XSF Discussion - 2019-08-18

lovetox, https://github.com/siacs/Conversations/commit/fddd974412fccecbd88e1302afe77d31ab8329aa

great Daniel !

something is not clear for the MUC XEP for me

can a service change my nick while im joined?

Good question. Probably?

i dont see an example how this would unfold

But I doubt they will. People are afraid to even use reassignment on join

would it send first an unavailable with a 303

then a available with a 210

this is needed for stuff like irc transport

on IRC you have one nick on the server across all rooms

if you change your nick in one room its changed in all rooms

so the server would have to modify my nick in all other rooms

Dunno. I know that Conversations would handle the new available presence with both self and reassignment code just fine

But an unexpected unavailable I would not like

yeah i see the 210 code just as info

i dont think i have to do anything special

Daniel that would be wrong, it would be ok for you

but not for all other participants

a nickchange must have a unavailable with 303 and the new nick

then an available

it should not matter if the nickchange is initiated by the user or server

Yeah I guess I can fix it

i will test this now with biboumi

Oh. Mhh I guess I'm handling it

I don't think biboumi handles this correctly, or conversations, or both

Because I've been /sanick'd on IRC servers and it messed up everything

It's been awhile though maybe it's fixed

i have an open issue with biboumi about this

specially it does not tell you when your nick is modified on join

lovetox, wouldn’t be looking at 110 be enough?

i mean granted biboumi should add the 210; but just looking at 110 and always assume it's yours should do the trick, no?

depends, if you take every self presence as a potential nick change by the service

yes

i mean what else are you going to do with a potential presence that has 110 but comes from an unexpected full jid

ignore it?

its not handled now

stuff breaks

but yes i also thought about this to treat every self presence as a potential nick change

That would be the most sane thing to do.

It seems I'm not on the trello board, can anybody add my request(?)/asking to join the editor team? ralphm, Seve, anybody? :)

pep.: What's your user name?

where?

On trello

I don't have an account

That seems useful

Oh, wait, I misunderstood

Cool, no need to create an account just yet then ✏

Added

Thanks

np