XSF Discussion - 2020-07-15

  1. mukt2 has left

  2. paul has left

  3. moparisthebest has left

  4. mukt2 has joined

  5. waqas has joined

  6. arc has left

  7. arc has joined

  8. moparisthebest has joined

  9. Jeybe has left

  10. emus has left

  11. mukt2 has left

  12. alameyo has left

  13. mukt2 has joined

  14. mukt2 has left

  15. mukt2 has joined

  16. Seve has left

  17. arc has left

  18. arc has joined

  19. arc has left

  20. arc has joined

  21. neshtaxmpp has left

  22. neshtaxmpp has joined

  23. lobodelrayo has left

  24. lobodelrayo has joined

  25. lobodelrayo has left

  26. lobodelrayo has joined

  27. mukt2 has left

  28. thorsten has left

  29. thorsten has joined

  30. mukt2 has joined

  31. stpeter has left

  32. mukt2 has left

  33. mukt2 has joined

  34. Neustradamus has joined

  35. stpeter has joined

  36. arc has left

  37. arc has joined

  38. arc has left

  39. arc has joined

  40. neshtaxmpp has left

  41. mukt2 has left

  42. stpeter has left

  43. mukt2 has joined

  44. LNJ has left

  45. thorsten has left

  46. thorsten has joined

  47. mukt2 has left

  48. Seve has joined

  49. mukt2 has joined

  50. alameyo has joined

  51. lobodelrayo has left

  52. Tobias has joined

  53. neshtaxmpp has joined

  54. mukt2 has left

  55. neshtaxmpp has left

  56. Nekit has joined

  57. Mikaela has joined

  58. arc has left

  59. arc has joined

  60. mimi89999 has left

  61. mimi89999 has joined

  62. mukt2 has joined

  63. lorddavidiii has joined

  64. arc has left

  65. arc has joined

  66. arc has left

  67. arc has joined

  68. stpeter has joined

  69. paul has joined

  70. stpeter has left

  71. waqas has left

  72. mukt2 has left

  73. krauq has left

  74. arc has left

  75. arc has joined

  76. Neustradamus has left

  77. mukt2 has joined

  78. Daniel has left

  79. arc has left

  80. arc has joined

  81. krauq has joined

  82. arc has left

  83. arc has joined

  84. jcbrand has joined

  85. Daniel has joined

  86. arc has left

  87. arc has joined

  88. debacle has joined

  89. nyco has left

  90. j.r has left

  91. Dele Olajide has joined

  92. Jeybe has joined

  93. nyco has joined

  94. mukt2 has left

  95. arc has left

  96. arc has joined

  97. mukt2 has joined

  98. sonny has left

  99. sonny has joined

  100. j.r has joined

  101. sonny has left

  102. sonny has joined

  103. sonny has left

  104. sonny has joined

  105. emus has joined

  106. stpeter has joined

  107. lskdjf has joined

  108. !XSF_Martin has left

  109. !XSF_Martin has joined

  110. arc has left

  111. arc has joined

  112. stpeter has left

  113. marc has joined

  114. floretta has left

  115. floretta has joined

  116. dwd has left

  117. dwd has joined

  118. marc has left

  119. karoshi has joined

  120. mukt2 has left

  121. mukt2 has joined

  122. oguzeducationcenter has joined

  123. emus

    Hello everyone, it's not just mid-week but also mid-month! If you have news of your projects or projects of interest please don't forget to bring it over to the XMPP Newsletter we draft here: https://github.com/xsf/xmpp.org/pull/730 Questions & help welcome!

  124. Steve Kille has left

  125. Steve Kille has joined

  126. sonny has left

  127. sonny has joined

  128. mukt2 has left

  129. thorsten has left

  130. thorsten has joined

  131. goffi has joined

  132. sonny has left

  133. sonny has joined

  134. debacle has left

  135. darkijah has left

  136. mukt2 has joined

  137. sonny has left

  138. sonny has joined

  139. arc has left

  140. arc has joined

  141. stpeter has joined

  142. arc has left

  143. arc has joined

  144. Shell has joined

  145. mukt2 has left

  146. mukt2 has joined

  147. oguzeducationcenter has left

  148. oguzeducationcenter has joined

  149. stpeter has left

  150. debacle has joined

  151. debacle has left

  152. oguzeducationcenter has left

  153. oguzeducationcenter has joined

  154. mukt2 has left

  155. sonny has left

  156. sonny has joined

  157. thorsten has left

  158. LNJ has joined

  159. arc has left

  160. arc has joined

  161. arc has left

  162. arc has joined

  163. arc has left

  164. arc has joined

  165. papatutuwawa has joined

  166. arc has left

  167. arc has joined

  168. adiaholic_ has left

  169. mukt2 has joined

  170. oguzeducationcenter has left

  171. sonny has left

  172. sonny has joined

  173. Andrzej has joined

  174. floretta has left

  175. Shell has left

  176. oguzeducationcenter has joined

  177. sonny has left

  178. sonny has joined

  179. sonny has left

  180. sonny has joined

  181. Half-Shot has left

  182. Bifrost Bot has left

  183. uhoreg has left

  184. karoshi has left

  185. Half-Shot has joined

  186. uhoreg has joined

  187. Bifrost Bot has joined

  188. Half-Shot has left

  189. Bifrost Bot has left

  190. uhoreg has left

  191. Half-Shot has joined

  192. uhoreg has joined

  193. Bifrost Bot has joined

  194. Bifrost Bot has left

  195. Half-Shot has left

  196. uhoreg has left

  197. Half-Shot has joined

  198. uhoreg has joined

  199. Bifrost Bot has joined

  200. floretta has joined

  201. adiaholic_ has joined

  202. papatutuwawa has left

  203. andrey.g has joined

  204. nyco has left

  205. nyco has joined

  206. debacle has joined

  207. mukt2 has left

  208. oguzeducationcenter has left

  209. mukt2 has joined

  210. oguzeducationcenter has joined

  211. arc has left

  212. arc has joined

  213. nyco has left

  214. Neustradamus has joined

  215. xsf has left

  216. marc has joined

  217. arc has left

  218. arc has joined

  219. mukt2 has left

  220. nyco has joined

  221. papatutuwawa has joined

  222. stpeter has joined

  223. sonny has left

  224. sonny has joined

  225. govanify has left

  226. govanify has joined

  227. arc has left

  228. arc has joined

  229. xsf has joined

  230. karoshi has joined

  231. arc has left

  232. arc has joined

  233. arc has left

  234. arc has joined

  235. sonny has left

  236. sonny has joined

  237. stpeter has left

  238. mukt2 has joined

  239. darkijah has joined

  240. arc has left

  241. arc has joined

  242. krauq has left

  243. mukt2 has left

  244. Shell has joined

  245. eta . o O ( maybe we should copy the Matrix folks and have TWIX: This Week In XMPP )

  246. mukt2 has joined

  247. Daniel


  248. !XSF_Martin


  249. Daniel

    oh riot is now element

  250. Half-Shot has left

  251. Bifrost Bot has left

  252. uhoreg has left

  253. Half-Shot has joined

  254. uhoreg has joined

  255. Bifrost Bot has joined

  256. sonny has left

  257. oguzeducationcenter has left

  258. sonny has joined

  259. Daniel

    that's easier to google…

  260. krauq has joined

  261. goffi

    they've also got a huge contract with German education apparently, I don't know if XMPP was on the table, but if it was not there is something going wrong.

  262. Daniel

    well there is nobody who could have put it on their table

  263. oguzeducationcenter has joined

  264. Maranda has left

  265. goffi

    I have no idea how this kind of things are negociated and who brings project proposition. Is it not supposed to be a call for bids or something like that?

  266. Daniel

    i guess. but 'XMPP' is not an entity that could put in a bid for something like that

  267. Daniel

    and as an individual freelancer you pratically (and probably rightfully) have no chance at winning that

  268. Shell has left

  269. Shell has joined

  270. eta

    yeah, what they're selling is their hosting service

  271. eta

    apart from isode maybe nobody in the XMPPverse is really doing that

  272. sonny has left

  273. goffi


  274. sonny has joined

  275. Daniel

    they don’t have clients

  276. Daniel

    if you are buying this for the use in schools you want a solution and not building blocks

  277. nyco has left

  278. goffi

    alright, makes sense.

  279. nyco has joined

  280. Shell has left

  281. Shell has joined

  282. eta

    evil plan, write a matrix c2s to XMPP translation layer, then undercut element because server hosting won't be as resource intensive

  283. Shell has left

  284. Shell has joined

  285. emus

    > eta . o O ( maybe we should copy the Matrix folks and have TWIX: This Week In XMPP ) I dont unterstand what you wanna say?

  286. eta

    emus: don't worry, I'm just joking

  287. eta

    emus: (by the way, I should probably submit my WhatsApp bridge to your newsletter!)

  288. Maranda has joined

  289. emus

    Are you still making jokes? 😦

  290. sonny has left

  291. sonny has joined

  292. eta

    nope, this actually exists

  293. Shell has left

  294. emus

    Okay, yes then feel free

  295. mukt2 has left

  296. arc has left

  297. arc has joined

  298. sonny has left

  299. sonny has joined

  300. mukt2 has joined

  301. andrey.g has left

  302. sonny has left

  303. sonny has joined

  304. papatutuwawa has left

  305. sonny has left

  306. sonny has joined

  307. mukt2 has left

  308. mukt2 has joined

  309. calvin has joined

  310. lorddavidiii has left

  311. Andrzej has left

  312. stpeter has joined

  313. calvin has left

  314. mukt2 has left

  315. emus has left

  316. emus has joined

  317. Shell has joined

  318. sonny has left

  319. sonny has joined

  320. mukt2 has joined

  321. stpeter has left

  322. APach has left

  323. APach has joined

  324. APach has left

  325. APach has joined

  326. lorddavidiii has joined

  327. Dele Olajide has left

  328. oguzeducationcenter has left

  329. j.r has left

  330. Dele Olajide has joined

  331. oguzeducationcenter has joined

  332. pasdesushi has joined

  333. Andrzej has joined

  334. Andrzej has left

  335. oguzeducationcenter has left

  336. sonny has left

  337. sonny has joined

  338. Dele Olajide has left

  339. pasdesushi has left

  340. pasdesushi has joined

  341. sonny has left

  342. sonny has joined

  343. j.r has joined

  344. mimi89999 has left

  345. pasdesushi has left

  346. pasdesushi has joined

  347. mimi89999 has joined

  348. j.r has left

  349. sonny has left

  350. j.r has joined

  351. sonny has joined

  352. Andrzej has joined

  353. goffi has left

  354. stpeter has joined

  355. Dele Olajide has joined

  356. sonny has left

  357. sonny has joined

  358. Dele Olajide has left

  359. Dele Olajide has joined

  360. Shell has left

  361. sonny has left

  362. sonny has joined

  363. goffi has joined

  364. mukt2 has left

  365. sonny has left

  366. sonny has joined

  367. mukt2 has joined

  368. mukt2 has left

  369. sonny has left

  370. sonny has joined

  371. arc has left

  372. arc has joined

  373. arc has left

  374. arc has joined

  375. arc has left

  376. arc has joined

  377. govanify has left

  378. govanify has joined

  379. mukt2 has joined

  380. Andrzej has left

  381. neshtaxmpp has joined

  382. Guus has left

  383. Guus has joined

  384. govanify has left

  385. govanify has joined

  386. larma has left

  387. floretta has left

  388. Yagiza has joined

  389. larma has joined

  390. adiaholic_ has left

  391. adiaholic_ has joined

  392. marc has left

  393. marc has joined

  394. govanify has left

  395. govanify has joined

  396. sonny has left

  397. sonny has joined

  398. marc has left

  399. marc has joined

  400. govanify has left

  401. govanify has joined

  402. nyco has left

  403. govanify has left

  404. sonny has left

  405. govanify has joined

  406. sonny has joined

  407. Neustradamus has left

  408. Neustradamus has joined

  409. govanify has left

  410. govanify has joined

  411. lobodelrayo has joined

  412. marc has left

  413. eevvoor has joined

  414. marc has joined

  415. nyco has joined

  416. eevvoor

    We have one strong supporter for XMPP in the German jouth authorities.

  417. sonny has left

  418. sonny has joined

  419. eevvoor

    But where have you heard that German schools start to use Matrix? This is new to me.

  420. adiaholic_ has left

  421. adiaholic_ has joined

  422. pep.


  423. eevvoor

    I know only of one district starting to use mailbox.org as mailserver which means additionally an XMPP-account.

  424. eevvoor

    > The deal announced on Wednesday will see the German states of Schleswig-Holstein and Hamburg deploy a Matrix-based solution for 500,000 users across public offices and education as part of its wider adoption of open source cloud strategy Project Phoenix being carried out by IT provider Dataport. Hm this is weird.

  425. eevvoor

    thx for the link pep.

  426. papatutuwawa has joined

  427. marc has left

  428. govanify has left

  429. govanify has joined

  430. mac87 has joined

  431. mac87 has left

  432. pasdesushi has left

  433. Wojtek has joined

  434. govanify has left

  435. govanify has joined

  436. pep.

    Is there anything at the IETF saying the XSF has a specific role when it comes to XMPP?

  437. pep.

    6120 has multiple mentions of "XSF" but it all seems very informal and not exclusive

  438. Zash

    Does it need to?

  439. pep.

    I'm just curious to know the current state

  440. eevvoor

    would be better ...

  441. eevvoor

    ... my guess

  442. pep.

    eevvoor, I'm not entirely sure, but that's not what I'm asking here anyway

  443. eevvoor

    do other protocols do that? pep.

  444. pasdesushi has joined

  445. pep.

    do what exactly? Define a separate entity to take care of them?

  446. mukt2 has left

  447. eevvoor


  448. Zash

    Other than the delegation of the `urn:xmpp` namespace, I don't think there's any need for anything special from anyhere.

  449. pep.

    eevvoor, don't know

  450. pep.

    Zash, again, not asking about needs

  451. eevvoor

    That would be interesting to check.

  452. Zash

    pep.: What are you asking?

  453. pep.

    The current state

  454. pep.

    "IS there anything at the IETF saying the XSF has a specific role when it comes to XMPP"

  455. pep.

    "Is there anything at the IETF saying the XSF has a specific role when it comes to XMPP"

  456. Zash

    I don't think there is.

  457. Zash

    Anything special comes from actually publishing XEPs.

  458. emus has left

  459. Holger

    So I can just publish Holger's Extension Protocols and the IETF Police can do ... *nothing*.

  460. Zash

    Anyone could publish XMPP extensions, there is no requirement that it goes through the XSF.

  461. Daniel

    I don't think we are sanctioned be the ietf or anything if that's what you mean

  462. moparisthebest

    one could even publish XMPP extensions as google docs in russian, if one were so inclined

  463. pep.

    Daniel: Yeah that's what I was asking, and I didn't think either but I thought it might be good to confirm

  464. Daniel

    I also don't know of a lot of other extensible protocols that don't remain with the ietf

  465. Daniel

    For example IMAP extensions are still ietf

  466. pep.

    moparisthebest, imagine somebody publishing that on a random website (xmpp.org) in english :p

  467. Zash

    Google published a bunch of docs on their custom extensions.

  468. Daniel

    Or ietf working groups

  469. govanify has left

  470. govanify has joined

  471. Daniel

    Which makes you wonder what lead to that decision

  472. pep.

    I'm curious why the XSF "had to" be a separate entity, I'd be interested to know the story behind this

  473. pasdesushi has left

  474. pep.


  475. mukt2 has joined

  476. Zash

    Probably because it already existed before the inital RFCs were created.

  477. Zash

    You could ask the same about the IETF

  478. pasdesushi has joined

  479. pep.

    I also wonder what made the XSF (or JSF at the time) decide to go through the IETF process for some but not all their specs

  480. Zash

    The IETF isn't even an organization AIUI, it's like an activity organized by some other organizations.

  481. Holger

    Kinda obvious that anyone is free to publish custom extensions. I guess the fun situation would be if someone forked the XSF and claimed to be THE XMPP standardization organization.

  482. Zash

    pep.: Roughly the same reasons you'd go to the XSF with XEPs.

  483. pep.

    (my question being somewhat similar to the one above, why is there a need for the XSF at all)

  484. pep.

    Zash, "legitimacy"? But then are other specs not legitimate? :p

  485. Zash

    No, review by other people.

  486. pep.

    And other specs don't need review? :P

  487. pep.

    Just thinking out loud, there is not specific point I'm trying to make

  488. Zash

    You know that someone (at least Council in our case) looked at a XEP and said "this isn't terrible"

  489. pep.

    I wonder if merging as an IETF working group has ever been considered during the less active years

  490. pep.

    (or at all)

  491. Zash

    That would probably have worked too.

  492. pasdesushi has left

  493. Daniel

    I don't think there are significant upsides or down sides of being a working group

  494. eevvoor

    can the XSF be both? Itsself and an IETF working group?

  495. pasdesushi has joined

  496. pep.

    I'm not sure it would be "The XSF" being an IETF working group but the same members

  497. Daniel

    Meaning I don't think that would benefit anyone in 'less active years'

  498. Daniel

    Work either gets done or it doesn't

  499. pep.

    Daniel, maybe it's slightly more visible to IETF people? dunno. I'm not really familiar with IETF

  500. eevvoor

    so it would be a mirror pep. ;)

  501. citizenzibb has left

  502. citizenzibb has joined

  503. citizenzibb has left

  504. citizenzibb has joined

  505. citizenzibb has left

  506. citizenzibb has joined

  507. citizenzibb has left

  508. citizenzibb has joined

  509. pep.

    But also we could share stuff like the infra etc. (using their ML and maybe some more if there is?)

  510. citizenzibb has left

  511. citizenzibb has joined

  512. eevvoor

    every xep to an rfc :D (disclaimer: really just a joke)

  513. citizenzibb has left

  514. citizenzibb has joined

  515. eevvoor

    ML is what pep.?

  516. Zash


  517. pep.

    eevvoor, Mailing List

  518. eevvoor

    ah :D

  519. APach has left

  520. pep.

    8800 RFCs.. I'm sure they can adopt another 400s :p

  521. Zash

    As always, some things are easier to do if you're independent. Other things are harder.

  522. pep.

    June 2020: JSON Canonicalization Scheme (RFC8785). Finally they get to it?

  523. moparisthebest

    then the XSF would simply exist to managed the Jabber trademark? (assuming it's still legally able to do so, still haven't seen proof of this)

  524. Zash

    A support group for XMPP developers?

  525. moparisthebest

    before someone links all the PDFs from xmpp.org they have all expired

  526. pasdesushi has left

  527. adiaholic_ has left

  528. sonny has left

  529. sonny has joined

  530. pasdesushi has joined

  531. flow

    pep.> But also we could share stuff like the infra etc. (using their ML and maybe some more if there is?) there is already an XMPP ML for the concluded XMPP WG

  532. pep.

    flow, yeah I do remember that

  533. flow

    i think one could also try to get an xmpp extension published as rfc

  534. flow

    but without an working group adopting the I-D, I'd assume that will require some contacts within the ietf to actually happen (cf. xmpp grid)

  535. pep.

    Sure, just like IoT stuff is being/has been published at the IEEE

  536. krauq has left

  537. pasdesushi has left

  538. pasdesushi has joined

  539. mukt2 has left

  540. mukt2 has joined

  541. Nekit has left

  542. adiaholic_ has joined

  543. APach has joined

  544. pasdesushi has left

  545. pasdesushi has joined

  546. stpeter

    Just catching up on the discussion. A few points: (1) the JSF predated our involvement with the IETF by a few years (2) the JSF was created to publish open documentation of the Jabber protocols and to add extensions in an open way too (3) we decided to formalize the core protocols at the IETF because we thought it would improve the quality/security of the core and also increase awareness / lead to more adoption especially by organizations that care about a more formal stamp of approval such as corporations and governments (4) there is no formal agreement in place between the IETF and the XSF about the division of responsibilities because we have a good working relationship with IETF folks and they prefer not to create formal agreements unless the working relationship isn't so healthy (5) yes, anyone can create and publish XMPP extensions but it's helpful to have a community of practice where we can review each other's work and therefore (we hope) produce better protocols for the sake of interoperability (6) I have sometimes considered the option of a separate RFC "stream" for XSF specs (there are already streams for IETF, IAB, IRTF, and "independent" documents) but I see no great reason to do that

  547. krauq has joined

  548. Mikaela has left

  549. pep.

    Thanks for the clarifications

  550. Shell has joined

  551. adiaholic_ has left

  552. eevvoor

    stpeter, sounds good

  553. pep.

    What's the "stream" thing exactly?

  554. pep.

    Also "lead to more adoption especially by organizations that care about a more formal stamp of approval" -> so yeah legitimacy

  555. stpeter

    Streams are input methods to the RFC publication process. They are described at https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc4844

  556. Zash

    The IETF process is a bit more nuanced than one might think at first. Not just I-D → RFC

  557. papatutuwawa has left

  558. papatutuwawa has joined

  559. stpeter

    Having published 45 RFCs, I can concur with that statement. :-)

  560. pasdesushi has left

  561. Shell has left

  562. Shell has joined

  563. stpeter

    I think I'm in the top 1%: https://www.arkko.com/tools/rfcstats/authactdistr.html

  564. mukt2 has left

  565. stpeter

    Not that it really matters.

  566. stpeter wanders off to his next $dayjob meeting

  567. pasdesushi has joined

  568. mukt2 has joined

  569. Mikaela has joined

  570. thorsten has joined

  571. pasdesushi has left

  572. govanify has left

  573. govanify has joined

  574. eevvoor has left

  575. eevvoor has joined

  576. adiaholic_ has joined

  577. Nekit has joined

  578. karoshi has left

  579. karoshi has joined

  580. Nekit has left

  581. pasdesushi has joined

  582. Dele Olajide has left

  583. pasdesushi has left

  584. pasdesushi has joined

  585. Yagiza has left

  586. pasdesushi has left

  587. eevvoor has left

  588. lovetox has joined

  589. marc has joined

  590. debacle has left

  591. emus has joined

  592. pasdesushi has joined

  593. eevvoor has joined

  594. Shell has left

  595. Shell has joined

  596. Shell has left

  597. Shell has joined

  598. marc has left

  599. Shell has left

  600. Shell has joined

  601. floretta has joined

  602. marc has joined

  603. goffi has left

  604. darkijah has left

  605. darkijah has joined

  606. pasdesushi has left

  607. goffi has joined

  608. pasdesushi has joined

  609. eevvoor has left

  610. marc has left

  611. Shell has left

  612. Shell has joined

  613. pasdesushi has left

  614. goffi has left

  615. mukt2 has left

  616. mukt2 has joined

  617. pasdesushi has joined

  618. mukt2 has left

  619. pasdesushi has left

  620. mukt2 has joined

  621. papatutuwawa has left

  622. lovetox has left

  623. pasdesushi has joined

  624. mukt2 has left

  625. mukt2 has joined

  626. Mikaela has left

  627. pasdesushi has left

  628. govanify has left

  629. govanify has joined

  630. Shell has left

  631. krauq has left

  632. waqas has joined

  633. krauq has joined

  634. nyco has left

  635. adiaholic_ has left

  636. adiaholic_ has joined

  637. werdan has joined

  638. jcbrand has left

  639. LNJ has left

  640. neshtaxmpp has left

  641. moparisthebest has left

  642. neshtaxmpp has joined

  643. neshtaxmpp has left

  644. LNJ has joined

  645. neshtaxmpp has joined

  646. pasdesushi has joined

  647. govanify has left

  648. govanify has joined

  649. pasdesushi has left

  650. gav has left

  651. mukt2 has left

  652. LNJ has left

  653. gav has joined

  654. mukt2 has joined

  655. arc has left

  656. arc has joined

  657. werdan has left

  658. moparisthebest has joined

  659. govanify has left

  660. govanify has joined

  661. neshtaxmpp has left

  662. alameyo has left

  663. neshtaxmpp has joined

  664. mukt2 has left

  665. mukt2 has joined

  666. neshtaxmpp has left

  667. Tobias has left

  668. Shell has joined

  669. darkijah has left

  670. robertooo has left

  671. robertooo has joined

  672. debacle has joined

  673. alameyo has joined

  674. darkijah has joined

  675. adiaholic_ has left

  676. adiaholic_ has joined

  677. darkijah has left

  678. mukt2 has left

  679. darkijah has joined

  680. karoshi has left

  681. mukt2 has joined

  682. karoshi has joined

  683. Wojtek has left

  684. pasdesushi has joined

  685. pasdesushi has left

  686. pasdesushi has joined

  687. neshtaxmpp has joined

  688. mukt2 has left

  689. xecks has left

  690. pasdesushi has left

  691. Wojtek has joined

  692. paul has left

  693. thorsten has left

  694. mukt2 has joined

  695. thorsten has joined

  696. Shell has left

  697. Shell has joined

  698. lorddavidiii has left

  699. Shell has left

  700. Shell has joined

  701. pasdesushi has joined

  702. lskdjf has left

  703. Shell has left

  704. Shell has joined

  705. pasdesushi has left

  706. mukt2 has left

  707. Shell has left

  708. Shell has joined

  709. Shell has left

  710. Shell has joined

  711. Shell has left

  712. Shell has joined

  713. mukt2 has joined

  714. karoshi has left

  715. Seve has left

  716. sonny has left

  717. sonny has joined

  718. alameyo has left

  719. alameyo has joined

  720. darkijah has left

  721. darkijah has joined

  722. arc has left

  723. arc has joined

  724. sonny has left

  725. thorsten has left

  726. mukt2 has left

  727. sonny has joined

  728. arc has left

  729. arc has joined

  730. sonny has left

  731. sonny has joined

  732. mimi89999 has left

  733. j.r has left

  734. j.r has joined

  735. sonny has left

  736. sonny has joined

  737. mukt2 has joined