XSF Discussion - 2020-05-05

00:01:32 govanify has left
00:01:32 govanify has joined
00:03:01 Wojtek has left
00:03:18 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has left
00:04:34 stpeter has joined
00:06:24 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has joined
00:11:54 govanify has left
00:11:55 govanify has joined
00:14:28 mukt2 has left
00:16:38 mukt2 has joined
00:21:55 stpeter has left
00:21:55 Nekit has left
00:35:03 arc has joined
00:40:05 govanify has left
00:40:05 govanify has joined
00:48:15 govanify has left
00:48:15 govanify has joined
00:50:37 mukt2 has left
00:50:45 emus has left
00:58:17 govanify has left
00:58:18 govanify has joined
01:01:30 moparisthebest has left
01:02:10 moparisthebest has joined
01:10:18 govanify has left
01:10:18 govanify has joined
01:12:20 stpeter has joined
01:15:27 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has left
01:22:15 govanify has left
01:22:15 govanify has joined
01:27:36 arc has left
01:27:37 arc has joined
01:29:57 rion has left
01:31:09 rion has joined
01:36:10 govanify has left
01:36:10 govanify has joined
01:39:58 pdurbin has joined
01:43:38 Shell has left
01:44:57 Shell has joined
01:49:59 govanify has left
01:49:59 govanify has joined
01:58:16 pdurbin has left
01:59:57 Shell has left
02:09:13 govanify has left
02:09:13 govanify has joined
02:16:43 govanify has left
02:16:44 govanify has joined
02:17:33 pdurbin has joined
02:22:34 govanify has left
02:22:34 govanify has joined
02:22:57 arc has left
02:23:06 arc has joined
02:23:46 arc has left
02:23:51 arc has joined
02:23:58 moparisthebest has left
02:24:38 moparisthebest has joined
02:25:17 arc has left
02:25:26 stpeter has left
02:25:31 arc has joined
02:29:54 arc has left
02:29:54 arc has joined
02:39:42 arc has left
02:39:43 arc has joined
02:40:12 arc has left
02:40:33 arc has joined
02:45:26 arc has left
02:45:26 arc has joined
02:48:56 neshtaxmpp has joined
02:54:13 govanify has left
02:54:13 govanify has joined
02:56:55 aj has joined
03:03:14 govanify has left
03:03:14 govanify has joined
03:05:58 calvin has left
03:09:09 neshtaxmpp has left
03:11:41 neshtaxmpp has joined
03:14:15 aj has left
03:18:11 Yagiza has joined
03:18:36 karoshi has joined
03:18:37 karoshi has left
03:18:46 xsf has left
03:18:49 xsf has joined
03:21:29 xsf has left
03:21:29 xsf has joined
03:32:47 govanify has left
03:32:47 govanify has joined
03:40:02 DebXWoody has joined
03:45:17 govanify has left
03:45:17 govanify has joined
03:45:35 arc has left
03:45:35 arc has joined
03:50:48 govanify has left
03:50:48 govanify has joined
03:52:12 neshtaxmpp has left
03:54:43 neshtaxmpp has joined
03:59:43 sonny has left
03:59:44 sonny has joined
04:05:57 arc has left
04:05:58 arc has joined
04:06:51 DebXWoody has left
04:06:56 arc has left
04:06:56 arc has joined
04:21:36 mukt2 has joined
04:25:40 Tobias has joined
04:27:25 DebXWoody has joined
04:34:14 govanify has left
04:34:15 govanify has joined
04:44:25 sonny has left
04:44:29 sonny has joined
04:45:31 mukt2 has left
04:46:31 Mikaela has joined
04:48:36 mukt2 has joined
04:54:17 mimi89999 has joined
04:56:29 sonny has left
04:56:50 sonny has joined
05:00:43 mukt2 has left
05:03:19 karoshi has joined
05:03:34 LNJ has joined
05:07:31 sonny has left
05:07:57 sonny has joined
05:19:48 alexis has left
05:20:38 mukt2 has joined
05:23:05 alexis has joined
05:28:13 govanify has left
05:28:13 govanify has joined
05:28:45 Neustradamus has left
05:31:34 mukt2 has left
05:33:05 mukt2 has joined
05:34:39 waqas has left
05:35:15 werdan has joined
05:36:45 lorddavidiii has joined
05:46:08 nyco has left
05:47:39 mukt2 has left
05:48:53 mukt2 has joined
05:53:57 arc has left
05:53:58 arc has joined
05:57:29 werdan has left
06:06:09 Jeybe has joined
06:07:11 Jeybe has left
06:07:18 Jeybe has joined
06:08:45 j.r has left
06:08:45 Jeybe has left
06:08:52 Jeybe has joined
06:11:44 Nekit has joined
06:11:45 emus has joined
06:15:36 sonny has left
06:15:37 sonny has joined
06:21:24 nyco has joined
06:21:35 j.r has joined
06:23:48 adiaholic_ has left
06:23:50 adiaholic_ has joined
06:26:24 andrey.g has left
06:28:12 andy has joined
06:32:25 LNJ has left
06:35:36 lskdjf has joined
06:40:12 adiaholic_ has left
06:40:14 adiaholic_ has joined
06:46:12 j.r has left
06:46:20 j.r has joined
06:47:50 j.r has left
06:49:04 j.r has joined
06:50:47 j.r has left
06:51:05 j.r has joined
06:51:32 derdaniel has joined
06:53:12 j.r has left
06:53:20 j.r has joined
06:53:23 derdaniel has left
07:00:01 govanify has left
07:05:19 govanify has joined
07:06:13 Steve Kille has left
07:10:43 Steve Kille has joined
07:10:58 gav has left
07:10:58 Mikaela has left
07:11:05 Jeybe has left
07:11:20 Jeybe has joined
07:11:45 Mikaela has joined
07:12:08 gav has joined
07:14:26 xecks has joined
07:21:05 mukt2 has left
07:21:05 mukt2 has joined
07:47:05 adiaholic_ has left
07:47:07 adiaholic_ has joined
07:49:16 andy has left
07:51:35 adiaholic_ has left
07:51:37 adiaholic_ has joined
07:55:57 andy has joined
07:56:38 adiaholic_ has left
07:56:40 adiaholic_ has joined
07:57:56 adiaholic_ has left
07:57:58 adiaholic_ has joined
07:58:01 vanitasvitae has left
07:58:46 vanitasvitae has joined
08:04:08 karoshi has left
08:04:27 karoshi has joined
08:10:45 sonny has left
08:10:46 sonny has joined
08:18:30 neshtaxmpp has left
08:20:42 paul has left
08:20:43 paul has joined
08:33:41 adiaholic_ has left
08:33:43 adiaholic_ has joined
08:37:34 adiaholic_ has left
08:37:36 adiaholic_ has joined
08:44:49 Dele Olajide has joined
08:49:51 Dele Olajide has left
08:50:47 adiaholic_ has left
08:50:49 adiaholic_ has joined
08:59:29 neshtaxmpp has joined
09:02:30 eta has left
09:02:32 eta has joined
09:04:57 debacle has joined
09:14:50 adiaholic_ has left
09:14:52 adiaholic_ has joined
09:18:22 sonny has left
09:19:16 edhelas has left
09:19:49 edhelas has joined
09:21:32 Jeybe has left
09:21:48 Jeybe has joined
09:28:53 debacle has left
09:34:43 karoshi has left
09:35:23 karoshi has joined
09:37:58 mukt2 has left
09:39:38 emus has left
09:42:37 emus has joined
09:43:13 mukt2 has joined
09:43:21 !XSF_Martin has left
09:44:03 !XSF_Martin has joined
10:14:31 Jeybe has left
10:14:35 arc has left
10:14:35 arc has joined
10:14:43 karoshi has left
10:14:48 Jeybe has joined
10:15:24 karoshi has joined
10:16:51 Jeybe has left
10:17:06 Jeybe has joined
10:23:26 adiaholic_ has left
10:23:28 adiaholic_ has joined
10:29:09 lovetox has left
10:30:27 Neustradamus has joined
10:32:20 Neustradamus_ has joined
10:33:42 werdan has joined
10:35:21 Zash has left
10:35:43 sonny has joined
10:36:12 Zash has joined
10:38:33 werdan has left
10:38:39 southerntofu has left
10:42:03 royalsexy4u has joined
10:42:28 royalsexy4u has left
10:45:06 Shell has joined
10:45:18 Jeybe has left
10:45:25 Jeybe has joined
10:45:39 karoshi has left
10:46:19 karoshi has joined
10:57:46 goffi has joined
10:58:37 goffi has left
10:58:39 Shell has left
10:58:50 Shell has joined
11:01:16 Neustradamus has left
11:01:16 Neustradamus has joined
11:01:17 Neustradamus has left
11:06:52 arc has left
11:06:54 arc has joined
11:07:35 Neustradamus has joined
11:08:11 mukt2 has left
11:08:20 debacle has joined
11:08:30 Neustradamus_ has left
11:08:52 Neustradamus_ has joined
11:11:12 adiaholic_ has left
11:11:14 adiaholic_ has joined
11:12:53 mukt2 has joined
11:15:48 sonny has left
11:15:51 sonny has joined
11:22:43 adiaholic_ has left
11:24:10 adiaholic_ has joined
11:29:54 pdurbin has left
11:30:05 adiaholic_ has left
11:30:07 adiaholic_ has joined
11:34:57 adiaholic_ has left
11:34:59 adiaholic_ has joined
11:35:28 adiaholic_ has left
11:35:30 adiaholic_ has joined
11:41:35 adiaholic_ has left
11:41:37 adiaholic_ has joined
11:46:06 karoshi has left
11:46:48 karoshi has joined
11:59:41 xsf has left
11:59:59 lovetox has joined
12:04:33 Shell has left
12:06:05 andy has left
12:08:34 calvin has joined
12:12:50 andy has joined
12:28:40 sonny has left
12:28:41 sonny has joined
12:43:55 goffi has joined
12:45:50 karoshi has left
12:46:30 karoshi has joined
12:46:31 karoshi has left
13:05:20 alameyo has left
13:05:21 alameyo has joined
13:05:46 Shell has joined
13:10:20 adiaholic_ has left
13:10:22 adiaholic_ has joined
13:16:52 Shell has left
13:16:53 Shell has joined
13:23:41 LNJ has joined
13:24:03 pdurbin has joined
13:45:09 stpeter has joined
13:45:56 pdurbin has left
13:47:15 karoshi has joined
13:48:34 adiaholic_ has left
13:48:37 adiaholic_ has joined
13:58:13 Guus has left
13:58:13 alameyo has left
13:59:35 Guus has joined
14:01:02 stpeter has left
14:03:34 alameyo has joined
14:14:34 mukt2 has left
14:25:35 mukt2 has joined
14:26:35 sonny has left
14:26:37 sonny has joined
14:29:23 alexis has left
14:31:26 goffi has left
14:31:59 Dele Olajide has joined
14:34:00 werdan has joined
14:34:09 karoshi has left
14:34:47 karoshi has joined
14:40:03 derdaniel has joined
14:40:21 derdaniel has left
14:44:01 krauq has left
14:44:36 Shell has left
14:47:40 Dele Olajide has left
14:51:11 Dele Olajide has joined
14:52:01 Jeybe has left
14:52:20 Jeybe has joined
14:55:41 krauq has joined
14:57:07 werdan has left
15:04:00 werdan has joined
15:04:16 bear has left
15:05:39 karoshi has left
15:08:14 karoshi has joined
15:11:58 andrey.g has joined
15:24:03 pdurbin has joined
15:31:03 mukt2 has left
15:36:11 emus has left
15:36:20 emus has joined
15:38:29 stpeter has joined
15:40:26 pdurbin has left
15:41:03 werdan has left
15:41:19 werdan has joined
15:43:17 mukt2 has joined
15:48:12 bear has joined
15:52:09 werdan has left
15:58:50 sonny has left
15:58:59 sonny has joined
16:12:53 Jeybe has left
16:15:55 Wojtek has joined
16:29:45 Yagiza has left
16:34:36 karoshi has left
16:35:15 karoshi has joined
16:36:17 Daniel has left
16:37:41 Daniel has joined
16:55:00 alexis has joined
16:55:14 adiaholic_ has left
16:56:22 nyco has left
16:58:37 nyco has joined
17:00:06 Jeybe has joined
17:03:30 govanify has left
17:03:31 govanify has joined
17:06:29 goffi has joined
17:07:07 adiaholic_ has joined
17:07:56 govanify has left
17:07:57 govanify has joined
17:12:24 contrapunctus has joined
17:13:44 adiaholic_ has left
17:13:48 contrapunctus has left
17:20:54 govanify has left
17:20:54 govanify has joined
17:21:01 debacle has left
17:23:38 goffi has left
17:24:03 pdurbin has joined
17:25:38 govanify has left
17:25:39 govanify has joined
17:26:09 govanify has left
17:26:10 govanify has joined
17:26:28 goffi has joined
17:28:35 sonny has left
17:28:36 sonny has joined
17:29:13 goffi has left
17:30:45 adiaholic_ has joined
17:30:55 pdurbin has left
17:35:05 Yagiza has joined
17:37:21 werdan has joined
17:46:26 govanify has left
17:46:27 govanify has joined
17:47:56 debacle has joined
17:48:18 debacle has left
17:48:24 debacle has joined
17:50:22 arc has left
17:50:23 arc has joined
17:58:00 edhelas has left
17:58:44 edhelas has joined
18:04:12 goffi has joined
18:06:08 neshtaxmpp has left
18:06:10 neshtaxmpp has joined
18:07:07 neshtaxmpp has left
18:07:43 neshtaxmpp has joined
18:12:00 adiaholic_ has left
18:12:02 adiaholic_ has joined
18:22:59 calvin has left
18:32:52 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has joined
18:38:38 govanify has left
18:38:38 govanify has joined
18:39:22 contrapunctus has joined
18:45:01 flow larma, do you remember why we came to the conclusion that FORM_FIELD fields must not explicitly declare a type on form submission (form type 'submit')?
18:45:55 flow I was about to create a new PR with dwd's feedback incooperated, but I can't remember what caused your PR in the first place
18:46:17 flow I think there was some indirection over another XEP involved, but I do not seem to recall
18:46:47 larma I think the general rule for form submit is that the type is not required or something like that
18:46:57 arc has left
18:46:57 arc has joined
18:47:07 larma because type is mostly for user interface and submitted forms are not displayed to user interfaces
18:47:31 flow exactly, that is what I also assumed
18:47:33 alexis has left
18:47:48 flow but then I looked at xep4 where submit forms have field types explicitly stated in the example
18:47:49 Dele Olajide2 has joined
18:49:14 flow so I look for the text in the specification which says "you don't need to explicitly specify the field type on submission" which I can refer too
18:50:49 flow ahh found it
18:51:37 flow soo I actually think dwd rejected this on the false grounds
18:51:52 flow soo I actually think dwd rejected this on false grounds
18:52:46 larma XEP-0004 §3.2 > For data forms of type "submit", inclusion of the 'type' attribute is OPTIONAL, since the form-processing entity is assumed to understand the data types associated with forms that it processes.
18:52:52 larma ah you already had it 😉
18:55:12 contrapunctus has left
19:06:48 afrogeek has joined
19:08:05 afrogeek has left
19:08:20 afrogeek has joined
19:19:06 adiaholic_ has left
19:19:08 adiaholic_ has joined
19:22:36 rion has left
19:23:11 afrogeek has left
19:24:04 pdurbin has joined
19:27:58 Nekit has left
19:31:05 rion has joined
19:34:19 pdurbin has left
19:37:56 Yagiza has left
19:38:54 Yagiza has joined
19:40:35 stpeter has left
19:44:49 Yagiza has left
19:48:09 stpeter has joined
19:50:42 lovetox has left
19:56:13 Dele Olajide2 has left
19:58:19 lovetox has joined
19:59:05 stpeter has left
19:59:06 stpeter has joined
20:04:42 robertooo has left
20:06:25 DebXWoody has left
20:20:59 Mikaela has left
20:29:51 goffi has left
20:31:03 Maranda has left
20:31:05 Maranda has joined
20:39:32 karoshi has left
20:45:21 karoshi has joined
20:47:02 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has left
20:51:52 werdan has left
20:56:35 Jeybe has left
20:56:49 Jeybe has joined
20:57:28 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has joined
21:07:51 Nekit has joined
21:09:38 Tobias has left
21:09:43 karoshi has left
21:09:47 Nekit has left
21:09:48 Nekit has joined
21:09:48 karoshi has joined
21:12:55 alexis has joined
21:18:00 govanify has left
21:18:01 govanify has joined
21:19:44 Jeybe has left
21:19:56 Jeybe has joined
21:24:03 pdurbin has joined
21:35:50 govanify has left
21:35:50 govanify has joined
21:36:20 lovetox has left
21:36:54 adiaholic_ has left
21:36:57 adiaholic_ has joined
21:40:56 krauq has left
21:43:19 pdurbin has left
21:50:42 krauq has joined
22:00:04 lovetox has joined
22:09:25 Jeybe has left
22:10:44 xecks has left
22:20:56 moparisthebest has left
22:21:22 moparisthebest has joined
22:26:19 andy has left
22:31:28 mukt2 has left
22:31:43 arc has left
22:31:44 arc has joined
22:38:13 moparisthebest has left
22:38:40 moparisthebest has joined
22:43:11 mukt2 has joined
22:46:13 Wojtek has left
22:46:17 Wojtek has joined
22:46:59 Wojtek has left
22:50:19 Daniel has left
22:51:16 govanify has left
22:51:17 govanify has joined
22:51:29 Daniel has joined
22:53:41 mukt2 has left
22:54:49 Wojtek has joined
22:56:33 xsf has joined
23:00:50 waqas has joined
23:01:51 darkijah has joined
23:11:28 Wojtek has left
23:11:32 Wojtek has joined
23:11:59 Nekit has left
23:12:14 Wojtek has left
23:12:19 Wojtek has joined
23:13:00 Wojtek has left
23:13:05 Wojtek has joined
23:13:46 Wojtek has left
23:13:51 Wojtek has joined
23:14:33 Wojtek has left
23:14:37 Wojtek has joined
23:15:19 Wojtek has left
23:15:24 Wojtek has joined
23:16:05 Wojtek has left
23:16:14 andrey.g has left
23:18:53 darkijah has left
23:18:57 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has left
23:21:02 darkijah has joined
23:22:34 darkijah has left
23:24:04 pdurbin has joined
23:24:54 darkijah has joined
23:28:47 karoshi has left
23:32:58 pdurbin has left
23:33:50 DarkiJah - JesusIsGodAlmighty.Life has joined
23:35:11 darkijah has left
23:35:39 darkijah has joined
23:38:11 Wojtek has joined
23:40:09 Wojtek has left
23:40:14 Wojtek has joined
23:40:55 Wojtek has left
23:46:31 arc has left
23:46:32 arc has joined
23:47:35 arc has left
23:47:36 arc has joined
23:49:34 arc has left
23:49:58 arc has joined
23:57:10 mimi89999 has left
23:57:17 mimi89999 has joined
23:59:34 arc has left
23:59:35 arc has joined