XSF Discussion - 2020-09-30

  1. alameyo has joined

  2. paul has left

  3. xecks has left

  4. mimi89999 has left

  5. Seve has left

  6. dwd has left

  7. Wojtek has left

  8. antranigv has left

  9. antranigv has joined

  10. krauq has left

  11. krauq has joined

  12. Andrzej has joined

  13. mimi89999 has joined

  14. Andrzej has left

  15. alameyo has left

  16. alameyo has joined

  17. krauq has left

  18. stpeter has joined

  19. stpeter has left

  20. mimi89999 has left

  21. krauq has joined

  22. q1594963197 has joined

  23. q1594963197 has left

  24. arc has left

  25. arc has joined

  26. q1594963197 has joined

  27. q1594963197 has left

  28. alameyo has left

  29. alameyo has joined

  30. lorddavidiii has left

  31. waqas has joined

  32. krauq has left

  33. krauq has joined

  34. mukt2 has left

  35. Andrzej has joined

  36. mukt2 has joined

  37. neshtaxmpp has left

  38. neshtaxmpp has joined

  39. papatutuwawa has left

  40. papatutuwawa has joined

  41. Andrzej has left

  42. antranigv has left

  43. lorddavidiii has joined

  44. lorddavidiii has left

  45. mdosch has left

  46. mdosch has joined

  47. lorddavidiii has joined

  48. adityaborikar has left

  49. adityaborikar has joined

  50. Yagiza has joined

  51. mukt2 has left

  52. moparisthebest has left

  53. peetah has left

  54. peetah has joined

  55. dwd has joined

  56. Seve has joined

  57. Tobias has joined

  58. Nekit has joined

  59. DebXWoody has joined

  60. Andrzej has joined

  61. Andrzej has left

  62. Andrzej has joined

  63. lorddavidiii has left

  64. Andrzej has left

  65. Andrzej has joined

  66. DebXWoody has left

  67. jcbrand has joined

  68. Andrzej has left

  69. Andrzej has joined

  70. DebXWoody has joined

  71. paul has joined

  72. Andrzej has left

  73. DebXWoody has left

  74. sonny has left

  75. sonny has joined

  76. Andrzej has joined

  77. Mikaela has joined

  78. Andrzej has left

  79. Andrzej has joined

  80. Andrzej has left

  81. Andrzej has joined

  82. Andrzej has left

  83. Andrzej has joined

  84. sonny has left

  85. sonny has joined

  86. Andrzej has left

  87. Andrzej has joined

  88. Andrzej has left

  89. Andrzej has joined

  90. Andrzej has left

  91. Andrzej has joined

  92. matkor has left

  93. matkor has joined

  94. neshtaxmpp has left

  95. sonny has left

  96. arc has left

  97. arc has joined

  98. sonny has joined

  99. sonny has left

  100. sonny has joined

  101. sonny has left

  102. karoshi has joined

  103. mimi89999 has joined

  104. sonny has joined

  105. Andrzej has left

  106. sonny has left

  107. sonny has joined

  108. waqas has left

  109. arc has left

  110. arc has joined

  111. sonny has left

  112. Andrzej has joined

  113. sonny has joined

  114. sonny has left

  115. Andrzej has left

  116. Andrzej has joined

  117. Andrzej has left

  118. Andrzej has joined

  119. sonny has joined

  120. sonny has left

  121. sonny has joined

  122. sonny has left

  123. sonny has joined

  124. Andrzej has left

  125. Andrzej has joined

  126. paul has left

  127. paul has joined

  128. adityaborikar has left

  129. adityaborikar has joined

  130. Andrzej has left

  131. debacle has joined

  132. mimi89999 has left

  133. emus has joined

  134. floretta has left

  135. APach has left

  136. APach has joined

  137. Andrzej has joined

  138. sonny has left

  139. sonny has joined

  140. mimi89999 has joined

  141. sonny has left

  142. adityaborikar has left

  143. adityaborikar has joined

  144. sonny has joined

  145. APach has left

  146. APach has joined

  147. floretta has joined

  148. sonny has left

  149. sonny has joined

  150. goffi has joined

  151. APach has left

  152. APach has joined

  153. sonny has left

  154. arc has left

  155. arc has joined

  156. lskdjf has joined

  157. floretta has left

  158. sonny has joined

  159. Zash

    pep., re https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/986 I wonder if the type thing should also be mentioned under https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0277.html#node_config

  160. Zash

    edhelas, have you seen that ^ btw? comments?

  161. pep.

    goffi gave me an ok :p

  162. pep.

    Zash: k, I can add that

  163. sonny has left

  164. edhelas

    Zash https://github.com/movim/movim/blob/master/lib/moxl/src/Stanza/Pubsub.php#L187 ?

  165. pep.

    I guess he meant "have you seen the PR"

  166. Zash

    Yes, the PR

  167. APach has left

  168. j.r has left

  169. edhelas

    looks good to me, i'm just wondering how I can migrate to that

  170. j.r has joined

  171. pep.

    yeah.. migration is always "fun". Setting the type on creation for a start (to eventually stop creating type-empty nodes), then set the type on type-empty nodes when writing to them? or if you can detect signs of microblog such as presence of id='0' etc.

  172. debacle has left

  173. pep.

    I also need to mandate that for comment nodes right

  174. goffi has left

  175. DebXWoody has joined

  176. sonny has joined

  177. sonny has left

  178. sonny has joined

  179. sonny has left

  180. adityaborikar has left

  181. adityaborikar has joined

  182. neshtaxmpp has joined

  183. sonny has joined

  184. adityaborikar has left

  185. adityaborikar has joined

  186. Maranda has left

  187. Maranda has joined

  188. j.r has left

  189. j.r has joined

  190. debacle has joined

  191. adityaborikar has left

  192. adityaborikar has joined

  193. xecks has joined

  194. j.r has left

  195. j.r has joined

  196. j.r has left

  197. j.r has joined

  198. j.r has left

  199. pep.

    Zash, pushed! Thanks

  200. pep.

    Re comment nodes I'm not entirely sure.

  201. pep.

    I guess whether it's on PEP or PubSub doesn't change the fact that the node will be named urn:xmpp:microblog:0:comments/ID. But it might be good for consistency

  202. pep.

    Also I was gonna add a "MAY" set pubsub#type on PEP (anyway). For consistency always, even though it's also obvious here

  203. pep.

    It's probably the same code that's gonna be used here so at least saying that it's a thing may be good

  204. Zash

    I wonder if MUST is a bit strong (for the other thing). Is #type even widely supported?

  205. Zash

    The field

  206. pep.

    I find the XEP a bit useless without MUST tbh

  207. pep.

    Well, this change, rather. But the XEP becomes unusable without the MUST the second another spec uses pubsub + atom

  208. j.r has joined

  209. Zash

    That's already a thing that's done, e.g. fetching rss/atom feeds and pushing into pubsub, or our commit (etc) notifications

  210. pep.

    Here you go

  211. pep.

    I'm not saying I don't want a tool reading "generic" pubsub+atom (whatever that means), but I definitely don't want a tool editing my pubsub+atom extension labelled "not-microblog" with microblog rules

  212. krauq has left

  213. krauq has joined

  214. mukt2 has joined

  215. Zash

    Hm. I've got a thing that derives a <body> for pubsub notifications, but it seems it bases it on the payload xmlns, not the #type

  216. Steve Kille has left

  217. Steve Kille has joined

  218. goffi has joined

  219. mukt2 has left

  220. krauq has left

  221. krauq has joined

  222. papatutuwawa has left

  223. Syndace has left

  224. LNJ has joined

  225. krauq has left

  226. krauq has joined

  227. antranigv has joined

  228. alameyo has left

  229. alameyo has joined

  230. sonny has left

  231. sonny has joined

  232. papatutuwawa has joined

  233. stpeter has joined

  234. stpeter has left

  235. alameyo has left

  236. alameyo has joined

  237. neshtaxmpp has left

  238. moparisthebest has joined

  239. sonny has left

  240. sonny has joined

  241. sonny has left

  242. antranigv has left

  243. sonny has joined

  244. sonny has left

  245. sonny has joined

  246. krauq has left

  247. sonny has left

  248. krauq has joined

  249. sonny has joined

  250. sonny has left

  251. neshtaxmpp has joined

  252. sonny has joined

  253. sonny has left

  254. alameyo has left

  255. alameyo has joined

  256. sonny has joined

  257. Shell has left

  258. sonny has left

  259. andrey.g has joined

  260. Nano4BeingYou has joined

  261. sonny has joined

  262. Shell has joined

  263. Syndace has joined

  264. Andrzej has left

  265. sonny has left

  266. Andrzej has joined

  267. krauq has left

  268. krauq has joined

  269. Shell has left

  270. antranigv has joined

  271. antranigv has left

  272. sonny has joined

  273. edhelas


  274. mdosch

    It's two days now and I still don't understand Jabber + TLS = e2e²…

  275. floretta has joined

  276. flow

    Am I the only one who finds it remarkably that xkcd #2365 does not mention Matrix?

  277. pep.

    Don't jynx it

  278. Shell has joined

  279. moparisthebest

    it doesn't mention XMPP either

  280. edhelas

    Jabber is the new XMPP

  281. mdosch

    I guess for them Jabber == XMPP…

  282. moparisthebest

    I assumed he meant legacy Cisco© Jabber©

  283. pep.

    flow, it also doesn't mention IRC fwiw

  284. pep.

    Well not in the picture

  285. Shell has left

  286. Shell has joined

  287. mdosch

    https://xkcd.com/1810/ didn't mention neither jabber nor xmpp.

  288. mdosch

    > Jabber.org (based on XMPP) is a communications protocol based on XML that was developed in 1999. The Jabber protocol could be used with Transport Layer Security (TLS) to have a secure communications service. https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/2365:_Messaging_Systems

  289. mdosch

    Never saw that wiki before. 😂

  290. LNJ has left

  291. LNJ has joined

  292. sonny has left

  293. sonny has joined

  294. adityaborikar has left

  295. adityaborikar has joined

  296. j.r has left

  297. j.r has joined

  298. Andrzej has left

  299. sonny has left

  300. sonny has joined

  301. j.r has left

  302. j.r has joined

  303. sonny has left

  304. adityaborikar has left

  305. Andrzej has joined

  306. sonny has joined

  307. eevvoor has joined

  308. stpeter has joined

  309. stpeter has left

  310. sonny has left

  311. sonny has joined

  312. sonny has left

  313. sonny has joined

  314. pasdesushi has joined

  315. Andrzej has left

  316. pasdesushi has left

  317. pasdesushi has joined

  318. pasdesushi has left

  319. pasdesushi has joined

  320. alameyo has left

  321. alameyo has joined

  322. krauq has left

  323. krauq has joined

  324. Andrzej has joined

  325. Nano4BeingYou has left

  326. Shell has left

  327. pasdesushi has left

  328. pasdesushi has joined

  329. Andrzej has left

  330. andrey.g has left

  331. adityaborikar has joined

  332. Shell has joined

  333. Wojtek has joined

  334. Steve Kille has left

  335. Steve Kille has joined

  336. pasdesushi has left

  337. pasdesushi has joined

  338. pasdesushi has left

  339. pasdesushi has joined

  340. pasdesushi has left

  341. pasdesushi has joined

  342. Andrzej has joined

  343. Neustradamus

    Mistake, it is XMPP since 2004, the original name was Jabber in 1998. Jabber.org is an XMPP service.

  344. arc has left

  345. arc has joined

  346. j.r has left

  347. pasdesushi has left

  348. pep.

    Neustradamus, maybe you should propose a change on that wiki?

  349. pasdesushi has joined

  350. j.r has joined

  351. krauq has left

  352. krauq has joined

  353. pasdesushi has left

  354. Shell has left

  355. floretta has left

  356. floretta has joined

  357. pasdesushi has joined

  358. Andrzej has left

  359. Zash

    TOPIC: Another episode of the never-ending XHTML-IM vs Message Styling story

  360. Daniel

    Anyway I think what ever proper solution comes out of xhtml-im2 or out of body markup or what ever is independent of what we do with 393

  361. eta

    Daniel: agreed

  362. pep.

    Yeah I didn't like the proposal made during summit either tbh..

  363. jonas’

    (for anyone who wants context, start here: https://logs.xmpp.org/council/2020-09-30#2020-09-30-0b1875408a3ee1bb )

  364. Andrzej has joined

  365. Zash

    Random comment: I like the way that SVG has attributes mirroring CSS properties, which seems somehow easier to deal with.

  366. Daniel

    I mean the point raised during summit (remember summits?) of not wanting two truth is also valid and should be taken into consideration

  367. pep.

    Daniel, sure. Which makes me say again "What pains me most is devs thinking this is actually a good solution"

  368. jonas’

    Zash, but then SVG still has CSS to make things more confusing

  369. Daniel

    But again independent of 393

  370. Zash


  371. Kev

    I think that is right in principle. Although I think that if you added <strippable/> (which, as noted in https://mail.jabber.org/pipermail/standards/2020-June/037514.html is going to be a huge benefit to Accessibility) 393 would actually be Good Enough, rather than needing immediate replacing.

  372. jonas’

    strippable, which would be a SHOULD or MUST to add? being equivalent to the opt-in I’ve been asking for all the time?

  373. Kev

    jonas’: I think you SHOULD add it if you determine(wave hands) that the user intended the markup - e.g. because you rendered it that way on the text input.

  374. pep.

    And poezio will never add the flag unfortunatley, so receivers will never know

  375. Kev

    Things continue to render it without the strippable, but they have to render the control characters.

  376. pep.

    Fortunately for receivers, poezio is not the most widely used clients out there

  377. Kev

    So I don't claim that by adding this 393 would be the perfect solution (to what I think is an impossible problem), merely that it makes 393 better.

  378. jcbrand has left

  379. jcbrand has joined

  380. Shell has joined

  381. Neustradamus

    pep.: XMPP + TLS or XMPP or other?

  382. jcbrand has left

  383. jcbrand has joined

  384. pep.

    I don't know, whatever you think is best. Maybe you can be nice with them. XMPP was after all called "Jabber" at the beginning, and the author does still use IRC so I wouldn't be surprised if they still think of XMPP as something from that time

  385. pep.

    Wasn't it called Jabber still when OTR came up? :P

  386. pasdesushi has left

  387. eevvoor has left

  388. pep.

    arf, stpeter replies to #986 and possibly swipes all the +1 I was gonna get :(

  389. Neustradamus

    pep.: https://twitter.com/neustradamus/status/1311337554793377792

  390. pep.


  391. lovetox has joined

  392. Andrzej has left

  393. Neustradamus

    It will be really good if we can plan a migration of mail.jabber.org to mail.xmpp.org...

  394. debacle has left

  395. j.r has left

  396. j.r has joined

  397. APach has joined

  398. j.r has left

  399. j.r has joined

  400. mukt2 has joined

  401. werdan has joined

  402. j.r has left

  403. j.r has joined

  404. j.r has left

  405. j.r has joined

  406. j.r has left

  407. j.r has joined

  408. j.r has left

  409. j.r has joined

  410. j.r has left

  411. j.r has joined

  412. Andrzej has joined

  413. j.r has left

  414. j.r has joined

  415. arc has left

  416. arc has joined

  417. arc has left

  418. arc has joined

  419. j.r has left

  420. j.r has joined

  421. APach has left

  422. j.r has left

  423. j.r has joined

  424. j.r has left

  425. j.r has joined

  426. arc has left

  427. arc has joined

  428. eevvoor has joined

  429. Andrzej has left

  430. APach has joined

  431. sonny has left

  432. sonny has joined

  433. disgyze has left

  434. disgyze has joined

  435. Daniel

    pep.: if the goal is to find all mircoblogs. Doesn't it matter to what value the type is set to as long as its known and agreed upon?

  436. pep.

    To “Here the payload is Atom, right?” I was gonna reply “I'm saying I wouldn't define the payload as Atom, no.”.

  437. pep.

    The goal is..

  438. Alex has left

  439. pep.

    to be able to distinguish what kind of payload that is. Now it seems peter and I are disagreeing on what payload means..

  440. pep.

    Not especially microblog

  441. arc has left

  442. arc has joined

  443. arc has left

  444. arc has joined

  445. pep.

    Say I publish my new spec also using pubsub + atom with different but very specific rules about how to handle Atom stuff that is also different from how the Atom spec defines things, I can, right? It's my spec.

  446. pep.

    Now I don't want microblog clients coming on my stuff and doing non-compliant things

  447. pep.

    And I guess they also wouldn't want that from me

  448. mukt2 has left

  449. mukt2 has joined

  450. flow

    IMHO pubsub#type should not define the pubsub node's payload type, but the node's type. and the node's type defines which payload(s) you may find in the node's items

  451. flow

    Neustradamus, did it occur to you that explainxkcd.com may be not related to xkcd? because it looks that way

  452. sonny has left

  453. sonny has joined

  454. Andrzej has joined

  455. pasdesushi has joined

  456. sonny has left

  457. waqas has joined

  458. pasdesushi has left

  459. goffi has left

  460. arc has left

  461. arc has joined

  462. arc has left

  463. arc has joined

  464. sonny has joined

  465. Lance has joined

  466. Yagiza has left

  467. Yagiza has joined

  468. sonny has left

  469. sonny has joined

  470. sonny has left

  471. mukt2 has left

  472. sonny has joined

  473. sonny has left

  474. APach has left

  475. Shell has left

  476. Shell has joined

  477. arc has left

  478. sonny has joined

  479. APach has joined

  480. werdan has left

  481. Yagiza has left

  482. Alex has joined

  483. mukt2 has joined

  484. sonny has left

  485. eevvoor has left

  486. debacle has joined

  487. mukt2 has left

  488. Andrzej has left

  489. waqas has left

  490. pasdesushi has joined

  491. sonny has joined

  492. pasdesushi has left

  493. lovetox has left

  494. sonny has left

  495. sonny has joined

  496. sonny has left

  497. Neustradamus

    flow: Have you looked the source? - https://xkcd.com/2365/

  498. Neustradamus

    The problem is here

  499. Neustradamus

    After the update, the picture will be updated in explainxkcd.com

  500. APach has left

  501. Andrzej has joined

  502. LNJ has left

  503. pasdesushi has joined

  504. j.r has left

  505. j.r has joined

  506. pasdesushi has left

  507. APach has joined

  508. Andrzej has left

  509. pasdesushi has joined

  510. sonny has joined

  511. pasdesushi has left

  512. pasdesushi has joined

  513. sonny has left

  514. pasdesushi has left

  515. sonny has joined

  516. krauq has left

  517. krauq has joined

  518. Alex has left

  519. Andrzej has joined

  520. Alex has joined

  521. sonny has left

  522. DebXWoody has left

  523. eevvoor has joined

  524. LNJ has joined

  525. Tobias has left

  526. Andrzej has left

  527. eevvoor has left

  528. mukt2 has joined

  529. j.r has left

  530. j.r has joined

  531. dwd has left

  532. mukt2 has left

  533. Wojtek has left

  534. Wojtek has joined

  535. APach has left

  536. APach has joined

  537. jcbrand has left

  538. sonny has joined

  539. Andrzej has joined

  540. mdosch has left

  541. mdosch has joined

  542. mdosch has left

  543. mdosch has joined

  544. j.r has left

  545. APach has left

  546. APach has joined

  547. sonny has left

  548. Andrzej has left

  549. j.r has joined

  550. Mikaela has left

  551. sonny has joined

  552. alameyo has left

  553. alameyo has joined

  554. Andrzej has joined

  555. sonny has left

  556. karoshi has left

  557. sonny has joined

  558. dwd has joined

  559. debacle has left

  560. Andrzej has left

  561. stpeter has joined

  562. stpeter has left

  563. sonny has left

  564. Wojtek has left

  565. sonny has joined

  566. sonny has left

  567. sonny has joined

  568. lskdjf has left

  569. Andrzej has joined

  570. sonny has left

  571. alameyo has left

  572. krauq has left

  573. krauq has joined

  574. Seve has left

  575. LNJ has left

  576. sonny has joined

  577. sonny has left

  578. sonny has joined

  579. Andrzej has left