XSF Discussion - 2020-04-28


  1. pdurbin has joined
  2. bear has joined
  3. gav has left
  4. aj has left
  5. pdurbin has left
  6. Wojtek has left
  7. debacle has left
  8. mukt2 has left
  9. bear has left
  10. alexis has left
  11. mukt2 has joined
  12. alexis has joined
  13. govanify has left
  14. govanify has joined
  15. alexis has left
  16. govanify has left
  17. govanify has joined
  18. mukt2 has left
  19. alexis has joined
  20. mukt2 has joined
  21. emus has left
  22. lorddavidiii has left
  23. lskdjf has left
  24. govanify has left
  25. govanify has joined
  26. bear has joined
  27. govanify has left
  28. govanify has joined
  29. mukt2 has left
  30. bear has left
  31. mukt2 has joined
  32. stpeter has joined
  33. stpeter has left
  34. mukt2 has left
  35. arc has left
  36. arc has joined
  37. mukt2 has joined
  38. waqas has left
  39. waqas has joined
  40. karoshi has left
  41. govanify has left
  42. govanify has joined
  43. mukt2 has left
  44. pdurbin has joined
  45. bear has joined
  46. Daniel has left
  47. Daniel has joined
  48. pdurbin has left
  49. pdurbin has joined
  50. arc has left
  51. arc has joined
  52. pdurbin has left
  53. bear has left
  54. govanify has left
  55. govanify has joined
  56. pdurbin has joined
  57. govanify has left
  58. govanify has joined
  59. mukt2 has joined
  60. stpeter has joined
  61. stpeter has left
  62. govanify has left
  63. govanify has joined
  64. bear has joined
  65. mukt2 has left
  66. govanify has left
  67. govanify has joined
  68. bear has left
  69. govanify has left
  70. govanify has joined
  71. xsf has left
  72. andy has joined
  73. govanify has left
  74. govanify has joined
  75. xsf has joined
  76. govanify has left
  77. govanify has joined
  78. waqas has left
  79. Daniel has left
  80. mimi89999 has left
  81. mimi89999 has joined
  82. Daniel has joined
  83. bear has joined
  84. DebXWoody has joined
  85. waqas has joined
  86. adiaholic_ has joined
  87. adiaholic_ has left
  88. adiaholic_ has joined
  89. mimi89999 has left
  90. mimi89999 has joined
  91. waqas has left
  92. bear has left
  93. Tobias has joined
  94. govanify has left
  95. govanify has joined
  96. arc has left
  97. arc has joined
  98. Mikaela has joined
  99. adiaholic_ has left
  100. adiaholic_ has joined
  101. mukt2 has joined
  102. bear has joined
  103. Daniel has left
  104. Daniel has joined
  105. Daniel has left
  106. Daniel has joined
  107. Daniel has left
  108. Daniel has joined
  109. Daniel has left
  110. Daniel has joined
  111. Daniel has left
  112. Daniel has joined
  113. paul has joined
  114. Daniel has left
  115. Daniel has joined
  116. Daniel has left
  117. Daniel has joined
  118. krauq has left
  119. lovetox has joined
  120. krauq has joined
  121. rion has left
  122. rion has joined
  123. marc has left
  124. adiaholic_ has left
  125. adiaholic_ has joined
  126. mukt2 has left
  127. lorddavidiii has joined
  128. marc has joined
  129. adiaholic_ has left
  130. adiaholic_ has joined
  131. andrey.g has joined
  132. xecks has joined
  133. ths has joined
  134. ths has left
  135. ths has joined
  136. Nekit has joined
  137. Alex has joined
  138. werdan has joined
  139. Jeybe has joined
  140. Jeybe has left
  141. Jeybe has joined
  142. LNJ has joined
  143. mukt2 has joined
  144. Jeybe has left
  145. Jeybe has joined
  146. debacle has joined
  147. Jeybe has left
  148. Jeybe has joined
  149. wurstsalat has joined
  150. mukt2 has left
  151. emus has joined
  152. Jeybe has left
  153. Jeybe has joined
  154. adiaholic_ has left
  155. adiaholic_ has joined
  156. Jeybe has left
  157. Jeybe has joined
  158. Maranda has joined
  159. Jeybe has left
  160. Jeybe has joined
  161. adiaholic_ has left
  162. adiaholic_ has joined
  163. Jeybe has left
  164. Jeybe has joined
  165. lovetox has left
  166. Jeybe has left
  167. Jeybe has joined
  168. goffi has joined
  169. Jeybe has left
  170. Jeybe has joined
  171. mukt2 has joined
  172. Daniel has left
  173. Daniel has joined
  174. Jeybe has left
  175. Jeybe has joined
  176. vanitasvitae has left
  177. vanitasvitae has joined
  178. lovetox has joined
  179. Jeybe has left
  180. Jeybe has joined
  181. lovetox has left
  182. lovetox has joined
  183. govanify has left
  184. mukt2 has left
  185. Jeybe has left
  186. Jeybe has joined
  187. govanify has joined
  188. adiaholic_ has left
  189. adiaholic_ has joined
  190. Jeybe has left
  191. Jeybe has joined
  192. debacle has left
  193. Jeybe has left
  194. Jeybe has joined
  195. neshtaxmpp has joined
  196. Jeybe has left
  197. Jeybe has joined
  198. Jeybe has left
  199. Jeybe has joined
  200. marc has left
  201. Jeybe has left
  202. Jeybe has joined
  203. marc has joined
  204. bear has left
  205. xsf has left
  206. xsf has joined
  207. karoshi has joined
  208. larma has left
  209. neshtaxmpp has left
  210. mukt2 has joined
  211. larma has joined
  212. xsf has left
  213. xsf has joined
  214. mukt2 has left
  215. vanitasvitae has left
  216. vanitasvitae has joined
  217. bear has joined
  218. marc has left
  219. lskdjf has joined
  220. bear has left
  221. j.r has joined
  222. LNJ has left
  223. LNJ has joined
  224. mukt2 has joined
  225. mukt2 has left
  226. govanify has left
  227. govanify has joined
  228. contrapunctus has joined
  229. sonny has left
  230. sonny has joined
  231. sonny has left
  232. sonny has joined
  233. Maranda has left
  234. govanify has left
  235. govanify has joined
  236. xsf has left
  237. xsf has joined
  238. marc has joined
  239. Maranda has joined
  240. bear has joined
  241. bear has left
  242. govanify has left
  243. govanify has joined
  244. mukt2 has joined
  245. krauq has left
  246. krauq has joined
  247. krauq has left
  248. govanify has left
  249. govanify has joined
  250. govanify has left
  251. govanify has joined
  252. adiaholic_ has left
  253. adiaholic_ has joined
  254. govanify has left
  255. govanify has joined
  256. !XSF_Martin has left
  257. !XSF_Martin has joined
  258. Jeybe has left
  259. Jeybe has joined
  260. bear has joined
  261. krauq has joined
  262. Jeybe has left
  263. pdurbin has left
  264. bear has left
  265. krauq has left
  266. krauq has joined
  267. debacle has joined
  268. govanify has left
  269. govanify has joined
  270. mukt2 has left
  271. Jeybe has joined
  272. bear has joined
  273. Jeybe has left
  274. Jeybe has joined
  275. Jeybe has left
  276. Jeybe has joined
  277. Jeybe has left
  278. Jeybe has joined
  279. bear has left
  280. LNJ has left
  281. LNJ has joined
  282. bear has joined
  283. pdurbin has joined
  284. govanify has left
  285. govanify has joined
  286. bear has left
  287. govanify has left
  288. govanify has joined
  289. pdurbin has left
  290. Ge0rG has left
  291. Ge0rG has joined
  292. govanify has left
  293. govanify has joined
  294. werdan has left
  295. werdan has joined
  296. Jeybe has left
  297. Jeybe has joined
  298. contrapunctus has left
  299. Jeybe has left
  300. Jeybe has joined
  301. bear has joined
  302. emus has left
  303. emus has joined
  304. Jeybe has left
  305. Jeybe has joined
  306. emus has left
  307. emus has joined
  308. emus has left
  309. emus has joined
  310. emus has left
  311. emus has joined
  312. emus has left
  313. emus has joined
  314. marc0s has left
  315. bear has left
  316. emus has left
  317. emus has joined
  318. emus has left
  319. emus has joined
  320. lovetox has left
  321. lovetox has joined
  322. bear has joined
  323. Maranda has left
  324. stpeter has joined
  325. stpeter has left
  326. marc0s has joined
  327. larma XEP-0308 allows to edit the last message of each full jid by the bare jid in direct messages. Which means I could technically edit another resources message. But when I do, I run into a race condition as that other resource could send another message shortly before my correction thus effectively making my correction "out of scope" of XEP-0308.
  328. andrey.g has left
  329. larma Also, when I send each message with a new resource, I could technically use XEP-0308 standards compliant to correct any message, not only the latest
  330. larma The issue with race condition also applies to editing in MUCs, due to multi session nicks
  331. Ge0rG larma: the scoping doesn't make much sense. I'd suggest you roll a D20 to determine how many recent messages you accept edits for, and only count those based on the sender's bare JID / identity
  332. Ge0rG larma: also you could hope that a user won't send a message from device A and *at the same time* edit an old message from device B
  333. Zash Aren't edits by id too?
  334. larma Ge0rG, question is not only for incoming but also outgoing. And "at the same time" could be caused by a mobile device coming back online and having that message still in its offline queue.
  335. larma Zash, yes, we do have the ID, but 0308 has some obscure rules beside ID (which seems to be so that legacy fallback can easier spot that it's a correction)
  336. Ge0rG larma: yaxim is limiting editing to the last 10 messages from the same sender
  337. Ge0rG larma: the XEP author said "editing other than the last message is out of scope of the XEP"
  338. Ge0rG and don't even get me started on which ID to edit in multi-edits.
  339. larma so yaxim allows incoming and outcoming edits that are not specified in any standard?
  340. Ge0rG yes.
  341. Ge0rG and it's even worse than that.
  342. larma And then other clients don't support those edits incoming I guess? So UX is crap
  343. Ge0rG yaxim allows edits in semi-anon MUCs originating from the same nickname, even if somebody stole the nickname
  344. Ge0rG larma: 🤷
  345. larma re nick stealing: 0421 to the rescue?
  346. Blue has left
  347. Ge0rG larma: 0421 has interesting issues of its own. But yes, it's on my long-term todo list
  348. Ge0rG which is probably just an elaborate way of saying: I don't care
  349. Ge0rG if you want to attach identity to nicknames in semi-anon MUCs, then register the nicknames or don't use semi-anon
  350. larma also, which clients will allow this correction-10-messages-ago incoming? And why 10? And is that the last 10 by bare jid, so if I write 1 message X with resource A and then >10 message with resource B, you don't allow correction of message X anymore (even though you should under XEP-0308)?
  351. Ge0rG larma: 1. yaxim, I don't care about the others. 2. It seemed like a good trade-off, given nobody else cared about it. 3. Yes, by bare JID (or by nickname in MUCs)
  352. larma Great, so we probably have a mix of incompatible rules for last message correction in various clients and even the spec is broken by design
  353. Ge0rG larma: indeed
  354. larma So, how do we fix this mess?
  355. Ge0rG larma: write a new XEP that extends 0308 to the last N messages.
  356. pdurbin has joined
  357. lovetox has left
  358. Ge0rG larma: Daniel suggested YMC, "YOLO Message Correction", allowing to edit any messages regardless of age and sender.
  359. Ge0rG I can't find any relevant mail from me to standards, so it probably was buried in a Council meeting
  360. larma But when we do "any message correction", fallback body becomes pretty useless, no?
  361. Ge0rG fallback body of what?
  362. larma well fallback body of correction
  363. Ge0rG why should there be a *fallback* body?
  364. larma for clients not supporting it?
  365. Zash fallback body should be "I mean $message *"
  366. Ge0rG larma: there is no fallback body in 0308
  367. larma Ge0rG, well the body is the fallback
  368. Ge0rG larma: the body is the newbody.
  369. larma Well, it happens to have two usecases at the same time
  370. larma because legacy clients will display it as a normal message
  371. larma which is ok, if it really is the last message
  372. larma which is ok, if it really is the last message, see?
  373. pdurbin has left
  374. Ge0rG larma: so your point is: correcting an older message will lead to confusion in non-0308 client users?
  375. larma with 0308 we don't really have that problem due to its restriction to the last message.
  376. larma if we allow edits of older messages though, we get into trouble
  377. Ge0rG let me make a controversial proposal: editing of older messages should be restricted by their age, not by their amount.
  378. larma still the same issue, no?
  379. Zash Why not both‽
  380. Ge0rG it's happened to me many times that I sent a message, then another one, then realized I had a typo in the first one.
  381. Ge0rG larma: actually it's a much worse issue: time is relative
  382. Zash Sneak-edit of a message that has scrolled out of view seems about as bad as a sneak-edit of a 7 hour old message.
  383. gav has joined
  384. larma "sneak-edit"?
  385. Zash Snake edit?
  386. Zash Snape edit!
  387. Zash I mean an edit that you're unlikely to notice
  388. Zash Ie because it scrolled out of view.
  389. larma I don't consider those an issue really
  390. Ge0rG Zash: but how large is the view?
  391. Zash Either because time passed or because discussio
  392. Zash Ge0rG, three fiddy
  393. Ge0rG in yaxim, a view is roughly ten messages. See, I found a reason for the arbitrary number
  394. Zash Dice roll
  395. larma If I edit an old message that is probably scrolled out of view at the recipient, I must expect the edit not to be recognized by them
  396. larma that's ok
  397. Ge0rG larma: "But you said yes to my contract proposal, it's binding now!"
  398. Ge0rG the older a message, the lower the probability that you actually *need* to edit it.
  399. larma Ge0rG, "My client says 'Yes (edited)', and you changed to from 'No'"
  400. larma Ge0rG, "My client says 'Yes (edited)', and you changed it from 'No'"
  401. larma Also, this seems to be a social issue, not a protocol issue.
  402. Ge0rG of course it is
  403. larma I can also edit paper contracts after you signed them, even without you noticing.
  404. larma I don't think we need to do better than reality here.
  405. Ge0rG larma: what limits do you consider sensible?
  406. larma No limit?
  407. Ge0rG edit everything?
  408. larma Yes, but I don't see the solution for the "not sure which message was edited" in the fallback case
  409. gav has left
  410. larma except not showing edits to legacy clients at all.
  411. Ge0rG larma: stop caring too much about legacy clients.
  412. Ge0rG if you edit the 11th-last message, yaxim will not merge the edit into the original, but will display this as a new message with an "edited" tag
  413. larma Ge0rG, legacy client = literally every client right now
  414. Ge0rG 0308 is part of Advanced IM 2020
  415. larma Yes, but only the "version" accepting an edit of the last message of each full jid by the corresponding bare jid, which I bet nobody implements.
  416. pep. fwiw I was also considering with poezio taking into account more than the latest, in a proper way. poezio already does AMC in reading
  417. pep. (maybe unintentionally, dunno, it was the case when I joined)
  418. pep. and it's possible to send AMC with /rawxml (great UX!)
  419. Ge0rG larma: 0308 was adopted in 2013, that was long before my activity started.
  420. andrey.g has joined
  421. Ge0rG larma: I could theoretically imagine Council relaxing the "last message only" rule, but I wouldn't bet on it
  422. debacle has left
  423. larma Ge0rG, well my point is: If I fix a typo 10 messages ago, I don't want any client to display that typo-fixing as a new message, as it would just cause confusion. But I still want to be able to do those fixes.
  424. Ge0rG larma: I agree.
  425. larma So just changing XEP-0308 to allow AMC doesn't solve the issue
  426. Ge0rG larma: nothing will solve the issue right now.
  427. Ge0rG not even creating a new XEP that defines AMC on top of 0308.
  428. pep. larma, maybe using <body> for this is just wrong :P
  429. Ge0rG except maybe creating that new XEP and putting it into CS2021 and then waiting.
  430. Ge0rG pep.: please no!
  431. pep. <replace @id>correction</replace>
  432. Dele Olajide has joined
  433. larma creating a new XEP that defines AMC *outside* of 0308 so that legacy clients / 0308-clients do not display the correction at all would solve the issue.
  434. larma but that implies not using <body>
  435. mukt2 has joined
  436. larma Or precisely not using <body> in <message>
  437. pep. And then people want you to take into consideration non-implementing clients and you're back to square one
  438. Ge0rG pep.: easy: just add a legacy body into AMC!
  439. larma could still be <message><edit xmlns="urn:xmpp:edit:0"><body xmlns="jabber:client">Correction</body></edit></message>
  440. Ge0rG larma: that would make some sense indeed.
  441. Ge0rG would allow differentiating the *edited* part from the edit metadata part.
  442. pep. larma, I'm not sure I understand the intent
  443. pep. non-implementing clients won't understand this
  444. larma <message><body>/me edits "Corection" in message from 01:02:03 to "Correction"</body><edit xmlns="urn:xmpp:edit:0"><body xmlns="jabber:client">Correction</body></edit></message>
  445. Ge0rG Yeah.
  446. pep. ugh
  447. larma Fallback body *only* if I want legacy clients to display something of course
  448. larma (not in the case of fixing that one type)
  449. pep. Seeing the wire format of /me hurts every single time
  450. lovetox has joined
  451. pep. larma, still not sure I understand the point of <body/> in <edit/>
  452. pep. Also in your fallback you included localtime
  453. pep. Or UTC, or ?
  454. pep. Which one is it
  455. larma Well the <body> in <message> is only for those clients that don't understand the <edit>. The client supporting <edit> will just edit the old message and not display the fallback at all.
  456. pep. I did say the <body> in <edit>
  457. larma yes, that's whay is used as a replacement for the body when the client supports <edit>
  458. larma because I might want to edit other elements than edit
  459. pep. Why do you need an extra child
  460. pep. ah ok
  461. larma because I might want to edit other elements than body
  462. pep. That's the info I was missing
  463. larma And it also seems consistent to have the displayed body in the <body> element
  464. pep. If you could only edit <body>, I don't think so
  465. pep. I think it's being frowned upon anyway to edit anything else than <body/>, iiuc
  466. larma Well, if I upload a file, why not edit the description of the file (assuming a SIMS-alike file sending)
  467. pep. I'm personally fine with this
  468. Ge0rG why not replace the file with another one?
  469. larma or that
  470. Ge0rG I accidentally a dickpic.
  471. larma or if the file is a text file and has a typo in it
  472. pep. Ge0rG, the internet will have to live with it forever
  473. larma OK, solution was found, now just need someone to write the XEP 😀
  474. larma And then a council to accept it even if it's not making use of fastenings 😕
  475. Ge0rG larma: but it should make use of fastenings! You fasten the correction to the original message!
  476. larma Ge0rG, my message is end-to-end-encrypted with forward secrecy, I am not fastening anything because fastening is crap when having forward secrecy
  477. larma newsflash: OMEMO uses forward secrecy and is literally what made XMPP popular again
  478. larma but it's probably a sidecase we don't want to care about 😕
  479. Blue has joined
  480. Blue Can somebody smart explain me something about stanza id xep?
  481. Ge0rG Blue: if you find somebody smart...
  482. mukt2 has left
  483. pep. larma: everyone has a different opinion on what makes XMPP (not) popular :p
  484. Blue I'm pretty sure most of you here are smart on my terms =)
  485. arc has left
  486. arc has joined
  487. Ge0rG Blue: then maybe ask the question :)
  488. larma pep., yeah, I just needed my daily criticism of the reactions decision, didn't want to actually make a point here 😉
  489. pep. hehe
  490. Zash What if we lock all stakeholders in a room until the whole reactions thing is resolved?
  491. pep. that is, everybody kills each other?
  492. flow larma> Fallback body *only* if I want legacy clients to display something of course that's also the approach which I would be pursuing
  493. Blue So, there is nice and cool "id" attribute for the message. You can edit retract confirm delivery with that and so much more. Basically - da heck is stansa id? How to behave with it?
  494. flow larma> Well, if I upload a file, why not edit the description of the file (assuming a SIMS-alike file sending) that a nice idea, but I fear it is far easier to implement just re-issuing the SIMS
  495. pep. flow, then a client displays two "media" thing?
  496. pep. For ""the same"" file
  497. flow pep., maybe, or it does only display the corrected SIMS, while still allowing data fetches of the old SIMS
  498. larma Blue, id attribute and <origin-id> id attribute should be the same. <stanza-id> is important for MUCs and MAM.
  499. Ge0rG Blue: old clients don't generate a unique id attribute.
  500. pep. Ah, fight on 0359, that's also something I was curious about
  501. LNJ has left
  502. Ge0rG and <stanza-id> is added by somebody else than the sender, typically an archive
  503. flow Blue, if something doesn't explicitly talk about xep359 IDs then use the RFC 6120 IDs
  504. MattJ Blue, the 'id' attribute is optional, and set by the first entity to generate the stanza. It may not be present, and it may not be unique. The stanza-id element allows other entities (such as a client's server) to inject their own ids.
  505. LNJ has joined
  506. MattJ The id attribute is useful for short-term error tracking, stanza-id is useful for an entity to assign a more permanent unique id to a stanza (and it's not limited to just one)
  507. MattJ and origin-id is mostly a hack that we've discussed potentially removing in the past (though it has a couple of useful properties)
  508. Ge0rG I'm interested in those useful properties, beyond virtue signaling of "proper" ID generation
  509. Blue I just don't get how to treat them. You see, I have sort of message order in my lil app. I ordered them using ID attribute. Do i need the same order of stansaIds pointing to the same messages? Or do I just replace my pointing to the message id with newly discovered stansa id? Then how do I discover the stansa id server assigned to my outgoing message? There are attachements to the messages described in some xep, they go to stansa id, but i just checked message corrections - they go only to origin ids.... I'm a bit lost and confused =)
  510. MattJ None of the ids are guaranteed to be sortable
  511. MattJ So you can't use them for order
  512. MattJ There is currently no (sensible) way to discover the stanza-id assigned by the server to an outgoing stanza, that's something that will hopefully be fixed at some point
  513. Blue but that doesn't make sence... There is sorted by time stream of messages...
  514. contrapunctus has joined
  515. MattJ Sure, I'm not saying messages don't have an order. I'm saying that ids are not used to convey the order.
  516. Blue but... how to query the history then?
  517. LNJ has left
  518. MattJ You can still query from the last incoming message
  519. LNJ has joined
  520. Blue but I cant relay on time either - it's also optional (stamp if I'm not mistaken) and a little to approximate, isn't it?
  521. MattJ Yes, don't use time
  522. zzzed has joined
  523. Zash Time where?
  524. MattJ Anywhere
  525. Zash I do have this "origin-time" draft...
  526. zzzed Hello, when i try to start private convesation (otr) and to generate fingerprints app instant close
  527. zzzed any help?
  528. arc has left
  529. arc has joined
  530. arc has left
  531. arc has joined
  532. Blue so... for that reason I build an order of messages, but seems like I have miscalculated about the id's I use in that order
  533. zzzed has left
  534. zzzed has joined
  535. zzzed anyone to help me out?
  536. arc has left
  537. arc has joined
  538. zzzed Kev MattJ ralphm
  539. Nekit has left
  540. arc has left
  541. arc has joined
  542. Zash has left
  543. Zash has joined
  544. zzzed am
  545. zzzed intosi
  546. zzzed admin
  547. MattJ zzzed, you're asking the wrong people in the wrong channel
  548. MattJ Stop highlighting people for no reason please
  549. zzzed aha , where should i finde help then?
  550. MattJ What app are you using?
  551. zzzed you dont need to be rude at all , you can say on nice way
  552. zzzed PSI
  553. MattJ https://search.jabber.network/search?q=psi
  554. zzzed thanks
  555. zzzed have a nice day
  556. MattJ You too
  557. zzzed has left
  558. adiaholic_ has left
  559. adiaholic_ has joined
  560. alexis has left
  561. Wojtek has joined
  562. debacle has joined
  563. Jeybe has left
  564. Jeybe has joined
  565. Jeybe has left
  566. Jeybe has joined
  567. Jeybe has left
  568. Jeybe has joined
  569. lovetox has left
  570. pdurbin has joined
  571. Jeybe has left
  572. Jeybe has joined
  573. lorddavidiii has left
  574. lorddavidiii has joined
  575. Jeybe has left
  576. Jeybe has joined
  577. arc has left
  578. arc has joined
  579. pdurbin has left
  580. jonas’ does anyone have a clue about those ref files we generate for XEPs?
  581. jonas’ https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/938
  582. jonas’ I’d love to get a review on that one before hiting the green button
  583. flow jonas’, lgtm
  584. jonas’ flow, can you add a review on github please?
  585. flow those are mostly used by https://xml2rfc.tools.ietf.org/
  586. mukt2 has joined
  587. flow and as you can see, e.g. https://xmpp.org/extensions/refs/reference.XSF.XEP-0435.xml has no target
  588. flow int the root note
  589. flow in the root node
  590. flow wheras https://xml2rfc.tools.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml2/reference.NIST.SP.800-185.xml has
  591. jonas’ flow, good, can you add that as a review on github?
  592. jonas’ thx
  593. Max has left
  594. Maranda has joined
  595. j.r has left
  596. Max has joined
  597. Zash What are this?
  598. flow Zash, "this"?
  599. Zash These refs things
  600. arc has left
  601. arc has joined
  602. flow those ref entries are consumed by xml2rfc and can be used as references in I-Ds and RFCs
  603. flow think of biblatex entries for RFCs
  604. Zash Oh-kay
  605. Maranda has left
  606. mukt2 has left
  607. Nekit has joined
  608. Maranda has joined
  609. LNJ has left
  610. LNJ has joined
  611. Jeybe has left
  612. Jeybe has joined
  613. waqas has joined
  614. j.r has joined
  615. LNJ has left
  616. alexis has joined
  617. LNJ has joined
  618. sonny has left
  619. sonny has joined
  620. sonny has left
  621. sonny has joined
  622. mukt2 has joined
  623. Jeybe has left
  624. Jeybe has joined
  625. j.r has left
  626. j.r has joined
  627. j.r has left
  628. j.r has joined
  629. Jeybe has left
  630. Jeybe has joined
  631. Jeybe has left
  632. Jeybe has joined
  633. ths has left
  634. mukt2 has left
  635. LNJ has left
  636. Dele Olajide has left
  637. lovetox has joined
  638. pdurbin has joined
  639. LNJ has joined
  640. Jeybe has left
  641. pdurbin has left
  642. mukt2 has joined
  643. DebXWoody has left
  644. DebXWoody has joined
  645. DebXWoody has left
  646. DebXWoody has joined
  647. DebXWoody has left
  648. Jeybe has joined
  649. alexis has left
  650. lovetox has left
  651. lovetox has joined
  652. lovetox has left
  653. lovetox has joined
  654. lovetox has left
  655. lovetox has joined
  656. lovetox has left
  657. lovetox has joined
  658. lovetox has left
  659. lovetox has joined
  660. lovetox has left
  661. lovetox has joined
  662. lovetox has left
  663. lovetox has joined
  664. lovetox has left
  665. lovetox has joined
  666. lovetox has left
  667. lovetox has joined
  668. lovetox has left
  669. lovetox has joined
  670. lovetox has left
  671. lovetox has joined
  672. lovetox has left
  673. lovetox has joined
  674. Jeybe has left
  675. Jeybe has joined
  676. lovetox has left
  677. lovetox has joined
  678. lovetox has left
  679. lovetox has joined
  680. lovetox has left
  681. adiaholic_ has left
  682. adiaholic_ has joined
  683. neshtaxmpp has joined
  684. adiaholic_ has left
  685. alexis has joined
  686. adiaholic_ has joined
  687. lovetox has joined
  688. lovetox has left
  689. lovetox has joined
  690. lovetox has left
  691. lovetox has joined
  692. Jeybe has left
  693. Jeybe has joined
  694. Jeybe has left
  695. Jeybe has joined
  696. calvin has joined
  697. Jeybe has left
  698. Jeybe has joined
  699. Daniel has left
  700. Daniel has joined
  701. lovetox has left
  702. jonas’ has left
  703. Jeybe has left
  704. Jeybe has joined
  705. jonas’ has joined
  706. xecks has left
  707. Mikaela has left
  708. Jeybe has left
  709. Jeybe has joined
  710. werdan has left
  711. Tobias has left
  712. Jeybe has left
  713. Jeybe has joined
  714. Daniel has left
  715. Daniel has joined
  716. pdurbin has joined
  717. Jeybe has left
  718. Jeybe has joined
  719. Jeybe has left
  720. Jeybe has joined
  721. Jeybe has left
  722. Jeybe has joined
  723. pdurbin has left
  724. alexis has left
  725. Jeybe has left
  726. Jeybe has joined
  727. Jeybe has left
  728. Jeybe has joined
  729. mukt2 has left
  730. wurstsalat has left
  731. wurstsalat has joined
  732. goffi has left
  733. Jeybe has left
  734. j.r has left
  735. Jeybe has joined
  736. j.r has joined
  737. mukt2 has joined
  738. govanify has left
  739. govanify has joined
  740. govanify has left
  741. govanify has joined
  742. alexis has joined
  743. govanify has left
  744. govanify has joined
  745. Jeybe has left
  746. Jeybe has joined
  747. Jeybe has left
  748. Jeybe has joined
  749. Jeybe has left
  750. Jeybe has joined
  751. Daniel has left
  752. j.r has left
  753. j.r has joined
  754. Jeybe has left
  755. Jeybe has joined
  756. alexis has left
  757. Daniel has joined
  758. Jeybe has left
  759. Jeybe has joined
  760. alexis has joined
  761. Jeybe has left
  762. Jeybe has joined
  763. Jeybe has left
  764. Jeybe has joined
  765. robertooo has left
  766. robertooo has joined
  767. eta has left
  768. eta has joined
  769. Jeybe has left
  770. Daniel has left
  771. Jeybe has joined
  772. Daniel has joined
  773. Jeybe has left
  774. Jeybe has joined
  775. marc has left
  776. Jeybe has left
  777. wurstsalat has left
  778. vanitasvitae has left
  779. vanitasvitae has joined
  780. arc has left
  781. arc has joined
  782. arc has left
  783. arc has joined
  784. emus has left
  785. emus has joined
  786. vanitasvitae has left
  787. vanitasvitae has joined
  788. andy has left
  789. vanitasvitae has left
  790. Daniel has left
  791. mukt2 has left
  792. Daniel has joined
  793. mukt2 has joined
  794. vanitasvitae has joined
  795. sonny has left
  796. sonny has joined
  797. vanitasvitae has left
  798. pdurbin has joined
  799. vanitasvitae has joined
  800. mukt2 has left
  801. Daniel has left
  802. Nekit has left
  803. Daniel has joined
  804. pdurbin has left
  805. mukt2 has joined
  806. govanify has left
  807. govanify has joined
  808. mukt2 has left
  809. Seve has left
  810. mukt2 has joined
  811. Wojtek has left
  812. lorddavidiii has left
  813. Daniel has left
  814. Daniel has joined
  815. paul has left
  816. LNJ has left
  817. xsf has left