XSF Discussion - 2019-11-02


  1. jubalh has left

  2. j.r has left

  3. kokonoe has left

  4. Daniel has left

  5. mathijs has left

  6. mathijs has joined

  7. Daniel has joined

  8. mathijs has left

  9. mathijs has joined

  10. mukt2 has left

  11. mathijs has left

  12. mathijs has joined

  13. mukt2 has joined

  14. Daniel has left

  15. mathijs has left

  16. mathijs has joined

  17. andrey.g has left

  18. andrey.g has joined

  19. karoshi has left

  20. mukt2 has left

  21. pdurbin has joined

  22. mukt2 has joined

  23. pdurbin has left

  24. Daniel has joined

  25. wurstsalat has left

  26. aj has joined

  27. Daniel has left

  28. emus has left

  29. emus has joined

  30. moparisthebest has left

  31. moparisthebest has joined

  32. moparisthebest has left

  33. moparisthebest has joined

  34. xalek has joined

  35. lskdjf has left

  36. Douglas Terabyte has joined

  37. pdurbin has joined

  38. neshtaxmpp has left

  39. neshtaxmpp has joined

  40. Daniel has joined

  41. pdurbin has left

  42. mukt2 has left

  43. mukt2 has joined

  44. waqas has left

  45. Daniel has left

  46. mukt2 has left

  47. adiaholic has left

  48. Shell has left

  49. Shell has joined

  50. winfried has left

  51. mukt2 has joined

  52. winfried has joined

  53. strypey has joined

  54. pdurbin has joined

  55. strypey has left

  56. mukt2 has left

  57. mukt2 has joined

  58. Yagiza has joined

  59. Daniel has joined

  60. mukt2 has left

  61. mukt2 has joined

  62. pdurbin has left

  63. winfried has left

  64. winfried has joined

  65. winfried has left

  66. winfried has joined

  67. Nekit has joined

  68. mukt2 has left

  69. mukt2 has joined

  70. adiaholic has joined

  71. xalek has left

  72. mukt2 has left

  73. mukt2 has joined

  74. mukt2 has left

  75. mukt2 has joined

  76. mukt2 has left

  77. mukt2 has joined

  78. chronosx88 has joined

  79. wurstsalat has joined

  80. Daniel has left

  81. Daniel has joined

  82. Daniel has left

  83. Daniel has joined

  84. pdurbin has joined

  85. pdurbin has left

  86. Daniel has left

  87. Daniel has joined

  88. Tobias has joined

  89. COM8 has joined

  90. COM8 has left

  91. COM8 has joined

  92. jubalh has joined

  93. Nekit has left

  94. COM8 has left

  95. Daniel has left

  96. Daniel has joined

  97. debxwoody has joined

  98. Daniel has left

  99. Daniel has joined

  100. debxwoody has left

  101. debxwoody has joined

  102. adiaholic has left

  103. jubalh has left

  104. Tobias has left

  105. Tobias has joined

  106. adiaholic has joined

  107. Daniel has left

  108. Daniel has joined

  109. Daniel has left

  110. Daniel has joined

  111. Daniel has left

  112. Daniel has joined

  113. Daniel has left

  114. Daniel has joined

  115. lovetox has joined

  116. mukt2 has left

  117. mathijs has left

  118. mathijs has joined

  119. mukt2 has joined

  120. mathijs has left

  121. mathijs has joined

  122. Shell has left

  123. karoshi has joined

  124. debxwoody

    I think it would be helpful to have more provider at https://wiki.xmpp.org/web/Provider_Recommendations

  125. Daniel has left

  126. andy has left

  127. Daniel has joined

  128. Daniel

    debxwoody, it’s a wiki. you can add servers

  129. debxwoody

    Daniel: OK, I will check with the provider and fill the page 👍

  130. winfried has left

  131. winfried has joined

  132. winfried has left

  133. winfried has joined

  134. adiaholic has left

  135. Mikaela has joined

  136. pdurbin has joined

  137. andy has joined

  138. pdurbin has left

  139. mukt2 has left

  140. adiaholic has joined

  141. winfried has left

  142. winfried has joined

  143. winfried has left

  144. winfried has joined

  145. winfried has left

  146. winfried has joined

  147. aj has left

  148. winfried has left

  149. winfried has joined

  150. mathijs has left

  151. mathijs has joined

  152. adiaholic has left

  153. mukt2 has joined

  154. winfried has left

  155. winfried has joined

  156. adiaholic has joined

  157. winfried has left

  158. winfried has joined

  159. Tobias has left

  160. Tobias has joined

  161. lskdjf has joined

  162. Dele (Mobile) has joined

  163. Dele (Mobile) has left

  164. winfried has left

  165. winfried has joined

  166. curen has joined

  167. mathijs has left

  168. mathijs has joined

  169. mathijs has left

  170. mathijs has joined

  171. mathijs has left

  172. mathijs has joined

  173. aj has joined

  174. winfried has left

  175. winfried has joined

  176. Yagiza has left

  177. winfried has left

  178. pdurbin has joined

  179. winfried has joined

  180. mukt2 has left

  181. jubalh has joined

  182. mukt2 has joined

  183. adiaholic has left

  184. adiaholic has joined

  185. mukt2 has left

  186. mathijs has left

  187. mathijs has joined

  188. mukt2 has joined

  189. mathijs has left

  190. mathijs has joined

  191. adiaholic has left

  192. mukt2 has left

  193. DebXWoody has left

  194. jubalh has left

  195. jubalh has joined

  196. jubalh has left

  197. jubalh has joined

  198. adiaholic has joined

  199. mukt2 has joined

  200. jubalh has left

  201. adiaholic has left

  202. mukt2 has left

  203. DebXWoody has joined

  204. adiaholic has joined

  205. pdurbin has left

  206. mukt2 has joined

  207. curen has left

  208. larma has left

  209. mukt2 has left

  210. mukt2 has joined

  211. larma has joined

  212. Ge0rG

    (I'm sure I sound grumpy and bitter, but those criteria sound like the page should be renamed to "Conversations server recommendations")

  213. winfried has left

  214. winfried has joined

  215. Nekit has joined

  216. winfried has left

  217. winfried has joined

  218. debacle has joined

  219. karoshi has left

  220. Daniel

    It's not like someone has come forward with a better proposal

  221. Zash

    Yaxim server recommendations.

  222. marc_ has joined

  223. karoshi has joined

  224. !XSF_Martin

    There is a yaxim compliance tester.

  225. Daniel

    Would yaxim server recommendations be significantly different is the question

  226. adiaholic has left

  227. mukt2 has left

  228. adiaholic has joined

  229. mukt2 has joined

  230. chronosx88 has left

  231. winfried has left

  232. winfried has joined

  233. winfried has left

  234. winfried has joined

  235. winfried has left

  236. winfried has joined

  237. winfried has left

  238. winfried has joined

  239. winfried has left

  240. winfried has joined

  241. winfried has left

  242. winfried has joined

  243. winfried has left

  244. winfried has joined

  245. winfried has left

  246. winfried has joined

  247. winfried has left

  248. winfried has joined

  249. mukt2 has left

  250. mukt2 has joined

  251. adiaholic has left

  252. adiaholic has joined

  253. mathijs has left

  254. mathijs has joined

  255. debacle has left

  256. mukt2 has left

  257. mukt2 has joined

  258. winfried has left

  259. winfried has joined

  260. adiaholic has left

  261. adiaholic has joined

  262. pdurbin has joined

  263. adiaholic has left

  264. adiaholic has joined

  265. debxwoody

    It is difficult to recommend a provider. There are different needs for different people. Keep it open, like "XMPP Provider" and put the important information on top as description and some information within the list. The user can use.

  266. debxwoody

    s/use/choose

  267. pdurbin has left

  268. adiaholic has left

  269. Ge0rG

    Daniel [13:24]: > Would yaxim server recommendations be significantly different is the question Generalized, the question should be: what are the XEPs that should be part of a Compliance Suite that can be followed by server operators.

  270. winfried has left

  271. winfried has joined

  272. ralphm has left

  273. Daniel

    Isn't the 2020 compliance suite and the criteria on that page almost identical?

  274. adiaholic has joined

  275. Ge0rG

    Maybe somebody should check.

  276. Ge0rG

    It's Last Call after all!

  277. Daniel

    You started complaining / implying that this is not the case the assumed you did that beforehand

  278. mukt2 has left

  279. mukt2 has joined

  280. Chobbes has joined

  281. Ge0rG

    Let's see what's missing. IBR isn't listed in CS, but probably should be added to Core IM. I'm sure that will cause more controversy about closed deployments, but supporting is not the same as enabling it, I suppose.

  282. Zash

    Supported ≠ Deployed

  283. Zash

    Oh right you said that.

  284. adiaholic has left

  285. Ge0rG

    0065 is required by the Conversations tester, but not in the CS. What should I do with that?

  286. Ge0rG

    0160 would be a good addition to CS

  287. adiaholic has joined

  288. Ge0rG

    0384... It's not even a server feature, is it? The Conversations tester is mapping that to what? PEP publishing options?

  289. Daniel

    Yes

  290. Daniel

    Or broken ejabberd configurations

  291. Ge0rG

    0156 happens absolutely outside of xmpp as it is used. Should that be part of Advanced Web?

  292. Ge0rG

    How would I add PEP publishing options to the CS?

  293. Daniel

    It isn't part of advanced web yet?

  294. Daniel

    Or basic web even

  295. Ge0rG

    The above is a list of all differences I've found. Daniel, as the maintainer of the Compliance Tester, I'd absolutely love to hear your recommendations on how to change the CS, on standards@

  296. Ge0rG

    Not mentioned at all

  297. Daniel

    Also it is for now just an informational test

  298. Daniel

    Same as ibr

  299. Ge0rG

    But IBR is required in the wiki page

  300. jonas’

    Daniel, I rely on roominfo_occupants, yes. The number on the search is a moving average.

  301. kokonoe has joined

  302. Daniel

    > But IBR is required in the wiki page Is that an unreasonable ask from a list of provider recommendations?

  303. Daniel

    That you can actually sign up?

  304. Zash

    Does it suppor the thing in IBR where it can give you an URL instead?

  305. Daniel

    Yes

  306. Ge0rG

    Daniel: not at all. And it's not unreasonable to add IBR to CS. Probably with a remark about spammer accounts and 0157

  307. Daniel

    The provider recommendation thing says that's ok

  308. Ge0rG

    Daniel: do you have detailed information on how far the uptime measurement bot got / what the reasons for failing were? I'm interested in why yax.im is below 99

  309. Ge0rG

    I assume it's too cpu loaded to react to all requests within 10s, but data is better than guesses

  310. Nekit has left

  311. adiaholic has left

  312. emus has left

  313. emus has joined

  314. kokonoe has left

  315. winfried has left

  316. winfried has joined

  317. mukt2 has left

  318. andy has left

  319. andy has joined

  320. mukt2 has joined

  321. winfried has left

  322. winfried has joined

  323. Nekit has joined

  324. winfried has left

  325. winfried has joined

  326. mukt2 has left

  327. mukt2 has joined

  328. Ge0rG

    Kev: is there an exhaustive list of allowed presence annotations for XEP-0310?

  329. kokonoe has joined

  330. kokonoe has left

  331. adiaholic has joined

  332. Kev

    Blimey. I'd completely forgotten writing that. That was a long time ago.

  333. mukt2 has left

  334. mukt2 has joined

  335. adiaholic has left

  336. debacle has joined

  337. Ge0rG

    Kev: it obviously needs a way to be extended with own-namespace conditions, and neither stanza errors nor stream errors seem an appropriate fill-in.

  338. Ge0rG

    But it would be nice to have a 0280 hibernated marker.

  339. Ge0rG

    It would also be nice if somebody from the prosody team implemented it in mod_smacks :D

  340. winfried has left

  341. winfried has joined

  342. Kev

    If you've got a use for it and would like to see it updated, please feel free.

  343. Ge0rG

    Kev: bummer. The last time I took over authorship of a XEP didn't end well.

  344. winfried has left

  345. winfried has joined

  346. winfried has left

  347. winfried has joined

  348. winfried has left

  349. winfried has joined

  350. mukt2 has left

  351. kokonoe has joined

  352. aj has left

  353. winfried has left

  354. winfried has joined

  355. mukt2 has joined

  356. kokonoe has left

  357. adiaholic has joined

  358. pdurbin has joined

  359. kokonoe has joined

  360. !XSF_Martin has left

  361. !XSF_Martin has joined

  362. pdurbin has left

  363. adiaholic has left

  364. Nekit has left

  365. APach has left

  366. APach has joined

  367. mukt2 has left

  368. Daniel has left

  369. Daniel has joined

  370. mukt2 has joined

  371. aj has joined

  372. j.r has joined

  373. COM8 has joined

  374. debxwoody has left

  375. jubalh has joined

  376. mukt2 has left

  377. COM8 has left

  378. COM8 has joined

  379. debxwoody has joined

  380. mathijs has left

  381. mathijs has joined

  382. COM8 has left

  383. jubalh has left

  384. xalek has joined

  385. mukt2 has joined

  386. COM8 has joined

  387. kokonoe has left

  388. COM8 has left

  389. kokonoe has joined

  390. kokonoe has left

  391. andy has left

  392. COM8 has joined

  393. COM8 has left

  394. COM8 has joined

  395. mathijs has left

  396. mathijs has joined

  397. COM8 has left

  398. COM8 has joined

  399. COM8 has left

  400. adiaholic has joined

  401. kokonoe has joined

  402. mukt2 has left

  403. mukt2 has joined

  404. COM8 has joined

  405. debacle has left

  406. jubalh has joined

  407. goffi has joined

  408. COM8 has left

  409. mathijs has left

  410. mathijs has joined

  411. mathijs has left

  412. mathijs has joined

  413. mathijs has left

  414. mathijs has joined

  415. Zash

    .

  416. dwd has joined

  417. andy has joined

  418. jubalh has left

  419. kokonoe has left

  420. winfried has left

  421. winfried has joined

  422. pdurbin has joined

  423. winfried has left

  424. winfried has joined

  425. pdurbin has left

  426. debacle has joined

  427. kokonoe has joined

  428. mathijs has left

  429. mathijs has joined

  430. mukt2 has left

  431. mukt2 has joined

  432. Zash

    .

  433. alameyo has left

  434. alameyo has joined

  435. Ge0rG

    Zash: you know you can just /ping the MUC?

  436. Zash

    /how does this even work

  437. Zash

    Ge0rG, does /ping work in Dino?

  438. Zash

    pep., can you hear me?

  439. Ge0rG

    Zash: you can make it happen!

  440. Ge0rG

    Or just use a full featured client.

  441. Ge0rG

    Or lament on standards@ to make ping required by CS 2020

  442. Ge0rG

    So many options!

  443. mathijs has left

  444. mathijs has joined

  445. mukt2 has left

  446. mukt2 has joined

  447. dwd has left

  448. mathijs has left

  449. mathijs has joined

  450. mathijs has left

  451. mathijs has joined

  452. winfried has left

  453. winfried has joined

  454. winfried has left

  455. winfried has joined

  456. winfried has left

  457. winfried has joined

  458. winfried has left

  459. winfried has joined

  460. winfried has left

  461. winfried has joined

  462. winfried has left

  463. winfried has joined

  464. mathijs has left

  465. mathijs has joined

  466. Shell has joined

  467. winfried has left

  468. winfried has joined

  469. winfried has left

  470. winfried has joined

  471. winfried has left

  472. winfried has joined

  473. Chobbes has left

  474. Chobbes has joined

  475. xalek has left

  476. Chobbes has left

  477. Chobbes has joined

  478. xalek has joined

  479. emus has left

  480. Guest has left

  481. emus has joined

  482. j.r has left

  483. Shell has left

  484. Shell has joined

  485. debacle has left

  486. debacle has joined

  487. pdurbin has joined

  488. j.r has joined

  489. pdurbin has left

  490. debacle has left

  491. marc_ has left

  492. winfried has left

  493. winfried has joined

  494. Shell has left

  495. Shell has joined

  496. winfried has left

  497. winfried has joined

  498. winfried has left

  499. winfried has joined

  500. andrey.g has left

  501. winfried has left

  502. winfried has joined

  503. !XSF_Martin has left

  504. winfried has left

  505. winfried has joined

  506. Chobbes has left

  507. Chobbes has joined

  508. winfried has left

  509. winfried has joined

  510. winfried has left

  511. winfried has joined

  512. jubalh has joined

  513. Chobbes has left

  514. Chobbes has joined

  515. jubalh has left

  516. !XSF_Martin has joined

  517. Shell has left

  518. winfried has left

  519. winfried has joined

  520. Mikaela has left

  521. Mikaela has joined

  522. APach has left

  523. ralphm has joined

  524. Nekit has joined

  525. Shell has joined

  526. Shell has left

  527. Shell has joined

  528. adiaholic has left

  529. adiaholic has joined

  530. mathijs has left

  531. mathijs has joined

  532. mathijs has left

  533. mathijs has joined

  534. adiaholic has left

  535. mukt2 has left

  536. adiaholic has joined

  537. jubalh has joined

  538. jubalh has left

  539. winfried has left

  540. winfried has joined

  541. mukt2 has joined

  542. remko has joined

  543. xalek has left

  544. kokonoe has left

  545. pdurbin has joined

  546. kokonoe has joined

  547. Shell has left

  548. Shell has joined

  549. mukt2 has left

  550. DebXWoody has left

  551. remko has left

  552. mukt2 has joined

  553. pdurbin has left

  554. remko has joined

  555. Chobbes has left

  556. Chobbes has joined

  557. mukt2 has left

  558. mukt2 has joined

  559. Chobbes has left

  560. lovetox has left

  561. LNJ has left

  562. remko has left

  563. emus has left

  564. mathijs has left

  565. mathijs has joined

  566. mukt2 has left

  567. mukt2 has joined

  568. emus has joined

  569. mathijs has left

  570. mathijs has joined

  571. murabito has joined

  572. mathijs has left

  573. mathijs has joined

  574. mukt2 has left

  575. pdurbin has joined

  576. mukt2 has joined

  577. david has left

  578. david has joined

  579. pdurbin has left

  580. mukt2 has left

  581. mukt2 has joined

  582. remko has joined

  583. goffi has left

  584. Zash has left

  585. Zash has joined