blabla has joined
09:50:38 alacer has joined
09:52:33 oli has joined
09:52:39 frainz has joined
09:56:25 igoose has left
09:56:28 igoose has joined
09:57:17 Wiktor has left
09:57:20 Wiktor has joined
09:57:45 ta Whatever floats your boat.
10:09:26 novnov has left
10:09:41 alacer has left
10:15:06 Nekit has left
10:30:50 alexis has joined
10:34:39 j.r has joined
10:39:00 !xsf_Martin has left
10:42:38 wurstsalat has left
10:42:43 wurstsalat has joined
10:47:44 j.r has left
10:57:30 kokonoe has left
11:02:34 kokonoe has joined
11:03:04 efrit has left
11:03:18 contrapunctus has left
11:03:21 contrapunctus has joined
11:10:20 Half-ShotX has joined
11:10:33 Half-ShotX has left
11:10:33 Half-ShotX has joined
11:11:09 Half-ShotX has left
11:11:10 Half-ShotX has joined
11:12:20 waqas has left
11:12:32 waqas has joined
11:12:33 waqas has left
11:13:44 wurstsalat has left
11:19:30 j.r has joined
11:21:11 Half-ShotX has left
11:21:11 Half-ShotX has joined
11:24:13 lnj has joined
11:29:51 oli has left
11:31:17 Half-ShotX has left
11:31:18 Half-ShotX has joined
11:31:24 Half-ShotX has left
11:31:25 Half-ShotX has joined
11:37:48 jmpman has left
11:42:11 Half-ShotX has left
11:42:11 Half-ShotX has joined
11:44:40 karoshi has joined
11:52:37 Half-ShotX has left
11:52:38 Half-ShotX has joined
11:53:50 jmpman has joined
11:55:48 j.r has left
12:01:45 Half-ShotX has left
12:02:47 j.r has joined
12:07:14 lskdjf has left
12:07:15 lskdjf has joined
12:25:25 mimi89999 has left
12:27:44 rtq3 has left
12:28:10 rtq3 has joined
12:31:29 Andrew Nenakhov has left
12:32:48 oli has joined
12:36:24 mimi89999 has joined
12:55:26 alacer has joined
13:02:28 Tobias has left
13:03:03 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
13:06:11 Andrew Nenakhov has left
13:11:06 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
13:12:50 Half-ShotX has joined
13:13:52 Andrew Nenakhov has left
13:14:57 Half-ShotX has left
13:14:58 Half-ShotX has joined
13:15:08 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
13:15:18 Andrew Nenakhov has left
13:15:18 Andrew Nenakhov has joined
13:15:20 Andrew Nenakhov has left
13:16:29 alacer has left
13:16:39 ThibG has left
13:16:46 ThibG has joined
13:18:46 Half-ShotX has left
13:22:14 alacer has joined
13:26:42 lumi has joined
13:30:20 igoose has left
13:30:35 krauq has left
13:32:17 ThibG has left
13:32:25 ThibG has joined
13:32:29 krauq has joined
13:32:37 igoose has joined
13:32:56 kokonoe has left
13:35:16 kokonoe has joined
13:37:15 Neustradamus has left
13:37:22 Neustradamus has joined
13:39:14 Neustradamus has left
13:39:23 Neustradamus has joined
13:39:28 valo has left
13:40:56 Half-ShotX has joined
13:40:57 Half-ShotX has left
13:42:51 ThibG has left
13:42:52 Neustradamus has left
13:42:56 ThibG has joined
13:43:03 Neustradamus has joined
13:43:04 debacle has left
13:46:02 melvo has joined
13:49:36 j.r has left
13:49:38 j.r has joined
13:57:48 alacer has left
13:58:35 Nekit has joined
14:04:24 Half-ShotX has joined
14:09:09 Half-ShotX has left
14:14:32 Half-ShotX has joined
14:17:46 Half-ShotX has left
14:20:28 Tobias has joined
14:23:54 valo has joined
14:24:50 Half-ShotX has joined
14:30:48 Half-ShotX has left
14:31:18 ThibG has left
14:31:23 ThibG has joined
14:32:53 melvo has left
14:34:47 Half-ShotX has joined
14:38:53 404.city has left
14:42:17 Neustradamus has left
14:44:59 Half-ShotX has left
14:45:01 Half-ShotX has joined
14:45:26 404.city has joined
14:45:35 Half-ShotX has left
14:46:03 Neustradamus has joined
14:54:08 dele has joined
14:59:32 Maranda has left
14:59:34 Maranda has joined
15:07:25 valo has left
15:09:39 valo has joined
15:10:37 karoshi has left
15:10:44 karoshi has joined
15:13:17 rtq3 has left
15:15:47 rtq3 has joined
15:23:16 bowlofeggs has joined
15:24:30 yvo has joined
15:38:59 waqas has joined
15:40:22 waqas has left
15:51:37 efrit has joined
15:53:27 waqas has joined
15:54:49 j.r has left
15:55:16 j.r has joined
15:58:10 Nekit has left
15:58:11 Nekit has joined
15:59:20 kokonoe has left
15:59:34 mimi89999 has left
16:00:48 efrit has left
16:01:40 kokonoe has joined
16:03:19 moparisthebest has left
16:07:08 valo has left
16:07:13 yvo has left
16:12:21 valo has joined
16:16:17 lumi has left
16:18:45 Neustradamus has left
16:18:46 !xsf_Martin has joined
16:18:49 !xsf_Martin has left
16:18:52 Neustradamus has joined
16:19:01 !xsf_Martin has joined
16:19:04 !xsf_Martin has left
16:19:10 !xsf_Martin has joined
16:19:13 !xsf_Martin has left
16:19:16 !xsf_Martin has joined
16:27:55 moparisthebest has joined
16:32:37 jmpman has left
16:33:48 !xsf_Martin has left
16:34:24 Alex has left
16:37:55 vaulor has left
16:37:56 vaulor has joined
16:39:36 Alex has joined
16:45:53 404.city has left
16:46:54 404.city has joined
16:47:40 404.city has left
16:54:25 Nekit has left
16:56:19 Nekit has joined
16:56:27 oli has left
16:57:15 Neustradamus has left
16:57:30 Neustradamus has joined
16:58:34 Nekit has left
17:00:39 mimi89999 has joined
17:04:12 rtq3 has left
17:04:37 rtq3 has joined
17:07:20 j.r has left
17:07:50 j.r has joined
17:08:32 Half-ShotX has joined
17:18:18 lorddavidiii has joined
17:18:46 debacle has joined
17:25:20 debacle has left
17:26:28 lovetox has joined
17:44:55 Yagiza has left
17:59:52 alexis has left
18:15:37 edhelas has left
18:19:40 j.r has left
18:19:44 j.r has joined
18:24:53 alacer has joined
18:36:02 alacer has left
18:38:41 edhelas has joined
18:43:56 dele has left
18:46:37 melvo has joined
19:01:10 oli has joined
19:07:06 j.r has left
19:07:10 j.r has joined
19:16:31 lorddavidiii has left
19:21:22 Nekit has joined
19:25:44 Half-ShotX has left
19:28:00 rtq3 has left
19:28:18 rtq3 has joined
19:28:44 alacer has joined
19:30:55 Half-ShotX has joined
19:31:29 Half-ShotX has left
19:33:46 Neustradamus has left
19:34:19 arc has left
19:34:19 arc has joined
19:34:26 Neustradamus has joined
19:37:35 alacer has left
19:50:15 oli has left
19:52:40 Neustradamus has left
19:53:24 Neustradamus has joined
20:00:54 blabla has left
20:01:03 blabla has joined
20:05:55 oli has joined
20:08:11 ThibG has left
20:08:18 ThibG has joined
20:11:33 Kev has left
20:14:59 tux has left
20:31:32 tux has joined
20:42:21 wurstsalat has joined
20:53:54 lorddavidiii has joined
21:00:19 debacle has joined
21:04:40 Kev has joined
21:06:05 Link Mauve Hi, for people who have read/written MIX, what is the story with user PEP?
21:06:08 j.r has left
21:06:11 moparisthebest has left
21:06:13 j.r has joined
21:07:49 Link Mauve If I join a MIX channel and want to obtain e.g. the User Tune of all members, will the MIX service subscribe to everything I have a +notify for, or does it rely on the participants explicitly publishing their User Tune to each MIX channel they’re in?
21:10:22 rtq3 has left
21:10:45 rtq3 has joined
21:12:08 Steve Kille My basic model is that the primary goal of MIX sharing of participant info is to share who are the participants. With JID hidden, this is typically going to be minimal information. With JIDs shared, I see that sharing further info can go directly, and should not be involving the MIX channel.
21:12:38 j.r has left
21:13:12 j.r has joined
21:13:21 Link Mauve So in my case, a participant interested in the User Tune of each other participant should subscribe manually to all of them?
21:13:39 Link Mauve Or retrieve it as the user scrolls in the list, or something like that, depending on the UI of the client.
21:17:50 Kev I've been assuming that the server can straightforwardly proxy PEP, but I might be being naive.
21:18:06 Kev Well, semi-straightforwardly.
21:19:09 Link Mauve Would PAM imply that the MIX channel is auto-subscribed to all PEP items?
21:19:15 Link Mauve Or something like that.
21:19:28 Kev That was my assumption.
21:19:37 Link Mauve Great, thanks.
21:19:50 Link Mauve PEP nodes*
21:19:54 Kev Details TBC.
21:19:58 zinid Link Mauve: are you implementing mix?
21:20:14 Link Mauve zinid, I’m actually thinking about PEP proxying for MUC.
21:20:28 zinid Link Mauve: ah
21:20:29 Link Mauve Somehow.
21:20:49 Link Mauve Details TBC too, I’m just playing with a poc.
21:21:26 zinid whatever, I decided to stop fiddling with muc in ejabberd and focus on mix
21:21:40 zinid fiddling with both is too taxing
21:21:47 Link Mauve It was prompted by https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/760 and the idea to finally deprecate 0153.
21:22:05 zinid I know the idea
21:22:08 lumi has joined
21:22:42 Link Mauve I’m trying to see if it’s viable before I push this PR to standards@.
21:23:10 zinid Link Mauve: well, the council decided to start the discussion 😁
21:23:21 zinid before voting
21:23:25 Link Mauve Yes.
21:24:09 zinid I am honestly not sure why are you worried about it so much 🤔
21:24:27 zinid I am honestly not sure why you are worried about it so much 🤔
21:25:10 bowlofeggs has left
21:25:45 zinid I really don't like the situation when we cannot decide where to move, we will end up with incompatible implementations
21:26:20 j.r has left
21:26:24 j.r has joined
21:26:30 Link Mauve Yeah, I guess I could just send my proposal instead.
21:29:01 zinid either we continue muc necromancy or focus on mix.
21:29:33 Link Mauve I’m fine with both so far.
21:29:49 Link Mauve With a slight preference towards fixing what we have.
21:30:41 Kev has left
21:31:38 arc has left
21:31:45 arc has joined
21:34:58 melvo has left
21:36:50 rtq3 has left
21:37:14 rtq3 has joined
21:40:20 zinid well, I am not 😀
21:41:08 kokonoe has left
21:41:22 Link Mauve Neither clients nor servers will be able to go MIX-only for quite a while, even if all implementations got MIX support today.
21:41:51 Link Mauve So, fixing MUC will be useful during the transition period anyway.
21:43:12 kokonoe has joined
21:46:21 zinid > Neither clients nor servers will be able to go MIX-only for quite a while, even if all implementations got MIX support today. True. My approach in ejabberd is to implement very tiny muc subset above the mix code. Like joining/leaving and message sending.
21:46:52 Link Mauve Only that? :/
21:46:56 pep. And then tell users MUC is bad because you implement only 3% ? :P
21:47:42 zinid Link Mauve: I didn't decide what exactly to implement.
21:47:50 zinid yet
21:48:40 zinid I just want to make sure the chat is usable in at least popular clients.
21:49:00 zinid configuration/moderation won't be supported for sure
21:49:47 Link Mauve zinid, is your current MUC code not reusable at all?
21:50:05 zinid Link Mauve: no, it's total garbage
21:50:05 Link Mauve zinid, sounds pretty bad. :x
21:50:42 zinid and strictly speaking it's not my code 😋
21:51:01 Link Mauve zinid, “your” as in Ejabberd’s. :p
21:51:01 zinid I only patched that trash
21:51:17 zinid Link Mauve: I mean technically I didn't write it
21:51:49 Link Mauve Prosody recently got a rewrite of its MUC code, it now is very easy to extend and could maybe become the basis of some kind of MIX.
21:52:06 Link Mauve But I have yet to read a recent version. :x
21:52:41 zinid Link Mauve: yes, but I don't want to rewrite it. this was the basic dilemma for me: either rewrite it or go mix.
21:52:57 Link Mauve Ok.
21:53:03 Link Mauve That’s sensible.
21:56:14 alexis has joined
22:11:02 j.r has left
22:11:11 j.r has joined
22:13:38 lorddavidiii has left
22:13:55 tux has left
22:25:38 Nekit has left
22:30:48 igoose has left
22:31:07 igoose has joined
22:36:04 melvo has joined
22:36:59 tux has joined
22:52:01 karoshi has left
22:53:23 moparisthebest has joined
22:54:10 rtq3 has left
22:55:07 alexis has left
22:55:25 alexis has joined
22:56:52 lovetox has left
23:00:11 lnj has left
23:00:25 bowlofeggs has joined
23:01:11 moparisthebest has left
23:01:40 moparisthebest has joined
23:01:50 ta has left
23:01:53 ta has joined
23:06:16 rtq3 has joined
23:06:50 goffi has left
23:09:23 alexis has left
23:09:41 alexis has joined
23:12:36 melvo has left
23:14:19 ThibG has left
23:14:26 ThibG has joined
23:14:53 kokonoe has left
23:15:18 kokonoe has joined
23:17:43 alexis has left
23:18:02 alexis has joined
23:25:00 moparisthebest has left
23:25:32 moparisthebest has joined
23:26:00 efrit has joined
23:41:54 yvo has joined
23:46:42 alexis has left
23:49:30 yvo has left
23:55:04 neshtaxmpp has left
23:55:05 neshtaxmpp has joined