XSF Discussion - 2020-07-21

  1. mukt2 has left

  2. Shell has joined

  3. andrey.g has left

  4. mukt2 has joined

  5. Andrzej has left

  6. Shell has left

  7. arc has left

  8. arc has joined

  9. Lance has left

  10. alameyo has left

  11. govanify has left

  12. govanify has joined

  13. govanify has left

  14. govanify has joined

  15. Wojtek has left

  16. maines has left

  17. maines has joined

  18. arc has left

  19. arc has joined

  20. govanify has left

  21. govanify has joined

  22. sonny has left

  23. sonny has joined

  24. govanify has left

  25. govanify has joined

  26. arc has left

  27. arc has joined

  28. arc has left

  29. arc has joined

  30. alameyo has joined

  31. Andrzej has joined

  32. sabry has joined

  33. neshtaxmpp has left

  34. neshtaxmpp has joined

  35. sabry has left

  36. sabry has joined

  37. arc has left

  38. arc has joined

  39. arc has left

  40. arc has joined

  41. sonny has left

  42. sonny has joined

  43. Andrzej has left

  44. govanify has left

  45. govanify has joined

  46. waqas has joined

  47. govanify has left

  48. govanify has joined

  49. moparisthebest has left

  50. sabry has left

  51. govanify has left

  52. govanify has joined

  53. Andrzej has joined

  54. strypey has joined

  55. mimi89999 has left

  56. neshtaxmpp has left

  57. moparisthebest has joined

  58. strypey has left

  59. govanify has left

  60. govanify has joined

  61. alameyo has left

  62. neshtaxmpp has joined

  63. Andrzej has left

  64. Andrzej has joined

  65. neshtaxmpp has left

  66. sonny has left

  67. sonny has joined

  68. neshtaxmpp has joined

  69. Andrzej has left

  70. neshtaxmpp has left

  71. sonny has left

  72. sonny has joined

  73. mimi89999 has joined

  74. arc has left

  75. arc has joined

  76. neshtaxmpp has joined

  77. Andrzej has joined

  78. Seve has joined

  79. sonny has left

  80. sonny has joined

  81. neshtaxmpp has left

  82. mukt2 has left

  83. alameyo has joined

  84. Seve has left

  85. Seve has joined

  86. govanify has left

  87. govanify has joined

  88. Andrzej has left

  89. sonny has left

  90. sonny has joined

  91. jcbrand has joined

  92. adiaholic_ has left

  93. adiaholic_ has joined

  94. Tobias has joined

  95. sonny has left

  96. sonny has joined

  97. jcbrand has left

  98. Andrzej has joined

  99. jcbrand has joined

  100. lovetox has joined

  101. arc has left

  102. arc has joined

  103. Andrzej has left

  104. govanify has left

  105. govanify has joined

  106. lovetox has left

  107. Andrzej has joined

  108. Andrzej has left

  109. Andrzej has joined

  110. Andrzej has left

  111. Andrzej has joined

  112. mimi89999 has left

  113. Andrzej has left

  114. Andrzej has joined

  115. Andrzej has left

  116. Andrzej has joined

  117. mimi89999 has joined

  118. paul has joined

  119. lorddavidiii has joined

  120. Andrzej has left

  121. Andrzej has joined

  122. werdan has joined

  123. Andrzej has left

  124. Andrzej has joined

  125. werdan has left

  126. Mikaela has joined

  127. Andrzej has left

  128. Yagiza has joined

  129. strypey has joined

  130. Andrzej has joined

  131. andrey.g has joined

  132. Andrzej has left

  133. mukt2 has joined

  134. strypey has left

  135. strypey has joined

  136. strypey has left

  137. adiaholic_ has left

  138. adiaholic_ has joined

  139. xsf has left

  140. xsf has joined

  141. mukt2 has left

  142. Andrzej has joined

  143. karoshi has joined

  144. Zash has left

  145. Andrzej has left

  146. emus has joined

  147. mukt2 has joined

  148. xecks has joined

  149. lskdjf has joined

  150. Maranda has left

  151. Maranda has joined

  152. marc has joined

  153. Andrzej has joined

  154. marc has left

  155. marc has joined

  156. Dele Olajide has joined

  157. Zash has joined

  158. mukt2 has left

  159. Kev has joined

  160. Andrzej has left

  161. Andrzej has joined

  162. andrey.g has left

  163. Zash has left

  164. Zash has joined

  165. debacle has joined

  166. maines has left

  167. Steve Kille has left

  168. maines has joined

  169. Steve Kille has joined

  170. Daniel has left

  171. Daniel has joined

  172. Andrzej has left

  173. Andrzej has joined

  174. adiaholic_ has left

  175. adiaholic_ has joined

  176. arc has left

  177. arc has joined

  178. waqas has left

  179. neshtaxmpp has joined

  180. waffles417 has joined

  181. waffles417

    can soeone help me set up my pidgon?

  182. waffles417


  183. waffles417


  184. waffles417 has left

  185. intosi

    I see I missed the opportunity to handle a user support ticket for Pidgin.

  186. debacle has left

  187. mukt2 has joined

  188. Link Mauve has left

  189. govanify has left

  190. govanify has joined

  191. Yagiza has left

  192. karoshi has left

  193. karoshi has joined

  194. mukt2 has left

  195. debacle has joined

  196. sonny has left

  197. sonny has joined

  198. sonny has left

  199. sonny has joined

  200. darkijah has left

  201. debacle has left

  202. maines has left

  203. xsf has left

  204. strypey has joined

  205. xsf has joined

  206. strypey has left

  207. debacle has joined

  208. larma has left

  209. maines has joined

  210. larma has joined

  211. xsf has left

  212. govanify has left

  213. govanify has joined

  214. arc has left

  215. arc has joined

  216. j.r has joined

  217. karoshi has left

  218. karoshi has joined

  219. marc has left

  220. govanify has left

  221. govanify has joined

  222. marc has joined

  223. Daniel has left

  224. Daniel has joined

  225. marc has left

  226. darkijah has joined

  227. rion has left

  228. rion has joined

  229. marc has joined

  230. arc has left

  231. arc has joined

  232. eevvoor has joined

  233. maines has left

  234. Daniel has left

  235. Daniel has joined

  236. marc has left

  237. arc has left

  238. arc has joined

  239. waqas has joined

  240. marc has joined

  241. maines has joined

  242. govanify has left

  243. govanify has joined

  244. arc has left

  245. arc has joined

  246. Daniel has left

  247. Daniel has joined

  248. arc has left

  249. arc has joined

  250. Shell has joined

  251. arc has left

  252. arc has joined

  253. dwd has left

  254. Zash has left

  255. Zash has joined

  256. emus has left

  257. emus has joined

  258. edhelas

    hi folkds

  259. edhelas

    so i'm working on XEP-402 implementation

  260. edhelas

    with a small extension for Movim

  261. alameyo has left

  262. alameyo has joined

  263. edhelas

    <notifications xmlns="urn:movim:notifications:0" notify="all"/>

  264. edhelas

    i was wondering what other extensions you had in mind when forging the XEP ?

  265. edhelas

    (this extension will allow Movim users to configure per-room notifications, between none, when quoted and all)

  266. Link Mauve has joined

  267. govanify has left

  268. govanify has joined

  269. goffi has joined

  270. lovetox has joined

  271. Dele Olajide has left

  272. Dele Olajide has joined

  273. krauq has left

  274. krauq has joined

  275. alameyo has left

  276. Steve Kille has left

  277. Kev has left

  278. Steve Kille has joined

  279. Kev has joined

  280. maines has left

  281. Holger

    Oh it was renamed.

  282. jonas’

    what was?

  283. Holger


  284. lovetox has left

  285. Viktor Lindberg has joined

  286. Holger

    This was Bookmarks 2, no?

  287. eta


  288. Holger

    Ah, months ago.

  289. eta

    > This specification was originally entitled "Bookmarks 2: This Time It's Serious". Any implication of a sense of humour has been removed with the change in title.

  290. jonas’

    MattJ, https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/922 is that intentionally still Draft?

  291. arc has left

  292. arc has joined

  293. MattJ

    No, fixed

  294. MattJ

    I hadn't noticed it was draft, not used to that workflow :)

  295. govanify has left

  296. Link Mauve

    edhelas, don’t use urn:movim, it isn’t a registered URN name.

  297. govanify has joined

  298. edhelas

    ah :p what should I use then ?

  299. MattJ

    This should be an FAQ somewhere

  300. Link Mauve

    I use xmpp:linkmauve.fr/feature-foo, but you can use any URI you’re in control of.

  301. Link Mauve

    HTTP is a popular one.

  302. Kev

    HTTPS, please. More secure.

  303. Kev ducks

  304. MattJ

    or urn:uuid:!

  305. Link Mauve


  306. govanify has left

  307. govanify has joined

  308. jonas’

    MattJ, can you change the revision block to a more recent date?

  309. jonas’

    ... it’ll save us some trouble.

  310. govanify has left

  311. govanify has joined

  312. MattJ

    Can do, maybe later or possibly tomorrow

  313. arc has left

  314. arc has joined

  315. jonas’

    MattJ, ok, ping me

  316. govanify has left

  317. govanify has joined

  318. lovetox has joined

  319. Wojtek has joined

  320. maines has joined

  321. Guus has left

  322. Guus has joined

  323. govanify has left

  324. govanify has joined

  325. maines has left

  326. maines has joined

  327. Yagiza has joined

  328. Nekit has left

  329. Nekit has joined

  330. emus has left

  331. emus has joined

  332. Shell has left

  333. Shell has joined

  334. karoshi has left

  335. karoshi has joined

  336. maines has left

  337. arc has left

  338. arc has joined

  339. arc has left

  340. Yagiza has left

  341. arc has joined

  342. karoshi has left

  343. karoshi has joined

  344. maines has joined

  345. govanify has left

  346. govanify has joined

  347. govanify has left

  348. govanify has joined

  349. jmpman has joined

  350. andrey.g has joined

  351. Lance has joined

  352. thorsten has left

  353. maines has left

  354. Shell has left

  355. Shell has joined

  356. maines has joined

  357. amuza@riseup.net has joined

  358. mukt2 has joined

  359. Shell has left

  360. Shell has joined

  361. thorsten has joined

  362. lovetox has left

  363. andrey.g has left

  364. Steve Kille has left

  365. mukt2 has left

  366. Steve Kille has joined

  367. jmpman has left

  368. jmpman has joined

  369. Andrzej has left

  370. lovetox has joined

  371. Andrzej has joined

  372. amuza@riseup.net has left

  373. Shell has left

  374. Shell has joined

  375. papatutuwawa has joined

  376. flow

    how does a s2s "receiving" server know that the initating server supports the dialback "same certificate" shortcut (xep344 § 2.7)?

  377. flow

    or will the receiving server just tolerate the initating server not taking the shortcut, even though the initating server just received a 'valid' db result?

  378. flow

    and if so, shouldn't the xep state that?

  379. jonas’

    flow, note that your description of #972 on the ML is incomplete; it also changes the SHOULD for type="submit" to a MUST.

  380. Shell has left

  381. Shell has joined

  382. Andrzej has left

  383. Andrzej has joined

  384. amuza@riseup.net has joined

  385. alameyo has joined

  386. arc has left

  387. arc has joined

  388. Lance has left

  389. flow

    jonas’, I see how one could come to that conclusion, but if I am not mistaken there is no explicit statement about what to do for 'submit' type forms

  390. jonas’

    flow, sorry, I was typing that from memory.

  391. jonas’

    I meant for type="form", not for type="submit"

  392. flow

    ahh that SHOULD

  393. flow

    that is also ambiguous: does it may 'form' type forms SHOULD contain type annotation unless it's type-single (which is the default), *or*, does it mean that you can send/receive 'form' type forms without any type annotation at all?

  394. flow

    I tried to get rid of that ambiguity in the text, but I am not sure how successful I was

  395. flow

    s/does it may/does it mean/

  396. jonas’

    flow, can you reformulate the ambiguity?

  397. jonas’

    flow, I think it means both

  398. jonas’

    I’m not sure how the parts to the left and right of your "or" contradict each other

  399. flow

    it's not really a contradicition, the latter obviouisly allows the former, but the former does not allow the latter

  400. jonas’

    it does, depending on how strict you read SHOULD

  401. Andrzej has left

  402. flow

    the difference is, with one interpretation text-multi fields always have an 'type' attribute, with the other not

  403. jonas’

    flow, for as much as things "always" happen with SHOULD (as opposed to MUST)

  404. jonas’

    my reading is clearly that they SHOULD have the type attribute set

  405. jonas’

    I don’t see how you can find another, more lax interpretation from the text, but I’d be curious to hear

  406. flow

    mine too, but that does not mean it's clear to everybody

  407. jonas’

    but you must’ve had some reason to believe why one might read it differently?

  408. flow

    Sure, I read the sentence and found it ambiguous. The sentence is " For data forms of type "form", each <field/> element SHOULD possess a 'type' attribute that defines the data "type" of the field data" without the subordinate clause in the braces

  409. jonas’

    how is that ambiguous?

  410. flow

    that sentence allone reads like you could (but you shouldn't) have 'form' type forms without any type annotations, even for text-multi

  411. jonas’

    yes, that is clear so far

  412. Andrzej has joined

  413. debacle has left

  414. flow

    but that is my point, I think this is not what the XEP tries to state (nor what should be the case)

  415. jonas’

    what do you think it’s trying to state instead?

  416. Zash

    flow: re dialback, no need to know that. the verifying server could do the verification any way it wanted, either by doing the actual dialing-back, checking the certificate, or flipping a coin

  417. flow

    jonas’, that it should have field type annotations unless the field is text-single

  418. Zash

    I will however assumet that you are as confused as me when looking at that XEP, everything is weird and worded backwards.

  419. flow

    because text-single is the default, and hence you can elide those

  420. flow

    Zash, but in the shortcase case there was no db:result by the initating server, nor a db:verify by the receiving one

  421. flow

    Zash, but in the shortcut case there was no db:result by the initating server, nor a db:verify by the receiving one

  422. jonas’

    flow, right, even so, I don’t think that a MUST is a clarification there, but an outright change

  423. flow

    jonas’, I somehow assumed that it is consens that 'form' type forms must have field type annotations for all fields that are not text-single. If you think otherwise, then we should clarify this too

  424. flow

    jonas’, as I said, I may not be that successful with my attempt to clarify it

  425. jonas’

    I fail to see how changing SHOULD -> MUST is a clarification in any world

  426. flow

    jonas’, but again it is now "MUST possess unless it is text-single"

  427. jonas’

    and what if it is text-single? that is unclear now

  428. jonas’

    (while that "@type defaults to 'text-single'" is clear.)

  429. flow

    the "default is text-single" statement is still there

  430. flow

    which could be probably be more elaborated

  431. flow

    jonas’, I think if I would simply s/MUST/SHOULD/ in the diff, then I would actually allow 'form' type fields without no type annotations, even for non text-single fields. And that is something I'd like to avoid

  432. adiaholic_ has left

  433. adiaholic_ has joined

  434. flow

    but I am happy about any suggestions on how to improve the wording

  435. jonas’

    flow, sure, I’d like to avoid that too

  436. jonas’

    but that goes beyond a clarification

  437. flow

    does it?

  438. jonas’

    changes normative language in a Final document? yes.

  439. jonas’

    that’s never a clarification, period.

  440. flow

    I assumed there is consensus that 'form' type fields need type annotations for fields other than text-single

  441. flow

    And if this is true, then I think this is nothing but a clarification

  442. Andrzej has left

  443. stpeter has left

  444. stpeter has joined

  445. jmpman has left

  446. debacle has joined

  447. papatutuwawa has left

  448. Andrzej has joined

  449. amuza@riseup.net has left

  450. Dele Olajide has left

  451. Lance has joined

  452. Lance has left

  453. darkijah has left

  454. neshtaxmpp has left

  455. darkijah has joined

  456. goffi has left

  457. eevvoor has left

  458. Andrzej has left

  459. neshtaxmpp has joined

  460. lovetox has left

  461. jcbrand has left

  462. amuza@riseup.net has joined

  463. Tobias has left

  464. moparisthebest has left

  465. jcbrand has joined

  466. arc has left

  467. arc has joined

  468. xsf has joined

  469. moparisthebest has joined

  470. werdan has joined

  471. mukt2 has joined

  472. werdan has left

  473. Mikaela has left

  474. marc has left

  475. mukt2 has left

  476. Andrzej has joined

  477. dwd has joined

  478. edhelas has left

  479. rion has left

  480. rion has joined

  481. edhelas has joined

  482. Lance has joined

  483. govanify has left

  484. govanify has joined

  485. Lance has left

  486. darkijah has left

  487. Andrzej has left

  488. Andrzej has joined

  489. jcbrand has left

  490. edhelas has left

  491. karoshi has left

  492. darkijah has joined

  493. robertooo has left

  494. robertooo has joined

  495. Daniel has left

  496. edhelas has joined

  497. Daniel has joined

  498. Andrzej has left

  499. Andrzej has joined

  500. edhelas has left

  501. edhelas has joined

  502. edhelas has left

  503. edhelas has joined

  504. Andrzej has left

  505. Andrzej has joined

  506. mukt2 has joined

  507. Andrzej has left

  508. Andrzej has joined

  509. Andrzej has left

  510. Andrzej has joined

  511. Viktor Lindberg has left

  512. Viktor Lindberg has joined

  513. alameyo has left

  514. alameyo has joined

  515. mukt2 has left

  516. debacle has left

  517. Andrzej has left

  518. Andrzej has joined

  519. Andrzej has left

  520. Andrzej has joined

  521. maines has left

  522. Andrzej has left

  523. waqas has left

  524. Andrzej has joined

  525. Seve has left

  526. mukt2 has joined

  527. Daniel has left

  528. Daniel has joined

  529. maines has joined

  530. Andrzej has left

  531. govanify has left

  532. govanify has joined

  533. lskdjf has left

  534. paul has left

  535. Andrzej has joined

  536. mukt2 has left

  537. Andrzej has left