XSF Discussion - 2023-05-04

  1. *IM* has joined

  2. xnamed has left

  3. neshtaxmpp has left

  4. neshtaxmpp has joined

  5. Maranda[x] has left

  6. *IM* has left

  7. antranigv has joined

  8. projjalm has left

  9. adiaholic has left

  10. Maranda[x] has joined

  11. tee has left

  12. tee has joined

  13. gooya has left

  14. stp has left

  15. Maranda[x] has left

  16. adiaholic has joined

  17. *IM* has joined

  18. gooya has joined

  19. jgart has joined

  20. no_1729 has left

  21. gooya has left

  22. SteveF has left

  23. Tim R has left

  24. Steve Kille has left

  25. SteveF has joined

  26. Tim R has joined

  27. Steve has joined

  28. no_1729 has joined

  29. Steve has left

  30. Steve has joined

  31. Wojtek has joined

  32. *IM* has left

  33. Wojtek has left

  34. jgart has left

  35. *IM* has joined

  36. Calvin has left

  37. singpolyma has left

  38. Yagiza has joined

  39. Yagiza has left

  40. Yagiza has joined

  41. singpolyma has joined

  42. Tobi has joined

  43. Tobias has joined

  44. *IM* has left

  45. Maranda[x] has joined

  46. Tobias has left

  47. Tobi has left

  48. lissine has joined

  49. Yagiza has left

  50. Yagiza has joined

  51. 644043 has left

  52. neshtaxmpp has left

  53. neshtaxmpp has joined

  54. deimos has joined

  55. Martin has left

  56. Martin has joined

  57. lissine has left

  58. Axel R. has joined

  59. Tobi has joined

  60. Tobi has left

  61. Tobi has joined

  62. Tobias has joined

  63. mimi89999 has left

  64. mimi89999 has joined

  65. lissine has joined

  66. Seve has joined

  67. L29Ah has left

  68. lissine has left

  69. Maranda[x] has left

  70. BASSGOD has joined

  71. tee has left

  72. L29Ah has joined

  73. tee has joined

  74. resoli has joined

  75. atomicwatch has joined

  76. atomicwatch has left

  77. atomicwatch has joined

  78. atomicwatch has left

  79. atomicwatch has joined

  80. atomicwatch has left

  81. atomicwatch has joined

  82. atomicwatch has left

  83. atomicwatch has joined

  84. atomicwatch has left

  85. Martin has left

  86. Martin has joined

  87. BASSGOD has left

  88. eevvoor has joined

  89. carlos has left

  90. carlos has joined

  91. adiaholic has left

  92. TheCoffeMaker has left

  93. adiaholic has joined

  94. andrew has left

  95. oshn has left

  96. oshn has joined

  97. BASSGOD has joined

  98. TheCoffeMaker has joined

  99. Trung has joined

  100. cal0pteryx (wurstsalat) has joined

  101. SteveF has left

  102. jcbrand has joined

  103. *IM* has joined

  104. Seve has left

  105. *IM* has left

  106. resoli has left

  107. *IM* has joined

  108. mirux has joined

  109. oshn has left

  110. BASSGOD has left

  111. Seve has joined

  112. wladmis has left

  113. wladmis has joined

  114. BASSGOD has joined

  115. PeterW has left

  116. Peter Waher has left

  117. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has joined

  118. thndrbvr has left

  119. BASSGOD has left

  120. BASSGOD has joined

  121. LNJ has joined

  122. oshn has joined

  123. Alex has joined

  124. LNJ has left

  125. LNJ has joined

  126. tee has left

  127. tee has joined

  128. neshtaxmpp has left

  129. neshtaxmpp has joined

  130. Titi has joined

  131. tee has left

  132. tee has joined

  133. lskdjf has joined

  134. wladmis has left

  135. nicomuc has joined

  136. wladmis has joined

  137. tee has left

  138. tee has joined

  139. nicomuc has left

  140. nicomuc has joined

  141. jcbrand has left

  142. jcbrand has joined

  143. chipmnk has left

  144. Maranda[x] has joined

  145. chipmnk has joined

  146. tmolitor has left

  147. tmolitor has joined

  148. kurisu has left

  149. kurisu has joined

  150. *IM* has left

  151. *IM* has joined

  152. Kev has joined

  153. stp has joined

  154. Rebeld has left

  155. *IM* has left

  156. emus has joined

  157. *IM* has joined

  158. nicomuc has left

  159. debacle has joined

  160. nicoco has left

  161. nicoco has joined

  162. goffi has joined

  163. Andrzej has joined

  164. goffi has left

  165. goffi has joined

  166. no_1729 has left

  167. no_1729 has joined

  168. Friendly Resident Cynic has joined

  169. stp has left

  170. Dele Olajide has joined

  171. goffi has left

  172. goffi has joined

  173. govanify has left

  174. Andrzej has left

  175. poliux has left

  176. *IM* has left

  177. *IM* has joined

  178. kurisu has left

  179. kurisu has joined

  180. debacle has left

  181. govanify has joined

  182. Kev has left

  183. Steve has left

  184. Tim R has left

  185. Tim R has joined

  186. Tim R has left

  187. Kev has joined

  188. Tim R has joined

  189. Steve Kille has joined

  190. poliux has joined

  191. uhoreg has left

  192. Half-Shot has left

  193. Matthew has left

  194. homebeach has left

  195. Half-Shot has joined

  196. Matthew has joined

  197. homebeach has joined

  198. uhoreg has joined

  199. *IM* has left

  200. *IM* has joined

  201. Trung has left

  202. sjm has left

  203. sjm has joined

  204. floretta has left

  205. floretta has joined

  206. Vaulor has joined

  207. eevvoor has left

  208. Steve Kille has left

  209. Steve Kille has joined

  210. Romeo has joined

  211. neshtaxmpp has left

  212. neshtaxmpp has joined

  213. resoli has joined

  214. *IM* has left

  215. eevvoor has joined

  216. Romeo has left

  217. neox has joined

  218. gooya has joined

  219. BASSGOD has left

  220. antranigv has left

  221. antranigv has joined

  222. projjalm has joined

  223. resoli has left

  224. BASSGOD has joined

  225. SteveF has joined

  226. SteveF has left

  227. SteveF has joined

  228. resoli has joined

  229. *IM* has joined

  230. Andrzej has joined

  231. *IM* has left

  232. neshtaxmpp has left

  233. neshtaxmpp has joined

  234. *IM* has joined

  235. debacle has joined

  236. chipmnk has left

  237. BASSGOD has left

  238. reika has left

  239. *IM* has left

  240. xnamed has joined

  241. poliux has left

  242. BASSGOD has joined

  243. Trung has joined

  244. *IM* has joined

  245. Chad has left

  246. Chad has joined

  247. eevvoor has left

  248. eevvoor has joined

  249. 644043 has joined

  250. resoli has left

  251. floretta has left

  252. resoli has joined

  253. chipmnk has joined

  254. floretta has joined

  255. Josh has left

  256. Josh has joined

  257. Josh has left

  258. resoli has left

  259. inky has joined

  260. SteveF has left

  261. cal0pteryx (wurstsalat) has left

  262. cal0pteryx (wurstsalat) has joined

  263. inky has left

  264. Wojtek has joined

  265. Josh has joined

  266. Josh has left

  267. inky has joined

  268. Wojtek has left

  269. Josh has joined

  270. Josh has left

  271. paul has left

  272. Trung has left

  273. 775857429 has joined

  274. Peter Waher has joined

  275. Steve Kille has left

  276. Josh has joined

  277. Josh has left

  278. Trung has joined

  279. xnamed has left

  280. xnamed has joined

  281. Romeo has joined

  282. Romeo has left

  283. papatutuwawa has joined

  284. Josh has joined

  285. Josh has left

  286. poliux has joined

  287. Romeo has joined

  288. floretta has left

  289. Romeo has left

  290. Josh has joined

  291. Josh has left

  292. neox has left

  293. Wojtek has joined

  294. projjalm has left

  295. Wojtek has left

  296. neox has joined

  297. Josh has joined

  298. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  299. Rebeld has joined

  300. BASSGOD has left

  301. 775857429 has left

  302. oshn has left

  303. oshn has joined

  304. floretta has joined

  305. asterix has left

  306. asterix has joined

  307. asterix has left

  308. asterix has joined

  309. asterix has left

  310. projjalm has joined

  311. asterix has joined

  312. gooya has left

  313. Zash has left

  314. PeterW has joined

  315. asterix has left

  316. asterix has joined

  317. gooya has joined

  318. Seve has left

  319. neshtaxmpp has left

  320. Zash has joined

  321. oshn has left

  322. asterix has left

  323. Seve has joined

  324. asterix has joined

  325. uhoreg has left

  326. Half-Shot has left

  327. Matthew has left

  328. homebeach has left

  329. Half-Shot has joined

  330. Matthew has joined

  331. homebeach has joined

  332. uhoreg has joined

  333. paul has joined

  334. andrew has joined

  335. Andrzej has left

  336. BASSGOD has joined

  337. singpolyma has left

  338. singpolyma has joined

  339. Calvin has joined

  340. Alex has left

  341. Alex has joined

  342. stp has joined

  343. asterix has left

  344. asterix has joined

  345. *IM* has left

  346. *IM* has joined

  347. asterix has left

  348. pablo has joined

  349. asterix has joined

  350. sonny has left

  351. Romeo has joined

  352. Andrzej has joined

  353. Romeo has left

  354. Romeo has joined

  355. sonny has joined

  356. neshtaxmpp has joined

  357. singpolyma has left

  358. Romeo has left

  359. singpolyma has joined

  360. 775857429 has joined

  361. moparisthebest has left

  362. moparisthebest has joined

  363. guus.der.kinderen has left

  364. paul has left

  365. xnamed has left

  366. pablo has left

  367. paul has joined

  368. PeterW has left

  369. PeterW has joined

  370. papatutuwawa has left

  371. *IM* has left

  372. Ingolf has left

  373. Ingolf has joined

  374. guus.der.kinderen has joined

  375. edhelas

    XEP-0482: Call Invites <3

  376. oshn has joined

  377. Romeo has joined

  378. 775857429 has left

  379. jgart has joined

  380. Menel has left

  381. Romeo has left

  382. xnamed has joined

  383. PeterW has left

  384. no_1729 has left

  385. Menel has joined

  386. Chad has left

  387. Chad has joined

  388. inky has left

  389. deimos has left

  390. Titi has left

  391. stp has left

  392. stp has joined

  393. Wojtek has joined

  394. papatutuwawa has joined

  395. singpolyma has left

  396. singpolyma has joined

  397. floretta has left

  398. mjk has joined

  399. floretta has joined

  400. oshn has left

  401. Andrzej has left

  402. 775857429 has joined

  403. inky has joined

  404. resoli has joined

  405. oshn has joined

  406. guus.der.kinderen has left

  407. resoli has left

  408. *IM* has joined

  409. PeterW has joined

  410. resoli has joined

  411. 775857429 has left

  412. 775857429 has joined

  413. singpolyma has left

  414. PeterW has left

  415. singpolyma has joined

  416. jgart has left

  417. Seve has left

  418. PeterW has joined

  419. Kev has left

  420. Seve has joined

  421. PeterW has left

  422. *IM* has left

  423. PeterW has joined

  424. PeterW has left

  425. PeterW has joined

  426. Andrzej has joined

  427. mirux has left

  428. mirux has joined

  429. PeterW has left

  430. Dele Olajide has left

  431. *IM* has joined

  432. deimos has joined

  433. Dele Olajide has joined

  434. Josh has left

  435. singpolyma has left

  436. debacle has left

  437. singpolyma has joined

  438. catchy has joined

  439. stpeter has joined

  440. matthias has joined

  441. Maxence has left

  442. Maxence has joined

  443. *IM* has left

  444. *IM* has joined

  445. floretta has left

  446. sjm has left

  447. PeterW has joined

  448. poliux has left

  449. Josh has joined

  450. resoli has left

  451. Calvin has left

  452. stp has left

  453. marc0s has left

  454. jgart has joined

  455. Arne has left

  456. Arne has joined

  457. TheCoffeMaker has left

  458. TheCoffeMaker has joined

  459. emus

    Hello, almost Board time ✨

  460. stpeter


  461. moparisthebest

    Until then... Bored time...

  462. stpeter


  463. Calvin has joined

  464. BASSGOD has left

  465. 775857429 has left

  466. emus

    📯🔔📢 Board is on time - right?

  467. ralphm bangs the gavel

  468. ralphm

    0. Welcome

  469. ralphm


  470. emus

  471. singpolyma has left

  472. singpolyma has joined

  473. jgart has left

  474. ralphm

    Who do we have?

  475. stpeter notes that there is a rough agenda at https://wiki.xmpp.org/web/Board-Meeting-2023-05-04

  476. stpeter


  477. ralphm

    MattJ, Arc?

  478. MattJ

    Here o/

  479. emus


  480. Arne


  481. ralphm

    I actually don't see Arc in here and he doesn't show as online to me, so let's continue.

  482. emus


  483. ralphm


  484. ralphm

    Anything to report at this front?

  485. stpeter

    I can report on my recent activities.

  486. ralphm

    Please do

  487. Wojtek has left

  488. stpeter

    I’ve had two conversations with the MIMI WG chairs.

  489. emus

    (Everyone must have got my reminder for my meting yesterday)

  490. emus

    (Everyone must have got my reminder for the meting yesterday)

  491. stpeter

    After the first conversation I talked with MattJ.

  492. stpeter

    And MattJ has started an email thread with folks who are interested in working on an XMPP profile of MLS.

  493. ralphm

    (emus: I just used my calendar :-) )

  494. Arne

    > (Everyone must have got my reminder for the meting yesterday) per e-mail?

  495. stpeter

    I’ve also reached out to the MLS WG chairs but I haven’t heard back yet.

  496. stpeter

    Here is a short summary….

  497. emus

    > ralphm: > 2023-05-04 07:04 (GMT+02:00) > (emus: I just used my calendar :-) ) (yes just to be sure after last meetings)

  498. emus

    Arne: just to board

  499. stpeter

    The MIMI folks are basically hoping that the threat of DMA fines forces the “gatekeepers” (big tech companies with chat systems) to get involved with the IETF effort.

  500. stpeter

    But I am skeptical that will happen.

  501. no_1729 has joined

  502. emus

    > stpeter: > 2023-05-04 07:05 (GMT+02:00) > I’ve also reached out to the MLS WG chairs but I haven’t heard back yet. > Here is a short summary…. on which regard exactly have you reached out?

  503. stpeter

    Supposedly some of the gatekeepers are open to a standardized solution, not one-off bilateral agreements.

  504. stpeter

    But gatekeeper representatives are not involved yet.

  505. ralphm

    I think it hinges on several things: a) MIMI offering a viable approach, b) the EU Commission forcing their hand

  506. stpeter

    And we don’t have anyone from the XMPP community who wants to dedicate lots of time to the MIMI effort. I was asked and I declined because I’m semi-retired, y’see. ;-)

  507. ralphm

    And my personal feeling is that a) kinda requires XMPP

  508. emus

    > stpeter: > 2023-05-04 07:07 (GMT+02:00) > And we don’t have anyone from the XMPP community who wants to dedicate lots of time to the MIMI effort. I was asked and I declined because I’m semi-retired, y’see. ;-) Are there further other active actions we should start over to encourgae that? What is preventing?

  509. stpeter

    So IMHO MIMI is sort of dead in the water until (b) happens

  510. stpeter

    Well, who wants to work on MIMI? It’s basically volunteering a whole bunch of your time to work on technical solutions that will save Google and Facebook millions/billions of dollars, but you’re going to do all that work for free!

  511. stpeter

    And we’ve been down this road before!

  512. ralphm

    emus: it requires someone who can navigate the IETF, the XMPP community and its standards process, as well as someone apt enough to work through the politics of this all. Most of the problems aren't really technical.

  513. stpeter

    @ralph right, which is why they tried to recruit me. ;-)

  514. emus

    Is it about paid time for people from our side?

  515. stpeter

    As to MLS, that seems much more viable.

  516. ralphm

    MLS is also kind of a requirement to get MIMI done.

  517. singpolyma

    I think it's a very time expensive thing. I see value there, but I see more value in other things most people are spending time on (sorry if I should be silent during meeting I will be after this if you say)

  518. stpeter

    Eventually we might want to have MLS-based solutions to MUC encryption and so on, and we have people who are interested in working on that, either at the XSF or the IETF.

  519. ralphm

    Because the DMA requires an e2e component

  520. Steve Kille has joined

  521. emus

    Do we still need to develop an official position from "XMPP / XSF side

  522. stpeter

    It turns out that the MLS might not be the place to work on MLS profiles (like MLS over XMPP), so it might be fine to do this work at the XSF for now. This is why I have asked the MLS WG chairs for their insights.

  523. MattJ

    singpolyma, no, board meetings are open to participation from "the floor" :)

  524. stpeter

    s/the MLS/the MLS WG/

  525. *IM* has left

  526. stpeter

    And as Ralph says, MLS over XMPP is a good first step toward DMA compliance.

  527. emus

    > stpeter: > 2023-05-04 07:11 (GMT+02:00) > It turns out that the MLS might not be the place to work on MLS profiles (like MLS over XMPP), so it might be fine to do this work at the XSF for now. This is why I have asked the MLS WG chairs for their insights. But noone wants to spent time on it?

  528. stpeter

    @emus we do have people who want to work on MLS over XMPP

  529. ralphm

    My feeling about MLS on MUC should not be hard. I.e. not as hard as it is to get Matrix going (hence the dMLS stuff). But unfortunately I haven't spent enough time on it to make a proper determination.

  530. emus

    Ok, I understood the opposite

  531. stpeter

    But we don’t have people who want to define a new S2S protocol that Google and Facebook can use.

  532. Calvin has left

  533. emus

    stpeter: sure

  534. moparisthebest

    Right, because they can just use XMPP s2s as is

  535. singpolyma

    I mean, ideal this new s2s protocol would be "XMPP" but I guess they want a big chunk of it written down in a certain way

  536. ralphm

    My understanding was that we had Tim and Marvin interested in working on MLS. Correct, MattJ?

  537. MattJ


  538. stpeter

    One piece of tech-ish feedback from the MIMI chairs is that the gatekeepers think XMPP s2s is a non-starter because it’s too hard to scale. They don’t know how to manage long-lived sessions across multiple servers etc.

  539. emus

    Well, my only concerns are that this very important topic is bot actively adress to our best capabilities

  540. Steve Kille has left

  541. MattJ

    moparisthebest, singpolyma: agreed, though there are some people (involved in MIMI) who are sceptical about that

  542. emus

    Well, my only concerns are that this very important topic is not actively adress to our best capabilities

  543. stpeter

    Because we don’t have direct connections with the gatekeeper people, it’s hard to have a real conversation even if we wanted to.

  544. moparisthebest

    The gatekeepers opinions don't matter, they aren't even involved and likely won't use any of this anyway

  545. stpeter

    @moparisthebest I tend to agree.

  546. singpolyma

    moparisthebest: except that it's being done "for them"

  547. ralphm

    stpeter: I am surprised that this is still the argument. Is that really a problem? And if so, we could redefine s2s streams to not require permanent connections.

  548. ralphm

    I don't think it even requires a protocol change.

  549. singpolyma

    I think you can already close s2s stream when you like and reopen as needed it's just less efficient. Something something quic

  550. stpeter

    @ralphm Right, but someone would need to define that option in XMPP - basically negotiate it upfront or switch to non-persistent version.

  551. Zash

    s2s streams don't require permanent connections already? you can time out whenever you want. with direct tls and bidi it's super fast too

  552. moparisthebest

    Plus "won't scale" etc is just provably false ie https://www.process-one.net/blog/ejabberd-nintendo-switch-npns/

  553. floretta has joined

  554. Zash

    Google Talk proved it scales just fine

  555. ralphm

    singpolyma: sure, defining XMPP on top QUIC is something we should do anyway. The problem is probably in proper library support for the relatively new IETF QUIC.

  556. stpeter

    @Zash I believe the concern is keeping a user session alive across the s2s restart etc.

  557. stpeter

    Anyway, this is getting into a technical discussion.

  558. L29Ah has left

  559. singpolyma

    Getting a real contact at any of the gatekeepers would be a huge win independent of MIMI and DMA stuff

  560. stpeter

    And the basic problem here is people / political.

  561. ralphm

    Zash: Google literally used "XMPP is not ready for the cloud" as an argument for shutting down federation and eventually Talk.

  562. moparisthebest

    ralphm: we already have XMPP on quic defined and implemented and deployed...

  563. inky has left

  564. Zash

    So we need someone to ~bribe~ lunch with the right people in the right lobbies then. Who likes to eat? :)

  565. stpeter

    @singpolyma We had great contacts originally with the Google Talk team but those atrophied and their commitment to XMPP wavered once a new product manager took over. Etc. I don’t see a lot of upside here.

  566. emus

    stpeter: (as you are writing miniutes, can you liate the technical implentations mentioned)

  567. Steve Kille has joined

  568. stpeter

    “We’re trillion dollar companies, please do all this work for free to save us from EU fines” is simply not a great offer.

  569. singpolyma

    stpeter: right. That's one issue with all political work. New people always come and go and it needs constant renewal. It's not a project more like a job unfortunately

  570. ralphm

    In any case, we're more or less where we started: nobody that has the cycles and/or desire to do this work.

  571. Zash

    stpeter, ... "or we'll do it an even worse way!"

  572. antranigv has left

  573. ralphm

    If money is the problem, however, we can apply for funding, and likely get that sorted.

  574. antranigv has joined

  575. Zash

    EU funding?

  576. ralphm


  577. emus

    So don't know the problem? or is it money?

  578. stpeter

    These companies are likely to create bilateral agreements or one-off APIs in order to comply. They will not be pretty, but they will help the gatekeepers avoid fines.

  579. emus

    there is also the german security fund

  580. singpolyma

    Unless XSF wants to become the kind of org that has staff I think funding probably won't help this particular kind of issue. Unless it's just about flights or whatever

  581. emus

    there is also the german souvernaity fund

  582. Arne

    what about the sovereing tech fund?

  583. emus

    Arne: yes, mentioned that

  584. Arne

    May I ask, how the progress of the application?

  585. Arne

    May I ask, how far is the progress of the application?

  586. emus

    > Arne: > 2023-05-04 07:21 (GMT+02:00) > May I ask, how the progress of the application? no application

  587. stpeter

    Well, there’s also a question of who the hell wants to do this kind of political / standards work for literally years on end.

  588. moparisthebest

    Yes, they aren't going to federate with the open XMPP network no matter how much we butcher XMPP s2s to please them, so why expend any effort?

  589. ralphm

    stpeter: there was discussion on this at the DMA meeting in Brussels, and all parties there, except Meta of course, made it clear that they didn't think that bilateral APIs were going to be an acceptable approach. The summary by the EUC representative made me think that the C would agree.

  590. moparisthebest

    Remember their goal is user lock in

  591. emus

    I't rather start with a funding and work towards this if that is what we all believe is the right way

  592. stpeter

    Even if we think there is a high likelihood of success from the XMPP perspective, we’re talking about 3+ years of unpleasant political / standards work. I’m pretty sure everyone here would rather spend their time writing code and making their software better for real people.

  593. ralphm

    If we put in a good proposal NLNet will likely provide funding. But as I said, and Peter is as well, somebody has to want to do this. And also have the qualifications I mentioned above.

  594. singpolyma

    > Well, there’s also a question of who the hell wants to do this kind of political / standards work for literally years on end. Yes, it's a kind of work that's extra hard to do long term with volunteers

  595. emus

    ralphm, stpeter: but please lets define what we believe are required and meaningful questions and how to adress. then we can call and see how we could reach this in a second step

  596. stpeter

    If I hadn’t been working for JINC and then Cisco, I don’t think I would have done all that IETF work for the last 20 years.

  597. MattJ

    I don't have anything further to say and I don't think we have any action items here (other than generally keeping on top of MLS)

  598. stpeter

    @emus Sure, we can do that.

  599. ralphm

    So I'd focus on the people part first, then arrange the funding.

  600. emus

    Action, peoplex funding, rather?

  601. stpeter

    But in any case I think a good first step, no matter what, is to jumpstart the MLS over XMPP work.

  602. emus

    Action, people, funding, rather?

  603. stpeter

    That’s a concrete, useful effort, and we have people who want to work on it.

  604. emus

    Should we make it an official team? I mean its really important right?

  605. stpeter

    I think it makes sense to take a wait-and-see attitude w.r.t. MIMI.

  606. ralphm

    emus: so far the team is called Board, and I don't think that creating a dedicated work team will change the outcome at this point.

  607. emus

    ok, but you mentined others too right?

  608. stpeter

    @emus It’s a XEP. Potential authors can submit a proposal anytime. Not sure we need a team for it.

  609. emus

    sorry, matt mentined

  610. emus


  611. ralphm

    emus: I mentioned people who have previously indicated a desire to work on MLS. I don't know what the current status is, but maybe MattJ knows

  612. emus


  613. stpeter

    And I am no longer convinced that the MLS WG is the right place to do this work, until we have a conversation with the MLS WG chairs.

  614. MattJ

    For MLS we may form some kind of official team, but there is no pressing need

  615. marc0s has joined

  616. stpeter

    @ralphm we have an email thread going

  617. emus

    stpeter: open for all? :-)

  618. stpeter

    (Which I need to reply in given my recent discoveries.)

  619. ralphm

    Various people in the MLS WG have indicated they'd help out if needed. Including Raphael Robert.

  620. emus

    (whos that?)

  621. stpeter

    @emus Just an organizational thing among potential spec authors. Once they get organized, I’m sure a XEP will be forthcoming.

  622. stpeter

    @ralphm Yes, Richard Barnes offered to share insights, too.

  623. stpeter

    Anyway, I think we have enough to go on for the moment, let’s see how the next few weeks shake out and we can discussion again in the next Board meeting.

  624. emus

    (Anything I can do even though I lack may required competences?)

  625. ralphm

    stpeter: where is the thread?

  626. emus


  627. ralphm

    (I may have missed it completely)

  628. ralphm

    Agreed on moving on.

  629. ralphm

    2. Infra

  630. ralphm

    I understand there have been issues and work was done. What's the latest?

  631. emus

    fine, but lets write good mnutes here and cycle them

  632. stpeter

    @ralphm It’s not on any list yet.

  633. arcxi has left

  634. ralphm

    stpeter: ok, then it makes sense I haven't seen it :-D

  635. emus

    > stpeter: > 2023-05-04 07:31 (GMT+02:00) > @ralphm It’s not on any list yet. lets move it there please

  636. stpeter

    @emus Yes, I will write up some minutes based on the discussion here, likely tomorrow.

  637. emus


  638. ralphm

    MattJ: infra?

  639. MattJ

    (typing :) )

  640. MattJ

    There are no major infrastructure emergencies right now, but some ongoing issues of various severities. Top ones that come to mind are the lack of web-accessble archives on the mailing lists since restoration, and a lack of IPv6. The first one is within our control, the second seems to be some issue at USSHC and so far Jerry has not responded to a couple of pings about the issue (but I didn't press too hard because he was helping us with more urgent issues). I'll try and get on top of both issues as soon as I can.

  641. marc0s has left

  642. MattJ

    The lack of IPv6 affects all our USSHC servers, so for us that's primarily our mail server, DNS server and everything we host at xmpp.net (beyond the XSF, jabber.org is also affected). The website and XMPP service are not affected.

  643. *IM* has joined

  644. 775857429 has joined

  645. ralphm

    Is lack of IPv6 a problem?

  646. ralphm

    (or a desire)

  647. MattJ

    Yes, it means the service can't be accessed by people with IPv6-only internet connections, for example

  648. ralphm

    Right. I have no idea how large that group is

  649. MattJ

    and we can't deliver (or receive mail from) IPv6-only mail servers

  650. MattJ

    It's not the largest group on the internet, but it's certainly a group

  651. floretta has left

  652. sjm has joined

  653. Zash

    One small part of holding us back in the Legacy IP dark ages!

  654. ralphm

    Yep. Ok. Thanks for the update.

  655. ralphm

    3. AOB

  656. ralphm

    Any OB?

  657. emus


  658. stpeter

    Well, another issue is that we still haven’t fully configured mailman - we need to install/configure nginx and re-enable list archives and perhaps a few other tasks. I’ve been traveling so I have been remiss in working on this.

  659. stpeter

    (At least I think those tasks still need to be completed, but I might be out of the loop.)

  660. MattJ

    I did mention that above, I'm planning to look into it

  661. emus

    stpeter: Maybe we can ask singpolyma for help if thats required

  662. ralphm

    stpeter: I think that was in MattJ's message

  663. stpeter

    OK, sorry, my attention wandered.

  664. ralphm

    No worries

  665. stpeter

    In finance news, I just reimbursed Ralph for FOSDEM/Summit expenses.

  666. ralphm

    Any other business?

  667. ralphm

    YES! And got it, too

  668. L29Ah has joined

  669. stpeter

    That was somewhat expensive. :-)

  670. ralphm

    Well yeah, it is has been a while since we needed to pay for a venue

  671. emus

    wait I may have one extra announcement

  672. stpeter

    So instead of $16k+ in the bank we now have $13k-ish in the bank.

  673. stpeter

    But we can talk next time about sponsors again and I can provide a more complete finance report.

  674. Arne

    About finances, I'm thinking about contacting a potential investor. He has some small political contacts and he came to me once after I won a price for my project. I could try to introduce him to xmpp. Maybe anyone here could help then?

  675. emus

    Na not yet

  676. ralphm


  677. stpeter

    Arne: sounds intriguing.

  678. emus

    (nothing to announce yet from my side)

  679. ralphm

    Arne: nice!

  680. stpeter

    @emus OK, but the suspense is killing me!

  681. ralphm

    So yes, we can help

  682. stpeter

    No more AOB here.

  683. ralphm

    emus: guess the next meeting then.

  684. ralphm

    4. Date of Next

  685. emus

    ralphm: later hopefully :-0

  686. Arne

    > So yes, we can help Thanks

  687. stpeter

    June 1 or 8?

  688. stpeter has left

  689. ralphm

    June 1 works for me

  690. emus

    7th in my cakender

  691. wladmis has left

  692. emus

    but should be 8 righy?

  693. wladmis has joined

  694. ralphm

    AFAIK we haven't picked a date in June yet

  695. emus

    I thought we did. ok wait

  696. stpeter has joined

  697. emus

    id prefer 8th

  698. ralphm


  699. ralphm

    Next meeting is on June 8, 17:00 UTC.

  700. ralphm

    5. Close

  701. ralphm

    Thanks all!

  702. ralphm bangs gavel

  703. *IM* has left

  704. stpeter has left

  705. stpeter has joined

  706. stpeter


  707. emus

    but actually, didt we agree on first Wed? thats how it is in my calendar

  708. Arne

    Thanks and bye!

  709. *IM* has joined

  710. stpeter

    I thought we agreed on Wednesday?

  711. stpeter

    I mean Thursday.

  712. stpeter

    Anyway, we can work it out on the Board list.

  713. stpeter

    I need to run, cya later!

  714. emus

    fun :-) I got blamed sending a reminder :-0

  715. stpeter has left

  716. emus

    kk bye

  717. ralphm

    emus: We only recognise 64v3vs15qlalgqv0j7r99ikm1c@group.calendar.google.com

  718. emus

    ralphm: well didnt worked for arc I think

  719. ralphm

    arc always has calendar issues. One of the constants in the universe

  720. emus

    🙈 people don't believe we work in tech

  721. emus

    Good night

  722. Menel has left

  723. Menel has joined

  724. floretta has joined

  725. Zash

    Tech workers have the most tech problems, probably.

  726. moparisthebest

    Relevant https://www.moparisthebest.com/images/enthusiasts-vs-engineers.png

    😂️ 1
  727. Zash

    A printer? Someone likes to live dangerously

  728. xnamed has left

  729. xnamed has joined

  730. Arne

    Printers often make problems

  731. 775857429 has left

  732. crk has joined

  733. stp has joined

  734. Tobias has left

  735. Tobias has joined

  736. singpolyma has left

  737. arcxi has joined

  738. singpolyma has joined

  739. Tobias has left

  740. Tobias has joined

  741. tee has left

  742. Tobias has left

  743. Tobias has joined

  744. tee has joined

  745. Seve has left

  746. tee has left

  747. tee has joined

  748. tee has left

  749. tee has joined

  750. tee has left

  751. tee has joined

  752. tee has left

  753. tee has joined

  754. deimos has left

  755. deimos has joined

  756. uhoreg has left

  757. Half-Shot has left

  758. Matthew has left

  759. homebeach has left

  760. Half-Shot has joined

  761. Matthew has joined

  762. homebeach has joined

  763. uhoreg has joined

  764. stp has left

  765. neshtaxmpp has left

  766. neshtaxmpp has joined

  767. Seve has joined

  768. Arne has left

  769. Arne has joined

  770. Wojtek has joined

  771. *IM* has left

  772. marc0s has joined

  773. bhavy has left

  774. Maxence has left

  775. emus


  776. bhavy has joined

  777. *IM* has joined

  778. Wojtek has left

  779. singpolyma has left

  780. singpolyma has joined

  781. asterix has left

  782. asterix has joined

  783. marc0s has left

  784. Maxence has joined

  785. bean has joined

  786. andrey.g has joined

  787. Titi has joined

  788. Friendly Resident Cynic has left

  789. Friendly Resident Cynic has joined

  790. Tobias has left

  791. Tobias has joined

  792. resoli has joined

  793. singpolyma has left

  794. singpolyma has joined

  795. 775857429 has joined

  796. Tobias has left

  797. Tobias has joined

  798. asterix has left

  799. asterix has joined

  800. Tobias has left

  801. Tobias has joined

  802. resoli has left

  803. catchy has left

  804. catchy has joined

  805. antranigv has left

  806. wladmis has left

  807. wladmis has joined

  808. eevvoor has left

  809. Andrzej has left

  810. antranigv has joined

  811. Wojtek has joined

  812. neshtaxmpp has left

  813. neshtaxmpp has joined

  814. neshtaxmpp has left

  815. neshtaxmpp has joined

  816. debacle has joined

  817. Calvin has joined

  818. stp has joined

  819. singpolyma has left

  820. Josh has left

  821. singpolyma has joined

  822. Josh has joined

  823. marc0s has joined

  824. L29Ah has left

  825. Josh has left

  826. Josh has joined

  827. bean has left

  828. uhoreg has left

  829. Half-Shot has left

  830. Matthew has left

  831. homebeach has left

  832. Half-Shot has joined

  833. Matthew has joined

  834. homebeach has joined

  835. uhoreg has joined

  836. Dele Olajide has left

  837. andrey.g has left

  838. MSavoritias (fae,ve) has left

  839. L29Ah has joined

  840. matthias has left

  841. singpolyma has left

  842. djorz has joined

  843. singpolyma has joined

  844. miho has joined

  845. emus

    ralphm, stpeter: But we used to say that we want to have a strategy before be start asking for a funding in any direction. now I understood it was mention to "simply" look for people and funding. Im a bit confused... Btw, I want to remind that nicola, a lawyer and politician from Italy offered support in eg. legal questions if that is required.

  846. miho has left

  847. miho has joined

  848. ralphm

    emus: I strongly believe that we should first find a person that would want to lead this effort, and has time to do this. This could mean that instead of doing other work, this person will dedicate his time for this *if paid for it*. But we'd first have to find a person that is _willing_ and _capable_. Then if funding is the "only" concern, we can try and find funding for that.

  849. 775857429 has left

  850. poliux has joined

  851. Alex has left

  852. Trung has left

  853. Trung has joined

  854. singpolyma has left

  855. emus

    But I'd rather say lets set the goals or what ever we want to work towards and set the scene. why only one person. maybe the could be done by people part time. or people act on certain parts, not all of it. I mean we are looking for one champion, but maybe thats too high of an expectation?

  856. singpolyma has joined

  857. singpolyma

    Are we still talking about doing political/ietf work? Because that's at least focus of one person to realistically happen in full

  858. singpolyma

    Rag tag group can do a lot but some stuff needs continuity

  859. inky has joined

  860. Axel R. has left

  861. chipmnk has left

  862. *IM* has left

  863. chipmnk has joined

  864. *IM* has joined

  865. pablo has joined

  866. Titi has left

  867. Tobi has left

  868. Tobias has left

  869. resoli has joined

  870. miho has left

  871. Yagiza has left

  872. singpolyma has left

  873. singpolyma has joined

  874. emus

    sure, not ignoring that

  875. uhoreg has left

  876. Half-Shot has left

  877. Matthew has left

  878. homebeach has left

  879. Half-Shot has joined

  880. Matthew has joined

  881. homebeach has joined

  882. uhoreg has joined

  883. mirux has left

  884. marc0s has left

  885. Wojtek has left

  886. asterix has left

  887. asterix has joined

  888. resoli has left

  889. Wojtek has joined

  890. pablo has left

  891. pablo has joined

  892. goffi has left

  893. singpolyma has left

  894. Trung has left

  895. singpolyma has joined

  896. floretta has left

  897. floretta has joined

  898. pablo has left

  899. Dele Olajide has joined

  900. Tobi has joined

  901. Tobias has joined

  902. Menel has left

  903. Dele Olajide has left

  904. *IM* has left

  905. floretta has left

  906. cal0pteryx (wurstsalat) has left

  907. neshtaxmpp has left

  908. neshtaxmpp has joined

  909. neshtaxmpp has left

  910. neshtaxmpp has joined

  911. singpolyma has left

  912. singpolyma has joined

  913. pablo has joined

  914. papatutuwawa has left

  915. Tobi has left

  916. Tobias has left

  917. floretta has joined

  918. BASSGOD has joined

  919. zonsopkomst has left

  920. zonsopkomst has joined

  921. jcbrand has left

  922. stp has left

  923. BASSGOD has left

  924. Wojtek has left

  925. marc0s has joined

  926. LNJ has left

  927. BASSGOD has joined

  928. singpolyma has left

  929. singpolyma has joined

  930. marc0s has left

  931. Friendly Resident Cynic has left

  932. pablo has left

  933. singpolyma has left

  934. singpolyma has joined

  935. Calvin has left

  936. kurisu has left

  937. floretta has left

  938. djorz has left

  939. *IM* has joined

  940. Calvin has joined

  941. Calvin has left

  942. Calvin has joined

  943. Calvin has left

  944. Calvin has joined

  945. Calvin has left

  946. catchy has left

  947. emus has left

  948. Chad has left

  949. catchy has joined

  950. singpolyma has left

  951. singpolyma has joined

  952. Chad has joined

  953. lskdjf has left

  954. BASSGOD has left

  955. edhelas has left

  956. BASSGOD has joined

  957. edhelas has joined

  958. neox has left

  959. djorz has joined

  960. *IM* has left

  961. BASSGOD has left

  962. projjalm has left

  963. BASSGOD has joined

  964. BASSGOD has left

  965. 775857429 has joined

  966. BASSGOD has joined

  967. crk has left

  968. *IM* has joined

  969. crk has joined