mathieuiedhelas does, afaik; I have an up-to-date slixmpp implementation and I need to go back to the POC branch I made for poezio 3 years ago
fuanahas joined
edhelasI do
fuanahas left
fuanahas joined
MattJOk, thanks. Sounds like the path forward then :)
MattJThe only thing that worries me with this approach is correctly aggregating the reactions for display in the UI
emusMattJ: there was a request for Monal as well. but I guess that is not a priority
MattJThe deployment that wants this is currently using Converse.js, and it's struggling enough with sync problems already. But that's likely just something that needs fixing in Converse.js...
Wojtekhas left
fuanahas left
mathijshas left
mathijshas joined
Adihas left
Wojtekhas joined
edhelasI choosed to display it the Signal/Discord way (simple quote), and not the Slack/Mattermost way (threads)
edhelasoh no wait, I though we were talking about Reply, not Reactions
mathieuiedhelas, that’s not 0444, isn’t it?
edhelasYeah reactions have counts and aggregation :) My bad
MattJAh, k :)
mathijshas left
edhelasWorks pretty well and its used quite a lot on Movim :)
MattJI was going to say, people like to use them for polls, so counting is generally required for that use-case
edhelasI think it's a pretty good XEP, not that hard to implement and just "do the job"
mathieui(and since you are supposed to fill the gaps in history with MAM, if you get the original message, you also get the reactions as well)
MattJWell, obviously something like logs.xmpp.org wouldn't be able to display reactions
ZashSure it could, as long as you don't react to something from yesterday
mathieuitrue
MattJZash, right, but in the case of polls people will get unhappy about incorrect counts ;)
MattJIn a "product" I can easily imagine someone making the call that there is a valid time window for reactions, and after that they are ignored
nycohas joined
fuanahas joined
Guushas left
ZashIf you're going to react to something from a long long time ago, you'll have to excuse me for not doing that without support from the storage layer.
Wojtekhas left
ZashMattJ, looking forward to yet another complete redesign of the storage layer? 🙂
MattJ:S
edhelasMight be fixed along MIX when it will arrive, soon ™
edhelas*along with
Andrzejfor a reactions and proper counting storage would need to support something like https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0422.html
Andrzejhas left
ZashI found the argument that aggregation will need per-spec rules convincing.
KevI think whatever you do, you don’t want per-spec fetching, though. I think you want that aggregated.
KevSo even if you don’t want 422, I think you need 427 (give or take).
fuanahas left
Andrzejhas joined
inkyhas joined
antranigvhas joined
mathijshas joined
Andrzejhas left
marekhas left
marekhas joined
alacerhas joined
alacerhas left
Andrzejhas joined
SamWhitedHi, where do board minutes live? I went to the mailing list but I don't see any for this year
govanifyhas left
govanifyhas joined
MattJThe members mailing list is the official destination
Andrzejhas left
MattJI'm not sure how many meetings there have been so far this year, but at least one of them had me as the minute-taker and I haven't got around to writing them up yet
MattJUnfortunately finding volunteer minute-takers got increasingly hard the past couple of terms
marekhas left
marekhas joined
Andrzejhas joined
inkyhas left
inkyhas joined
Adihas left
florettahas joined
Adihas joined
andyhas left
ti_gj06has left
Andrzejhas left
SamWhitedThanks. FWIW if volunteers are the issue I'm happy to help. As long as I'm not part of the meeting I can take minutes (if it's something I'm in I can't for the life of me pay attention and take minutes at the same time)
adiaholichas left
esilhas joined
esilhas left
antranigvhas left
antranigvhas joined
adiaholichas joined
Steve Killehas left
emusMaybe we can ask each members to once a year to do this?
ZashI hear the key to good meeting minutes is to write them before the meeting.
serge90has left
Steve Killehas joined
KevIs someone channeling their inner Kev?
papatutuwawahas joined
MattJWrite minutes, skip the meeting
andrey.ghas joined
emusSounds like time traveling - nice!
ZashYou see, before the meeting, they're called "agenda".
ZashAnd "suggested decisions"
mathijshas left
ZashAnd above ground the magma is called lava. Wait, what were we talking about?
fuanahas joined
mathijshas joined
mathijshas left
mathijshas joined
fuanahas left
mathijshas left
stpeterhas joined
stpeterhas left
serge90has joined
ti_gj06has joined
matkorhas left
inkyhas left
inkyhas joined
serge90has left
neshtaxmpphas left
serge90has joined
emus^^ agenda =/= meeting minutes
emusbut we are getting off-topic
Zashmeeting minutes := agenda + decisions
Andrzejhas joined
Syndacehas left
Syndacehas joined
fuanahas joined
papatutuwawahas left
fuanahas left
KevMattJ: That was (I’m assuming you wrote it) a very good post.