XSF Discussion - 2022-01-09

  1. wladmis has left

  2. msavoritias has left

  3. intosi has left

  4. adiaholic has joined

  5. adiaholic has left

  6. adiaholic has joined

  7. BASSGOD has left

  8. wladmis has joined

  9. Nekit has joined

  10. adiaholic has left

  11. Stefan

    The need of a product is more for users. For XMPP specification it would be helpful to have developers for XMPP libs. If you are going to develop a lib, you will look into the design and use cases.

  12. norkki has left

  13. norkki has joined

  14. adiaholic has joined

  15. Tobias has left

  16. paul has left

  17. millesimus has left

  18. adiaholic has left

  19. karoshi has left

  20. BASSGOD has joined

  21. Maranda

    I think that without appealing users with modern looking clients and/or solutions, it's like the Titanic still moving forward after it struck on the iceberg.. no offense.

  22. wladmis has left

  23. intosi has joined

  24. BASSGOD has left

  25. wladmis has joined

  26. millesimus has joined

  27. BASSGOD has joined

  28. BASSGOD has left

  29. Titi has left

  30. pjn has left

  31. BASSGOD has joined

  32. BASSGOD has left

  33. intosi has left

  34. wladmis has left

  35. adiaholic has joined

  36. BASSGOD has joined

  37. Titi has joined

  38. lskdjf has left

  39. atomicwatch has left

  40. wurstsalat has left

  41. adiaholic has left

  42. atomicwatch has joined

  43. Titi has left

  44. adiaholic has joined

  45. homebeach has left

  46. Matthew has left

  47. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  48. uhoreg has left

  49. Half-Shot has left

  50. Half-Shot has joined

  51. Matthew has joined

  52. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  53. uhoreg has joined

  54. homebeach has joined

  55. Maranda[x] has left

  56. Maranda[x] has joined

  57. emus has left

  58. wladmis has joined

  59. sonny has left

  60. sonny has joined

  61. sonny has left

  62. sonny has joined

  63. adiaholic has left

  64. adiaholic has joined

  65. wladmis has left

  66. stp has left

  67. BASSGOD has left

  68. adiaholic has left

  69. intosi has joined

  70. marc0s has left

  71. marc0s has joined

  72. moparisthebest

    Define "modern looking"

  73. John has left

  74. moparisthebest has left

  75. BASSGOD has joined

  76. John has joined

  77. adiaholic has joined

  78. BASSGOD has left

  79. moparisthebest has joined

  80. intosi has left

  81. BASSGOD has joined

  82. BASSGOD has left

  83. BASSGOD has joined

  84. kurisu has joined

  85. pjn has joined

  86. adiaholic has left

  87. adiaholic has joined

  88. arcxi has joined

  89. kurisu has left

  90. adiaholic has left

  91. Steve Kille has left

  92. Steve Kille has joined

  93. kyemxden has left

  94. kyemxden has joined

  95. վարյա has left

  96. վարյա has joined

  97. kurisu has joined

  98. djorz has left

  99. kurisu has left

  100. intosi has joined

  101. debacle has left

  102. adiaholic has joined

  103. thilo.molitor has left

  104. thilo.molitor has joined

  105. kurisu has joined

  106. arcxi has left

  107. arcxi has joined

  108. intosi has left

  109. arcxi has left

  110. arcxi has joined

  111. arcxi has left

  112. Ingolf has left

  113. Ingolf has joined

  114. kurisu has left

  115. stp has joined

  116. kyemxden has left

  117. kyemxden has joined

  118. kurisu has joined

  119. intosi has joined

  120. rumin-miller has joined

  121. rumin-miller has left

  122. kurisu has left

  123. sonny has left

  124. sonny has joined

  125. intosi has left

  126. adiaholic has left

  127. kurisu has joined

  128. floretta has left

  129. adiaholic has joined

  130. restive_monk has left

  131. kyemxden has left

  132. kyemxden has joined

  133. kurisu has left

  134. Seve has joined

  135. restive_monk has joined

  136. ti_gj06 has joined

  137. adiaholic has left

  138. adiaholic has joined

  139. kurisu has joined

  140. ti_gj06 has left

  141. intosi has joined

  142. adiaholic has left

  143. adiaholic has joined

  144. intosi has left

  145. floretta has joined

  146. kurisu has left

  147. kurisu has joined

  148. david has left

  149. david has joined

  150. Menel has joined

  151. ti_gj06 has joined

  152. kurisu has left

  153. uhoreg has left

  154. homebeach has left

  155. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  156. Matthew has left

  157. Half-Shot has left

  158. Half-Shot has joined

  159. Matthew has joined

  160. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  161. uhoreg has joined

  162. homebeach has joined

  163. paul has joined

  164. adiaholic has left

  165. pasdesushi has joined

  166. adiaholic has joined

  167. pjn has left

  168. Menel has left

  169. neshtaxmpp has left

  170. neshtaxmpp has joined

  171. jcbrand has joined

  172. karoshi has joined

  173. kyemxden has left

  174. adiaholic has left

  175. lorddavidiii has left

  176. Seve has left

  177. kyemxden has joined

  178. uhoreg has left

  179. homebeach has left

  180. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  181. Matthew has left

  182. Half-Shot has left

  183. Half-Shot has joined

  184. Matthew has joined

  185. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  186. uhoreg has joined

  187. homebeach has joined

  188. Seve has joined

  189. kurisu has joined

  190. Ingolf has left

  191. Ingolf has joined

  192. kyemxden has left

  193. kyemxden has joined

  194. Friendly Resident Cynic has joined

  195. karoshi has left

  196. Friendly Resident Cynic

    > I think that without appealing users with modern looking clients and/or solutions, it's like the Titanic still moving forward after it struck on the iceberg.. no offense. Conversations app looks perfect to me. clean and simple. I wouldn't use it if it looked as bloated as Facebook Messenger.

  197. Friendly Resident Cynic

    Although... If there was an xmpp Client app that also let you manage your SMS text messages it would add an extra level of convenience for the end user.

  198. atomicwatch has left

  199. kurisu has left

  200. pasdesushi has left

  201. kurisu has joined

  202. pjn has joined

  203. kurisu has left

  204. pasdesushi has joined

  205. BASSGOD has left

  206. atomicwatch has joined

  207. adiaholic has joined

  208. BASSGOD has joined

  209. lovetox

    for this has nothing to do with users and if the use clients or not

  210. lovetox

    i was speaking from a point of coherent protocol design

  211. lovetox

    i have the opinion that devs can also build good clients with very bad specs

  212. lovetox

    but it is much more work

  213. ti_gj06 has left

  214. wladmis has joined

  215. lorddavidiii has joined

  216. karoshi has joined

  217. wladmis has left

  218. wladmis has joined

  219. atomicwatch has left

  220. sonny has left

  221. sonny has joined

  222. վարյա has left

  223. wladmis has left

  224. Yagiza has joined

  225. Daniel

    lovetox: I think a lot of the misunderstanding stems from the fact that we give almost anything a number and giving it a number doesn't mean any andorsement whatsoever

  226. pasdesushi has left

  227. Daniel

    Compliance suite and/or 'stable' are the endorsements

  228. Daniel


  229. ti_gj06 has joined

  230. Daniel

    I've personally voted a lot of xeps into experimental that I don't agree with

  231. Daniel

    I don't think it's my job as council to put that kind of barrier up. not due to lazyness but because I think (thought?) we had some kind of consensus that this is how the process works

  232. Daniel

    I fact I'm describing that in my council application

  233. Daniel

    However I do see how it having a number can signal endorsement to the outside.

  234. Daniel

    Especially because other standards bodies (the ietf for example) put much more scrutiny into an rfc before assigning it a number

  235. restive_monk has left

  236. Daniel

    I'm personally actually leaning more towards the ietf approach

  237. Daniel

    But I can't start voting that way (blocking experimental xeps) if we don't have a consensus that this is how we want it to be

  238. Daniel

    It would also be somewhat weird to change the process 20 years in with that many (sorry) garbage xeps already having a number

  239. millesimus has left

  240. millesimus has joined

  241. mjk has joined

  242. mjk has left

  243. mjk has joined

  244. ti_gj06 has left

  245. Daniel

    putting council aside I think the best quality XEPs are produced if a group of people work on solving the same problem at the same time. meaning having the need for and implementing a xep in the same ~6 month time span. that can spark great discussions and great informed feedback because they are all implementing it. for example I actually kinda like what we did with jingle message init. three people implemented it; basically ran into the same issues and collectively came up with solutions for those issues. implemented the solutions and modified the xep. only that this happened over 2 years+ in the case of jingle message init because we client developers aren't always working on the same issues

  246. Daniel

    at least not at the same time

  247. pjn has left

  248. lovetox

    i think this apprach puts council in a corner

  249. lovetox

    you publish a XEP, a number of clients implement it

  250. lovetox

    after they want it stable

  251. lovetox

    council looks at it, and says, this is horrible from a design perspective, it does not fit good into our other specs

  252. lovetox

    but you cant say no, because many clients use and implement it and they tell you: for what is council good if you obviously dont want the things we implement and work

  253. lovetox

    so the whole big picture of the xmpp protocol design, goes out of the window for a more pratical, if X people implement it its good enough

  254. lovetox

    even if it violates design principles of XEPs that we have since X years

  255. lovetox

    i dont have a concrete example, thats just what i would fear if i were a council member

  256. emus has joined

  257. John has left

  258. pasdesushi has joined

  259. John has joined

  260. Alex has joined

  261. Daniel

    It's not like council is constantly moving ~garbage~ xeps that don't fit The Vision to stable

  262. lovetox

    but if i think about it i really talk about the subtle things of a XEP - do i put this element in its own namespace or not - do i add this data as attribute or as element - do i wrap this into a <query> or not etc.

  263. lovetox

    i have the feeling such things are almost never a stopper

  264. Daniel

    In fact council is very rarely moving stuff to stable. (maybe because there is only garbage in experimental)

  265. Daniel

    Yes xeps that are written in a single voice

  266. Daniel

    That's true. And somewhat said. But I'm not sure if that's the most pressing thing we need to focus on

  267. Daniel

    I mean we we obviously get better results if council were five individuals who are both elected and employed full time by their respective companies to write the xeps

  268. Daniel

    But that's just not the case

  269. reimar has joined

  270. Daniel

    We can agree to change the process but we can't magically make good protocol designers appear

  271. lovetox

    i whised it was more like code review

  272. lovetox

    someone proposes a XEP, then some maintainer goes like, change this, this this this

  273. lovetox

    ok now we have something we can merge

  274. lovetox

    does not mean it gets adopted

  275. alacer has left

  276. alacer has joined

  277. վարյա has joined

  278. lovetox

    but at least its consistent with other syntax and approaches we have in other xeps

  279. lovetox

    im not sure we need someone fulltime for that, maybe just the consensus that someone has the power to tell people that

  280. kyemxden has left

  281. kyemxden has joined

  282. marc0s has left

  283. marc0s has joined

  284. marc0s has left

  285. marc0s has joined

  286. wladmis has joined

  287. ti_gj06 has joined

  288. marc0s has left

  289. marc0s has joined

  290. marc0s has left

  291. marc0s has joined

  292. wladmis has left

  293. wladmis has joined

  294. marc0s has left

  295. marc0s has joined

  296. kyemxden has left

  297. goffi has joined

  298. marc0s has left

  299. marc0s has joined

  300. Stefan

    Maybe some kind of Mentor.

  301. John has left

  302. kyemxden has joined

  303. John has joined

  304. kurisu has joined

  305. msavoritias has joined

  306. pjn has joined

  307. ti_gj06 has left

  308. druthid has left

  309. Tobias has joined

  310. wladmis has left

  311. adiaholic has left

  312. marc0s has left

  313. ti_gj06 has joined

  314. marc0s has joined

  315. floretta has left

  316. wladmis has joined

  317. wurstsalat has joined

  318. floretta has joined

  319. վարյա has left

  320. վարյա has joined

  321. ti_gj06 has left

  322. tykayn has joined

  323. kurisu has left

  324. adiaholic has joined

  325. kurisu has joined

  326. lskdjf has joined

  327. wgreenhouse has left

  328. goffi has left

  329. kurisu has left

  330. kurisu has joined

  331. homebeach has left

  332. Matthew has left

  333. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  334. uhoreg has left

  335. Half-Shot has left

  336. Half-Shot has joined

  337. Matthew has joined

  338. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  339. uhoreg has joined

  340. homebeach has joined

  341. goffi has joined

  342. ti_gj06 has joined

  343. floretta has left

  344. floretta has joined

  345. moparisthebest has left

  346. floretta has left

  347. bean has joined

  348. bean has left

  349. bean has joined

  350. wladmis has left

  351. wladmis has joined

  352. bean has left

  353. bean has joined

  354. moparisthebest has joined

  355. Mikaela has joined

  356. ti_gj06 has left

  357. floretta has joined

  358. goffi has left

  359. nicola has joined

  360. pjn has left

  361. nicola has left

  362. nicola has joined

  363. eab has left

  364. eab has joined

  365. kyemxden has left

  366. wladmis has left

  367. kyemxden has joined

  368. arcxi has joined

  369. nicola has left

  370. restive_monk has joined

  371. debacle has joined

  372. MattJ

    Well, stpeter filled this role in the past - whether it was technically part of the role of "Editor" or not, it's definitely not today. Peter wrote and maintained a vast number of XEPs, recording community consensus from the mailing list. These days writing XEPs is not considered anyone's job in particular. I think that's unfortunate.

  373. wladmis has joined

  374. wgreenhouse has joined

  375. jonas’

    lovetox, FWIW, nothing stops a XEP author to gather feedback from standards@ or the MUCs (jdev@, xsf@ or in some cases even editor@ would be a godo choice),

  376. jonas’

    lovetox, FWIW, nothing stops a XEP author to gather feedback from standards@ or the MUCs (jdev@, xsf@ or in some cases even editor@ would be a godo choice).

  377. arcxi has left

  378. jonas’

    it's just that virtually nobody does this for whatever reason.

  379. lovetox

    because they dont need to, if you can get your merge request merged without conulting the maintainer you probably would also just do

  380. lovetox

    i understand that its different because nobody does own XMPP

  381. floretta has left

  382. lovetox

    it would still need somebody that consider it his own, and acts like it

  383. jonas’

    well, the XEP author "owns" the XEP in that regard

  384. jonas’

    you cannot get patches to a XEP merged without author or council consensus

  385. jonas’

    (or an editor mistake :))

  386. MattJ

    That's different to "owning" XMPP though

  387. jonas’


  388. jonas’


  389. lovetox

    i mean i know i speak obvious things, and i know nobody can magically make someone appear who does that

  390. MattJ

    Summits were a good way to get everyone on the same page, or at least a couple of pages

  391. wgreenhouse has left

  392. jonas’

    MattJ, though summits were, at least from my perspective, to considerable parts attended by folks who are only barely working on public XMPP impls.

  393. MattJ

    Yeah, in some way sprints were a good counter to that :)

  394. lorddavidiii has left

  395. millesimus has left

  396. floretta has joined

  397. lorddavidiii has joined

  398. arcxi has joined

  399. Seve has left

  400. Seve has joined

  401. Titi has joined

  402. wladmis has left

  403. lovetox

    i thought about more why i feel that way right now, and its all the new XEPs, there seems to be many that use some kind of "apply-to" or "fasten" mechanism, and also what currently is discussed on the list with "compatibility fallbacks" and for me it began with the still kind of unresolved deprecation of XHTML and the two styling xeps that resultet from that. their seems much movement but nothing that guides that into a good channel. We recently added that moderation XEP, afterwards it didnt receive so good feedback on the list, design wise, of course it fullfills the use case perfectly fine. Im really hesitant to implement any of these new things, and without implementation there is no feedback, hence they can not actively developed ..

  404. arcxi has left

  405. arcxi has joined

  406. jl4 has joined

  407. jonas’

    at the time moderation was accepted, fastening was new and it wasn't clear yet whether it'd be continued and take off, so basing things on it made sense. now it's two years later and nothing's going on with fastening so it's not as clear it should still be used.

  408. jonas’

    (irrespective of the reasons for any of that)

  409. jonas’

    lovetox, initially, the experimental phase was designed for design discussions, not for implementation, so your hesitance isn't completely surprising. this is mostly showing the divide between the "first code then spec" and "first spec then code" people, I think.

  410. jonas’

    the former are often funded in one way or another.

  411. raghavgururajan has left

  412. jonas’

    though I note that some of the feedback to moderation et al. should've come during the acceptance

  413. jonas’

    e.g. "make a requirements section" etc.

  414. pjn has joined

  415. kurisu has left

  416. kurisu has joined

  417. kyemxden has left

  418. kyemxden has joined

  419. kurisu has left

  420. millesimus has joined

  421. wgreenhouse has joined

  422. deuill has joined

  423. reimar has left

  424. reimar has joined

  425. wgreenhouse has left

  426. kyemxden has left

  427. kyemxden has joined

  428. arcxi has left

  429. arcxi has joined

  430. nicola has joined

  431. nicola has left

  432. nicola has joined

  433. wgreenhouse has joined

  434. ti_gj06 has joined

  435. nicola has left

  436. wgreenhouse has left

  437. restive_monk has left

  438. kurisu has joined

  439. floretta has left

  440. restive_monk has joined

  441. lorddavidiii has left

  442. adiaholic has left

  443. guus.der.kinderen has left

  444. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  445. lorddavidiii has joined

  446. adiaholic has joined

  447. floretta has joined

  448. bean has left

  449. stp has left

  450. flow

    I am not sure that the idea was ever to perform design discussion without having, at least prototypical, implementations

  451. flow

    I am not sure that the idea was ever to perform design discussions without having, at least prototypical, implementations

  452. flow

    on the other hand, we tend to hold on to "good enough" implementations. I am not sure what the current state is, but at least in the past, OMEMO was, and maybe still is, a prime example

  453. millesimus has left

  454. mjk has left

  455. flow

    the initial omemo spec works good enough, even though it has significant drawbacks, so the current omemo spec does not see much adoption (again, not sure what the current state is)

  456. mjk has joined

  457. flow

    to be fair, initially omemo probably gained so much adoption because it filled a large specification holed that people really wanted to see filled

  458. flow

    to be fair, initially omemo probably gained so much adoption because it filled a large specification hole that people really wanted to see filled

  459. kyemxden has left

  460. kyemxden has joined

  461. adiaholic has left

  462. flow

    to be fair, the initial omemo spec probably gained so much adoption because it filled a large specification hole that people really wanted to see filled

  463. wgreenhouse has joined

  464. restive_monk has left

  465. dan.caseley has left

  466. dan.caseley has joined

  467. adiaholic has joined

  468. millesimus has joined

  469. flow

    fwiw, the subscription count of r/xmpp: https://subredditstats.com/r/xmpp

  470. flow

    feel free to compare to r/matrixdotorg ;)

  471. u70jfzo5eyeb468b9o has left

  472. millesimus has left

  473. Yagiza has left

  474. Alex has left

  475. lorddavidiii has left

  476. Zash


  477. adiaholic has left

  478. Nekit has left

  479. adiaholic has joined

  480. marc0s has left

  481. marc0s has joined

  482. djorz has joined

  483. restive_monk has joined

  484. millesimus has joined

  485. dan.caseley has left

  486. dan.caseley has joined

  487. raghavgururajan has joined

  488. millesimus has left

  489. ti_gj06 has left

  490. adiaholic has left

  491. u70jfzo5eyeb468b9o has joined

  492. u70jfzo5eyeb468b9o has left

  493. u70jfzo5eyeb468b9o has joined

  494. stp has joined

  495. debacle has left

  496. rubi has left

  497. John has left

  498. stp has left

  499. jl4 has left

  500. jl4 has joined

  501. moparisthebest has left

  502. rubi has joined

  503. Alex has joined

  504. druthid has joined

  505. kurisu has left

  506. kurisu has joined

  507. kurisu has left

  508. millesimus has joined

  509. stp has joined

  510. lorddavidiii has joined

  511. lorddavidiii has left

  512. moparisthebest has joined

  513. deuill has left

  514. jgart has left

  515. adiaholic has joined

  516. restive_monk has left

  517. harry837374884 has left

  518. harry837374884 has joined

  519. lorddavidiii has joined

  520. lorddavidiii has left

  521. Yagiza has joined

  522. lorddavidiii has joined

  523. rocco has joined

  524. jgart has joined

  525. rocco has left

  526. adiaholic has left

  527. adiaholic has joined

  528. guus.der.kinderen has left

  529. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  530. millesimus has left

  531. atomicwatch has joined

  532. adiaholic has left

  533. adiaholic has joined

  534. kurisu has joined

  535. millesimus has joined

  536. restive_monk has joined

  537. jgart has left

  538. restive_monk has left

  539. millesimus has left

  540. goffi has joined

  541. kurisu has left

  542. ti_gj06 has joined

  543. kyemxden has left

  544. kyemxden has joined

  545. John has joined

  546. lorddavidiii has left

  547. millesimus has joined

  548. lorddavidiii has joined

  549. lorddavidiii has left

  550. lorddavidiii has joined

  551. lorddavidiii has left

  552. harry837374884 has left

  553. lorddavidiii has joined

  554. lorddavidiii has left

  555. lorddavidiii has joined

  556. lorddavidiii has left

  557. millesimus has left

  558. lorddavidiii has joined

  559. lorddavidiii has left

  560. lorddavidiii has joined

  561. lorddavidiii has left

  562. lorddavidiii has joined

  563. lorddavidiii has left

  564. adiaholic has left

  565. lorddavidiii has joined

  566. lorddavidiii has left

  567. lorddavidiii has joined

  568. lorddavidiii has left

  569. lorddavidiii has joined

  570. lorddavidiii has left

  571. millesimus has joined

  572. harry837374884 has joined

  573. lorddavidiii has joined

  574. lorddavidiii has left

  575. adiaholic has joined

  576. lorddavidiii has joined

  577. lorddavidiii has left

  578. lorddavidiii has joined

  579. lorddavidiii has left

  580. adiaholic has left

  581. lorddavidiii has joined

  582. lorddavidiii has left

  583. millesimus has left

  584. kurisu has joined

  585. kurisu has left

  586. adiaholic has joined

  587. me9 has joined

  588. lorddavidiii has joined

  589. lorddavidiii has left

  590. neshtaxmpp has left

  591. neshtaxmpp has joined

  592. lorddavidiii has joined

  593. lorddavidiii has left

  594. lorddavidiii has joined

  595. lorddavidiii has left

  596. millesimus has joined

  597. lorddavidiii has joined

  598. lorddavidiii has left

  599. lorddavidiii has joined

  600. lorddavidiii has left

  601. lorddavidiii has joined

  602. lorddavidiii has left

  603. rubi has left

  604. rubi has joined

  605. lorddavidiii has joined

  606. lorddavidiii has left

  607. lorddavidiii has joined

  608. lorddavidiii has left

  609. jl4 has left

  610. adiaholic has left

  611. lorddavidiii has joined

  612. lorddavidiii has left

  613. adiaholic has joined

  614. lorddavidiii has joined

  615. lorddavidiii has left

  616. lorddavidiii has joined

  617. rubi has left

  618. rubi has joined

  619. marc0s has left

  620. marc0s has joined

  621. harry837374884 has left

  622. larma

    I think the whole apply-to/fasten/mam-fc/... problem is that this is actually more like a server feature but it needs to go in client XEPs and also no client is relying on this server feature or expecting it, so no server developer puts time in this. A single hand that develops both server and thin (web) client and ideally wants to add the new features (replies, reactions, etc) prototypical would be very helpful here, as they would actually know what they need. But we're not going to get someone to volunteer for this as it's a hell lot of work. BTW: I once built this concept [https://gist.github.com/mar-v-in/e5a6c7f551dab7c833829d604a825d63], but I felt it doesn't make a lot of sense to further write this into a full XEP without also designing a corresponding server XEP which I felt not to be the right person for.

  623. adiaholic has left

  624. adiaholic has joined

  625. Zash

    <hat:prosody-developer> In Prosody, properly supporting generic apply/fasten/whatever seems to demand yet another low-level storage API re-design, which has lower priority than finishing 0.12 right now. The current API is split into a fairly simple key-value store and and an append-only thing for archives, which had to be extended a bit for '425. Even PEP barely makes sense currently, due to being one level deeper than the currently fixed depth / width of key-tuples or whatyoucallit. </hat>

  626. marc0s has left

  627. marc0s has joined

  628. harry837374884 has joined

  629. Maranda[x] has left

  630. Maranda[x] has joined

  631. floretta has left

  632. millesimus has left

  633. pasdesushi has left

  634. ti_gj06 has left

  635. adiaholic has left

  636. jgart has joined

  637. pasdesushi has joined

  638. adiaholic has joined

  639. floretta has joined

  640. debacle has joined

  641. Titi has left

  642. mjk has left

  643. mjk has joined

  644. Paganini has left

  645. ti_gj06 has joined

  646. millesimus has joined

  647. floretta has left

  648. wladmis has joined

  649. adiaholic has left

  650. wladmis has left

  651. wladmis has joined

  652. jl4 has joined

  653. uhoreg has left

  654. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  655. homebeach has left

  656. Matthew has left

  657. Half-Shot has left

  658. Half-Shot has joined

  659. Matthew has joined

  660. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  661. uhoreg has joined

  662. homebeach has joined

  663. bean has joined

  664. adiaholic has joined

  665. floretta has joined

  666. jl4 has left

  667. jl4 has joined

  668. homebeach has left

  669. Matthew has left

  670. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  671. uhoreg has left

  672. Half-Shot has left

  673. adiaholic has left

  674. Half-Shot has joined

  675. Matthew has joined

  676. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  677. uhoreg has joined

  678. homebeach has joined

  679. ti_gj06 has left

  680. ti_gj06 has joined

  681. wladmis has left

  682. TheCoffeMaker has left

  683. BASSGOD has left

  684. adiaholic has joined

  685. BASSGOD has joined

  686. jl4 has left

  687. adiaholic has left

  688. ti_gj06 has left

  689. floretta has left

  690. floretta has joined

  691. Titi has joined

  692. atomicwatch has left

  693. adiaholic has joined

  694. atomicwatch has joined

  695. wladmis has joined

  696. wladmis has left

  697. adiaholic has left

  698. wladmis has joined

  699. ti_gj06 has joined

  700. wladmis has left

  701. wladmis has joined

  702. floretta has left

  703. pjn has left

  704. wladmis has left

  705. Titi has left

  706. Titi has joined

  707. BASSGOD has left

  708. floretta has joined

  709. adiaholic has joined

  710. Fishbowler has joined

  711. BASSGOD has joined

  712. goffi has left

  713. wladmis has joined

  714. pjn has joined

  715. wladmis has left

  716. wladmis has joined

  717. adiaholic has left

  718. Fishbowler has left

  719. Fishbowler has joined

  720. Fishbowler has left

  721. atomicwatch has left

  722. Fishbowler has joined

  723. Fishbowler has left

  724. Fishbowler has joined

  725. floretta has left

  726. Yagiza has left

  727. Fishbowler has left

  728. Shackleton has joined

  729. mjk has left

  730. mjk has joined

  731. Friendly Resident Cynic has left

  732. atomicwatch has joined

  733. Shackleton has left

  734. papatutuwawa has joined

  735. ti_gj06 has left

  736. wladmis has left

  737. sonny has left

  738. sonny has joined

  739. xecks has left

  740. Friendly Resident Cynic has joined

  741. goffi has joined

  742. Vaulor has left

  743. Titi has left

  744. BASSGOD has left

  745. Titi has joined

  746. xecks has joined

  747. Tobias has left

  748. Tobias has joined

  749. floretta has joined

  750. BASSGOD has joined

  751. Vaulor has joined

  752. marc0s has left

  753. marc0s has joined

  754. Valerian has joined

  755. Valerian has left

  756. BASSGOD has left

  757. BASSGOD has joined

  758. John has left

  759. me9 has left

  760. stp has left

  761. jgart has left

  762. BASSGOD has left

  763. վարյա has left

  764. վարյա has joined

  765. John has joined

  766. L29Ah has left

  767. John has left

  768. John has joined

  769. pjn has left

  770. millesimus has left

  771. BASSGOD has joined

  772. pjn has joined

  773. inky has left

  774. John has left

  775. millesimus has joined

  776. floretta has left

  777. huhn has joined

  778. John has joined

  779. L29Ah has joined

  780. andrey.g has joined

  781. BASSGOD has left

  782. floretta has joined

  783. millesimus has left

  784. reimar has left

  785. L29Ah has left

  786. L29Ah has joined

  787. andrey.g has left

  788. wladmis has joined

  789. jcbrand has left

  790. jgart has joined

  791. millesimus has joined

  792. millesimus has left

  793. phryk has left

  794. millesimus has joined

  795. floretta has left

  796. phryk has joined

  797. L29Ah has left

  798. BASSGOD has joined

  799. L29Ah has joined

  800. atomicwatch has left

  801. wladmis has left

  802. wladmis has joined

  803. Maranda[x] has left

  804. Maranda[x] has joined

  805. wladmis has left

  806. floretta has joined

  807. chronosx88 has left

  808. chronosx88 has joined

  809. jcbrand has joined

  810. վարյա has left

  811. վարյա has joined

  812. atomicwatch has joined

  813. u70jfzo5eyeb468b9o has left

  814. u70jfzo5eyeb468b9o has joined

  815. karoshi has left

  816. karoshi has joined

  817. kyemxden has left

  818. kyemxden has joined

  819. stp has joined

  820. atomicwatch has left

  821. sonny has left

  822. sonny has joined

  823. chronosx88 has left

  824. chronosx88 has joined

  825. Tobias has left

  826. sonny has left

  827. sonny has joined

  828. sonny has left

  829. sonny has joined

  830. sonny has left

  831. sonny has joined

  832. bean has left

  833. sonny has left

  834. sonny has joined

  835. stp has left

  836. sonny has left

  837. sonny has joined

  838. uhoreg has left

  839. homebeach has left

  840. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  841. Matthew has left

  842. Half-Shot has left

  843. Seve has left

  844. Half-Shot has joined

  845. Matthew has joined

  846. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  847. uhoreg has joined

  848. homebeach has joined

  849. atomicwatch has joined

  850. sonny has left

  851. sonny has joined

  852. lorddavidiii has left

  853. pasdesushi has left

  854. L29Ah has left

  855. millesimus has left

  856. uhoreg has left

  857. homebeach has left

  858. Rixon 👁🗨 has left

  859. Matthew has left

  860. Half-Shot has left

  861. Half-Shot has joined

  862. Matthew has joined

  863. Rixon 👁🗨 has joined

  864. uhoreg has joined

  865. homebeach has joined

  866. millesimus has joined

  867. marc0s has left

  868. marc0s has joined

  869. emus has left

  870. վարյա has left

  871. Mikaela has left

  872. msavoritias has left

  873. L29Ah has joined

  874. goffi has left

  875. վարյա has joined

  876. marc0s has left

  877. marc0s has joined

  878. sonny has left

  879. sonny has joined

  880. papatutuwawa has left

  881. sonny has left

  882. sonny has joined

  883. neshtaxmpp has left

  884. neshtaxmpp has joined

  885. floretta has left

  886. BASSGOD has left

  887. marc0s has left

  888. marc0s has joined

  889. BASSGOD has joined

  890. restive_monk has joined

  891. sonny has left

  892. sonny has joined

  893. Titi has left

  894. sonny has left

  895. sonny has joined

  896. sonny has left

  897. sonny has joined

  898. wurstsalat has left

  899. sonny has left

  900. sonny has joined

  901. sonny has left

  902. sonny has joined

  903. restive_monk has left

  904. restive_monk has joined

  905. sonny has left