XSF Discussion - 2021-08-25


  1. soundconcept has left
  2. stpeter has joined
  3. stpeter has left
  4. soundconcept has joined
  5. DebXWoody has joined
  6. DebXWoody has left
  7. larma has joined
  8. arc has left
  9. arc has joined
  10. lorddavidiii has left
  11. arc has left
  12. arc has joined
  13. adiaholic has joined
  14. stpeter has joined
  15. stpeter has left
  16. soundconcept has left
  17. soundconcept has joined
  18. soundconcept has left
  19. soundconcept has joined
  20. adiaholic has left
  21. lskdjf has left
  22. eab has left
  23. andrey.g has left
  24. eab has joined
  25. adiaholic has joined
  26. jgart has left
  27. adiaholic has left
  28. Shackleton has left
  29. soundconcept has left
  30. soundconcept has joined
  31. soundconcept has left
  32. soundconcept has joined
  33. soundconcept has left
  34. soundconcept has joined
  35. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has left
  36. Matthew has left
  37. homebeach has left
  38. Half-Shot has left
  39. uhoreg has left
  40. Rixon 👁🗨 has left
  41. Half-Shot has joined
  42. Matthew has joined
  43. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined
  44. uhoreg has joined
  45. homebeach has joined
  46. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has joined
  47. xsf has left
  48. xsf has joined
  49. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has left
  50. Matthew has left
  51. homebeach has left
  52. Half-Shot has left
  53. uhoreg has left
  54. Rixon 👁🗨 has left
  55. Half-Shot has joined
  56. Matthew has joined
  57. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined
  58. uhoreg has joined
  59. homebeach has joined
  60. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has joined
  61. adiaholic has joined
  62. adiaholic has left
  63. adiaholic has joined
  64. soundconcept has left
  65. adiaholic has left
  66. adiaholic has joined
  67. wladmis has left
  68. adiaholic has left
  69. xsf has left
  70. adiaholic has joined
  71. adiaholic has left
  72. adiaholic has joined
  73. adiaholic has left
  74. adiaholic has joined
  75. arc has left
  76. arc has joined
  77. adiaholic has left
  78. adiaholic has joined
  79. arc has left
  80. arc has joined
  81. arc has left
  82. arc has joined
  83. mukt2 has joined
  84. arc has left
  85. arc has joined
  86. jgart has joined
  87. govanify has left
  88. govanify has joined
  89. chronosx88 has left
  90. adiaholic has left
  91. adiaholic has joined
  92. mukt2 has left
  93. Yagiza has joined
  94. adiaholic has left
  95. adiaholic has joined
  96. stpeter has joined
  97. stpeter has left
  98. adiaholic has left
  99. adiaholic has joined
  100. mukt2 has joined
  101. adiaholic has left
  102. Calvin has left
  103. Vaulor has joined
  104. mukt2 has left
  105. adiaholic has joined
  106. adiaholic has left
  107. adiaholic has joined
  108. adiaholic has left
  109. adiaholic has joined
  110. adiaholic has left
  111. DebXWoody has joined
  112. mukt2 has joined
  113. ben has joined
  114. adiaholic has joined
  115. adiaholic has left
  116. adiaholic has joined
  117. mukt2 has left
  118. adiaholic has left
  119. lorddavidiii has joined
  120. adiaholic has joined
  121. adiaholic has left
  122. ti_gj06 has joined
  123. Tobias has joined
  124. winfried has left
  125. winfried has joined
  126. winfried has left
  127. winfried has joined
  128. jcbrand has left
  129. adiaholic has joined
  130. mukt2 has joined
  131. winfried has left
  132. winfried has joined
  133. adiaholic has left
  134. adiaholic has joined
  135. xutaxkamay has left
  136. adiaholic has left
  137. winfried has left
  138. adiaholic has joined
  139. karoshi has joined
  140. stp has joined
  141. mukt2 has left
  142. Menel has joined
  143. adiaholic has left
  144. xsf has joined
  145. mjk has joined
  146. adiaholic has joined
  147. adiaholic has left
  148. xsf has left
  149. xsf has joined
  150. xutaxkamay has joined
  151. Shackleton has joined
  152. Shackleton has left
  153. Shackleton has joined
  154. matkor has left
  155. Shackleton has left
  156. Mikaela has joined
  157. adiaholic has joined
  158. govanify has left
  159. govanify has joined
  160. mukt2 has joined
  161. adiaholic has left
  162. adiaholic has joined
  163. Bung has joined
  164. adiaholic has left
  165. mukt2 has left
  166. matkor has joined
  167. COM8 has joined
  168. wurstsalat has joined
  169. xsf has left
  170. LNJ has joined
  171. ti_gj06 has left
  172. Shackleton has joined
  173. Shackleton has left
  174. lorddavidiii has left
  175. adiaholic has joined
  176. chronosx88 has joined
  177. lorddavidiii has joined
  178. Shackleton has joined
  179. stp has left
  180. Syndace has joined
  181. debacle has joined
  182. Shackleton has left
  183. jcbrand has joined
  184. goffi has joined
  185. Shackleton has joined
  186. Shackleton has left
  187. marc has joined
  188. matkor has left
  189. xsf has joined
  190. adiaholic has left
  191. adiaholic has joined
  192. Mikaela has left
  193. Mikaela has joined
  194. COM8 has left
  195. Shackleton has joined
  196. arc has left
  197. arc has joined
  198. jl4 has joined
  199. debacle has left
  200. alex11 has joined
  201. Bung has left
  202. arc has left
  203. arc has joined
  204. matkor has joined
  205. adiaholic has left
  206. adiaholic has joined
  207. stpeter has joined
  208. stpeter has left
  209. arc has left
  210. arc has joined
  211. arc has left
  212. arc has joined
  213. arc has left
  214. arc has joined
  215. debacle has joined
  216. adiaholic has left
  217. Bung has joined
  218. stp has joined
  219. me9 has joined
  220. adiaholic has joined
  221. jgart has left
  222. emus has joined
  223. Bung has left
  224. adiaholic has left
  225. Alex has left
  226. ti_gj06 has joined
  227. Shackleton has left
  228. Sam has left
  229. stpeter has joined
  230. stpeter has left
  231. Alex has joined
  232. Bung has joined
  233. stp has left
  234. Bung has left
  235. georgeorwell has joined
  236. Bung has joined
  237. adiaholic has joined
  238. stp has joined
  239. ti_gj06 has left
  240. mukt2 has joined
  241. Sam has joined
  242. adiaholic has left
  243. adiaholic has joined
  244. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has left
  245. Matthew has left
  246. Rixon 👁🗨 has left
  247. Half-Shot has left
  248. uhoreg has left
  249. homebeach has left
  250. Half-Shot has joined
  251. Matthew has joined
  252. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined
  253. uhoreg has joined
  254. homebeach has joined
  255. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has joined
  256. mukt2 has left
  257. Bung has left
  258. me9 has left
  259. arc has left
  260. arc has joined
  261. me9 has joined
  262. arc has left
  263. arc has joined
  264. ti_gj06 has joined
  265. Tobias has left
  266. Tobias has joined
  267. lskdjf has joined
  268. adiaholic has left
  269. adiaholic has joined
  270. Bung has joined
  271. adiaholic has left
  272. mjk has left
  273. adiaholic has joined
  274. mjk has joined
  275. adiaholic has left
  276. mjk has left
  277. mukt2 has joined
  278. Alex has left
  279. lovetox has left
  280. belong has left
  281. adiaholic has joined
  282. inky has joined
  283. belong has joined
  284. mukt2 has left
  285. adiaholic has left
  286. inky has left
  287. inky has joined
  288. adiaholic has joined
  289. deuill has left
  290. adiaholic has left
  291. papatutuwawa has joined
  292. ti_gj06 has left
  293. ti_gj06 has joined
  294. me9 'ello! I have a question about a XEP which I guess exists. What XEP defines how a 'raw' (?) text message should look like and what metadata it contains for the clients to interpret and display it right to the user? I'd like to see how it's built for a second, later question.
  295. inky has left
  296. antranigv has left
  297. antranigv has joined
  298. Sam me9: welcome! The body of messages is actually defined by the core RFCs, not in an XEP. However, that's just text (no special formatting or anything). Metadata and formatting is defined by many different XEPs depending on the feature you want.
  299. Sam (the IETF maintains the core of XMPP in a handful of RFCs, the XSF maintains any extensions to the core protocol in XEPs)
  300. Sam Is there something specific you're looking to learn how to do? Maybe I can point you at a more concrete document
  301. me9 I'm looking for what metadata there is for time and date.
  302. inky has joined
  303. flow me9 like https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0203.html ?
  304. me9 Uuuhhh.
  305. me9 I don't understand what it does. But I can tell/show you what I was thinking about.
  306. deuill has joined
  307. Sam Sure, that might help
  308. Holger me9: As the XEP title suggests, the idea is to only add <delay/> timestamps in case the message was actually delayed for some reason (sender was offline while the message was written, message was stored in MAM/offline spool, ...). The idea is that you can assume instant delivery if no such timestamp is included. (But of course there's no _guarantee_).
  309. deuill has left
  310. Holger XMPP's original standard operation was _instant_ messaging ... :-)
  311. me9 Holger: Aha ok. Well I just meant how date and time look universally before the client shows it right.
  312. me9 > Holger wrote: > XMPP's original standard operation was _instant_ messaging ... :-) Yeah I get it. That's also interesting.
  313. Holger XEPs that add timestamps usually refer to this format: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0082.html
  314. flow me9, https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0082.html maybe?
  315. Holger Holger <-> flow 1:0
  316. me9 Mhm. Seems right.
  317. me9 XD
  318. me9 Seems the XEP is talking about the problem someone and me found.
  319. me9 A bit.
  320. flow me9, feel free to elaborate on the problem
  321. me9 Wait a bit, I want to look at that XEP. It's always so long.. :))
  322. mukt2 has joined
  323. me9 But maybe you can think about my idea while I'm reading. This is also about the formatting of quotes. There's an issue on one XMPP client (Blabber.im). Blabber normally does this when you quote woth the ontegrated function of quoting: ```[nick] wrote: > [quoted text]``` But the issue wanted to add a date to that. But we figured that only a client adding a date wouldn't be internationally friendly, as when you have people from.different countries and rimezones meeting, they write and display date and time (very) differently. So what we'd need for a date to be added would probably be some kind of XEP which let's the cleitn translate the date and time into the persons local format. Here's what I wrote at the end: https://codeberg.org/kriztan/blabber.im/issues/499#issuecomment-249559
  324. me9 So this is actually about the text before a quote, which more than one client would have to use for it to be useful and not confusing.
  325. me9 Maybe the idea is just too fiddly and not useful for many people, I don't know... Just wanted to give a readon to close that issue, really.
  326. me9 Maybe the idea is just too fiddly and not useful for many people, I don't know... Just wanted to give a readäson to close that issue, really.
  327. me9 Maybe the idea is just too fiddly and not useful for many people, I don't know... Just wanted to give a reason to close that issue, really.
  328. deuill has joined
  329. Zash Quotes are currently just plain text prefixed by `>`. There's a XEP or two for referencing earlier messages by id, which would likely make things easier in the long run
  330. wurstsalat me9 to takle this problem, you'd need message references/fastening
  331. wurstsalat tackle, that is
  332. me9 > Zash wrote: > Quotes are currently just plain text prefixed by `>`. There's a XEP or two for referencing earlier messages by id, which would likely make things easier in the long run IDs would be very useful, that's true.
  333. adiaholic has joined
  334. antranigv has left
  335. antranigv has joined
  336. me9 wurstsalat: Is that what Zash meant?
  337. wurstsalat yep, didn't see that message
  338. alex11 has left
  339. deuill has left
  340. deuill has joined
  341. me9 Okay.
  342. wgreenhouse has left
  343. Alex has joined
  344. me9 https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0082.html at point 6. Security Considerations: [...] if it's set to the local time of a user, and thus concerns users' *privcacy*. To avoid this issue developers are advised to [...] :D
  345. deuill has left
  346. me9 https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0082.html at point 6. Security Considerations: > [...] if it's set to the local time of a user, and thus concerns users' *privcacy*. To avoid this issue developers are advised to [...] :D
  347. adiaholic has left
  348. alex11 has joined
  349. wgreenhouse has joined
  350. adiaholic has joined
  351. jonas’ me9, feel free to PR :) -> https://github.com/xsf/xeps/
  352. antranigv has left
  353. me9 jonas’: A PR for removing one character in that giant text? Okay.
  354. x51 has joined
  355. Zash That should make review easy
  356. jonas’ me9, what else? :)
  357. jonas’ can't give you +w on the repository and I can't do it myself right now
  358. me9 Dunno. There was also that editor JID for errata. But I'll try.
  359. BASSGOD has left
  360. jonas’ editor ... JID?
  361. me9 editor@xmpp.org
  362. flow I think there is only a editor mail address
  363. jonas’ that's no JID
  364. jonas’ what flow says
  365. me9 Uh. Okay. :D
  366. jonas’ it would end up with me making a PR though ;)
  367. jonas’ (or the equivalent of...)
  368. me9 Okay I'll do it jonas’ xD
  369. me9 One freaky character.
  370. me9 Heh.
  371. jonas’ maybe you can find something else to fix in that document, too :)
  372. flow an improvement is an improvement, no matter how small it is
  373. jonas’ true
  374. jonas’ many people probably just skimmed past that and possibly thought "ugh, they can't even edit their documents properly!!kk"
  375. antranigv has joined
  376. adiaholic has left
  377. me9 Hmm.
  378. me9 So my quote-date-stuff idea wasn't very good, I guess?
  379. BASSGOD has joined
  380. jonas’ if only we had proper markup instead of magic characters stuffed in <body/>
  381. adiaholic has joined
  382. me9 Do you always use 'an' before 'X...' words? Or just when the long version begins with a vowel?
  383. Holger me9: You use it when 'X' is the first letter of an abbreviation, because it's about pronounciation, not spelling. "An (e)XMPP client."
  384. jonas’ an exx emm pee pee
  385. Holger Holger <-> jonas’ 1:0
  386. me9 Ah, because one says ex for x?
  387. jonas’ me9, yes
  388. jonas’ Holger, :P
  389. me9 Holger: You already have two points. What now? You won?
  390. Holger I'd say so, waiting for presents now.
  391. jonas’ <presents type="unavailable"/>
  392. Wojtek has joined
  393. deuill has joined
  394. mukt2 has left
  395. Bung has left
  396. LNJ has left
  397. wurstsalat thanks for the giggles (again)
  398. LNJ has joined
  399. Bung has joined
  400. ti_gj06 has left
  401. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has left
  402. homebeach has left
  403. Half-Shot has left
  404. Matthew has left
  405. uhoreg has left
  406. Rixon 👁🗨 has left
  407. Half-Shot has joined
  408. Matthew has joined
  409. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined
  410. uhoreg has joined
  411. homebeach has joined
  412. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has joined
  413. adiaholic has left
  414. jl4 has left
  415. adiaholic has joined
  416. me9 Ha! I found one more inconsistency in 0082. XD
  417. adiaholic has left
  418. antranigv has left
  419. millesimus has left
  420. adiaholic has joined
  421. papatutuwawa has left
  422. mukt2 has joined
  423. adiaholic has left
  424. antranigv has joined
  425. adiaholic has joined
  426. me9 Did somebody already point out the following little UI issues, which seems to appear with every single XEP? (Or is it just my browser being weird?)
  427. me9 https://upload.wiuwiu.de/share.php/2cf0b044-64d8-4976-b1e7-8cf60a1aac90/20210825_134516681_b421.jpg
  428. millesimus has joined
  429. Zash Looks fine here
  430. Alex has left
  431. mukt2 has left
  432. adiaholic has left
  433. wgreenhouse has left
  434. jonas’ probably an edge-case with that very narrow screen
  435. jonas’ feel free to open an issue with that screenshot, I think there can be something done about it
  436. Zash Looked fine on every screen width I tried
  437. Zash Ctrl-Shift-M in Firefox and then resized the viewport, could not reproduce that overlap issue.
  438. adiaholic has joined
  439. wgreenhouse has joined
  440. mdosch Looks even good on mobile with fennec here.
  441. adiaholic has left
  442. mdosch > probably an edge-case with that very narrow screen But at the JabberID the width is more than enough. Maybe some browser doing weird things withs padding or how it was called again.
  443. adiaholic has joined
  444. me9 > jonas’ wrote: > probably an edge-case with that very narrow screen I zoomed in and cut off something, it looks different.
  445. me9 The photo is from Ungoogled Chromium on my phone but with the desktop view. Both desktop and mobile view do it in Ungoogled Chromium. But with Fennec, it's perfectly fine.
  446. APach has left
  447. vanitasvitae has left
  448. vanitasvitae has joined
  449. antranigv has left
  450. antranigv has joined
  451. wurstsalat Edge case it is then
  452. jonas’ wurstsalat, no they said Chromium, not Edge *scnr*
  453. Bung has left
  454. wurstsalat Touché
  455. jgart has joined
  456. me9 Hehe.
  457. me9 My little PR should be good and deployed now by the way.
  458. jonas’ me9, next editor work window is next tuesday, so don't hold your breath :)
  459. me9 jonas’: Fine 👍
  460. me9 Do I have to do that CLA thing?
  461. lovetox has joined
  462. wladmis has joined
  463. inky has left
  464. antranigv has left
  465. wladmis has left
  466. antranigv has joined
  467. Bung has joined
  468. adiaholic has left
  469. adiaholic has joined
  470. lorddavidiii has left
  471. lorddavidiii has joined
  472. adiaholic has left
  473. antranigv has left
  474. antranigv has joined
  475. wladmis has joined
  476. adiaholic has joined
  477. wladmis has left
  478. lovetox has left
  479. wgreenhouse has left
  480. adiaholic has left
  481. wurstsalat MattJ, jonas’, do you have plans/ideas on how to proceed with https://github.com/xsf/xmpp.org/pull/953 ? should I rebase it peridically? anything I can do to help reviewing?
  482. wgreenhouse has joined
  483. wladmis has joined
  484. jonas’ me9, I don't think that this contribution is really copyrightable, so it would've been OK without I guess
  485. wladmis has left
  486. lorddavidiii has left
  487. BASSGOD has left
  488. me9 jonas’: I did it anyway. It remember that for the rest, right?
  489. me9 jonas’: I did it anyway. It remembers that for the rest, right?
  490. jonas’ it does
  491. me9 Good.
  492. adiaholic has joined
  493. antranigv has left
  494. antranigv has joined
  495. adiaholic has left
  496. antranigv has left
  497. antranigv has joined
  498. wladmis has joined
  499. antranigv has left
  500. antranigv has joined
  501. wladmis has left
  502. mjk has joined
  503. wladmis has joined
  504. antranigv has left
  505. mjk has left
  506. lorddavidiii has joined
  507. mjk has joined
  508. adiaholic has joined
  509. jl4 has joined
  510. govanify has left
  511. govanify has joined
  512. govanify has left
  513. Menel has left
  514. govanify has joined
  515. stpeter has joined
  516. stpeter has left
  517. jl4 has left
  518. ti_gj06 has joined
  519. wladmis has left
  520. wladmis has joined
  521. wladmis has left
  522. wladmis has joined
  523. Sam I am writing up a list of open questions about ad-hoc commands because this entire XEP is confusing to me. I will submit a patch to try and clarify any of them at a later date, please consider adding your own questions to the document. Thanks. https://pad.disroot.org/p/adhocquestions
  524. wgreenhouse has left
  525. jonas’ better don't look at what "execute" means.
  526. wgreenhouse has joined
  527. Sam Oh yah, that's one I should add. All it had to say was "also there's a default action" and it would make sense, but instead it's got tons of text about when "execute" means something else or means itself and what?
  528. Zash no, no, noooooo
  529. jonas’ I said you should *not* look at it :P
  530. Sam Anyways, I'm sick of reading and re-reading this and having dozens of bugs due to misreading the spec (no idea if it's me or others misreading the spec, but I'm doing whatever I see other things doing) so I'm going to at least try to put together a PR if I can get it all straight in my head. First step is listing the questions.
  531. David Cridland has joined
  532. David Cridland has left
  533. Alex has joined
  534. wladmis has left
  535. wladmis has joined
  536. wladmis has left
  537. adiaholic has left
  538. Alex has left
  539. Alex has joined
  540. werdan has joined
  541. flow Sam you may want to look at (and add to) https://wiki.xmpp.org/web/XEP-Remarks/XEP-0050:Ad-Hoc_Commands
  542. Sam good to know; thanks
  543. adiaholic has joined
  544. adiaholic has left
  545. wladmis has joined
  546. antranigv has joined
  547. marc has left
  548. adiaholic has joined
  549. marc has joined
  550. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has left
  551. homebeach has left
  552. Half-Shot has left
  553. Matthew has left
  554. uhoreg has left
  555. Rixon 👁🗨 has left
  556. Half-Shot has joined
  557. Matthew has joined
  558. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined
  559. uhoreg has joined
  560. homebeach has joined
  561. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has joined
  562. wladmis has left
  563. marc has left
  564. marc has joined
  565. adiaholic has left
  566. jl4 has joined
  567. arc has left
  568. arc has joined
  569. BASSGOD has joined
  570. arc has left
  571. arc has joined
  572. wladmis has joined
  573. wladmis has left
  574. wladmis has joined
  575. jl4 has left
  576. jl4 has joined
  577. jl4 has left
  578. jl4 has joined
  579. adiaholic has joined
  580. jl4 has left
  581. jl4 has joined
  582. govanify has left
  583. govanify has joined
  584. govanify has left
  585. govanify has joined
  586. arc has left
  587. arc has joined
  588. jl4 has left
  589. jl4 has joined
  590. jl4 has left
  591. jl4 has joined
  592. jl4 has left
  593. jl4 has joined
  594. papatutuwawa has joined
  595. MattJ wurstsalat, next steps - I just want to give it a quick review, merge and deploy. My usual time allocated to XSF infrastructure was yesterday, but it got taken over by other stuff. I'll get to it soon!
  596. adiaholic has left
  597. adiaholic has joined
  598. marc has left
  599. mjk has left
  600. Steve Kille has left
  601. lovetox has joined
  602. wurstsalat MattJ: thanks :) I'll rebase next monday then
  603. wgreenhouse has left
  604. Steve Kille has joined
  605. adiaholic has left
  606. dwd has joined
  607. eab has left
  608. arc has left
  609. arc has joined
  610. wgreenhouse has joined
  611. marc has joined
  612. jl4 has left
  613. arc has left
  614. arc has joined
  615. arc has left
  616. arc has joined
  617. adiaholic has joined
  618. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has left
  619. homebeach has left
  620. Half-Shot has left
  621. Matthew has left
  622. uhoreg has left
  623. Rixon 👁🗨 has left
  624. Half-Shot has joined
  625. Matthew has joined
  626. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined
  627. uhoreg has joined
  628. homebeach has joined
  629. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has joined
  630. eab has joined
  631. jl4 has joined
  632. jl4 has left
  633. jl4 has joined
  634. eab has left
  635. eab has joined
  636. jl4 has left
  637. jl4 has joined
  638. ti_gj06 has left
  639. eab has left
  640. govanify has left
  641. govanify has joined
  642. eab has joined
  643. eab has left
  644. eab has joined
  645. ti_gj06 has joined
  646. govanify has left
  647. govanify has joined
  648. govanify has left
  649. govanify has joined
  650. eab has left
  651. eab has joined
  652. eab has left
  653. eab has joined
  654. wladmis has left
  655. wladmis has joined
  656. millesimus has left
  657. adiaholic has left
  658. arc has left
  659. mjk has joined
  660. arc has joined
  661. arc has left
  662. arc has joined
  663. adiaholic has joined
  664. eab has left
  665. eab has joined
  666. andrey.g has joined
  667. eab has left
  668. eab has joined
  669. eab has left
  670. millesimus has joined
  671. eab has joined
  672. eab has left
  673. eab has joined
  674. eab has left
  675. eab has joined
  676. eab has left
  677. eab has joined
  678. jl4 has left
  679. jl4 has joined
  680. eab has left
  681. Link Mauve has left
  682. adiaholic has left
  683. eab has joined
  684. ralphm has left
  685. ralphm has joined
  686. jl4 has left
  687. adiaholic has joined
  688. ti_gj06 has left
  689. me9 has left
  690. lorddavidiii has left
  691. scorch has left
  692. chronosx88 has left
  693. chronosx88 has joined
  694. eab has left
  695. eab has joined
  696. mjk It has come to my attention that XEP-0363 (http upload) requires a particular kind of transport security (TLS), with seemingly no regard for things like .onion domains. This makes onion-service admins either to jump through hoops to enable a redundant and useless (no cert verification performed by clients) security layer, or to go against the spec, allowing http://abcdef.onion up-/download. Would it be too late to change the xep to require some unspecified transport security form, only referring to TLS and onion services in a note?
  697. jl4 has joined
  698. andrey.g has left
  699. mjk I should add that, in my observation, many onion services go against the spec here
  700. werdan has left
  701. antranigv has left
  702. antranigv has joined
  703. lovetox has left
  704. Zash Related observation: Things that do the aesgcm:// thing, they can't deal with http://
  705. mjk :nod:
  706. Zash Luckily that's not a XEP so not our problem! YOLO GLHF /me hides
  707. mjk Hm? It's been a xep since december, if I'm not mistaken :p
  708. Zash Has it?
  709. mjk Let me look up the number
  710. Zash Oh, historical
  711. Zash 454
  712. ti_gj06 has joined
  713. Zash `/correct s/XEP/Standards Track XEP/` then
  714. mjk Okay then :l
  715. mjk Okay then :)
  716. mjk I hope for future orthogonalization of file encryption (aes gcm) and transport protocols (http over tls, http over onion...)
  717. Zash Something something reference to earlier talk about things being rushed into production ahead of standardization and causing awkwardness.
  718. mjk Something like `omemo:http://abcdef.onion/path/to/file#foo`
  719. Zash I've seen e.g. git+https:// elsewhere. Some MIME thing could also have worked
  720. Zash `application/some-encrypted-container` 🤷️
  721. jl4 has left
  722. jl4 has joined
  723. antranigv has left
  724. mjk Yeah, `aesgcm+https` would have worked too
  725. mjk Yeah, `aesgcm+https` scheme would have worked too
  726. Zash inb4 `aesgcm+tftp://`
  727. mjk We're getting dangerously bikesheddy
  728. ti_gj06 has left
  729. jl4 has left
  730. jl4 has joined
  731. adiaholic has left
  732. Zash Nah, I'm just sprinting ahead on tangents
  733. wladmis has left
  734. scorch has joined
  735. mjk Right
  736. xecks has left
  737. xecks has joined
  738. adiaholic has joined
  739. mjk Going back to 0363, clients generally seem to allow plain http upload too, with a notable exception of Gajim (if I'm reading the code correctly). But, e.g., this <https://github.com/dino/dino/pull/1098> Dino PR, if accepted as is, would break the, admittedly non-standard, functionality
  740. Zash There was a question somewhere earlier about whether file transfer used UDP or TCP. Recently there's been deployment of TURN UDP proxies. Soooo could you do say TFTP over TURN? That'd be funny.
  741. wladmis has joined
  742. Zash Maybe the whole thing will break down and everyone will move towards Jingle File Transfer? (plz do)
  743. mdosch Would it be possible to ditch http and jingle it to the server and the server transfers it over jingle to other clients requesting the file?
  744. Zash JFT can use HTTP Upload for transport per some XEP somewhere, and OMEMO for security, so in theory it should be possible to combine those properties and not have to use the assgcm:// hack
  745. mjk Nah, SIMS FTW
  746. wladmis has left
  747. Zash mdosch, why not? "over jingle" can mean a lot of things tho
  748. lovetox has joined
  749. Zash mjk, SIMS being something of a combination of Jingle File Transfer and Jingle Message Initialization...
  750. mjk Ok nevermind me
  751. Zash And then there's XEP-0447 and 448...
  752. mjk Jm2c regarding 0363
  753. Zash A/B fight plz
  754. adiaholic has left
  755. jl4 has left
  756. jl4 has joined
  757. wladmis has joined
  758. jl4 has left
  759. jl4 has joined
  760. adiaholic has joined
  761. jl4 has left
  762. jl4 has joined
  763. ralphm has left
  764. ralphm has joined
  765. Yagiza has left
  766. jl4 has left
  767. jl4 has joined
  768. karoshi has left
  769. jl4 has left
  770. jl4 has joined
  771. wladmis has left
  772. mukt2 has joined
  773. govanify has left
  774. govanify has joined
  775. govanify has left
  776. govanify has joined
  777. jl4 has left
  778. jl4 has joined
  779. jl4 has left
  780. jl4 has joined
  781. wladmis has joined
  782. karoshi has joined
  783. jl4 has left
  784. jl4 has joined
  785. antranigv has joined
  786. antranigv has left
  787. antranigv has joined
  788. jl4 has left
  789. jl4 has joined
  790. jl4 has left
  791. jl4 has joined
  792. Sam has left
  793. Sam has joined
  794. jl4 has left
  795. jl4 has joined
  796. adiaholic has left
  797. jl4 has left
  798. jl4 has joined
  799. wladmis has left
  800. wladmis has joined
  801. arc has left
  802. adiaholic has joined
  803. jl4 has left
  804. jl4 has joined
  805. wladmis has left
  806. jl4 has left
  807. jl4 has joined
  808. mukt2 has left
  809. wladmis has joined
  810. jl4 has left
  811. jl4 has joined
  812. wladmis has left
  813. wladmis has joined
  814. jl4 has left
  815. jl4 has joined
  816. jl4 has left
  817. jl4 has joined
  818. wladmis has left
  819. jl4 has left
  820. jl4 has joined
  821. jl4 has left
  822. jl4 has joined
  823. Paganini has left
  824. jl4 has left
  825. jl4 has joined
  826. me9 has joined
  827. jl4 has left
  828. jl4 has joined
  829. jl4 has left
  830. jl4 has joined
  831. wladmis has joined
  832. Calvin has joined
  833. Wojtek has left
  834. adiaholic has left
  835. wladmis has left
  836. debacle has left
  837. wladmis has joined
  838. jl4 has left
  839. jl4 has joined
  840. neshtaxmpp has joined
  841. x51 has left
  842. papatutuwawa has left
  843. deuill has left
  844. debacle has joined
  845. deuill has joined
  846. goffi has left
  847. Zash has left
  848. Zash has joined
  849. Zash has left
  850. Zash has joined
  851. mukt2 has joined
  852. Zash has left
  853. eab has left
  854. Zash has joined
  855. Calvin has left
  856. eab has joined
  857. arc has joined
  858. georgeorwell has left
  859. Menel has joined
  860. mukt2 has left
  861. Paganini has joined
  862. arc has left
  863. arc has joined
  864. BASSGOD has left
  865. BASSGOD has joined
  866. Tobias has left
  867. mukt2 has joined
  868. mukt2 has left
  869. belong has left
  870. belong has joined
  871. jl4 has left
  872. LNJ has left
  873. sebastian has left
  874. Calvin has joined
  875. robertooo has left
  876. robertooo has joined
  877. eab has left
  878. LNJ has joined
  879. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has left
  880. Matthew has left
  881. homebeach has left
  882. Rixon 👁🗨 has left
  883. Half-Shot has left
  884. uhoreg has left
  885. Half-Shot has joined
  886. Matthew has joined
  887. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined
  888. uhoreg has joined
  889. homebeach has joined
  890. Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) has joined
  891. mjk has left
  892. arc has left
  893. arc has joined
  894. chronosx88 has left
  895. chronosx88 has joined
  896. adiaholic has joined
  897. Mikaela has left
  898. marc has left
  899. adiaholic has left
  900. arc has left
  901. arc has joined
  902. mukt2 has joined
  903. stp has left
  904. xecks has left
  905. Menel has left
  906. eevvoor has left
  907. mukt2 has left
  908. millesimus has left
  909. millesimus has joined
  910. adiaholic has joined
  911. wurstsalat has left
  912. adiaholic has left
  913. Calvin has left
  914. karoshi has left
  915. LNJ has left
  916. debacle has left
  917. emus has left
  918. me9 has left
  919. mukt2 has joined
  920. wladmis has left
  921. stpeter has joined
  922. stpeter has left
  923. mukt2 has left