XSF Discussion - 2022-05-31

  1. floretta has left

  2. andrey.g has left

  3. floretta has joined

  4. adiaholic has joined

  5. debacle has left

  6. eu has left

  7. adiaholic has left

  8. eu has joined

  9. adiaholic has joined

  10. adiaholic has left

  11. stp has joined

  12. jl4 has left

  13. Maranda[x] has left

  14. neshtaxmpp has left

  15. floretta has left

  16. floretta has joined

  17. adiaholic has joined

  18. adiaholic has left

  19. neshtaxmpp has joined

  20. anamulhaque has joined

  21. anamulhaque has left

  22. anamulhaque has joined

  23. neshtaxmpp has left

  24. gooya has joined

  25. floretta has left

  26. floretta has joined

  27. rumin-miller has joined

  28. rumin-miller has left

  29. adiaholic has joined

  30. adiaholic has left

  31. anamulhaque has left

  32. anamulhaque has joined

  33. adiaholic has joined

  34. floretta has left

  35. floretta has joined

  36. Calvin has joined

  37. anamulhaque has left

  38. anamulhaque has joined

  39. gooya has left

  40. jcbrand has left

  41. jgart has left

  42. pablo has joined

  43. anamulhaque has left

  44. anamulhaque has joined

  45. adiaholic has left

  46. neshtaxmpp has joined

  47. floretta has left

  48. floretta has joined

  49. Steve Kille has left

  50. Steve Kille has joined

  51. anamulhaque has left

  52. anamulhaque has joined

  53. neshtaxmpp has left

  54. david has joined

  55. david has left

  56. pablo has left

  57. anamulhaque has left

  58. anamulhaque has joined

  59. floretta has left

  60. floretta has joined

  61. Maranda[x] has joined

  62. konstantinos has joined

  63. adiaholic has joined

  64. thndrbvr has left

  65. floretta has left

  66. Yagiza has joined

  67. RayTutu has left

  68. djorz has left

  69. floretta has joined

  70. konstantinos has left

  71. Calvin has left

  72. Half-Shot has left

  73. Matthew has left

  74. uhoreg has left

  75. homebeach has left

  76. Half-Shot has joined

  77. Matthew has joined

  78. homebeach has joined

  79. uhoreg has joined

  80. pjn has left

  81. anamulhaque has left

  82. anamulhaque has joined

  83. Ingolf has joined

  84. konstantinos has joined

  85. menel has joined

  86. anamulhaque has left

  87. anamulhaque has joined

  88. neshtaxmpp has joined

  89. neshtaxmpp has left

  90. pasdesushi has joined

  91. Ingolf has left

  92. Seve has joined

  93. floretta has left

  94. floretta has joined

  95. anamulhaque has left

  96. anamulhaque has joined

  97. nikhilmwarrier has joined

  98. mjk has left

  99. mjk has joined

  100. adiaholic has left

  101. anamulhaque has left

  102. anamulhaque has joined

  103. adiaholic has joined

  104. Ingolf has joined

  105. neshtaxmpp has joined

  106. adiaholic has left

  107. Tobias has joined

  108. adiaholic has joined

  109. anamulhaque has left

  110. anamulhaque has joined

  111. adiaholic has left

  112. mimi89999 has left

  113. Tobias has left

  114. Tobias has joined

  115. Tobias has left

  116. Tobias has joined

  117. adiaholic has joined

  118. lovetox has left

  119. lovetox has joined

  120. Sam has left

  121. Sam has joined

  122. adiaholic has left

  123. neshtaxmpp has left

  124. neshtaxmpp has joined

  125. anamulhaque has left

  126. anamulhaque has joined

  127. adiaholic has joined

  128. neshtaxmpp has left

  129. neshtaxmpp has joined

  130. neshtaxmpp has left

  131. neshtaxmpp has joined

  132. adiaholic has left

  133. lskdjf has joined

  134. mimi89999 has joined

  135. Tobias has left

  136. Tobias has joined

  137. adiaholic has joined

  138. anamulhaque has left

  139. anamulhaque has joined

  140. debacle has joined

  141. wurstsalat has joined

  142. thndrbvr has joined

  143. Paganini has left

  144. emus has joined

  145. adiaholic has left

  146. jcbrand has joined

  147. lovetox has left

  148. adiaholic has joined

  149. anamulhaque has left

  150. anamulhaque has joined

  151. lovetox has joined

  152. neshtaxmpp has left

  153. neshtaxmpp has joined

  154. neshtaxmpp has left

  155. neshtaxmpp has joined

  156. neshtaxmpp has left

  157. neshtaxmpp has joined

  158. neshtaxmpp has left

  159. neshtaxmpp has joined

  160. Sam has left

  161. rebeld22 has left

  162. adiaholic has left

  163. konstantinos has left

  164. karoshi has joined

  165. Sam has joined

  166. neshtaxmpp has left

  167. neshtaxmpp has joined

  168. david has joined

  169. david has left

  170. djorz has joined

  171. anamulhaque has left

  172. anamulhaque has joined

  173. Titi has joined

  174. Titi has left

  175. djorz has left

  176. anamulhaque has left

  177. anamulhaque has joined

  178. Titi has joined

  179. djorz has joined

  180. nikhilmwarrier has left

  181. Steve Kille has left

  182. Steve Kille has joined

  183. L29Ah has left

  184. sebastian has left

  185. sebastian has joined

  186. anamulhaque has left

  187. anamulhaque has joined

  188. adiaholic has joined

  189. goffi has joined

  190. pasdesushi has left

  191. karoshi has left

  192. neshtaxmpp has left

  193. neshtaxmpp has joined

  194. Fishbowler has left

  195. Fishbowler has joined

  196. pasdesushi has joined

  197. goffi has left

  198. djorz has left

  199. adiaholic has left

  200. konstantinos has joined

  201. adiaholic has joined

  202. karoshi has joined

  203. adiaholic has left

  204. msavoritias has joined

  205. anamulhaque has left

  206. adiaholic has joined

  207. goffi has joined

  208. Kev has joined

  209. Guus

    Are there any best practices on ensuing that only a recognized (mobile) device is used by a particular end-user? For example, not any other phone than the first one that was used by the client (unless some kind of manual administrative action is performed?

  210. APach has left

  211. APach has joined

  212. Guus

    Basically, I'm looking for a way to prevent a device other than the one that's either implicitly or explicitly associated with the end-user to be used for the account of that end-user.

  213. mh has left

  214. Ingolf has left

  215. Ingolf has joined

  216. Kev

    Do you control the client and server?

  217. chipmnk has left

  218. Kev

    It's not a best practice, but in that case you could fairly easily use a persistent resource from the client (but would obviously have to then randomise it on the server).

  219. konstantinos has left

  220. Tim R has joined

  221. jonas’

    Guus, generate a certificate, use client-certificate authentication.

  222. mh has joined

  223. SteveF has joined

  224. jonas’

    (and put the key into device storage which cannot be copied (easily) to another device, don't allow sign-up with another key unless administrative action)

  225. Kev

    Or that, depending how much 'administrative action' you want to be required.

  226. Tim R has left

  227. Tim R has joined

  228. Guus

    Kev: as in resource binding? I thought of that, but I worried that this would be pretty easy to mimic - especially since the resource that's used will be used in stanzas that are sent to other users?

  229. APach has left

  230. Guus

    jonas’ thanks, that's the route that I was dreading :)

  231. Kev

    No, you'd reject the client-provided resource and use a server-provided one.

  232. APach has joined

  233. SteveF has left

  234. Guus

    Kev: ah, right - so the client-provided resource would never escape into the wild. That hinges on clients actually accepting a server-provided resource that's different from the one that they provide. I recall that the spec allows for this, but is that used in practice?

  235. Kev


  236. yushyin has left

  237. SteveF has joined

  238. SteveF has left

  239. SteveF has joined

  240. SteveF has left

  241. Kev

    Clients that don't cope with server-provided resources are broken.

  242. Kev

    But I did predictate it on you controlling the server and client :)

  243. Guus

    me controlling the server and client does not implicate that they're not broken. :D

  244. adiaholic has left

  245. Kev


  246. yushyin has joined

  247. jonas’

    Guus, why dreading? It should be simple and straightforward and it ensures your requirements more or less cryptographically

  248. adiaholic has joined

  249. Guus

    nothing involving client-sided certificates is ever simple, in my experience.

  250. jonas’

    it is if you treat them mostly as a private key

  251. Kev

    jonas’ : It does require that either the admin is generating new certs themselves and injecting them into the devices somehow, or that they are somehow tying up randomly client-generated certs with user credentials. Whereas the resource would allow you to build a system where the admin merely has to approve a new client, knowing for whom it is. I guess it depends on Guus's requirements.

  252. jonas’

    i.e. no CA involved, possibly even ignore expiration (or let them live for 1000 years)

  253. ralphm has left

  254. Kev

    But if you're happy to pre-provision the clients with generated certs, it should indeed not be terribly complicated. We've had deployments do similar things in the past.

  255. andrey.g has joined

  256. jonas’

    I'd just generate the key on initial sign up

  257. jonas’

    and use whatever procedure you use to trust the password the user supplies during signup to trust the key

  258. pasdesushi has left

  259. jonas’

    no pre-provisioning or CA involved, that's, indeed, just madneess

  260. jonas’

    no pre-provisioning or CA involved, that's, indeed, just madness

  261. APach has left

  262. Guus

    jonas’: so, have an initial password-based auth, which somehow provides a cert for the device, which, once registered makes unavailable the password-based auth and will require something like SASL External for that device from then on?

  263. Guus

    I guess that could be sold to the end-user as some kind of 'account activation', which under water registers a cert for the end-user.

  264. Sam has left

  265. SteveF has joined

  266. adiaholic has left

  267. SteveF has left

  268. SteveF has joined

  269. Wojtek has joined

  270. Sam has joined

  271. SteveF has left

  272. SteveF has joined

  273. jonas’

    what no

  274. jonas’

    just let the app provide the private key instead of the username/password on signup

  275. jonas’

    how does your signup procedure work?

  276. jonas’

    (if you're integrating with an existing username/password based scheme, then yes, your flow sounds sensible)

  277. adiaholic has joined

  278. konstantinos has joined

  279. neshtaxmpp has left

  280. neshtaxmpp has joined

  281. Sam has left

  282. Sam has joined

  283. xnamed has joined

  284. konstantinos has left

  285. SteveF has left

  286. SteveF has joined

  287. Wojtek has left

  288. marc0s has left

  289. marc0s has joined

  290. Guus

    jonas’: yeah, user definitions preexist.

  291. neshtaxmpp has left

  292. flow

    how does any of that ensure that only a recognized device is used by a particular user? the client cert could be transferred and the resource could also be simply configured by another device, no? I guess you need to have full control over the client software (which is possible on mobile platforms) and use some onbording procedure when the user starts the client for the first time

  293. flow

    fwiw, TLS-PSK (Pre Shared Key) is also a thing, but other than that, I aggree with jonas’ that (TLS) certs become easy if you treat them like "private keys"

  294. flow

    although I am not sure if they provide than any advantage ofer a PSK

  295. clouded has left

  296. andrey.g has left

  297. pasdesushi has joined

  298. sonny has left

  299. harry837374884 has joined

  300. Sam has left

  301. Dele Olajide has joined

  302. sonny has joined

  303. konstantinos has joined

  304. Sam has joined

  305. pasdesushi has left

  306. pasdesushi has joined

  307. SteveF has left

  308. SteveF has joined

  309. jonas’

    Guus, ah then the activation workflow makes sense

  310. Mikaela has left

  311. Mikaela has joined

  312. konstantinos has left

  313. nikhilmwarrier has joined

  314. Sam has left

  315. Sam has joined

  316. SteveF has left

  317. neshtaxmpp has joined

  318. Mikaela has left

  319. SteveF has joined

  320. Mikaela has joined

  321. Sam has left

  322. SteveF has left

  323. SteveF has joined

  324. SteveF has left

  325. SteveF has joined

  326. clouded has joined

  327. SteveF has left

  328. SteveF has joined

  329. SteveF has left

  330. SteveF has joined

  331. SteveF has left

  332. SteveF has joined

  333. Sam has joined

  334. SteveF has left

  335. SteveF has joined

  336. SteveF has left

  337. SteveF has joined

  338. Wojtek has joined

  339. adiaholic has left

  340. neshtaxmpp has left

  341. neshtaxmpp has joined

  342. konstantinos has joined

  343. Dele Olajide has left

  344. Dele Olajide has joined

  345. floretta has left

  346. Sam has left

  347. konstantinos has left

  348. Sam has joined

  349. pasdesushi has left

  350. stp has left

  351. L29Ah has joined

  352. pasdesushi has joined

  353. floretta has joined

  354. nuron has left

  355. marc0s has left

  356. marc0s has joined

  357. konstantinos has joined

  358. antranigv has left

  359. gooya has joined

  360. antranigv has joined

  361. antranigv has left

  362. nuron has joined

  363. adiaholic has joined

  364. Steve Kille has left

  365. Steve Kille has joined

  366. konstantinos has left

  367. antranigv has joined

  368. papatutuwawa has joined

  369. adiaholic has left

  370. jl4 has joined

  371. debacle has left

  372. adiaholic has joined

  373. antranigv has left

  374. antranigv has joined

  375. Dele Olajide has left

  376. Dele Olajide has joined

  377. adiaholic has left

  378. Steve Kille has left

  379. Dele Olajide has left

  380. Dele Olajide has joined

  381. Steve Kille has joined

  382. konstantinos has joined

  383. Dele Olajide has left

  384. Dele Olajide has joined

  385. Dele Olajide has left

  386. Dele Olajide has joined

  387. adiaholic has joined

  388. Dele Olajide has left

  389. Dele Olajide has joined

  390. antranigv has left

  391. Tim R has left

  392. Tim R has joined

  393. jl4 has left

  394. Tim R has left

  395. Tim R has joined

  396. neshtaxmpp has left

  397. neshtaxmpp has joined

  398. stp has joined

  399. adiaholic has left

  400. pasdesushi has left

  401. adiaholic has joined

  402. pasdesushi has joined

  403. adiaholic has left

  404. Steve Kille has left

  405. Tim R has left

  406. Kev has left

  407. Tim R has joined

  408. Kev has joined

  409. adiaholic has joined

  410. Kev has left

  411. Kev has joined

  412. Steve Kille has joined

  413. adiaholic has left

  414. Steve Kille has left

  415. Steve Kille has joined

  416. Dele Olajide has left

  417. karoshi has left

  418. Fishbowler has left

  419. Fishbowler has joined

  420. adiaholic has joined

  421. stp has left

  422. Tim R has left

  423. Tim R has joined

  424. karoshi has joined

  425. adiaholic has left

  426. adiaholic has joined

  427. adiaholic has left

  428. debacle has joined

  429. adiaholic has joined

  430. pasdesushi has left

  431. rebeld22 has joined

  432. Paganini has joined

  433. Dele Olajide has joined

  434. Dele Olajide has left

  435. Dele Olajide has joined

  436. adiaholic has left

  437. antranigv has joined

  438. pasdesushi has joined

  439. RayTutu has joined

  440. adiaholic has joined

  441. marc0s has left

  442. marc0s has joined

  443. marc0s has left

  444. marc0s has joined

  445. marc0s has left

  446. marc0s has joined

  447. adiaholic has left

  448. antranigv has left

  449. antranigv has joined

  450. adiaholic has joined

  451. neshtaxmpp has left

  452. neshtaxmpp has joined

  453. stp has joined

  454. antranigv has left

  455. antranigv has joined

  456. SteveF has left

  457. SteveF has joined

  458. SteveF has left

  459. SteveF has joined

  460. SteveF has left

  461. SteveF has joined

  462. marc0s has left

  463. marc0s has joined

  464. emus has left

  465. adiaholic has left

  466. adiaholic has joined

  467. marc0s has left

  468. marc0s has joined

  469. adiaholic has left

  470. papatutuwawa has left

  471. clouded has left

  472. clouded has joined

  473. antranigv has left

  474. antranigv has joined

  475. clouded has left

  476. clouded has joined

  477. adiaholic has joined

  478. moparisthebest

    smells of corporate security to me

  479. konstantinos has left

  480. moparisthebest

    and by that I mean they'll make it as user-hostile as possible for 0 benefit other than being able to check a box that says "secure"

  481. rebeld22 has left

  482. Calvin has joined

  483. antranigv has left

  484. Paganini has left

  485. Calvin has left

  486. papatutuwawa has joined

  487. antranigv has joined

  488. adiaholic has left

  489. adiaholic has joined

  490. konstantinos has joined

  491. Wojtek has left

  492. flow

    dunno, those specialized locked-down clients do not need to be user-hostile, in fact, the could be very user friendly

  493. flow

    wouldn't be surprised if Conversations would bring support for such a setup

  494. jonas’

    I am looking forward to the day we have actual per-device credentials (be it TLS keys, or Device-key-SASL, or whatever)

  495. jonas’

    of course, then without the limitation of one device per user

  496. MattJ

    Working on it :)

  497. Steve Kille has left

  498. Zash

    You can burn a full JID into the cert

  499. jonas’

    (well, actually not "whatever". I strongly think it should be devicekey or TLS keys)

  500. Zash

    Vaguely related, how do I https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7250 ?

  501. intosi has left

  502. intosi has joined

  503. papatutuwawa has left

  504. konstantinos has left

  505. papatutuwawa has joined

  506. Dele Olajide has left

  507. mjk has left

  508. clouded has left

  509. mjk has joined

  510. konstantinos has joined

  511. clouded has joined

  512. RayTutu has left

  513. Dele Olajide has joined

  514. antranigv has left

  515. nikhilmwarrier has left

  516. pjn has joined

  517. papatutuwawa has left

  518. antranigv has joined

  519. papatutuwawa has joined

  520. raucao has left

  521. raucao has joined

  522. Wojtek has joined

  523. marc0s has left

  524. marc0s has joined

  525. neshtaxmpp has left

  526. neshtaxmpp has joined

  527. RayTutu has joined

  528. konstantinos has left

  529. pablo has joined

  530. lovetox has left

  531. lovetox has joined

  532. RayTutu has left

  533. thndrbvr has left

  534. APach has joined

  535. Dele Olajide has left

  536. Dele Olajide has joined

  537. marc0s has left

  538. marc0s has joined

  539. marc0s has left

  540. marc0s has joined

  541. andrew has left

  542. emus has joined

  543. andrew has joined

  544. sernick has joined

  545. konstantinos has joined

  546. APach has left

  547. Andrzej has joined

  548. Dele Olajide has left

  549. Alex has left

  550. Alex has joined

  551. Alex has left

  552. Alex has joined

  553. Steve Kille has joined

  554. rebeld22 has joined

  555. Paganini has joined

  556. Steve Kille has left

  557. Steve Kille has joined

  558. Dele Olajide has joined

  559. Alex has left

  560. Alex has joined

  561. L29Ah has left

  562. L29Ah has joined

  563. inky has left

  564. pjn has left

  565. pjn has joined

  566. Andrzej has left

  567. Andrzej has joined

  568. inky has joined

  569. neshtaxmpp has left

  570. neshtaxmpp has joined

  571. konstantinos has left

  572. konstantinos has joined

  573. ralphm has joined

  574. intosi has left

  575. intosi has joined

  576. pablo has left

  577. Steve Kille has left

  578. intosi has left

  579. intosi has joined

  580. debacle has left

  581. Tim R has left

  582. antranigv has left

  583. Steve Kille has joined

  584. krauq has left

  585. antranigv has joined

  586. konstantinos has left

  587. phoebos has joined

  588. krauq has joined

  589. APach has joined

  590. Andrzej has left

  591. Andrzej has joined

  592. raghavgururajan has joined

  593. intosi has left

  594. antranigv has left

  595. antranigv has joined

  596. intosi has joined

  597. konstantinos has joined

  598. debacle has joined

  599. wladmis has left

  600. wladmis has joined

  601. xnamed has left

  602. phoebos has left

  603. Andrzej has left

  604. stp has left

  605. Andrzej has joined

  606. thndrbvr has joined

  607. intosi has left

  608. krauq has left

  609. debacle has left

  610. SteveF has left

  611. Tobias has left

  612. Dele Olajide has left

  613. Tobias has joined

  614. intosi has joined

  615. adiaholic has left

  616. stp has joined

  617. antranigv has left

  618. Tim R has joined

  619. krauq has joined

  620. antranigv has joined

  621. Dele Olajide has joined

  622. Dele Olajide has left

  623. Andrzej has left

  624. antranigv has left

  625. antranigv has joined

  626. djorz has joined

  627. mdosch has left

  628. mdosch has joined

  629. marc0s has left

  630. marc0s has joined

  631. krauq has left

  632. raghavgururajan has left

  633. intosi has left

  634. konstantinos has left

  635. adiaholic has joined

  636. andrey.g has joined

  637. intosi has joined

  638. andrey.g has left

  639. floretta has left

  640. adiaholic has left

  641. Wojtek has left

  642. antranigv has left

  643. antranigv has joined

  644. mdosch has left

  645. krauq has joined

  646. mdosch has joined

  647. Andrzej has joined

  648. qy

    You know how clients like to skip entire bundles of XEPs to "keep their UI simple"? Maybe it'd be useful to have a standand UI or UI guidelines, so that doesn't have to be the case?

  649. neshtaxmpp has left

  650. neshtaxmpp has joined

  651. qy looking at conversations and dino particularly

  652. emus has left

  653. Seve

    https://matrix.org/blog/2022/05/30/welcoming-rocket-chat-to-matrix moparisthebest: already discussed this too?

  654. Zash

    qy, huh?

  655. Zash

    something something https://docs.modernxmpp.org/

  656. qy

    Zash: Gajim's rather feature complete, the other two are not, as i understand it primarily because they're UI-first and want to keep things "simple"/"easy to use" - so if there was a known UI form, that wouldnt be an excuse?

  657. adiaholic has joined

  658. qy

    > Zash wrote: > something something https://docs.modernxmpp.org/ ...oh

  659. intosi has left

  660. qy

    Well, 🚀 modernxmpp

  661. Zash

    Dino has video conferencing, your argument is invalid

  662. qy

    It doesn't have a disco browser :-)

  663. Zash

    Also, diversity and the freedom to try out different things is a strength here. All clients don't have to be the same.

  664. moparisthebest

    what features are you missing? all the stuff that has *terrible* UI like ad-hoc commands? :P

  665. qy

    Zash: But it is the biggest flaw of xmpp

  666. qy

    Well, it doesn't _have_ to have terrible ui if we figure out a nice one!

  667. moparisthebest

    has anyone ever used ad-hoc commands and thought "hmm that was a pleasent experience"

  668. Zash

    That's just, like, your opinion, man

  669. qy


  670. moparisthebest

    usually more like "hmm why did the whole thing freeze" "oh no I clicked back and it crashed" "why didn't anything save"

  671. qy

    moparisthebest: I actually think as theyre done in gajim, pretty nice. I'll agree in profanity, not a great time, but im grateful theyre at least there...

  672. konstantinos has joined

  673. qy

    How else am i meant to configure biboumi :|

  674. qy

    Routinely have to operate 5 different clients to do everything i want smh

  675. antranigv has left

  676. Andrzej has left

  677. moparisthebest

    biboumi should be configurable over a bot-like interface

  678. Zash

    I'm sure the Soprani.ca folks are plenty interested in improving the experience with gateways etc

  679. moparisthebest

    they just went ahead and made everything configurable via talking to a bot, works very well

  680. konstantinos has left

  681. Andrzej has joined

  682. adiaholic has left

  683. adiaholic has joined

  684. floretta has joined

  685. qy

    Are we just anti adhoc being a thing then?

  686. qy

    What about disco?

  687. wgreenhouse

    ad hoc is useful because you can do input validation, and you can also format the output of commands

  688. Zash

    Who's this "we"?

  689. wgreenhouse

    soprani.ca folks are adding it to their conversations fork, for that reason

  690. wgreenhouse

    > Who's this "we"? modernxmpp and/or the authors of more recent gui clients

  691. marc0s has left

  692. marc0s has joined

  693. adiaholic has left

  694. qy

    wgreenhouse: I may switch to that fork, unless blabber adopts it too...

  695. wgreenhouse

    > has anyone ever used ad-hoc commands and thought "hmm that was a pleasent experience" moparisthebest: they work great for me in jabber.el :D

  696. qy

    Is it a prompt-based flow in j.el?

  697. marc0s has left

  698. marc0s has joined

  699. intosi has joined

  700. Tobias has left

  701. antranigv has joined

  702. Tobias has joined

  703. moparisthebest

    you can do input validation in a bot too

  704. marc0s has left

  705. marc0s has joined

  706. qy

    moparisthebest: Do you have something against ad-hoc in particular? Or just think it can't be implemented nicely?

  707. antranigv has left

  708. qy

    It is a stable xep, isn't it?

  709. moparisthebest

    just that it can't be implemented nicely and serves no purpose that a bot doesn't serve easier, imho

  710. qy

    Feels like IRC logic; everything as chat :p

  711. Zash

    never say never, but it takes effort on both client and server side to get the most out of it

  712. floretta has left

  713. qy yearns for xmpp nickserv

  714. floretta has joined

  715. Zash

    I think Gajim did an excellent job, but on the other hand I haven't touched adhoc in months. Configuring Biboumi is mostly a one-time thing.

  716. Zash

    Most available ad-hoc commands are server admin related, for which `prosodyctl shell` is just so much nicer and more powerful.

  717. wgreenhouse

    > Is it a prompt-based flow in j.el? qy: no, it's a new emacs buffer with fields, like M-x customize

  718. qy

    Oh excellent indeed

  719. kinetik has left

  720. wgreenhouse

    so you can actually keep chatting with that jid, it doesn't "steal" the buffer

  721. moparisthebest

    ha yes, I last touched biboumi config years ago (using gajim), and haven't needed ad-hoc for prosody in years either for what Zash mentioned

  722. qy

    For weechat i think i'm gonna have to copy profanity's model but make it a bit more prompt-based

  723. moparisthebest

    good luck keeping your infinitly configurable UI code concise and bug free :D

  724. antranigv has joined

  725. wgreenhouse

    there are beaucoup bugs, just not in ad hoc handling. :P

  726. Sam

    This is something I've been particularly interested in lately. I really thought that dataforms were the main problem and couldn't be used to create a nice UI, and while I still don't love them I have come around on their existance a bit.

  727. Sam

    However, the ad-hoc spec is just *really* hard to understand and implement properly for something that should be simple, so I still suspect that it ends up being horribly buggy not because of UI problems, but because of how it's written and explained.

  728. Zash

    Observation: You don't need dataforms for parameter-less ad-hoc commands.

  729. clouded has left

  730. Sam

    Sure, that's why I thought forms were the problem then I discovered that even for parameterless ones there were lots of bugs and issues for something that should have been trivially simple.

  731. jl4 has joined

  732. Alex has left

  733. Zash

    Also, I think you could replace dataforms with anything as payload carrier, tho that's probably more interesting for some RPC uses

  734. Sam

    So I'm really not sure about them now. I've come around a little bit, but kind of think the whole thing should be thrown out and re-written. Then again, we haven't had much success with that strategy in the past, even for things that didn't have a huge number of implementations.

  735. krauq has left

  736. xnamed has joined

  737. Zash

    Overly generic things are tricky.

  738. Zash

    Many things could probably be done with the simpler registration XEP (77?)

  739. Sam

    This is probably the underlying problem ⤴️

  740. wgreenhouse

    registration would make more sense for things like biboumi

  741. wgreenhouse

    since what most people are doing is setting nickserv stuff and maybe changing the hostname to connect to

  742. Tobias has left

  743. pep.

    > moparisthebest> has anyone ever used ad-hoc commands and thought "hmm that was a pleasent experience" Actually, yes. Poezio's UI here is ok. I get it's an "advanced feature" (handling generic adhoc forms) and I think that's why it's not in C nor Dino, not because it's "not pretty" or "not easily usable".

  744. Tobias has joined

  745. qy grumbles about being an advanced user

  746. clouded has joined

  747. antranigv has left

  748. Sam

    Same with Communiqué, I think, but it was *really* hard to figure out all the weird ad-hoc bugs, and I'm sure it's still probably not compatible with some implementations.

  749. antranigv has joined

  750. krauq has joined

  751. Tobias has left

  752. Tobias has joined

  753. djorz has left

  754. Tobias has left

  755. Tobias has joined

  756. Tim R has left

  757. adiaholic has joined

  758. marc0s has left

  759. marc0s has joined

  760. marc0s has left

  761. marc0s has joined

  762. marc0s has left

  763. marc0s has joined

  764. moparisthebest

    so you are writing a service, and debating on how best to let users configure it, your options are: 1. text bot, works with literally everything, including bridges, don't need to test anything else because there aren't differences in implementations 2. ad-hoc commands, works with a couple clients, you have to test them each because they each display things differently and have different bugs, and no other clients care to support them because of all of these problems

  765. moparisthebest

    but hey whatever floats your boat, as an advanced user I'd much rather just use text anyway, ad-hoc commands are more akin to the windows registry :P

  766. pasdesushi has left

  767. wgreenhouse

    ouch. fair enough, though

  768. adiaholic has left

  769. antranigv has left

  770. kinetik has joined

  771. Alex has joined

  772. qy

    ...you're using the windows registry as an example of good, modern design?

  773. antranigv has joined

  774. moparisthebest

    yes, as good and modern as ad-hoc commands :)

  775. qy

    Have I entered the twilight zone 😧

  776. intosi has left

  777. qy

    Anyway, i agree for now, thats why i was trying to think of how to get more clients to implement ad-hoc commands

  778. qy

    Because if only half the clients implement it, its not worth any of them doing it

  779. moparisthebest

    classic chicken and egg

  780. Andrzej has left

  781. qy

    But if you premake the egg, who needs a chicken

  782. antranigv has left

  783. qy

    Hence, modernxmpp ui and implementation guidelines for ad-hoc commands, so its nice&easy

  784. qy

    > here's a yolk i prepared earlier

  785. marc0s has left

  786. marc0s has joined

  787. pasdesushi has joined

  788. stp has left

  789. pep.

    moparisthebest: bot-as-interface reminds me of your position regarding 393 :p

  790. pep.

    And I completely understand why you like it, and you may understand why I would hate it

  791. Andrzej has joined

  792. moparisthebest

    you might notice a pattern here, 393 and bots are KISS, ad-hoc and choose-your-own-markup are not :D

  793. qy

    moparisthebest: I feel like you would really like IRC

  794. pep.

    moparisthebest: KISS, but for whom :)

  795. antranigv has joined

  796. pep.

    The receiving client can't have any specific UI for your gateway if the interface is a bot, there's no choice but to make a generic message-sending UI

  797. Titi has left

  798. adiaholic has joined

  799. pep.

    It's simple for client devs, maybe, not for users

  800. djorz has joined

  801. Andrzej has left

  802. Andrzej has joined

  803. bean has joined

  804. Andrzej has left

  805. adiaholic has left

  806. kinetik has left

  807. moparisthebest

    it's more simple for users

  808. moparisthebest

    "message X and have a conversation" vs "60 minutes of them nodding their heads while attempting to explain what an ad-hoc is"

  809. moparisthebest

    qy, I do like IRC :P just through XMPP

  810. Sam

    I had a nice little library I was working on that let you design ad-hoc command flows and then it would respond to them both with forms and with chat messages (and I think the sopranica folks have something similar). It's not an either/or situation, but I definitely think for normal users a UI would be preferred. Even as someone who doesn't really care one way or another, the UI is way easier in some situations.

  811. moparisthebest

    yea both sounds like a good option if it's easy enough

  812. Sam

    There are situations where you can't have both, of course. Mcabber responds to a few ad-hoc commands to allow you to eg. set its staus from another client. It's quite nice, but obviously if you sent a message to the JID you'd expect it to just be delivered as a normal message

  813. Andrzej has joined

  814. antranigv has left

  815. Mx2 has left

  816. Mx2 has joined

  817. neshtaxmpp has left

  818. neshtaxmpp has joined

  819. adiaholic has joined

  820. antranigv has joined

  821. wgreenhouse

    the case where the recipient is also an entity you can message with is an argument for ad hoc. like, biboumi's configuration uses ad hoc in part because the server JID is also what you chat with to send raw IRC commands

  822. wgreenhouse

    maybe 0077 is a way out, if it's simpler to implement

  823. adiaholic has left

  824. Andrzej has left

  825. Andrzej has joined

  826. debacle has joined

  827. xnamed has left

  828. adiaholic has joined

  829. pep.

    I think the fact that it's simpler to implement is a non-argument between all of these options. Yes adhoc takes a bit more to implement but It's not like it (or a -- nonexistent -- different intetface with similar goals) was exceptionally hard to implement either

  830. Sam

    Oh I disagree, ad-hoc was exceptionally hard to implement correctly.

  831. Sam

    The spec is incredibly confusing and often vague.

  832. Zash

    I'm thinking it's okay to reserve it for where the complexity is warranted.

  833. krauq has left

  834. pep.

    Sam: maybe the spec needs improving/redoing, but I don't think that the concept in itself is complex

  835. adiaholic has left

  836. Zash

    Clarifications of the specs are always welcome

  837. qy

    What part was hard to implement, ooi?

  838. qy

    I haven't tried yet, so curious

  839. floretta has left

  840. floretta has joined

  841. xnamed has joined

  842. intosi has joined

  843. Titi has joined

  844. krauq has joined

  845. lovetox

    If I remember correctly it's a bit confusing with the actions and default actions that are available in each stage

  846. lovetox

    And I think there was clarifications on that part

  847. moparisthebest

    if you all are like me, you read/implement a spec, find it annoying/confusing, vow to write clarifications for the next poor soul...

  848. lovetox

    Othr than that, I would say "exceptional hard" is a hyperbole

  849. adiaholic has joined

  850. moparisthebest

    then a couple months pass and you've memorized all the things you needed to know and forgot what you intended to write down...

  851. jonas’

    Zash, to be fair, '77 has had its fair share of council/standards politics deadlock

  852. jonas’

    there is that edge case I don't dare to remember

  853. Zash

    I've conveniently swapped out all of it to the point I didn't remember the number 🤷️

  854. jonas’


  855. jonas’


  856. jonas’

    I didn't mean '77 actually, I meant '50

  857. kinetik has joined

  858. adiaholic has left

  859. konstantinos has joined

  860. paul has joined

  861. sebastian has left

  862. adiaholic has joined

  863. playerthree has left

  864. playerthree has joined

  865. floretta has left

  866. floretta has joined

  867. intosi has left

  868. krauq has left

  869. kinetik has left

  870. Tim R has joined

  871. adiaholic has left

  872. marc0s has left

  873. marc0s has joined

  874. marc0s has left

  875. marc0s has joined

  876. petrescatraian has joined

  877. petrescatraian has left

  878. krauq has joined

  879. krauq has left

  880. adiaholic has joined

  881. floretta has left

  882. floretta has joined

  883. krauq has joined

  884. adiaholic has left

  885. neshtaxmpp has left

  886. neshtaxmpp has joined

  887. konstantinos has left

  888. adiaholic has joined

  889. emus has joined

  890. krauq has left

  891. Andrzej has left

  892. RayTutu has joined

  893. Andrzej has joined

  894. adiaholic has left

  895. RayTutu has left

  896. papatutuwawa has left

  897. RayTutu has joined

  898. RayTutu has left

  899. RayTutu has joined

  900. atomicwatch has left

  901. krauq has joined

  902. jcbrand has left

  903. Yagiza has left

  904. adiaholic has joined

  905. Tobias has left

  906. Andrzej has left

  907. Andrzej has joined

  908. adiaholic has left

  909. marc0s has left

  910. marc0s has joined

  911. marc0s has left

  912. marc0s has joined

  913. krauq has left

  914. intosi has joined

  915. wgreenhouse has left

  916. sebastian has joined

  917. Tim R has left

  918. krauq has joined

  919. adiaholic has joined

  920. wgreenhouse has joined

  921. jcbrand has joined

  922. Andrzej has left

  923. msavoritias has left

  924. Andrzej has joined

  925. adiaholic has left

  926. intosi has left

  927. Steve Kille has left

  928. krauq has left

  929. Steve Kille has joined

  930. Titi has left

  931. antranigv has left

  932. Andrzej has left

  933. phryk has joined

  934. Kev has left

  935. Andrzej has joined

  936. krauq has joined

  937. adiaholic has joined

  938. kinetik has joined

  939. adiaholic has left

  940. adiaholic has joined

  941. adiaholic has left

  942. neshtaxmpp has left

  943. bean has left

  944. neshtaxmpp has joined

  945. neshtaxmpp has left

  946. neshtaxmpp has joined

  947. lskdjf has left

  948. daags has left

  949. clouded has left

  950. goffi has left

  951. intosi has joined

  952. daags has joined

  953. clouded has joined

  954. kinetik has left

  955. RayTutu has left

  956. david has joined

  957. david has left

  958. marc0s has left

  959. marc0s has joined

  960. sebastian has left

  961. sebastian has joined

  962. debacle has left

  963. neshtaxmpp has left

  964. neshtaxmpp has joined

  965. intosi has left

  966. lskdjf has joined

  967. menel has left

  968. inky has left

  969. stp has joined

  970. antranigv has joined

  971. kinetik has joined

  972. adiaholic has joined

  973. lskdjf has left

  974. gooya has left

  975. floretta has left

  976. floretta has joined

  977. emus has left

  978. adiaholic has left

  979. paul has left

  980. paul has joined

  981. wgreenhouse has left

  982. sernick has left

  983. stp has left

  984. lovetox has left

  985. gooya has joined

  986. wgreenhouse has joined

  987. adiaholic has joined

  988. wurstsalat has left

  989. kinetik has left

  990. krauq has left

  991. wgreenhouse has left

  992. adiaholic has left

  993. lovetox has joined

  994. wgreenhouse has joined

  995. intosi has joined

  996. intosi has left

  997. intosi has joined

  998. krauq has joined

  999. neshtaxmpp has left

  1000. neshtaxmpp has joined

  1001. pjn has left

  1002. floretta has left

  1003. marc0s has left

  1004. marc0s has joined

  1005. gooya has left

  1006. karoshi has left

  1007. kinetik has joined

  1008. djorz has left

  1009. xnamed has left

  1010. intosi has left

  1011. Seve has left

  1012. neshtaxmpp has left

  1013. floretta has joined