-
Sam
That clause doesn't mean everyone in the US gets to know who every accuser is in every trial.
-
Sam
It seems far more likely that a board member who legit did a bad thing would get accused, then people in the XSF would pile on to the accuser (like always happens on the internet). And you could register a fake account and accuse the board member either way, the only difference is whether the entire XSF gets to investigate or the CoC committee does.
-
Sam
I mean, no one is suggesting the CoC committee call a vote every time or immediately act on every accusation. Just that if they believe a board member should be removed they also have a way to start proceedings and let the membership vote. It gives some accountability w/o forcing the accusation to be drawn out in public, that seems good.
-
Sam
Although, while I'm thinking out loud (sorry, this is long, I know): I sort of feel like a CoC should just outline general behavior, not actual enforcement or policy. That belongs somewhere else IMO (although I've seen it done okay both ways).
-
moparisthebest
Trials are public record though, having the coc say "$boardmember is fired for secret reasons from a secret accuser, trust us" seems bad
-
Sam
That's not even close to what I suggested.
-
moparisthebest
I'm just misinterpreting it then
-
emus
Good night, buenas noches, N'abend and bon soir - on the 29th of June I finally managed to create the PR for the XMPP Newsletter! 😋️✌️ :tada: That did not stop people from using the online pad! Anyway, preferable now rather make a PR - but the pad for June is still open. https://github.com/xsf/xmpp.org/pull/935 However, if you have something to add for the June on XMPP topics, this is you chance, review starts very soon. Sorry for delay 😕✎ -
emus
Good night, buenas noches, N'abend and bon soir - on the 29th of June I finally managed to create the PR for the XMPP Newsletter! 😋️✌️ 🎉️ That did not stop people from using the online pad! Anyway, preferable now rather make a PR - but the pad for June is still open. https://github.com/xsf/xmpp.org/pull/935 However, if you have something to add for the June on XMPP topics, this is you chance, review starts very soon. Sorry for delay 😕 ✏
-
emus
Good night, buenas noches, N'abend and bon soir - on the 29th of June I finally managed to create the PR for the XMPP Newsletter! 😋️✌️ 🎉️ That did not stop people from using the online pad! Anyway, preferable now rather make a PR - but the pad for June is still open. https://github.com/xsf/xmpp.org/pull/935 If you have something to add for the June on XMPP topics, this is you chance, review starts very soon. Sorry for delay 😕 ✏